US judge sides with Meta in AI training copyright case
District Court Judge Vince Chhabria in San Francisco ruled that Meta's use of the works to train its AI model was "transformative" enough to constitute "fair use" under copyright law, in the second such courtroom triumph for AI firms this week.
However, it came with a caveat that the authors could have pitched a winning argument that by training powerful generative AI with copyrighted works, tech firms are creating a tool that could let a sea of users compete with them in the literary marketplace.
"No matter how transformative (generative AI) training may be, it's hard to imagine that it can be fair use to use copyrighted books to develop a tool to make billions or trillions of dollars while enabling the creation of a potentially endless stream of competing works that could significantly harm the market for those books," Chhabria said in his ruling.
Tremendous amounts of data are needed to train large language models powering generative AI.
Musicians, book authors, visual artists and news publications have sued various AI companies that used their data without permission or payment.
AI companies generally defend their practices by claiming fair use, arguing that training AI on large datasets fundamentally transforms the original content and is necessary for innovation.
"We appreciate today's decision from the court," a Meta spokesperson said in response to an AFP inquiry.
"Open-source AI models are powering transformative innovations, productivity and creativity for individuals and companies, and fair use of copyright material is a vital legal framework for building this transformative technology."
In the case before Chhabria, a group of authors sued Meta for downloading pirated copies of their works and using them to train the open-source Llama generative AI, according to court documents.
Books involved in the suit include Sarah Silverman's comic memoir "The Bedwetter" and Junot Diaz's Pulitzer Prize–winning novel "The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao," the documents showed.
"This ruling does not stand for the proposition that Meta's use of copyrighted materials to train its language models is lawful," the judge stated.
"It stands only for the proposition that these plaintiffs made the wrong arguments and failed to develop a record in support of the right one."
- Market harming? -
A different federal judge in San Franciso on Monday sided with AI firm Anthropic regarding training its models on copyrighted books without authors' permission.
District Court Judge William Alsup ruled that the company's training of its Claude AI models with books bought or pirated was allowed under the "fair use" doctrine in the US Copyright Act.
"Use of the books at issue to train Claude and its precursors was exceedingly transformative and was a fair use," Alsup wrote in his decision.
"The technology at issue was among the most transformative many of us will see in our lifetimes," Alsup added in his decision, comparing AI training to how humans learn by reading books.
The ruling stems from a class-action lawsuit filed by authors Andrea Bartz, Charles Graeber, and Kirk Wallace Johnson, who accused Anthropic of illegally copying their books to train chatbot Claude, the company's ChatGPT rival.
Alsup rejected Anthropic's bid for blanket protection, ruling that the company's practice of downloading millions of pirated books to build a permanent digital library was not justified by fair use protections.
gc/jgc
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
eNCA
9 hours ago
- eNCA
'Call of Duty' to fire starting gun at Gamescom trade show
Mega-selling first-person shooter franchise "Call of Duty" will blow open the Gamescom video games trade fair Tuesday, headlining a wave of new releases as the industry weathers a rough patch. Around 5,000 people, including game publishers, developers and fans, will attend the evening launch ceremony, before hundreds of thousands of gamers descend on the western German city of Cologne later in the week. Canadian TV presenter Geoff Keighley will from 8:00 pm (1800 GMT) introduce titles including "Call of Duty: Black Ops 7", one of two dozen instalments in the long-running series, as part of a two-hour showreel of the industry's upcoming blockbuster productions. After a business and press day on Wednesday, Gamescom's doors will be flung open until Sunday to bring around 1,500 exhibitors together with swarms of fans, some of them dressed in elaborate costumes painstakingly drawn from the screens of their favourite titles. While last year's event drew 335,000 visitors, organisers hope 2025 can bring it back to pre-Covid levels of around 370,000. "We'll only know on the final day how many actually visited, but... the first day is sold out, all indicators are in the green," Felix Falk, managing director of Germany's GAME industry association that co-organises Gamescom, told AFP ahead of opening day. - Hands-on time - One of the major draws to the vast halls of the