What's at stake if we lose sanctuary city laws
Why it matters: The city and state are facing intense scrutiny from the Trump administration and a federal lawsuit for our local policies.
The issue will be thrust into a national spotlight Wednesday when Mayor Brandon Johnson defends the policies before the U.S. House oversight committee, along with mayors from Denver, Boston and New York.
Defining terms: Chicago's Welcoming City ordinance and Illinois' TRUST Act generally:
Prohibit local law enforcement from participating in federal immigration law, except when federal agents present a criminal warrant issued by a judge.
Bar police from arresting or holding anybody based on immigration status, an ICE warrant or a hold request.
Ensure that everyone, regardless of immigration status, can access city services including education, medical care and police protections.
These laws don't prohibit local law enforcement from arresting anyone suspected of violating state or local laws.
Sanctuary city supporters say removing protections would hurt the city, not just the individuals involved, because it would discourage local undocumented people from reporting crime and cooperating with police; going to school, work and doctors appointments; supporting businesses; and getting things like car insurance.
Yes, but: It's difficult to gauge how much school attendance has already been affected by recent threats.
A Chicago Public Schools official told Axios by phone the district doesn't have weekly and daily attendance information and the CPS FOIA officer also denied Axios' open records request for the data.
What they're saying: We'd likely see "emboldened ICE operations and explicit profiling, as well as increasing mistrust between immigrant communities and local police," Fred Tsao of the Illinois Coalition for Immigrant and Refugee Rights tells Axios.
"It would feed into an atmosphere of fear rather than being welcoming. That said, local police could still choose not to prioritize ICE cooperation, but if the feds require police to cooperate, local police won't have a choice."
Meanwhile, Ald. Ray Lopez wants to preserve the Welcoming City ordinance but with one amendment that allows the CPD to assist ICE in apprehending "individuals who choose to commit criminal acts," Lopez tells Axios.
"I think it would reduce crime, help communities feel safer, and take the bullseye off the undocumented community, as the Trump administration continues to go after dangerous non-citizens," he says.
"There's 100% focus on cities like Chicago because we refuse to do this, and that's putting everyone in a state of panic."
Reality check: The City Council failed to pass a measure that would have made that change earlier this year.
The other side: Republican Cook County Commissioner Sean Morrison wants sanctuary policies dropped entirely.
It "would benefit public safety and encourage more individuals here illegally to return to their home countries and follow the legal process for citizenship," he tells Axios.
"I do not believe it would discourage victims from speaking with law enforcement, as protections exist to ensure victims and witnesses can safely report crimes. Additionally, reducing school overcrowding and the financial strain on taxpayers — who are already supporting critical services for our own citizens — is not a bad thing."
What we're watching: How New York City's partial cooperation with the Trump administration on deportation issues affects Mayor Eric Adams' treatment at this week's hearings and funding to the city.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
26 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump set to announce replacement for Fed Gov Kugler this week. The Fed chair in waiting?
