Unresolved questions require independent commission
Opinion
Manitoba's ethics commissioner, Jeffrey Schnoor, recently released a report in which he concluded that former Progressive Conservative premier Heather Stefanson and two of her former cabinet ministers violated the province's conflict-of-interest laws after losing the 2023 election.
They were accused of breaching the rules in an effort to approve the controversial Sio Silica sand mine during the short 'caretaker period' before the new NDP government was sworn in.
Schnoor found that their actions 'lacked ethical and constitutional legitimacy,' but failed to identify what motivated them to act so recklessly. He says he found no evidence that any of the them acted for personal benefit but, if that wasn't the reason, why did they do it?
MIKAELA MACKENZIE / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Then-premier Heather Stefanson and finance minister Cliff Cullen announce the 2023 budget to media. Columnist Deveryn Ross says it's time to have an independent commission examine PC spending decisions.
That's just one of many serious questions still swirling around the former government.
Last week, Finance Minister Adrien Sala asked auditor general Tyson Shtykalo to investigate what went wrong with Manitoba Public Insurance's Project Nova technology project. MPI abandoned the program two months ago after a review estimated that total project costs had soared from $107 million to $435 million.
The project was initially justified as an upgrade of MPI's digital capabilities, which would enable Manitobans to renew or amend their auto insurance and driver's licences online. It would also provide 'seamless connectivity' between MPI and repair shops.
That was the hope back in 2020. Five years later, however, MPI Minister Matt Wiebe describes the program as a 'waste of taxpayers' money.' Where did all that money go, and why did MPI keep spending it?
In April, the Kinew government asked Shtykalo to investigate an (almost) $100-million taxpayer-funded contract to build daycare facilities throughout the province. It alleges that the project, in which the province partnered with a company named JohnQ Public Inc., 'may not have followed normal provincial or municipal procurement practices.'
Specifically, the government claims the contract enabled the previous government to funnel $2.8 million to Boom Done Next, a company owned by Marni Larkin. Larkin was the campaign manager for the Tories' 2023 doomed re-election campaign. How does a company earn almost $3 million on such a project?
Two weeks ago, a CBC report revealed that the previous government gave an $18 million grant to JohnQ Public days before the 2023 provincial election was called. There was no public announcement of the funding, which was reportedly for a large land purchase in the RM of Ritchot to develop a proposed 'Winnipeg regional rail port.' Why the secrecy and rushed timing of the grant?
In February, at a debate between PC Party leadership candidates Obby Khan and Wally Daudrich, Kahn alleged that Daudrich was the party's top donor for 12 years and accused him of receiving 'licensing permits up north under the table' from the previous government.
Daudrich's company, Lazy Bear Lodge and Expeditions, first received approvals to operate off-road vehicle tours near Churchill in 2004. The total number of permits for all tour operators in the coastal plain of the Churchill Wildlife Management Area was limited to 18 between 1984 and 2020. Five years ago, however, the former Tory government reportedly approved two additional permits, both of which were awarded to Lazy Bear.
Did Khan have inside knowledge that permits were improperly issued to Daudrich's company, or was his accusation simply bluster in the heat of the moment?
There is no evidence that anybody acted improperly in these instances, let alone illegally, but there are many questions and few answers.
Weekday Evenings
Today's must-read stories and a roundup of the day's headlines, delivered every evening.
The Kinew government and many Manitobans are counting on the auditor general to expose and explain the questionable conduct of the previous government, but their hopes may be overly optimistic. That's because Shtykalo has significant discretion as to which matters he chooses to investigate, and his office has limited resources. Even if he decides to review the issues referred to him, more than a year could pass before any reports are issued.
That's neither good enough nor fast enough.
The better, more efficient course of action is for the government to appoint an independent commissioner to investigate the many unresolved issues, and to give that commissioner the power to compel testimony and gather evidence if necessary.
Manitobans deserve to know the truth. An independent commission is the best path to those answers.
