Captain Cook memorial will not return to Melbourne park after repeated vandalism
The City of Yarra on Tuesday voted unanimously not to restore the memorial, which stood at the entrance to Edinburgh Gardens in Melbourne's inner north.
The granite monument was toppled and graffitied on the Australia Day long weekend and is now in council storage.
A council report found that it would cost about $15,000 to repair and reinstate after it was toppled and spray painted with the words 'cook the colony' last year.
More than $100,000 has been spent over the past 25 years to maintain the memorial.
The report described the memorial as of 'little or no significance' and said conservation work should be prioritised elsewhere. It also noted the memorial was 'contentious within the community and Cook is a contested figure in relation to First Peoples'. It also noted the memorial's 'poor condition and structural integrity'.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
It recommended against a $250,000 option to refabricate and reinstall the memorial 'including a truth-telling marker'.
Yarra's mayor Stephen Jolly said removing the memorial would eliminate the yearly maintenance costs.
'It's a waste of ratepayers' money,' Jolly told ABC Melbourne.
The memorial has been vandalised several times since 2018.
In 2020, the memorial's plaque featuring Cook's face was spray-painted, with the words 'shame' and 'remove this' scrawled beneath it.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
A similar statue of Captain Cook was hacked off at the ankles in St Kilda, and another statue of Queen Victoria near the city's Botanic Gardens was splattered with red paint on the eve of Australia Day, last year.
Jolly denied council was giving in to vandals.
'I don't think it's a good idea to destroy statues of people from the past … but we simply can't afford it,' he said.
'If we wanted to keep it there permanently, we would probably have to have security guards there (and more) lighting. I just don't think the locals want that.'
The Victorian premier, Jacinta Allan, described the vandalism of monuments as 'deeply disrespectful' and called for community division to end.
'It is disappointing,' she told reporters on Wednesday.
The bronze plaques, which belong to the memorial, are expected to be given to the Captain Cook Society, which celebrates the British explorer.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Fitzy & Wippa are over - but one already has a new gig: Plus, awkward moment between Sky News and the Guardian at 'journo Oscars' - and the ABC tries to bury story about 'missing' reporter: INSIDE MAIL
Insider on the outside? The ABC got shirty with us this week when we enquired about the whereabouts of Claudia Long - the young reporter who in May wrongly accused two Nationals MPs of abandoning their electorates during the floods.
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Worcestershire police investigate St George flags on roundabouts
A police investigation has been launched into criminal damage after roundabouts in Worcestershire were painted with the St George's mini roundabouts in the county, including in Bromsgrove, were painted after similar decorations popped up in neighbouring Birmingham. Hundreds of flags have also been tied around lampposts, which Worcestershire County Council, run by a Reform UK minority, said would Reform UK councillor Karl Perks described the "illegal painting of red crosses on local roundabouts" as "acts of vandalism". He added the practice, which has been supported by some residents, was "costing tax payers money"."As the cabinet member for highways for Worcestershire County Council, I will be seeking criminal damages so that every other tax payer in the county does not pay for this," Cllr Perks Mercia Police confirmed they were investigating the daubing of roundabouts in Monday, a video of a man painting a red cross onto a mini roundabout in the town circulated on social the video, a police car is seen pulling up to the man for a few seconds before driving Richard Field from the West Mercia force said: "Painting roundabouts is not only dangerous to drivers and pedestrians, but it also amounts to criminal damage. "We are working closely with partners, including Worcestershire County Council, to tackle this issue and investigate where appropriate." In Worcester, landscape gardener Tom Conway told BBC Radio Hereford and Worcester he believed he had put up about 400 flags in the city."The morale in the community seemed low and, ever since we did it, people have driven past and shown nothing but love and happiness," he Conway added he thought the UK should be more like the United States, and fly the flag proud. 'Heated debate' On Tuesday, Perks said climbing up lampposts and attaching flags to them "may not be the best thing to do, mostly because it's dangerous and could cause damage".He suggested people could show their pride by flying the flag in their gardens, on cars, in home windows and on "community buildings where agreed by the whole community".He said, however, there was no specific plan to take the flags down. Ed Kimberley, who is a Labour Worcester City councillor for Warndon and Elbury Park, said he had been contacted by residents who disagreed with the flags."Is this a positive message of patriotism or is it something more sinister?" he said."If it is a message of positivity, then why is the debate heated?" Follow BBC Hereford & Worcester on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