President Trump said he plans to name a replacement this week for Federal Reserve governor Adriana Kugler, whose unexpected resignation set for this Friday offers the president an opportunity to put in place a successor for Fed Chair Jerome Powell. 'I have a couple of people in mind,' President Trump told reporters Sunday night. 'I'll be announcing that probably over the next couple of days.' Kugler's term as a governor was set to expire on Jan. 31. She has served as a Fed governor since Sept. 13, 2023, and will return to Georgetown University as a professor this fall. Kevin Warsh, a former Fed governor, and Kevin Hassett, the current chair of the President's Council of Economic Advisors, are thought to be at the top of the list for the next Fed chair and thus possible nominees to replace Kugler. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, who is leading the search for Powell's replacement and is also a potential contender, has already sketched out a scenario where the White House appoints someone to fill Kugler's seat who can then be in the running to succeed Powell next May. The White House also hopes that Powell decides to leave the Fed Board of Governors when his chairmanship is up, which would open up a second seat that Trump can fill. Powell has not yet said whether he intends to do that; his term as a Fed governor is not up until 2028. Read more: How much control does the president have over the Fed and interest rates? Warsh already has a lot of experience navigating the central bank. He served as Fed governor from 2006 until 2011 and became former Fed Chair Ben Bernanke's liaison to Wall Street during the chaos of the 2008 financial crisis. He is also a known figure to Trump, who interviewed him for the Fed chair post eight years ago before deciding on Powell. Trump appointed Powell to be Fed chair in 2018 at the direction of then-Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin. Former President Joe Biden reappointed Powell in 2022. Warsh has been critical of the Fed as of late. He has suggested that the Fed could look through increases in inflation from tariffs because it would be a one-time increase in prices. He's also argued that the costs involved in renovating the Fed's headquarters represent one of several examples of how the Fed "has lost its way" and that the American people "need a reformer to fix" the institution and rebuild its credibility. "Frankly, it's about breaking some heads," he said on Fox Business last month, calling for "regime change." Back in April, Warsh gave a speech in Washington, D.C., in which he said that the Fed's "current wounds are largely self-inflicted" and called for a "strategic reset" to ease a loss of credibility and damage to the Fed's standing. Hassett, meanwhile, already has a close relationship with Trump, given that he advises the president on economic policy and also served in the first Trump administration. Read more: How jobs, inflation, and the Fed are all related Earlier in the year, Hassett said he was more focused on the 10-year Treasury yield (^TNX) than on any quick monetary policy changes at the Federal Reserve. While the Fed can influence short-term bond yields and long-term bond yields, longer-term bond yields are influenced by many factors outside the Fed, and it is the yield on the 10-year Treasury that influences mortgage rates. But lately, Hassett has been more blatant, saying there's no reason why the Fed shouldn't be cutting rates now, something the president has repeatedly hammered the central bank to do. The president will likely watch whoever he appoints to the open Fed governor position to see how they perform and whether they'd be a successor for Powell, whose term ends next May. Though Fed governors Chris Waller and Michelle Bowman are also jockeying for the position of Fed chair, in part by dissenting at last week's Fed policy meeting in favor of cutting rates by 25 basis points, rather than holding rates steady. The opportunity for the White House to fill Kugler's seat earlier than expected comes as Trump applies pressure on Powell and the Fed board to lower rates by as many as 3 percentage points. Whoever the president appoints, it is the Federal Open Market Committee, which is composed of 19 members, that makes the decision, not just the Fed chair, and the new chair will have to contend with the committee. Jennifer Schonberger is a veteran financial journalist covering markets, the economy, and investing. At Yahoo Finance she covers the Federal Reserve, Congress, the White House, the Treasury, the SEC, the economy, cryptocurrencies, and the intersection of Washington policy with finance. Follow her on X @Jenniferisms and on Instagram. Click here for in-depth analysis of the latest stock market news and events moving stock prices Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Newsweek
27 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Woman With Green Card Detained by ICE After 14 Years in US, Boyfriend Says
