‘Leave grandma at home': Critics slam Sam Lawrence Park redesign
Another tried to visit and was unable to find parking.
They are among scores of Hamilton residents who have voiced concerns about the changes to the west side of the 18.6-acre park —
a former quarry named after a former Hamilton mayor
— situated at the top of the escarpment where the Jolley Cut meets Concession and Upper Wellington streets. The changes to the west side of the park, which to date have a $1.1-million price tag, have reduced parking from 22 spaces to eight — with plans to eliminate it entirely.
The city says street parking along Concession Street will help offset the lost spaces.
A City of Hamilton rendering shows the existing temporary parking solution in the western part of Sam Lawrence Park. The lot formerly had 22 parking spaces and has been reduced to eight. The traffic flow in the design has been changed to flow clockwise.
After a story about concerns around the redesign
, The Spectator put out a
survey for feedback on the changes
, which attracted more than 250 responses. The majority of respondents opposed the changes, citing accessibility concerns for older adults and people with mobility issues.
Mark Dyment said his parents are older and have mobility issues, so he would drive them to the park to enjoy the view.
'Where you could park the car, you could see the city — and if you're parking over on Concession (Street), there's not much point,' he said, adding he would like to see the parking revert to the previous layout.
He said the removal of parking has made accessing the park very difficult for any older people who use a wheelchair, walker or 'don't get around that quickly.'
'They want to park as close to the edge as possible,' he said. 'They're just not going to bother going.'
Anthony Quinn, chief operating officer of the Canadian Association of Retired Persons (CARP), said the removal of parking prevents many Hamiltonians — particularly those with mobility or breathing issues — from accessing 'this valued public space.'
'This policy is really saying, 'Leave grandma at home if you're visiting Sam Lawrence Park,'' he said.
He said these types of decisions — made by council after recommendations from city staff — are 'oblivious to the needs of older adults and frankly they don't seem to care.'
Quinn added while active transportation is often used in planning, it ignores a large segment of the population that is aging or disabled and is often not able to ride bicycles or public transit.
'Eliminating parking actually makes the park less accessible and it becomes the sole domain of the physically fit,' he said.
The final proposed design of the parking lot in the western portion of Sam Lawrence Park would remove all parking spaces and create a fully pedestrianized observation area.
Bill Dell, who is 77, said he recently tried to visit the park and was unable to find parking 'within a reasonable distance.' He said the changes make him less likely to visit in the future.
Dell said he is fortunate to still be quite mobile at his age, but he knows many people younger than himself who have serious mobility issues.
'Now they've made it so you have to be able-bodied just to get there,' he said of the parking changes. 'They've forgotten several generations.'
Dell, whose wife is a grandniece of Sam Lawrence, said he doubts Lawrence would approve what has been done to the park.
'To make the changes that they did, for the theme of making it accessible for pedestrians and bicycles, really eliminates a population who actually remembered who Sam Lawrence was.'
Shirley Trimmer, who lives on the Mountain, said she regularly visits the park, including to watch storms. Trimmer, who is in her 70s, said she has friends who bring their parents, who are in their 90s, to the park.
She said older people don't want to walk from the street into the park — and people who visit the park to watch storms don't want to stand out in the pouring rain.
'My biggest concern is people who drive there … like my friend with her 90-plus-year-old father,' she said. 'She drives him and he looks. He doesn't get out of the car.'
Jean Ralph and her dog Junebug survey the redesign of the western portion of Sam Lawrence Park. The Concession Street resident said she has already witnessed
the current parking layout be a hindrance to people with mobility challenges.
Meanwhile, Jean Ralph — who lives nearby and regularly visits the park — said she has already seen the current parking layout be a hindrance to people with mobility challenges.
She said she watched one woman unable to get a walker out of the trunk of the car for her mother, due to the parking.
'If somebody has a wheelchair or walker, how are they supposed to get it out of their trunk?' she said. 'Whoever approved that needs their head examined.'
City of Hamilton landscape architecture supervisor Meghan Stewart said via email that the design aims to address 'public safety and accessibility concerns.'
She said the proposed design was shaped by public feedback and expert research, and safety and accessibility were identified as key areas for improvement during the engagement process.
In fact, Stewart said public feedback indicated the western portion of the park lacked accessible connections to the rest of the park and and that the park overall suffered from underuse and illicit nighttime activity.
She said the plan includes relocating parking spaces from the western parking lot to Concession Street to allow for new barrier-free pathway connections, an improved pedestrian-focused space for viewing, gathering and events, improved lighting, additional seating and a connection between the east and west side of the park so pedestrians can safely access either side.
In response to parking concerns, Stewart said the parking lot on the east side of the park is expected to be expanded in a future phase of the park project. She added the plans for the park will continue to be 'implemented in various stages.'
