
'Has he gone mad?': Ram Gopal Varma recalls Mani Ratnam's blunt reaction to changing Dil Se climax
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
In a recent interaction, filmmaker Ram Gopal Varma, who co-produced the film, revealed a fascinating behind-the-scenes conflict where he acted as a mediator between Ratnam and another producer, Bharat Shah.
The proposed alternate ending
RGV recalled that producer Bharat Shah was profoundly unhappy with Dil Se's poignant climax. Following the film's initial negative audience feedback, Shah even suggested a drastically different ending to Mani Ratnam.
Speaking on IndiaTV ShowBiz, RGV recounted Shah's exact proposition: "When Dil Se released and there was massive negative talk, initially Bharat Shah said that people didn't like Shah Rukh being killed.
He asked not to make it a tragedy. After the film released, he told me that we should cut the bomb blast scene. He said that the moment Shah Rukh and Manisha hug each other, we should switch to the 'Chaiya Chaiya' song.' Shah's intention was for the audience to perceive a happy ending if a popular song played after the lead characters embraced.
Mani Ratnam's blunt response
RGV, acting as the intermediary, conveyed Bharat Shah's unconventional suggestion to Mani Ratnam. He recalled the director's unequivocal and blunt reaction: "Mani told me, 'Has he gone mad or what? How can Shah Rukh hug Manisha and in the next moment imagine Malaika Arora.'" This humorous yet firm dismissal underscored Ratnam's commitment to his artistic vision for the film's tragic narrative.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
Dil Se concludes with Manisha Koirala's character, a suicide bomber, being embraced by her lover, played by Shah Rukh Khan, just as the bomb detonates, killing both of them.
The reason behind the unusual suggestion
During the interview, it was also revealed that Bharat Shah's unusual idea to end the film with 'Chaiya Chaiya' wasn't random. It stemmed from feedback he received directly from exhibitors. Apparently, a significant number of people purchase tickets primarily to watch the immensely popular 'Chaiya Chaiya' song, which plays approximately ten minutes into the film, and then leave the theatre shortly thereafter.
This practice caused financial issues for theatre owners, particularly impacting sales of snacks like popcorn, cola, and samosas. Exhibitors had reportedly suggested moving the hit song to a post-interval slot to encourage audiences to stay longer and boost concession sales.
Despite its initial box office challenges in India, Dil Se garnered positive reviews from critics and achieved significant success overseas, cementing its status as a cult classic.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Indian Express
11 minutes ago
- Indian Express
‘Raj Kapoor was reduced to dust after making Mera Naam Joker, spiralled into debt,' says Mahesh Bhatt: ‘Those were very trying times for him'
Veteran filmmaker Mahesh Bhatt has given several iconic films to Hindi cinema. In his 51-year-long career in the Hindi film industry, the filmmaker says he has come to understand that 'success is a fluke and failure is guaranteed' in the movie business. To illustrate his point, he cited the example of Raj Kapoor's career. In an interaction on The Himanshu Mehta Show, Mahesh recalled how Raj Kapoor went broke trying to bankroll his now-iconic film Mera Naam Joker (1970), but the film bombed at the box office. However, he eventually received his due three years later with Bobby, which saw immense success at the box office. He said, 'Raj Kapoor was reduced to dust when he made Mera Naam Joker, but the same Raj Kapoor when he made Bobby, the whole nation came to make him successful because they in a way felt guilty for seeing such a great filmmaker spiral into economic debt. Those were very trying times for him, and that is the same time I joined films. I have seen him in those vulnerable times. Failure is very difficult to take in our business.' Mahesh Bhatt went on to talk about his conversation with the late legendary filmmaker Yash Chopra and how they both agreed on the importance of speaking more openly about failures with their juniors. He recalled, 'I was talking to Yash Chopra about what we need to talk to a junior about — the certainty of failure. If you want to be in this business, you have to be certain that you will fail more often than succeed. Success is a fluke, failure is guaranteed, and yet you have to keep on going.' In an old interaction with Filmy Charcha, veteran actor Raza Murad also recalled an instance after Mera Naam Joker and how distributors abandoned Raj Kapoor. He shared, 'After Mera Naam Joker, he was in tremendous debt. Things got so bad that distributors refused to buy Bobby without seeing it first. These were the same people who were once desperate to secure the rights to his movies. But after Mera Naam Joker, everything changed. He refused to show them the movie, but he agreed to show them the songs.' Prem Chopra, who was a part of Bobby, had earlier spoken to Lehren about how Raj Kapoor had to sell everything after Mera Naam Joker. 'Raj Kapoor was finished! Unka sab kuch bik gaya (He was compelled to sell everything he had). Mera Naam Joker failed miserably at the box office. Raj saab was under a tremendous financial crisis. He not only mortgaged RK Studios but also had to sell off his family properties, but he didn't give up on his love for filmmaking,' he had said. However, he had the vision to come back with Bobby starring Rishi Kapoor and Dimple Kapadia. 'He made this beautiful film (Bobby) which I was also part of. It went on to become a massive success and two new stars were born — Rishi and Dimple. However, during the making of Bobby, it didn't feel he had encountered such a massive failure and continued making it with an equal amount of passion and love,' Chopra had said.


