eThekwini ratepayer associations warn against 'superficial' 50 percent debt relief measure
The Bluff Ratepayers and Residents Association said that the eThekwini municipality's proposed 50% debt write-off is a welcome gesture, but it risks being more of a tick-box exercise than a real solution.
Image: File
The Bluff Ratepayers and Residents Association said that the eThekwini municipality's proposed 50% debt write-off is a welcome gesture, but it risks being more of a tick-box exercise than a real solution.
Norman Gilbert, chairman of the BRRA said that while it may offer short-term relief to struggling households and businesses, it doesn't address the deeper issues causing the debt—like poor service delivery, aging infrastructure, and unaffordable tariffs.
Ethekwini councillors gave the special debt relief programme the go-ahead at a council meeting on Wednesday. The water debt as at the end of January 2025, of R14.7 billion was the biggest contributor, due to undetected underground leaks and short payments by insurers. The municipality has found that many customers are unable to settle these debts and thus regarded this as irrecoverable.
The programme is an initiative aimed at reducing municipal debt by offering residents and businesses a 50% write-off, provided they pay the balance in full before the end of the financial year.
Other conditions include that prior to the customer settling the 50% of the arrear debt owed as at 31 January 2025, a customer must settle the entire debt from February 2025 to April 2025.
The municipality stated that should a customer not be in a financial position to settle the debt for the months after 31 January 2025, that such a customer must enter into a payment plan not exceeding six months, without making any down payment.
The total debtors book for the municipality, as of 31 January 2025 was R36 billion which grew significantly by R7.9 billion, when compared to January 2024. Government departments and parastatals owe the municipality R1.3 billion.
Gilbert stated that the water debt highlights systemic failures that have been ignored for too long.
'Similarly, R9 billion in unpaid rates and billions in household debt show just how unaffordable basic services have become for many residents. This isn't just about non-payment, it is about survival. The situation is worsened by government debt, which sends the wrong message to the public and undermines the municipality's debt recovery efforts,' he said.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Gilbert stated that while the debt relief proposal could help reduce the growing debt book, it lacks a long-term plan to prevent the same problem from recurring.
Ish Prahladh, chairperson of the eThekwini Ratepayers and Residents Association (ERRA), stated that ratepayers should be given oversight on municipal finances to put an end to tenders, advocate for competent staff and unnecessary overtime expenditure and consultancy fees.
'A municipal debt write-off will definitely benefit residents. Pensioners earn R2,000 but have to pay a R6,000 municipal bill (and this) makes life impossible for some residents. Hire competent plumbers to rectify the problems in the water department and cut our water losses to zero. Water insurance is pathetic as it does not cover the amount that is lost by the residents," Prahladh said.
zainul.dawood@inl.co.za
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
12 hours ago
- The Citizen
Are you one of the almost 16% who can afford a home loan over R1.3 million?
The question is not only if you can afford a home loan but if you can afford all the other expenses of owning a property. Recent research by an independent economist reveals that less than 16% of South Africans can genuinely afford homes priced above R1.3 million, underscoring a growing disparity between loan approvals and actual affordability. This raises questions about the financial sustainability of homeownership for the average buyer, Henri Le Grange, certified financial planner at Old Mutual Personal Finance, says. 'Qualifying for a bank loan does not necessarily mean you can afford all the costs that come with owning a home. 'The affordability gap often arises because banks assess loan eligibility primarily based on income thresholds, without considering your broader financial plan.' Le Grange says banks typically evaluate affordability based not only on gross income but also on disposable income, net income and previous monthly expenses. 