'This parking lot offers (the) opportunity for those who want to drive to the park to take in the views or connect to future barrier-free garden pathways or future entry plaza and bridge over the Jolley Cut.'
For more information on plans for Sam Lawrence Park, visit
hamilton.ca/samlawrencepark
.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hamilton Spectator
25-07-2025
- Hamilton Spectator
Brant Catholic school board affirms commitment to students with budget
On Wednesday, the Brant Haldimand Norfolk Catholic District School Board approved a nearly $202-million operating budget for 2025-26. It seems to address some of the pain points — like staffing and student supports — that parents and union heads brought up after four trustees took an art-buying trip to Italy last summer. The budget includes the equivalent of 46 new full-time staff positions. Among them, 15 elementary and nine secondary teachers, an ESL teacher, and 16 child-and-youth workers. All the positions are ''additional' to our current staffing complement,' fuelled by growth and a desire to ensure students have 'a safe and welcoming classroom environment where their academic and emotional needs are met,' a spokesperson for the board told The Spectator. The board's reserve has grown to $42 million, from $33.8 million as of August 2024. The increase is a reflection of 'the much-needed capital and the province's investment in educational infrastructure scheduled for dissemination of the new schools to be built,' the spokesperson said. But just because a board has a surplus doesn't mean they can readily use it. Some of the 'surplus' funds are already committed to initiatives, 'earmarked' with some flexibility to support one-time initiatives, or to support board operations 'including risk mitigation and board directed use,' the spokesperson told The Spectator. 'These categories are set out by the Ministry of Education' and mean that 'only portions of the reserves are available and for very targeted spending,' she said. The board is directing a $2.4-million operating surplus toward student supports like cognitive assessment fees, new curriculum resources, sports and extracurriculars, and classroom technology. And due to policy changes made to hospitality reimbursements, the board anticipates 'lower expenditures' to trustee expenses, which took a $1,000 cut this year, the spokesperson said. The board also approved a capital budget of nearly $40.5 million, driven by school renewal and improvements and the construction of St. Padre Pio Catholic Secondary School in Brantford, once approved, according to the report. The board is also preparing to purchase the lands for new elementary schools in Paris and southwest Brant, it said. Enrolment has increased 20 per cent over the past five years. The board expects to grow their student body of 12,576 by 188 new students next year, according to the budget report. 'This student-centred budget will allow us to meet our primary goal — ensuring enriched student learning within a safe, inclusive, equitable, faith filled and welcoming environment for all,' board chair Carol Luciani said in a news release. It's the first budget for the board's new business superintendent Rajini Nelson. She was hired in December 2024, following a vacancy in the role. Before that, Cheryl Dalrymple was board treasurer from June 2024 until September. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
Hamilton Spectator
17-07-2025
- Hamilton Spectator
Haldimand mayor skips heated meeting over CAO firing
Haldimand County councillors called a special meeting Monday to discuss Mayor Shelley Ann Bentley using strong-mayor powers to fire former chief administrator officer Cathy Case late last month. Residents packed council chambers to give the mayor a piece of their mind. But the mayor didn't show. 'Mayor Bentley had a special holiday booked, and she's away. We were aware of that,' said deputy mayor Rob Shirton. Some councillors suspect Bentley fired Case — a lifelong county employee with more than 30 years in the civil service — on June 27 as retribution for the former CAO launching an investigation into a leak of confidential documents during February's provincial election campaign. Longtime civil servant Cathy Case was ousted as Haldimand County's chief administrative officer on June 27. That investigation traced the leak to the mayor's office, with Bentley found to have ordered the documents printed. It remains unknown how they ended up on a Facebook page in what the investigator determined was an attempt to damage the campaign of a rival of Bentley's political ally, MPP Bobbi Ann Brady. Bentley has denied involvement in the leak and told The Spectator she did not fire Case as payback for starting the investigation, which has since been transferred to Haldimand's integrity commissioner. But resident Lesley Powell called Case's firing 'a blatant misuse of authority that has left the residents across this municipality stunned and outraged.' 'Especially considering the circumstances of the mayor currently being under investigation,' Powell said. 'Public trust has been shaken. Organizational morale has plummeted because of the misuse of these powers. And Haldimand County's reputation, once admired provincewide, is now clouded by a troubling lack of leadership integrity.' Powell noted there is a community petition demanding Bentley's resignation that, as of Thursday afternoon, had close to 400 signatories. Marianne Kidd, president of Dunnville's chamber of commerce, spoke of what she called a 'growing disconnect between how decisions are being made and what residents expect of their local government.' She asked council to pass a resolution requesting the province rescind Haldimand's strong-mayor powers, which Kidd said have caused 'organizational instability.' Such a resolution would have little effect, said lawyer John Mascarin from Aird and Berlis LLP , an expert on strong-mayor powers. Mascarin told councillors how Premier Doug Ford has modelled Ontario's municipalities after American cities, whose mayors have more power than their fellow council members. Mascarin called strong-mayor powers 'atrociously dangerous' and an affront to democracy, but said Haldimand is stuck with them until Ford changes the law or voters elect a different provincial government. 