Insurance co, docs told to pay Rs 3L to woman after C-section trauma
Ghaziabad: The district consumer disputes redressal commission (DCDRC) directed an insurance company to pay Rs 2.8 lakh to a patient who underwent a caesarean section at a local hospital in 2014 but faced severe complications due to doctors' negligence. The commission also ordered the doctors to pay Rs 20,000 as damages for physical and mental trauma, besides the cost of litigation.The petitioner, Varsha Singh, informed the commission that she was in labour when doctors Santosh Agrawal and Vinita Agrawal left her in that condition for three hours to take part in a marriage ceremony. The victim alleged that the delay in attending to her resulted in complications, forcing her to undergo a caesarean section for delivery at the Shyam Hospital, Ghaziabad. Her condition, however, deteriorated over time, and she remained under treatment for over a month, the woman told the commission.The woman informed the forum that persistent abdominal pain and bloating forced the family to consult another doctor at Madhu Nursing Home in Meerut on August 13, 2015.Upon checkup, it was found that a sponge was left inside her stomach at the time of delivery, causing septic infection of the intestine."When the abdominal pain and bloating did not subside, we consulted another doctor, who diagnosed a sponge left in my stomach that resulted in a septic infection of the intestine," Singh informed the commissionProducing records of the hospital bills and reated documents, Singh informed the commission that she underwent another surgery to remove a part of her intestine and clean the infection.Taking note of the evidence and medical records produced, chairman of the commission, Praveen Kumar Jain, decided in favour of the petitioner and held New India Assurance Company Limited accountable for payment of the entire sum on behalf of the erring doctors, as Shyam Hospital was fully insured by the insurance company.Not only the commission held the doctors responsible for showing medical negligence, the forum also rejected the insurance company's argument that they were not informed at the time of admission of the patient and that it violated section 8.1 of policy."The petitioners have made the insurance company a party in the case, which is sufficient to hold that the company was informed well within the time," stated the commission in its order.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
36 minutes ago
- Mint
Experts call for tracking source, transmission of new covid cases
There is a greater need to understand the transmission of the new covid wave, a disease control expert said, at a time when the number of cases in the country is inching closer to 5,000. Communities were flu-like symptoms lead to a rush of covid-19 hospitalizations need an epidemiological investigation—a process to figure out how it spreads and stop the transmission—according to Dr. Sujeet Singh, who led the National Centre for Disease Control (NCDC) during the pandemic outbreak five years ago. This will uncover transmission dynamics, trends among hospitalized cases and epidemiological profile of cases, besides assessment of morbidity and associated severity, Singh said in an interview. 'There has been a recent rise in covid cases in Singapore, Hongkong, Korea and some other countries. In India also, there has been a substantial rise in the last fortnight. The rise from 257 cases around 25 May to over 3,900 cases on 1 June, 2025 points to increased transmission,' said Singh, former NCDC director. He added that at present, the strategy of test, track and treat should be aimed at understanding the current scenarios, particularly in states where rise is being seen. On Thursday, India registered a 4866 active covid-19 cases, as per health ministry data. As many as seven deaths were reported in the previous 24 hours, two each in Delhi, Karnataka and three from Maharashtra. The total number of deaths have climbed to 51 since 1 January 2025. India's latest covid wave is caused by two new coronavirus variants, NB.1.8.1 and LF.7, mutations of the Omicron offspring JN.1 variant. 'Concerns over the sharp spike of covid-19 cases in India can be due to increased testing in influenza-like illnesses (ILI) or acute respiratory infection (ARI) cases. Testing can be focused in hospitalized ILI cases. Thereafter, the communities from where increased admission of ILI cases (which are covid-19 positive) need to be further epidemiologically investigated. The mortality in high-risk elderly population and persons with co-morbidities also needs to be investigated,' he said. The health ministry has directed all states and union territories to ensure health preparedness measures across health facilities to control the transmission of the infection. Assessment of oxygen supply system is being done in hospitals as part of the health preparedness measure. Dr. Chandrakant Lahariya, a public health expert, said that while there is fairly good understanding of SARS CoV2 virus to make inferences, it would be worthwhile for the government to regularly release epidemiological data of covid-19 cases. 'As of now, We don't know from where these covid-19 cases are being reported, what are their distribution patterns, do they have co-morbidities. The government should put data for epidemiological analysis to understand severity and pattern of the disease. The covid-19 virus has become mild to milder and people should not panic due to the spike in the covid. Furthermore, there should be a better communication approach and bring in more science and epidemiology while discussing on covid-19,' said Dr. Lahariya. Meanwhile, the government has advised the public to practise hand hygiene, cough etiquette, and avoid crowded places when unwell. The health ministry has noted that individuals with acute respiratory illness should self-monitor and seek medical care if symptoms worsen. According to Dr. Raman Gangakhedkar, a former scientist at the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) and currently national chair at ICMR, right now, India's surveillance strategy should focus more on hospitalization and death rates. 'The number of cases being reported in the country is not important unless we know whether the hospitalization and deaths rated are increasing. The number of cases increases if one tests more and more people. These absolute numbers are of limited value as this is a mild infection. Rather, these covid numbers create panic in the people. And if, the hospitalization and death rates increase, sequencing those samples to see whether the virus has mutated or is the circulating variant will help design an appropriate strategy further. If it is an old omicron strain, then there is nothing to worry but, if it is a new strain, then measures need to be taken.' Covid has become endemic, but the good news is that the newer variants continue to come from the omicron family over the last three years, Gangakedkar said.