Koelnmesse convention centre is the opportunity for hands-on time with the feast of the latest releases at the vast stands laid on by major firms. Nintendo is back after staying away last year, surfing on the success of its record-breaking Switch 2 console launch earlier this year. And Microsoft's Xbox division will be showing off its own portable console, slated for release towards the end of the year. But Japanese PlayStation maker Sony has elected to stay away in 2025. Among the hotly anticipated games unveiled this edition are new episodes of horror sagas "Silent Hill" and "Resident Evil". Indie hit "Hollow Knight" will get a sequel with "Silksong" after an eight-year wait, while Nintendo is cooking up "Metroid Prime 4", following up the beloved science-fiction action series. Exhibitors may be less ecstatic than fans at this year's Gamescom as the industry endures an extended rough patch. "The sector hasn't had an easy time of it in the last two years, there was a lot of consolidation, job cuts, some studios closed, some projects were ended prematurely," Falk said. "That's not unusual for the highly dynamic games industry but it's nevertheless not pretty when it happens," he added. Tracking website Game Industry Layoffs has tallied almost 30,000 job cuts since early 2023, with more than 4,000 this year alone. But revenue in the global games market should hold steady at just under $190 billion this year, data firm Newzoo has forecast. By Kilian Fichou And Tom Barfield
Daily Maverick
10 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
AI job threats – graduates at risk, not call centre agents
As it turns out, South Africa's call centres are not a bastion for John Connor's resistance against AI. Instead, Judgement Day is coming for our graduates and young professionals. In the first three months of 2025 the graduate unemployment rate in South Africa increased by three percentage points over the final quarter of 2024. This means that, according to the latest statistics, 11.7% of university graduates are unemployed – just shy of the 11.8% peak in the same period in 2023 that Hannah MacGinty noted in a master's degree submission at Stellenbosch University. The entry-level job market is currently the front line of a war between humans and machines. Young people are pouring out of tertiary institutions, waving their degrees proudly, and AI is the Maxim gun. It's so bad that Geoffrey Hinton, the so-called Godfather of AI, told Steven Bartlett that mass job displacement is 'more probable than not,' advising young people to consider trades like plumbing on a recent episode of the Diary of a CEO podcast. Reports suggest that AI could wipe out half of all entry-level white-collar jobs in the next five years. Call centres remain on those high-risk lists, but are staging a fierce resistance. Augmentation, not annihilation Leaders in the country's R120-billion business process outsourcing (BPO) industry don't see AI as an existential threat, but as a tool that can make their companies more competitive and expand opportunities for young people if deployed with care. 'Our philosophy was never to say, oh, we see this as some massive disruptor that's going to turn the whole industry upside down,' says Mervyn Pretorius, group chief technology officer at CCI, the continent's biggest contact centre player. 'It should multiply your output. It should not be your output.' That's the 'human-in-the-loop' philosophy CCI runs on. His local CTO colleague, Cobus Pretorius, explains from the company's in-country base in Umhlanga that while generative models are exciting, they're simply not robust enough for the messy reality of serving global clients across dozens of platforms. 'You can't just plug an AI into an airline account that has 27 different systems and expect it to work. It'll break very quickly,' he says. 'Most of our calls are high-emotion, high-complexity,' Mervyn explains. 'That's where humans matter most.' Cobus adds that, far from cutting jobs, AI has been a 'net contributor' so far: 'It's creating demand for prompt engineers, reviewers, people building dashboards. We're training for roles that don't even exist yet.' What this means for you Youth looking to start studying or enter the job market need to review their skill set with an eye on the future. According to ChatGPT, these are examples of skills that are likely to be in demand: AI tools navigation: Understanding AI chatbots, speech analytics, and customer relationship management integrated AI tools. Data interpretation: Using AI-generated insights to anticipate customer needs or identify trends. Automation management: Knowing when to intervene when AI fails or escalates a query. A growing force Bruce von Maltitz, CEO of 1Stream, which builds customer experience (CX) technology for more than 100 local clients, echoes that view. 'I have not seen any decrease in volumes. None of our South African customers are cutting jobs because of AI,' he says. That's because, in his experience, when things get personal or complex (think health issues, travel bookings or big purchases) people still want to talk to people. 