The Guardian
5 hours ago
- The Guardian
Afternoon Update: Israel diplomatic row deepens; Lehrmann a ‘national joke', court told; and the agony of a software update
Good afternoon. Australia's government has rejected Benjamin Netanyahu's incendiary criticism and accused some Israeli politicians of 'bigoted' views about Palestinians, as the extraordinary political fight between the two nations turns uglier. The federal government's refusal of a travel visa for the far-right Knesset member Simcha Rothman stoked criticism from the Israeli prime minister, who labelled Anthony Albanese a 'weak politician' who had 'abandoned Australia's Jews'. 'Strength is not measured by how many people you can blow up or how many children you can leave hungry,' the home affairs minister, Tony Burke, told Radio National on Wednesday. 'Strength is much better measured by exactly what [Albanese] has done, which is when there's a decision that we know Israel won't like, he goes straight to Benjamin Netanyahu.' On Wednesday afternoon, Albanese said he wouldn't take Netanyahu's comments personally. 'I engage with people diplomatically. [Netanyahu] has had similar things to say about other leaders.' Bruce Lehrmann has become a 'national joke' and can't afford barrister for defamation appeal, his lawyer says Children with autism to be diverted off NDIS under $2bn federal program Victoria's urgent childcare review recommendations unveiled: major reforms but no 'silver bullet' to stop 'dangerous individuals' French prosecutors investigating death of man during live stream Microsoft workers occupy HQ in protest at company's ties to Israeli military Why is the NZ government cutting Māori words from some school books? Recent media coverage claims that 'Australians, especially men, are reading less' and 'young men have stopped reading books'. But is that true? Guardian Australia's data editor, Nick Evershed, does a deep dive into whether that claim is backed up by the numbers. 'Liam's smashing it. I'm proud of him … I couldn't do the stadium thing like he does it, it's not in my nature. But I've got to say, I kind of look and I think, 'Good for you mate.' He's been amazing.' – Noel Gallagher Noel Gallagher has opened up about his feelings towards his long-estranged brother Liam during Oasis' sold-out global reunion tour for the first time. Fifteen years after their acrimonious split, Gallagher said it was 'great being back in the band with Liam, I forgot how funny he was'. Zelenskyy suits up for peace but can Trump deliver? Six months after their explosive meeting in the White House, Volodymyr Zelenskyy once again met Donald Trump in Washington. But this time the Ukrainian president arrived with the support of key European leaders, who dropped everything in the hopes of securing a potential deal to end the war with Russia. Washington bureau chief David Smith speaks to Nour Haydar about whether Europe's united front managed to steer Trump away from the Kremlin, what chance is left of a ceasefire and how Trump welcomed Vladimir Putin back on to the world stage. Listen to the episode here Sign up to Afternoon Update Our Australian afternoon update breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $ The promise of forced software patches is that they improve the software and apps we use every day – make them more convenient, maintain our security and so on. But what actually happens most of the time, writes Patrick Lum, is that updates change perfectly fine tech to the point where it sucks. Australian Book Week is here – and we'd love to see your children's costumes The highlight of Book Week for many kids is the chance to dress up as their most beloved characters, bringing them to life from the pages of a favourite book and into a costume parade. The annual event, which promotes literacy, is celebrating 80 years as part of Australian school life – and we'd love to see the weirdest, wackiest and most wonderful costumes. Today's starter word is: BOOT. You have five goes to get the longest word including the starter word. Play Wordiply. If you would like to receive this Afternoon Update to your email inbox every weekday, sign up here, or start your day with a curated breakdown of the key stories you need to know with our Morning Mail newsletter. You can follow the latest in US politics by signing up for This Week in Trumpland.
