Our smart cities are dumbing down
It's easy to launch a flashy new project. Way harder to keep it going. Despite grand makeovers and dutifully media-covered inaugurations, most cities have, to put it euphemistically, 'maintenance issues'. And as each monsoon reminds us, even so-called 'smart cities'. This week, Bengaluru and Pune, both ostensibly 'smart', were waterlogged after just a round of pre-monsoon showers, proof that smartness lies not in tech but in the dull discipline of upkeep.
In 2014, GoI announced 100 smart cities envisioned to use technology as the backbone to pre-empt and solve everyday challenges - from traffic snarls to urban flooding. But somewhere along the way, the goal shifted. Smart Cities Mission (SCM) became confined to renovating and retrofitting existing cities and providing basic facilities, such as housing, clean water, power and transport. Over the past decade, roughly 8,000 projects worth ₹1.64 lakh cr were sanctioned under SCM. The mission ended on March 31, but without clear answers about the future of SPVs, including integrated command and control centres (ICCCs), the nerve centre of these smart cities. These were set up in all 100 smart cities to enable real-time, data-driven decision-making.
To ensure continued maintenance of smart city assets, the parliamentary standing committee on housing and urban affairs rightly recommended that the ministry of housing and urban affairs (MoHUA) frame guidelines for SPVs to keep operating beyond the mission's end. But there has been no movement on this. Public money doesn't just need to be spent, it needs to work. Without a culture of upkeep and performance tracking, we'll keep rebuilding the same cities and assets every decade. This is as unsmart as it can get.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
6 hours ago
- Time of India
Viral truths
Covid's return not a big worry. But a case in Delhi HC shows what's worrying when it comes to outbreaks It is safe to assume that had Delhi HC not issued a notice to Centre for failing to present in court minimum standards for sample collection, most wouldn't have known that India has no SOP mandated for diagnostic labs. Protocols of course exist, but SOPs are not mandatory. This case has gained traction given the rise in Covid cases. Delhi HC sounded a note of caution. This is despite the fact that GOI, epidemiologists and medical fraternity all agree that given the endemicity of Covid and that almost 70% of the population is fully vaccinated, this round of Covid is little more than 'seasonal flu'. There is no cause for worry. But that is not to say now is not the time for the whole preparedness-shebang to kick in – from wearing masks to surveilling the spread with more testing. Cases are climbing, as are deaths. All deaths have been of those with Covid, not of Covid. Point is, India's burden of comorbidity is massive – diabetes to TB to COPD, chronic kidney disease, and cancer patients & survivors. Against this reality, it's hard to see why Union health ministry wasn't more proactive to Delhi HC's 2023 order to formulate minimum standards for sample collection. It is not about Covid alone. Our healthcare systems must brace for viral outbreaks at any point given the two major challenges today – a dizzying number of dangerous viruses (H5N1, dengue, chikungunya, Nipah, Zika are household terms) and antibiotic-resistant bacteria. Preparedness and quick response make healthcare systems more resilient. Govt estimates put Covid deaths at 5.3L. Lessons were learned. Every weak link in public health machinery was exposed. In the three years since, how many of these weaknesses have been fixed? Is surveillance better? Is the expanded virus research & diagnostic laboratory network fully equipped? Variant identification took a long time during the pandemic. Have we fixed that? Surveillance systems, healthcare infra and community engagement ensure public health. Covid may not be a threat, but as epidemiologist Gagandeep Kang put it: 'What we know we don't know is when, where and what our next disease outbreak will be.' An SOP for sample collection and transport seems to be the very least govt can do. Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email This piece appeared as an editorial opinion in the print edition of The Times of India.
