Daughter challenges stepfather after he inherits majority from her mother's R7. 9 million death benefit
An aggrieved chartered accountant took the Pension Fund Adjudicator and Allan Gray to the Financial Services Tribunal after her stepfather was allocated a major portion from her mother's death benefit.
Image: Pexels
An aggrieved chartered accountant took the Pension Fund Adjudicator (PFA) and Allan Gray to the Financial Services Tribunal (FST) after her stepfather was allocated a major portion from her mother's death benefit.
Hayley Marie Ward who was 25 years when her mother died, was unhappy after Allan Gray Retirement Fund (AGRF) and Allan Gray Pension Preservation Fund (AGPE) nominated Waynne Millard, 63, to receive 58% from her mother's R7.9 million death benefit.
The deceased, Gail Pamela Millard, 58, died in August 2023. She was married to Waynne for 18 years.
In her first marriage, she had three daughters, Hayley, Andrea Lynne Ward and Michelle Robin Ward.
Gail had over R7.9 million in the AGPE and over R24,000 in the AGRF.
In the AGPE, she nominated Waynne to receive 10%, Hayley 30%, Michelle 28%, and Andrea was allocated 32%. In respect of the AGRF, her nominations were 20% each for three beneficiaries except for Michelle who was allocated 40%.
Before releasing the funds, Allan Gray conducted an investigation and determined that Wayne and the deceased's mother were factually her dependents. Even though daughters are legally her dependants, they were not dependent on their mother at the time of her death.
Based on information gathered after the investigation, Allan Gray re-allocated the death benefit as follows:
Allan Gray Retirement Fund (AGRF) and Allan Gray Pension Preservation Fund (AGPE) nominated Waynne Millard to receive 58% from her mother's R7.9 million death benefit.
Image: Screenshot
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Disenchanted, Hayley lodged a complaint with the PFA in April 2024. The crux of the complaint was that Allan Gray used the incorrect life expectancy for Waynne hence an excessive portion of the death benefit had been re-allocated him. She argued that he was unjustly enriched, and this prejudiced her and her siblings.
She said had the correct facts and figures been used, Allan Gray ought to have allocated at most 19% of the total death benefit to Waynne and not 58%.
The PFA dismissed her complaint, and she sought relief at the FST.
Amongst other things, the FST looked at the evidence used by Allan Gray to allocate the funds.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
6 days ago
- IOL News
MultiChoice expects improved earnings despite tough trading conditions
MultiChoice, South Africa's leading pay-TV operator, has warned shareholders of a significant shift in its financial performance for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2025, driven by challenging macro-economic conditions and structural changes in the video entertainment industry across sub-Saharan Africa. MultiChoice, South Africa's leading pay-TV operator, has warned shareholders of a significant shift in its financial performance for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2025, driven by challenging macro-economic conditions and structural changes in the video entertainment industry across sub-Saharan Africa. It said, "The current period has seen the continuation of unprecedented financial disruption for economies, corporates and consumers across sub-Saharan Africa due to several macro-economic factors, including weaker average exchange rates, elevated inflation and interest rates, and power supply challenges. "Combined with the impact of structural industry changes in video entertainment, such as the rise of piracy, streaming services and social media, as well as the cost of investing in Showmax, this has materially affected the performance of the MultiChoice Group. The group has acted decisively to counter these headwinds by, focusing on key areas within its control such as maintaining inflationary pricing discipline, growing new revenue streams and driving further efficiencies to manage costs and cash flows," the group said. In a trading statement released on Thursday, MultiChoice projected a recovery in earnings per share (EPS), forecasting an increase of 128% to 132% compared to a loss of 935 cents per share in the prior year This translates to an expected EPS range of R12.62 - R12.94 per share. The group said it expects to report positive earnings per share due to the recognition of a profit on the sale of a 60% shareholding in NMS Insurance Services (NMSIS) to Sanlam Life Insurance Limited in November 2024, and a downward adjustment to the Showmax put option liability. Similarly, the group expects the headline loss per share (which excludes the profit on the sale of NMSIS) to narrow year-on-year. Headline earnings per share are expected to rise between 62% to 66%, in a range of between R4.43 - R4.72 per share, compared to a loss of 715c per share the prior year. Trading profit (reported) from R7.9 billion is likely to fall between 47% to 51%. MultiChoice said, "The ongoing investment in the Showmax streaming business, which remains at an early stage of development and has yet to scale into its cost base, is expected to result in the group reporting a lower trading profit. On an organic basis (excluding the effects of foreign currency and group composition changes), the decline in trading profit is expected to be much smaller." Trading profit (reported) was expected to fall by between 47% to 51% from R7.9 billion. BUSINESS REPORT
The Star
17-05-2025
- The Star
Veteran journalist Stephen Cranston explores the giants of South Africa's asset management sector in his book debut, 'The Mavericks'
Stephen Cranston has been writing about South Africa's financial world for years, earning recognition along the way with awards like the Citadel and Citigroup journalism prizes. So it's no surprise that his first book, The Mavericks , takes a closer look at the country's biggest names in asset management. In it, he digs into the stories behind Coronation, Ninety One and Allan Gray - firms that have shaped the industry and built their reputations on strong partnerships and long-standing relationships with asset consultants. Cranston doesn't just chart their rise; he also asks whether these giants can keep growing in a sluggish economy, and what the future might hold for local fund managers trying to break through. At the heart of the book, he takes a look at the crucial concept of partnerships, a notable feature of the Big Three firms, and details that the key to their success can be traced back to the solid relationships that these companies have established with asset consultants. 