Chair Refuses To Apologise, Rejects Use Of ‘Kia Ora' In Council Email
Mataura catchment liaison committee chair Hugh Gardyne has also rejected the use of 'kia ora' in an email reprimanding him for his actions.
The committee Gardyne oversees is one of eight in the region that supports Environment Southland with local river work.
In May, Gardyne gave a blunt presentation to councillors, alleging catchment management was in "a state of paralysis" under the watch of the council chief executive and that communication was ineffective with the general manager in charge.
He was shut down at the end of his talk, when he mentioned an abatement notice later revealed to be one issued by Environment Southland against itself.
A letter from Environment Southland chair Nicol Horrell on 28 May warned Gardyne of his behaviour, saying parts of his presentation were factually incorrect and disrespectful.
"My intention is both to correct your understanding of the facts, and to inform you that councillors will not tolerate any criticism levelled at staff in public meetings or disrespectful behaviour," Horrell wrote.
He added it was incorrect to suggest catchment work was in a state of paralysis and accused Gardyne of not having all the facts.
"I would be interested to know from where you are getting your information."
The letter ended with a suggestion that Gardyne apologise to the chief executive and manager in question, but Gardyne has defended his actions, saying his criticism was about questioning professional ability.
"It doesn't, in my opinion, deserve a response or an apology."
Gardyne said he would speak at council again in the future and the response from the general manager had been "great", following the presentation.
Separately, he also took exception with the use of 'kia ora' in the email sent by Horrell, which delivered the reprimanding letter.
Gardyne requested he instead be addressed with 'hello' or 'dear'.
Horrell told Local Democracy Reporting using the te reo Māori greeting was commonplace and he didn't think its use would be Gardyne's biggest issue.
"I would have thought that that's almost a wee bit racist."
In a letter back to Horrell, Gardyne doubled down on perceived issues with river management and questioned whether the chair's concerns were shared by other members.
Environment Southland oversees eight catchment liaison committees, which help the council develop annual maintenance programmes and budgets, as well as provide a local point of contact.
Gardyne has been involved with the Mataura group since the early 1990s.
Last month, the council said it was working to improve communication with its catchment committees.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
Should Māori born overseas automatically be NZ citizens? Father fights for children classed as illegal overstayers
John Bryers Ruddock pictured with his children, who are 8, 9 and 12. Photo: John Bryers Ruddock / Supplied The descendant of a Treaty signatory, All Black and " the voice of New Zealand" is fighting for Māori to have automatic New Zealand citizenship. John Bryers Ruddock (Ngāpuhi), recently returned to Aotearoa to live with his three children - ages 8, 9 and 10. But, he was born in Australia and all three of his children were born in Hawaii. As a result, he was now navigating an expensive process to get his tamariki recognised as New Zealand citizens. Despite their whakapapa including a number of famous New Zealanders - their great grandfather was All Black Ron Bryers, their grandmother was celebrated singer Rhonda Bryers, known as "the voice of New Zealand" and their great great grandfather was an original signatory to Te Tiriti, the children were technically overstayers and unable to attend school. Bryers Ruddock told Checkpoint , he had asked for a Waitangi Tribunal hearing to discuss the issue and wanted to see some kind of intervention. He said having his children being labelled as overstayers was not something as a father he wanted to put them through. "It's red tape after red tape," he said. "It's been a costly process so far, I have to finalise the court orders, so still dealing with that, I've spent over $17,000 so far." Bryers Ruddock said he wanted the tribunal to look at his case and change the policy around citizenship for people of Māori descent who were born overseas. "I just feel, you know, my mum was an ambassador for this country and culture... it's something I want to do for our people." Bryers Ruddock said he had sent in an application for the children to get citizenship under Section 61 of the Immigration Act, which allowed Immigration NZ to issue visas in special circumstances, and was waiting for a sponsor to help him get either a student visa or residency. The treaty claim had been lodged by Hastings law firm Manaia Legal, he said. John Bryers Raddock and his three children recently moved to Wellington. Photo: John Bryers Ruddock / Supplied Minister of Internal Affairs, Brooke van Velden, said in a statement provided to Checkpoint, she was not looking to change the citizen act and said the requirements of citizenship applied to all applicants equally. "The outcomes depend on the information provided for each case not the ethnicity of the applicant." The minister had the discretion to grant citizenship to people who didn't meet requirements bur had exceptional circumstances. Van Velden's office said it had not yet received an application about Bryers Ruddock's children and they needed to go through the application process with internal affairs first. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Otago Daily Times
12 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
High Court case and contentious letterbox drop: Who is Andrew Clark?