Deveryn Ross is a political commentator living in Brandon. deverynrossletters@gmail.com X: @deverynross
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
2 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Manitoba to announce tax extension for wildfire-affected businesses
Voluntary tax deferrals for businesses impacted by wildfires will be announced by the province Wednesday, the Free Press has learned. A source confirmed late Tuesday that the government will offer optional deferrals of the retail sales tax and payroll tax (the health and post-secondary education tax levy) to help businesses affected by the unprecedented emergency that has forced 21,000 Manitobans to flee 27 communities. A similar measure was announced by the province in March in response to U.S. tariffs, with such deferrals available from February through July. MIKE DEAL / FREE PRESS FILES Manitoba Finance Minister Adrien Sala. Details of the program related to wildfires will be made public Wednesday. Meanwhile, Manitoba businesses dealing with the fallout from an early, raging fire season have been waiting for the province to say if and how it will provide any government support. 'We have been hearing a lot of concern about the level of uncertainty — especially from tourism operators who are fearful they will miss out on the entire 2025 season,' said Canadian Federation of Independent Business spokesperson Brianna Solberg. She wrote to Finance Minister Adrien Sala on June 2 asking if the province would consider any specific cost relief or recovery measures for impacted small businesses. Flexibility on provincial tax and fee payments and remittances for affected businesses — such as retail and payroll tax deferrals — was one of the requests made in the letter. It also asked for emergency financial assistance or recovery grants and sought assurances that wildfire-impacted small businesses are eligible for Disaster Financial Assistance. It also requested co-ordination with federal counterparts to ensure Manitoba businesses are eligible for any national wildfire relief programs. Solberg said Tuesday she had yet to receive a response. Sala wouldn't talk about specific supports for businesses when brought up by the Free Press. 'Right now, the focus continues to be on keeping people safe and supporting individuals who've been impacted by the wildfires,' the minister said Tuesday. Sala noted there is $50 million in this year's budget for emergency expenditures and 'a number of relevant departments' have funding available. A separate budget for contingencies is $38.6 million. MIKE DEAL / FREE PRESS FILES Transportation and Infrastructure Minister Lisa Naylor. 'This wildfire season has been worse than many in recent memory, so we are seeing steady use of our existing budget lines to help respond to these challenges,' the minister said. He said the government would have a better idea about the cost of this wildfire season in September. 'It's still early days. I can say that I think we budgeted accordingly and have the resources needed to make sure that we can do what we need to do to take care of Manitobans during this challenging time.' Despite the impact of U.S. tariffs and provincial wildfires hurting the bottom line, Sala said the province still aims to balance the books in his first term. 'We're still committed to balancing the budget,' Sala said. The leader of the Progressive Conservatives said the response from the provincial government was lacking. 'They can be committed all they want, but we all are clearly seeing that the NDP are saying whatever they have to say and not doing the hard work behind the scenes,' Obby Khan said Tuesday. Weekday Mornings A quick glance at the news for the upcoming day. He pointed to Lisa Naylor, the minister responsible for the Emergency Management Organization, who said Manitobans hosting conventions or planning family trips should postpone them until later this summer to ensure there are enough hotel spaces for evacuees. 'Dozens of businesses have called me today, and text-messaged me that this government seems to make announcements and policies without doing their proper due diligence and consultation,' Khan said. 'It seems like they haven't spoken to many businesses, many industry leaders and it's evident with the minister coming out and asking people to reconsider or forego their travel to Manitoba when many of these operators really rely on this tourism and summer revenue and some of them are nowhere near the fires.' MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS FILES Progressive Conservative leader Obby Khan. The president and CEO of the Manitoba Chambers of Commerce said Naylor's plea took some by surprise. 'I think that the government is trying to do the best they can in the current situation,' Chuck Davidson said Tuesday. 'Obviously with the wildfire situation and the number of people that have been evacuated… it's trying to do everything possible to make sure that there's accommodation.' At the same time, tourism operators can't afford to lose guests, Davidson said. 'Some of these businesses are going to need those additional revenues to make sure that they can continue to operate moving forward.' Naylor said Tuesday that the province is housing evacuees in 68 hotels and motels in 14 communities across the province. 'We're looking everywhere for options if they're needed,' Naylor said. 'We're really at the beginning of the wildfire season. We don't know how this is going to go, and we don't know what's going to happen next… So we are trying to keep hotel rooms and motel rooms available as much as possible for evacuees.' Carol SandersLegislature reporter Carol Sanders is a reporter at the Free Press legislature bureau. The former general assignment reporter and copy editor joined the paper in 1997. Read more about Carol. Every piece of reporting Carol produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
CTV News
4 hours ago
- CTV News
‘These are not small margins:' Doug Ford's PCs hold 21-point lead, new survey suggests