'If there is one single explanation for the dominance of the CIA, or Big Three, it is the relationships that they built with the 'consultants'. These are not the men in suits from McKinsey and Bain, but the powerful group of asset consultants who were, and remain, key gatekeepers for money management shops. The domination of the Big Three owes a lot to the trust and credibility that they built up with consultants, perhaps no one more than Ant Lester, whose business started as Old Mutual Actuaries and Consultants (OMAC) before splitting to become Fifth Quadrant and eventually,' he writes. Looking back at these companies' backgrounds, he notes that Allan Gray's early days as a partnership established a standard for its business culture. However, Coronation has distinguished itself by sustaining this culture of collaboration even after going public in 2003. Meanwhile, Ninety One, which was formerly a member of Investec, is changing its model to resemble successful collaborations by taking cues from Baillie Gifford and its own history. 'One common denominator between Coronation, Ninety One, and Allan Gray is that all three refer to the partnership concept. Allan Gray, in its early days as Allan Gray Investment Counsel, was a partnership. Coronation also likes to use the term, though it has been a listed company from day one, initially as part of the Coronation Holdings conglomerate and, from 2003, in its own right as Coronation Fund Managers,' the book reveals. Cranston additionally takes into account what happened to the once-dominant Syfrets and BOE, whose fame faded in the late 1990s, as well as other independent fund managers like RMB Asset Management and African Harvest, who failed to achieve comparable success. His study includes observations from seasoned professionals in the field, such as Delphine Govender and Peter Major, who draw attention to the difficulties the industry faces, particularly its growing complexity and the slowing down of its dynamic nature. According to the book, Major asserts that from the late 1980s to the early 2000s, South Africa's financial markets had international acclaim, attributing this impression to the partnership model that was common among leading independent managers at the time. Cranston further highlights the understanding of the dynamics between large players and independent managers, which he says illuminates the challenges and opportunities within South Africa's asset management industry. He then also studies the current state of growth within the industry, noting that economic stagnation and rising unemployment could pose significant challenges for large asset management firms. In his writing he warns, 'But what about the future of the CIA themselves? All three are mature businesses in South Africa with negative net client cash flows every year. Unless economic growth recovers to at least 3% and unemployment falls, this is likely to continue. The CIA certainly has a great deal more potential internationally. Coronation is barely out of the starting gates, except in its Global Emerging Markets and Africa Frontiers strategy.' He does, however, bring up an important issue about the lack of diversity and representation in the industry, suggesting that diversity should be defined more broadly than just demographics. Cranston comes to the conclusion that building credibility and trust among asset consultants, some of whom have influenced the financial environment for decades, is another factor contributing to the Big Three's dominance. Saturday Star
IOL News
14-05-2025
- IOL News
eThekwini ratepayer associations warn against 'superficial' 50 percent debt relief measure
The Bluff Ratepayers and Residents Association said that the eThekwini municipality's proposed 50% debt write-off is a welcome gesture, but it risks being more of a tick-box exercise than a real solution. Image: File The Bluff Ratepayers and Residents Association said that the eThekwini municipality's proposed 50% debt write-off is a welcome gesture, but it risks being more of a tick-box exercise than a real solution. Norman Gilbert, chairman of the BRRA said that while it may offer short-term relief to struggling households and businesses, it doesn't address the deeper issues causing the debt—like poor service delivery, aging infrastructure, and unaffordable tariffs. Ethekwini councillors gave the special debt relief programme the go-ahead at a council meeting on Wednesday. The water debt as at the end of January 2025, of R14.7 billion was the biggest contributor, due to undetected underground leaks and short payments by insurers. The municipality has found that many customers are unable to settle these debts and thus regarded this as irrecoverable. The programme is an initiative aimed at reducing municipal debt by offering residents and businesses a 50% write-off, provided they pay the balance in full before the end of the financial year. Other conditions include that prior to the customer settling the 50% of the arrear debt owed as at 31 January 2025, a customer must settle the entire debt from February 2025 to April 2025. The municipality stated that should a customer not be in a financial position to settle the debt for the months after 31 January 2025, that such a customer must enter into a payment plan not exceeding six months, without making any down payment. The total debtors book for the municipality, as of 31 January 2025 was R36 billion which grew significantly by R7.9 billion, when compared to January 2024. Government departments and parastatals owe the municipality R1.3 billion. Gilbert stated that the water debt highlights systemic failures that have been ignored for too long. 'Similarly, R9 billion in unpaid rates and billions in household debt show just how unaffordable basic services have become for many residents. This isn't just about non-payment, it is about survival. The situation is worsened by government debt, which sends the wrong message to the public and undermines the municipality's debt recovery efforts,' he said. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Gilbert stated that while the debt relief proposal could help reduce the growing debt book, it lacks a long-term plan to prevent the same problem from recurring. Ish Prahladh, chairperson of the eThekwini Ratepayers and Residents Association (ERRA), stated that ratepayers should be given oversight on municipal finances to put an end to tenders, advocate for competent staff and unnecessary overtime expenditure and consultancy fees. 'A municipal debt write-off will definitely benefit residents. Pensioners earn R2,000 but have to pay a R6,000 municipal bill (and this) makes life impossible for some residents. Hire competent plumbers to rectify the problems in the water department and cut our water losses to zero. Water insurance is pathetic as it does not cover the amount that is lost by the residents," Prahladh said.