India.com
41 minutes ago
- India.com
Remember actress from Tere Naam who played role of a beggar? This is how she looks now, she works as...; Her name is...
Released in 2002, Tere Naam remains a milestone in Salman Khan's career. But tucked inside its emotional final act was a brief, gut-wrenching scene featuring a silent, beggar woman. That woman? Radhika Choudhary. She barely had screen time, but the weight of her presence left an unforgettable mark. Especially that last emotional exchange with Radhe (Salman), which many still remember. Where did she disappear after the film? While Radhika didn't chase Bollywood fame post-Tere Naam, her story quietly took a turn elsewhere. Though out of the limelight, she built her space in the South Indian film industry till 2004, and then took a 6-year break. What followed was unexpected: she moved to Los Angeles and reintroduced herself—not as an actress, but as a filmmaker. What made her an award-winning filmmaker? In 2010, she directed a short film titled Orange Blossom in LA, which explored the emotional complexity of a single mother navigating loneliness and misplaced trust. The film was shot in just four days and went on to win the Silver Ace Award at the Las Vegas Film Festival. Usha Kokate played the lead, alongside Jeff Doucette and John Paul Ouvrier. Did she ever return to mainstream cinema? Not in front of the camera. But in 2022, she took a significant step back into Hindi films as an executive producer for Aamir Khan's Laal Singh Chaddha. Quiet, but present. What is she doing now? Radhika, now known more in industry circles than among the masses, continues to work behind the scenes. She's active on Instagram, sharing slices of her current life. She's worked in multiple languages—Hindi, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada—and now, she's seen as a quiet powerhouse in the industry.


Time of India
43 minutes ago
- Time of India
Mumtaz: I am alive because of my husband
Veteran actress Mumtaz , known for her elegance and iconic roles in Hindi cinema, opened up about her deep bond with husband and business tycoon Mayur Madhvani, crediting him for being her constant through thick and thin, especially during her battle with cancer. 'I have known the Madhvani family since we were kids, they were neighbours,' she shared, speaking fondly of the man who's been her pillar for over three decades. 'My husband gives me everything. There is nothing that I don't have. He loves me so much. I never had a reason to leave him. He is a thorough gentleman, and he keeps me happy," she added. Getting candid about her health, Mumtaz said, 'Today I am alive because of my husband. When I was diagnosed with cancer, after I was operated on, he was the one to insist the doctors check my lymph nodes. And they did—and there was cancer. If he hadn't then…' Despite the years and the hardships, love continues to thrive between the two. 'We still go on dates. I am a very confident person. My husband still loves me so much,' she smiled. When asked if she ever considered returning to films, the actress was clear: 'Yaa toh majburi se kaam karta hai, but I don't have any majburi. My husband gives me everything. I don't have the majburi to go on screen.' Now preferring a quieter pace, she said, 'I'm getting tired of traveling. I live a very simple life. I don't make many friends."