'However, they consider past data and may not account for additional costs that come with homeownership, such as maintenance, insurance, or the impact of interest rate changes. ALSO READ: More SA consumers battling to pay their home loans and credit cards – report Some people get home loans but cannot afford true repayment 'As a result, I have seen customers approved for loans that exceed their true repayment capacity, threatening their financial well-being. This disconnect highlights the importance of seeking professional advice before buying a home.' Research by Izak Odendaal, Investment Strategist at Old Mutual Wealth, highlights key reasons why owning a home remains out of reach for many South Africans: stagnant wages, rising inflation and higher interest rates. 'South Africa's high interest rates and increasing property prices have made homeownership increasingly difficult. 'Many prospective buyers have been locked out of the market due to these combined factors, resulting in record-low affordability levels in the housing sector. 'Buying a home is one of the biggest financial decisions you will ever make, and it is easy to underestimate the true cost of ownership. 'Many customers also overlook the ongoing costs tied to homeownership, such as maintenance, insurance, property taxes and utilities, all expenses that can place additional strain on household budgets over time.' ALSO READ: South Africans cannot afford their homes but also can't afford to sell them Financial adviser can help look at your financial long-term plan However, he says that a financial adviser can help customers look beyond simply qualifying for a loan and ensure they are financially prepared for the long term. 'Many customers focus only on whether they can afford the loan repayment, often neglecting their long-term goals. It is not just about paying the bond. You must plan effectively to secure your long-term financial well-being.' Le Grange says working with a financial adviser helps you to create a realistic budget and prepare for upfront as well as long-term costs. 'A solid financial plan ensures you are ready for the responsibilities that come with homeownership. The goal is to help customers avoid borrowing more than they can manage and stay financially secure in the future.' Le Grange encourages consumers to take these practical steps to check if they can afford a home loan before committing to one: #1: Prepare for ongoing and unexpected costs: When you buy a home, do not just budget for the deposit and monthly home loan payments. Ensure you are ready for other costs, such as repairs, maintenance and higher utility bills. There are also transfer duty, conveyancing fees and bond registration costs, which consumers often overlook. These costs can arise unexpectedly, and therefore it is important to set aside extra money to cover these expenses and avoid financial strain. ALSO READ: Thinking of buying your first home, here are five key issues to consider #2: Test your ability to make home loan repayments: Before committing to a home loan, try putting aside the amount you would pay each month into a savings account. This will help you to see if you can afford the repayment comfortably and, if necessary, adjust your spending habits to make sure you are ready for the commitment. #3: Think about changes in interest rates: Interest rates can change, which means your home loan repayments may increase in the future. It is a good idea to think about how a rate increase could affect your budget and make sure you are in a position to handle any changes to your repayment amount. #4: Choose a loan term that fits your budget: When you take out a home loan, think about how much time you want to pay it off. A shorter loan term will mean higher monthly payments, but you will pay less interest overall. A longer loan term can lower your payments, but you will pay more interest in the long run. Choose a loan term that works for your budget and future needs. ALSO READ: How to finance your home loan if you do not have a regular income #5: Speak with a financial adviser and have a financial plan in place A financial adviser can help you consider your overall financial situation and create a plan that works for your short-term and long-term goals. They can also highlight any risks or hidden costs and suggest the best strategy for managing your home loan while keeping your finances healthy. In a challenging economic environment, affordability and financial resilience have never been more important, Le Grange says. 'Now more than ever, making informed financial decisions is key to building a secure future. Speaking to a trusted financial adviser can help to ensure your choices support both your immediate needs and long-term goals.'