India Today
37 minutes ago
- India Today
Delhi Chief Minister Rekha Gupta inaugurates a new waiting area at AIIMS
Delhi Chief Minister Rekha Gupta inaugurated the newly-constructed Dhanuka Waiting Area at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), New Delhi, on Wednesday. The facility has been developed under a CSR initiative by Dhanuka Group, a leading agro-product Gupta also participated in a hawan and pooja ceremony as part of the inauguration. Speaking to the media, she said AIIMS Delhi has witnessed major improvements over the past 10 years, especially since 2014, when the hospital was in poor is the biggest hospital in the country and handles about five lakh OPD cases annually. Before 2014, the hospital was in disarray. In the last 10 years, the facilities have improved significantly. "I thank the Dhanuka Group for this much-needed waiting area,' said CM Rekha Gupta. The Chief Minister said that many attendants accompanying patients have to sit on the roads due to the lack of proper space. The newly built waiting hall aims to provide a comfortable resting space for these visitors.'This is a big relief for families. CSR efforts like these not only improve services but also enhance the beauty of our city,' she added. TREE PLANTATION AT AIIMS UNDER 'EK PED MAA KE NAAM'Chief Minister Gupta also planted a tree on the AIIMS campus as part of the 'Ek Ped Maa Ke Naam' campaign, a green initiative to promote environmental Rekha Gupta stated that significant infrastructure projects worth Rs 35,000 crore under the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) are currently under construction in the national capital during a press conference at the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways. She also mentioned that the earlier projects with a value of Rs 64,000 crore have been completed, as well as another set of projects valued at Rs 24,000 crore, which will begin soon."I thank the Central Government and Union Minister Nitin Gadkari for developing roads and infrastructure in Delhi with the support of these enormous expenses."The Chief Minister also stated that the government stands by its commitment to fixing healthcare and transport infrastructure with the added figures for people's inputs from ANI
India Gazette
38 minutes ago
- India Gazette
"Taking full care of patients," Bengaluru's Bowring and Lady Curzon hospital administers to 11 injured in stadium stampede
Bengaluru (Karnataka) [India], June 5 (ANI): In the wake of the stampede at M Chinnaswamy Stadium that claimed 11 lives and injured 33 others, Medical authorities at Bowring and Lady Curzon Hospital reported receiving six bodies and 18 injured on the day of the incident. Speaking to the media, Medical superintendent Dr T. Kemparaju said, 'After the stampede, we received 18 injured persons and six bodies. Out of the 18 injured persons, eight received treatment and went home, and the remaining 10 patients were admitted to the hospital for observation. Among the 10 persons admitted to the hospital, three sustained fractures in the legs. We have received instructions to take full care of the patients.' Meanwhile, Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah has ordered a magisterial inquiry into the incident. The tragedy unfolded when thousands of fans overwhelmed the stadium area during Royal Challengers Bangalore's IPL victory celebration. Karnataka Home Minister Dr G Parameshwara confirmed that the state government had no role in organising the event. 'We did not request RCB or the KCA, they organised it (the victory celebration). They are the ones who brought the team to Bengaluru. The government also felt it should facilitate this, as it was the Bengaluru team. I feel very sorry that this incident happened,' Parameshwara said after inspecting the site. CM Siddaramaiah, addressing the media, said, '11 died and 33 were injured in the stampede. This tragedy should not have happened. The government expresses deep sorrow over this incident.' He announced a compensation of Rs 10 lakh for the families of the deceased and assured that all the injured will receive free medical treatment. 'I have ordered a magisterial inquiry and given 15 days. People even broke the gates of the stadium. There was a stampede. No one expected such a huge crowd. The stadium has a capacity of only 35,000 people, but 2-3 lakh people came,' the Chief Minister said, underlining the scale of the crowd and security strain. The Home Minister will convene a meeting with Bengaluru Police Commissioner, senior police officials, DCPs, and Karnataka State Cricket Association (KSCA) representatives at the stadium on Thursday to review crowd management lapses. (ANI)