Ontario Progressive Conservative Leader Doug Ford greets supporters after he was re-elected as the Premier of Ontario in Toronto on Thursday, February 27, 2025. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young The next Ontario election is likely still years away but a new poll suggests that Premier Doug Ford and the Progressive Conservative party remain well ahead of their rivals. Abacus Data surveyed 1,000 adult Ontarians between June 2 and June 5 and found that if an election were held today about 49 per cent of committed voters would support Ford's PC party. The Liberals were in second with the support of 28 per cent of committed voters while the NDP were at 14 per cent and the Greens were at five per cent. About four per cent of committed voters said that they would support another party. Ford's PC party was ahead in all regions surveyed by Abacus, though the gap was the closest in Toronto where they only had a four-point lead over the Liberals, according to the poll. Notably, support for the PCs was up four points from the last time Abacus Data surveyed Ontarians in the days prior to February's election. The Liberals were down one point, the NDP were down two points and support for the Greens was changed. 'These are not small margins. A 21-point lead over the second-place Liberals is rare in any political context. But for a third-term government battling economic insecurity, it is even more remarkable,' Abacus Data CEO David Coletto said in an analysis accompanying the poll results. The Abacus Data survey also examined Ford's personal popularity level for the first time since January. It found that 44 per cent of respondents approved of the job Ford and his government are doing, up two points since the winter. Abacus says that it is the highest approval number it has recorded for Ford since August, 2023. Similarly, 33 per cent of respondents said that they had a favourable impression of Ford compared to the 33 per cent who said that they viewed him negatively. About 31 per cent of respondents viewed Liberal Leader Bonnie Crombie favourably compared to the 33 per cent who viewed her negatively. NDP Leader Marit Stiles was viewed favourably by 28 per cent of respondents and viewed negatively by 25 per cent of respondents. But a comparatively higher percentage of respondents – 16 per cent – said that they did not know enough to offer an opinion. In his analysis, Coletto said that Ford currently possesses 'by far, the most defined political brand in the province' and 'remains in a very strong position' months after its re-election. 'Whether this holds depends on what happens next. The economy is still fragile. The housing crisis remains unresolved. And (U.S. President) Trump could introduce new anxieties that ripple across all levels of Canadian politics. But for now, the Ford government has time, space, and public goodwill. In politics, that is a rare combination, and one the Premier will no doubt seek to maintain and leverage to push his agenda forward,' he said. The survey was conducted using a set of opt-in panels using the Lucid exchange platform. While such polls are not assigned a margin of error, Abacus says that a comparable probability-based random sample of this size would carry a margin of error of plus or minus 3.1 percentage points, 19 times out of 20.
Global News
4 hours ago
- Global News
Credit rating agency says Manitoba's recent tax changes outweigh affordability offers
The Manitoba government is expected to use more 'revenue levers,' similar to its recent income and property tax changes, as part of its plan to reduce the deficit, a credit-rating agency report says. S&P Global Ratings has affirmed the Manitoba government's existing short-term and long-term credit ratings and says the outlook for the province is stable, based in part on expected revenue changes and spending control. 'The stable outlook reflects our expectation that, despite economic growth and trade uncertainty, Manitoba will deploy revenue levers and expenditure management to generate stronger fiscal outcomes in the next two years,' the report, issued May 26, said. The NDP government, elected in 2023, has promised to reduce costs for Manitobans. It has taken out advertising to promote its cut to the provincial fuel tax, an increase to a tax credit for renters and other measures. Story continues below advertisement But the money forgone by the province for those measures is outweighed by recent tax changes that are boosting provincial revenues, a director with S&P said. That includes a change in this year's budget that will no longer see income tax brackets automatically rise in line with inflation. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'That alone is enough to offset all the affordability measures that they're putting in,' Bhavini Patel, director in S&P's Canadian international public finance group, said in an interview. The NDP government has promised to balance the budget before the next election, slated for 2027. That would end a string of annual deficits that stretches back almost continuously to 2009, with the exception of two surpluses. Part of the province's revenue growth has come from recent changes that will see many property owners and income-earners pay more. In last year's budget, the government changed the way education tax credits on property are calculated. The government estimated the change would net the province an extra $148 million a year, although that number is likely to grow due to recent increases in property assessments and taxes levied by school divisions. In this year's budget, the government stopped indexing income tax brackets and the basic personal exemption to inflation. By keeping the brackets and exemption constant as wages increase, unlike most provinces, the government is forecasting an extra $82 million in revenue. Story continues below advertisement Finance Minister Adrien Sala said he's not looking at future tax changes aimed at garnering more money, and is expecting an economic boost to increase revenue. 'I think the biggest driver of new revenues will be economic growth,' he said in an interview. He pointed to the recent start of construction of the Alamos gold mine near Lynn Lake as an example. The government is also looking at keeping annual spending growth in check in order to balance the budget, he said.