IOL News
3 days ago
- IOL News
MultiChoice expects improved earnings despite tough trading conditions
MultiChoice, South Africa's leading pay-TV operator, has warned shareholders of a significant shift in its financial performance for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2025, driven by challenging macro-economic conditions and structural changes in the video entertainment industry across sub-Saharan Africa. MultiChoice, South Africa's leading pay-TV operator, has warned shareholders of a significant shift in its financial performance for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2025, driven by challenging macro-economic conditions and structural changes in the video entertainment industry across sub-Saharan Africa. It said, "The current period has seen the continuation of unprecedented financial disruption for economies, corporates and consumers across sub-Saharan Africa due to several macro-economic factors, including weaker average exchange rates, elevated inflation and interest rates, and power supply challenges. "Combined with the impact of structural industry changes in video entertainment, such as the rise of piracy, streaming services and social media, as well as the cost of investing in Showmax, this has materially affected the performance of the MultiChoice Group. The group has acted decisively to counter these headwinds by, focusing on key areas within its control such as maintaining inflationary pricing discipline, growing new revenue streams and driving further efficiencies to manage costs and cash flows," the group said. In a trading statement released on Thursday, MultiChoice projected a recovery in earnings per share (EPS), forecasting an increase of 128% to 132% compared to a loss of 935 cents per share in the prior year This translates to an expected EPS range of R12.62 - R12.94 per share. The group said it expects to report positive earnings per share due to the recognition of a profit on the sale of a 60% shareholding in NMS Insurance Services (NMSIS) to Sanlam Life Insurance Limited in November 2024, and a downward adjustment to the Showmax put option liability. Similarly, the group expects the headline loss per share (which excludes the profit on the sale of NMSIS) to narrow year-on-year. Headline earnings per share are expected to rise between 62% to 66%, in a range of between R4.43 - R4.72 per share, compared to a loss of 715c per share the prior year. Trading profit (reported) from R7.9 billion is likely to fall between 47% to 51%. MultiChoice said, "The ongoing investment in the Showmax streaming business, which remains at an early stage of development and has yet to scale into its cost base, is expected to result in the group reporting a lower trading profit. On an organic basis (excluding the effects of foreign currency and group composition changes), the decline in trading profit is expected to be much smaller." Trading profit (reported) was expected to fall by between 47% to 51% from R7.9 billion. BUSINESS REPORT
IOL News
3 days ago
- IOL News
Oops! Miscommunication sees construction start on bakery but at the wrong site in Durban
Homeland Security SA, a private security company with the Glenwood Urban Improvement Precinct (UIP), at the Davenport Park site in Umbilo. The metal rods protruding from the ground is where the concrete structure was going to be built. In the background is a community vegetable garden. Image: Tumi Pakkies/ Independent Newspapers The eThekwini Municipality's R6.7 million community bakery development programme got off to a bad start when construction started on one of them but on the wrong plot of land in Glenwood on Wednesday. In December 2024, the Economic Development and Planning Committee received support from council to fund five bakeries in ward 01: KwaXimba, Ward 94: KwaMakhutha, Ward 32: Albert Park, Ward 61: Tongaat and Ward 107: Ntuzuma/lnanda, during the 2024 and 2025 financial year. The cost per bakery container is R1.3 million. Two years ago Davenport Park was a crime hotspot and based on a park adoption agreement with the parks department, the Association Montessori International (AMI) and Umbilo Business Association(UBA) regenerated this ward 33 park. The lower Glenwood area has become notorious for prostitution and drug dealing on vacant land, in abandoned buildings and on street corners. The UBA policy director Ian Campbell-Gillies said three full time gardening jobs funded by both AMI and the UBA resulted in an urban farming operation of outstanding success in terms of regenerating the area and lowering crime. According to sources, a group of men arrived in a bakkie with building material at Davenport Park alongside the urban farming operation, a vegetable garden, on Wednesday. The men began constructing a cement pedestal for the bakery operation before it was halted when Durban Metro Police arrived together with parks department officials and the ward councillor. Following a discussion between ward 32 Councillor Protas Ngonyama and ward 33 Councillor Fran Kristofer the matter had been resolved after it was discovered that there could have been a misunderstanding with ward demarcations. Both councillors initially declined to comment further but Ngonyama later said that the bakery project would be placed on Dunkirk Park, within his ward in Umbilo. In a report to eThekwini council, it stated that the bakery programme is critical for achieving rural and township recovery objectives. The programme will also assist the city to contribute towards job creation and creation of sustainable livelihoods through supporting the development of Township-Based Enterprises, Co-operatives and Small, Medium, and Micro Enterprises (SMMEs). The report stated that the programme supports unemployed women, youth, people with disabilities and veterans, through the provision of fully equipped container bakeries and capacitating them to run sustainable businesses. This is aimed at affording them with proper and decent working facilities to produce high quality bakery products, easy access to their markets and creating employment within their areas. The report stated that the development of bakery facilities/industry within eThekwini is gaining momentum. Other benefits from the programme were: To enable customers attraction and diversification of product offerings Production of high-quality baked goods such as, bread, rolls and muffins combination of nutrition, convenience and luxury Linkages with other initiatives or complementing programs such soup kitchens community gatherings, local traditional events, church gatherings, stokvels School nutrition Provision of capacity building initiatives such as mentorship, business management and technical training [email protected]