'Unless there's provincial legislation, you won't be able to do anything about these powers,' he said. Bentley had initially signalled she would not appoint an interim replacement for Case, saying in her June 27 'mayoral decision' the CAO position would be filled by various senior staffers on a weekly rotating basis. But the mayor changed tack two weeks later, appointing treasurer Mark Merritt as interim CAO July 10. Haldimand spokesperson Kyra Hayes confirmed to The Spectator that Merritt will be in the role 'indefinitely' as the search continues for Case's successor. Mayors are not legally required to provide a written explanation when using strong-mayor powers to make personnel changes such as firing the CAO, Mascarin explained. Using the powers to veto a bylaw or table legislation to support provincial priorities like housing would have to come with a written rationale. But Mascarin said there is no law compelling the mayor to explain why she ousted Case. Coun. Patrick O'Neill, who requested Monday's special meeting with the support of a majority of councillors, said Bentley could have found a way to attend virtually while on vacation. 'It is a choice to get here,' he said. Coun. Brad Adams pointed out Bentley had suggested two dates to have the meeting after she returned from her vacation later this month, which Hayes confirmed with The Spectator. 'However, a majority of the members of council decided to have the meeting on July 14,' Hayes said. Monday's special meeting about strong-mayor powers was immediately followed by a second meeting about recruiting Haldimand's next CAO. Bentley called that meeting herself despite knowing she would not be there, as she had already met last week with Jon Stungevicius, a senior partner with Waterhouse Executive Search. Stungevicius said a committee consisting of Bentley and two councillors will lead the nine-week search for Haldimand's next CAO, with input from his firm and the county's human resources department. Candidates who make the final round of interviews would appear before all members of council. 'It's the mayor's process, but she does want to engage council and staff,' Stungevicius told councillors. That left O'Neill exasperated. 'I'm about to lose it over here,' he said, noting the mayor called the meeting the day before and then did not appear herself. Noting council 'had no input into what happened' to the last CAO, O'Neill was skeptical of Bentley's promise to get council's input before choosing Case's successor. 'This just feels like a slap in the face,' O'Neill said. Megan Jamieson, Haldimand's head of human resources, told councillors the cost to hire a professional recruiter to fill a senior position is typically 10 to 25 per cent of the new hire's annual salary. In Ontario, chief administrators make roughly $250,000 per year. Add in the severance payment to Case and the result of any lawsuit she may launch, and councillors are worried about the potential cost of Bentley flexing her strong-mayor powers. 'The county's looking at a very big bill,' Coun. Dan Lawrence said. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
Hamilton Spectator
14-07-2025
- Hamilton Spectator
Hamilton councillors balk at offering online voting in 2026 election
Some Hamilton councillors are balking at the idea of offering online voting during the upcoming Ward 8 byelection and the 2026 municipal election. A recommendation to consider offering online ballots as an alternative voting option was effectively voted down by a city committee this month on a 4-4 tie vote. But the idea can still be resurrected and debated at a full council meeting July 16. The city had previously authorized the use of online voting as an alternative during Ward 4's school board trustee byelection earlier this year. However, city councillors opposed to the idea raised the possibility of vote coercion, the cyberattack on the city last year — and concerns about trust in the election results. Coun. Jeff Beattie said he was originally 'bullish' on online voting — supporting the idea for the recent Ward 4 vote — but has since changed his stance, citing the cyberattack and a recent report that found 80 per cent of Hamiltonians lack trust in city hall . For his part, Coun. Brad Clark said he was opposed to the idea due to concerns about verifying and auditing the results of an online vote. While he admitted making voting accessible is important, he argued mail-in balloting provides some of that accessibility — and can be verified. City clerk Matthew Trennum told councillors even if the proposal had been approved as an alternative, there was no guarantee it would be used in a future election. He said the city's IT department would conduct an assessment on the system and decide if it was a safe, secure and feasible alternative before proceeding. Trennum added there were no concerns around voter coercion or fraud raised during the public school board trustee byelection and it met the 'extremely high threshold' IT staff had for the technology. 'Everything worked the way it was supposed to,' he said. Coun. Cameron Kroetsch spoke in favour of online balloting, adding he had heard from many Ward 2 residents with accessibility challenges who said the option would make it easier for them to vote. He added there isn't any evidence to support concerns around vote coercion or security threats. Coun. Tammy Hwang also spoke in favour of online voting, arguing it would provide convenience for residents. She noted the Association of Municipalities of Ontario did a roundup following the 2022 municipal elections and found 217 of 444 municipalities offered online voting. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