An Invercargill mayoral candidate says he is still fit for office despite past events landing him in the headlines and court. Andrew Clark is contesting the position currently held by his brother Nobby, in a move which has surprised and irked his older sibling. In Tasman, where Clark currently lives, he is also running for mayor under the first name Maxwell. The business owner made headlines for a range of incidents following the early 2000s including a land dispute, receiving money from a gang-affiliated event and spreading misinformation through pamphlets. Clark said he gave a lot of voluntary help to people and the issues were 'out of perspective' compared to what normal life had been for a long time. 'We've dealt with everything that comes up in a fair and reasonable basis, and I don't see any issue there whatsoever." In 2004, Clark faced legal action after the purchase of a neighbouring estate went awry. Problems arose when Clark and his partner presented a written agreement which was signed by all parties, only to be later contested for not reflecting the verbal agreement. The elderly neighbour - a trustee - said it was clear they were retaining the house and a parcel of land, but Clark and his partner maintained the $300,000 price tag included everything. Judge Ronald Young said in his judgement he did not find Clark to be 'a credible witness at all'. 'I had the distinct impression throughout his evidence that if he had no recollection of a proposition he was prepared to construct the happening and timing of it to suit himself,' Young wrote. He believed Clark knew he was getting a 'remarkable bargain' at $300,000 - a figure which was at least 50% under market value - and ordered the written contract be corrected. Clark told Local Democracy Reporting the neighbour "begged" them to buy the property with the sale only falling through after the other party pulled out thinking they could get more. He said the judge did not like him and he would have challenged the court ruling if he had money at the time. 'Very unfortunate. I'm very saddened by it all... I wish I could undo what had happened, but that's not possible.' Between 2012 and 2018, Clark was linked in media reports to a controversial Nelson biking event called Poker Run. Stuff reported the event was traditionally run by motorcycle gang associates with money raised going towards Clark's ambulance business Medimax. The events were monitored by police. Clark is still running Medimax and confirmed it operates as a business, not a charity. There were never any problems with the motorcycle group, which was charged like any other organisation, he said. 'These people, whether it's liked or not liked, they live in the community, they work in the community. 'For us it was just a professional role, do a professional job. That's all that was.' In 2018, Clark featured in a 1News bulletin as the man behind a pamphlet drop warning of a potential 8-metre tidal wave if the proposed Waimea Dam failed. Two thousand leaflets were distributed in Brightwater - a move labelled 'dirty and sneaky' by then-Nelson MP Nick Smith. Former Tasman mayor Richard Kempthorne said a catastrophic failure would see water going through houses at levels between 50cm and 100cm. Clark confirmed to Local Democracy Reporting he personally delivered the brochures and said he was just trying to share a risk which he thought hadn't been fully considered. The information included contact details for elected representatives. Clark is one of eight candidates contesting the Invercargill mayoralty this year and said he would move south, if elected. He will be in attendance the Southland Business Chamber mayoral debate on Tuesday. • LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air
RNZ News
12 hours ago
- RNZ News
A High Court case and contentious letterbox drop: Who is Andrew Clark?
Nelson-based Andrew Clark is running for mayor of Invercargill while simultaneously going for the top job in Tasman. Photo: LDR / Matthew Rosenberg An Invercargill mayoral candidate says he is still fit for office, despite past events landing him in both the headlines and court. Andrew Clark is contesting the position currently held by his brother Nobby, in a move which has surprised and irked his older sibling. In Tasman, where Clark currently lives, he is also running for mayor under the first name Maxwell. The business owner made headlines for a range of incidents since the early 2000s including a land dispute, receiving money from a gang affiliated event, and spreading misinformation through pamphlets. Clark said he gave a lot of voluntary help to people, and the issues were "out of perspective" compared to what normal life had been for a long time. "We've dealt with everything that comes up in a fair and reasonable basis, and I don't see any issue there whatsoever," he said. In 2004, Clark faced legal action after the purchase of a neighbouring estate went awry. Problems arose when Clark and his partner presented a written agreement which was signed by all parties, only to be later contested for not reflecting the verbal agreement. The elderly neighbour - a trustee - said it was clear they were retaining the house and a parcel of land, but Clark and his partner maintained the $300,000 price tag included everything. Judge Ronald Young said in his judgement he did not find Clark to be "a credible witness at all". "I had the distinct impression throughout his evidence that if he had no recollection of a proposition he was prepared to construct the happening and timing of it to suit himself," Young wrote. He believed Clark knew he was getting a "remarkable bargain" at $300,000 - a figure which was at least 50 percent under market value - and ordered the written contract be corrected. Clark told Local Democracy Reporting the neighbour "begged" them to buy the property with the sale only falling through after the other party pulled out thinking they could get more. He said the judge did not like him and he would have challenged the court ruling if he had money at the time. "Very unfortunate. I'm very saddened by it all... I wish I could undo what had happened, but that's not possible." Between 2012 and 2018, Clark was linked in media reports to a controversial Nelson biking event called Poker Run. Stuff reported the event was traditionally run by motorcycle gang associates with money raised going towards Clark's ambulance business Medimax. The events were monitored by police. Clark is still running Medimax, and confirmed it operates as a business and not a charity. There were never any problems with the motorcycle group, which was charged like any other organisation, he said. "These people, whether it's liked or not liked, they live in the community, they work in the community. "For us it was just a professional role, do a professional job. That's all that was." In 2018, Clark featured in a 1News bulletin as the man behind a pamphlet drop warning of a potential eight-metre tidal wave if the proposed Waimea Dam failed. Two thousand leaflets were distributed in Brightwater, a move labelled "dirty and sneaky" by then-Nelson MP Nick Smith. Former Tasman mayor Richard Kempthorne said a catastrophic failure would see water going through houses at levels between 50cm and 100cm. Clark confirmed to Local Democracy Reporting he personally delivered the brochures and said he was just trying to share a risk which he thought hadn't been fully considered. The information included contact details for elected representatives. Clark is one of eight candidates contesting the Invercargill mayoralty this year and said he would move south if elected. He will be in attendance at Tuesday's Southland Business Chamber mayoral debate. * LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air