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. A Colombian immigrant and green-card holder who has lived in Oklahoma for more than a decade and has American children has been detained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), according to her boyfriend. Newsweek reached out to ICE via email for comment. A GoFundMe was recently created to help raise funds for legal fees pertaining to the detainment of Daniela Villada Restrepo, who lives in Oklahoma City and works in health care. She has three children, all born in the U.S. She is a lawful permanent resident, meaning she has a green card. Why It Matters Restrepo's case underscores more widespread concerns by immigrants and attorneys warning caution about potential arrest and detainment, even to those without criminal records. Newsweek could not verify whether Restrepo has any type of criminal background. President Donald Trump has pledged to launch the largest mass deportation operation in U.S. history, and immigrants residing in the country illegally and legally, with valid documentation such as green cards and visas, have been detained. Newsweek has reported dozens of cases involving green-card holders and applicants who were swept up in raids and various arrests. ICE agents detain immigrants and asylum seekers reporting for immigration court proceedings at the Jacob K. Javits Federal Building's U.S. Immigration Court in New York City on July 24, 2025. ICE agents detain immigrants and asylum seekers reporting for immigration court proceedings at the Jacob K. Javits Federal Building's U.S. Immigration Court in New York City on July 24, 2025. DOMINIC GWINN/Middle East Images/AFP via Getty Images What To Know According to her boyfriend, Scott Sperber, ICE agents detained Restrepo on April 12 when she missed a mandatory mental health court appointment, incurring a warrant. ICE records show that she is being held at the Prairieland Detention Center in Alvarado, Texas, which Sperber claims is unable to provide her mental health therapy. Her Facebook page says she is originally from Medellín, Antioquia, in Colombia. "Daniela has since been held in an ICE detention center located in Alvarado, Texas, unable to complete her mental health therapy," Sperber wrote on the GoFundMe page he started on July 23. "Prior to this detainment, Daniela has legally lived in America for almost 14 years. She was married to an American citizen for almost 10 years, and she has three children living in the United States that are American citizens." Newsweek reached out to Sperber via the GoFundMe page for comment. As of the afternoon of August 4, the page had received just two donations totaling $80. Sperber described his girlfriend as a "wonderful mother and wonderful companion who has had some trials in her life with abusive relationships. She has been fighting to heal and progress." She has worked for the Oklahoma State Health Department for nearly five years and as director of patient care services at The Bilingual Clinic PLLC, a business started by her ex-husband and father of her children. "She is bilingual and has always strived to help provide the best care for those here in America with language barriers," Sperber said. "She has a character that is caring and loving. Daniela wants, above all, to continue living here legally in the United States so she may care for her children and experience the joy of watching them grow up as any parent would." Daniela's Facebook and Instagram accounts use the name "Daniela Deweber," writing in a March post on Facebook: "Daniela Villada Restrepo is the name my parents gave me, Daniela Deweber is my married name." The GoFundMe was started by Sperber because of legal fees associated with Restrepo's hopeful release, as well as limited funds due to multiple health situations. What People Are Saying ICE, on X on August 4: "ICE is targeting illegal aliens, not law-abiding citizens." What Happens Next A lawyer has been hired in Restrepo's case. Sperber, who said he is just starting to recover financially following an automobile accident, is also his grandfather's sole caregiver. The grandfather receives medical treatment for skin cancer. "With all of these overbearing aspects of financial life at play, I do not have the adequate funds to pay for her legal fees, her awarded bond, nor to pay her attorney to continue the fight," Sperber said. "Also, I don't have adequate financial means to pay for all my grandfather's health-related financial obligations. "I am living day by day, one step at a time, and it has become so overwhelming I am finally choosing to ask for help."
Buzz Feed
28 minutes ago
- Buzz Feed
Marjorie Taylor Greene Just Dropped A Truth Bomb About The Republican Party
Marjorie Taylor Greene is NOT happy with the Republican Party. She was pissed about the attack on Iran. She broke ranks with Republicans and called the crisis in Gaza a "genocide." And she won't stop talking about how Republicans won't deal with the national debt. Now, she's talking about breaking up with the Republican Party. In an interview with the Daily Mail, the Congress member said: "I don't know if the Republican Party is leaving me, or if I'm kind of not relating to Republican Party as much anymore. I don't know which one it is." She also said: "I think the Republican Party has turned its back on America First and the workers and just regular Americans." And finally, she criticized the way Republicans treat women: "I think there's other women in our party that are really sick and tired of the way men treat Republican women." Those anti-GOP quotes are going viral in a tweet by Brian Tyler Cohen: People in the replies are, like, duh: "What if she switches parties and becomes a normie dem," one person asked. "I really never thought i'd see that day she was saying shit like this and uttering the word 'genocide'…" another person said in disbelief. And then the Lincoln Project invited her to the party: "Welcome to the resistance, Marge." As this person said, "Trumps presidency is so goddamn bad that it wokeified marjorie taylor green."