Time of India
11 hours ago
- Time of India
Union min Tamta inspects key infra projects in Mizoram
Aizawl: Union minister of state for road transport and highways Ajay Tamta conducted a detailed assessment of infrastructure projects and public amenities in Mizoram during his recent state visit. The minister inspected the ongoing construction of a 100-metre arch bridge over the Tlawng River along the Aizawl-Lengpui airport route and NH-108 connecting Aizawl with Mamit district. He reviewed the progress with contractors and PWD officials, setting a completion deadline of Sept 2025. During his visit to the upcoming Sairang railway station site, he stressed the importance of rapid implementation to enhance regional transport links. At the planned Aizawl bypass location, Virender Jakhar, ED (Projects), RO Aizawl, provided a thorough presentation on the project's layout and essential features, designed to reduce traffic and improve urban movement. The western bypass construction is funded through PM-DevINE. According to MoRTH's press release, transport links have seen substantial improvement, with over 1,000 km of national highways developed, including 620 km completed by NHIDCL. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Giao dịch CFD với công nghệ và tốc độ tốt hơn IC Markets Đăng ký Undo In four years, NHIDCL has completed works worth over Rs 13,000 crore across these 620 km. Additionally, Rs 6,400 crore has been allocated for upcoming NHIDCL projects. The Aizawl-Tuipang Highway and Seling-Champhai Corridor have enhanced connections to Myanmar, Bangladesh, and neighbouring states including Assam, Tripura, and Manipur, facilitating commerce and transportation. Two significant bypasses are under construction in Aizawl — a 34.5-km eastern bypass under Bharatmala Pariyojana with a 2.4 km tunnel by NHIDCL costing Rs 2,300 crore, and a 45-km western bypass under PM-DevINE scheme worth Rs 500 crore by state PWD. Both projects target completion by 2028. Railway development gained momentum after 2014. Mizoram connected to the Broad Gauge network at Bhairabi in 2016. Aizawl will join the national railway network with the completion of the Bairabi-Sairang line, expected to operate by July. Sairang station's modernisation under the Amrit Bharat Scheme represents a significant milestone for regional connectivity. The housing sector has seen 48,000 homes constructed under PMAY. Aibawk town became India's first completed urban cluster, while Aizawl receives Rs 513 crore for development under Smart Cities Mission. JJM has provided tap water to over 1.24 lakh households. Healthcare access has expanded with 5.17 lakh Ayushman Bharat beneficiaries and 15 Jan Aushadhi Kendras. A State Medical College and Horticulture College are being established with Central support. A new 100-bed hospital at RIPANS will enhance tertiary healthcare. RIPANS, near Aizawl, serves northeast students in nursing, pharmacy, and paramedical programmes. Financial inclusion shows progress with 4 lakh Jan Dhan accounts, 53% held by women. PM Mudra Yojana has distributed Rs. 2,635 crore to 1.58 lakh beneficiaries, primarily SC/ST and women. PM SVANidhi supports 2,500 street vendors, with 8.8 lakh people covered under social security schemes. Economic growth continues through the Rs. 10,037 crore UNNATI 2024 scheme and increased tax allocation of Rs. 7,112 crore for 2025-26. Tourism receives Rs. 200 crore under Swadesh Darshan and PRASAD. Youth engagement occurs through Paryatan Mitra and Apna Radio 90.0 FM. Mizoram's development demonstrates the government's dedication to balanced regional growth. With central support, the state advances towards enhanced connectivity and prosperity.
Economic Times
22-05-2025
- Economic Times
Our smart cities are dumbing down
It's easy to launch a flashy new project. Way harder to keep it going. Despite grand makeovers and dutifully media-covered inaugurations, most cities have, to put it euphemistically, 'maintenance issues'. And as each monsoon reminds us, even so-called 'smart cities'. This week, Bengaluru and Pune, both ostensibly 'smart', were waterlogged after just a round of pre-monsoon showers, proof that smartness lies not in tech but in the dull discipline of upkeep. In 2014, GoI announced 100 smart cities envisioned to use technology as the backbone to pre-empt and solve everyday challenges - from traffic snarls to urban flooding. But somewhere along the way, the goal shifted. Smart Cities Mission (SCM) became confined to renovating and retrofitting existing cities and providing basic facilities, such as housing, clean water, power and transport. Over the past decade, roughly 8,000 projects worth ₹1.64 lakh cr were sanctioned under SCM. The mission ended on March 31, but without clear answers about the future of SPVs, including integrated command and control centres (ICCCs), the nerve centre of these smart cities. These were set up in all 100 smart cities to enable real-time, data-driven decision-making. To ensure continued maintenance of smart city assets, the parliamentary standing committee on housing and urban affairs rightly recommended that the ministry of housing and urban affairs (MoHUA) frame guidelines for SPVs to keep operating beyond the mission's end. But there has been no movement on this. Public money doesn't just need to be spent, it needs to work. Without a culture of upkeep and performance tracking, we'll keep rebuilding the same cities and assets every decade. This is as unsmart as it can get.