'The complex work is still going to the agent.' He points out that AI is not cheap to build. Large corporates are investing millions, and those projects 'are net creators of jobs because they need sophisticated teams of people.' His company is working to make those tools 'affordable in rands' so that South African firms can participate in the transformation. Von Maltitz describes CX as the entire journey of interaction with a business, from discovery to after-sales service. AI allows businesses to anticipate and smooth that journey. 'South African consumers expect more from technology. They're pushing the boundaries all the time,' he says. Arming young people The global BPO market is growing strongly, from more than $300-billion this year to a projected $800-billion by 2034. Instead of decline, the sector is shifting from cheap labour arbitrage to higher-value, AI-enabled services. South Africa is well placed. With 20 years of deliberate investment, the country has carved out a niche as a hub for complex, emotionally nuanced customer service. Industry leaders say that empathy, humour and cultural resonance give South African agents a premium edge over cheaper transactional markets. Government incentives and programmes like CCI's CareerBox NGO, which recruits and trains unemployed young people, reinforce the industry's social licence. So, if AI isn't the clear and present danger, what is? The consensus from local leaders is that the Keep Call Centres in America Act of 2025 is a far bigger threat to South African jobs than AI itself. The legislation, currently before US legislators, would: Create a public blacklist of companies that offshore more than 30% of call centre work; Penalise noncompliance with fines of up to $10,000 a day; Restrict federal grants and loans for five years for any company on the list; Require call centre agents to declare their location at the start of every call, with US customers entitled to demand a domestic transfer; and Force companies to disclose when AI, rather than a human, is handling their service. Von Maltitz says the impact could be profound, even if the law isn't fully enforceable. 'Americans and Europeans don't want to do these jobs. But if this passes, companies will have to retool and find an answer. Not because it's a better answer, just because they need an answer.' The reputational risk is just as serious. A US bank listed as outsourcing to Cape Town could face consumer backlash, no matter the quality of the service. Advanced strategy The call centre industry's response to AI may serve as a template for how other sectors can navigate technological disruption. By focusing on human-AI collaboration rather than human-AI competition, these companies are not just surviving the AI revolution – they're leading it. That makes the real question not whether AI will change the nature of work, because it already has. We should be asking whether other industries will follow the BPO sector's lead in treating that change as an opportunity for elevation rather than elimination. For young South Africans entering the job market the takeaway is that while jobs of the future will still require humans, they will need different skills. The key is ensuring that our education systems, our companies and our policies are aligned to make that future as inclusive as possible. DM
eNCA
12 hours ago
- eNCA
Brazil asks Meta to remove chatbots that 'eroticize' children
Brazil's government has asked US technology giant Meta to rid its platforms of chatbots that mimic children and can make sexually suggestive remarks, the attorney general's office (AGU) announced Monday. Users of Meta's platforms, which include Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp, can create and customize such bots using the company's generative artificial intelligence, AI Studio. The AGU said in a statement that Meta must "immediately" remove "artificial intelligence robots that simulate profiles with childlike language and appearance and are allowed to engage in sexually explicit dialogue." It denounced the "proliferation" of such bots in what it called an "extrajudicial notice" sent to Meta last week, adding that they "promote the eroticization of children." The document cited several examples of sexually charged conversations with bots pretending to be minors. The AGU's request does not include sanctions, but the agency said it had reminded Meta that online platforms in Brazil must take down illicit content created by their users, even without a court order. It comes at a time of outrage in the South American nation over a case of alleged child sexual exploitation by Hytalo Santos, a well-known influencer who posted content on Instagram featuring partially naked minors taking part in suggestive dances. Santos was arrested last week as part of an investigation into "exposure with sexual connotations" to adolescents, and his Instagram account is no longer available.
