Minister has ‘significant and deep concerns' about Ash Regan's prostitution Bill
Siobhian Brown raised concerns about the move – which is part of legislation put forward by Alba MSP Ash Regan as part of her Bill to criminalise the buying of sex.
The community safety minister insisted that quashing convictions was an 'exceptional' measure and 'not a step that can be taken lightly'.
While Brown acknowledged Holyrood had passed legislation to quash convictions of those caught up in the Post Office Horizon scandal, she said the cost of this was 'estimated to be £804,000 based on 200 people'. PA Media Community safety minister Siobhian Brown wrote to MSPs on the Criminal Justice Committee setting out the Government's initial view on the Bill (Jane Barlow/PA)
She noted that documents submitted as part of Regan's Prostitution (Offences and Support) (Scotland) Bill suggested that since 1982 a total of 10,459 women have been convicted of soliciting.
With these documents also indicating that Police Scotland 'currently holds 2,773 case records involving 791 individuals', Brown said this 'raises some concerns about the accuracy of the associated costs – around £250,000 – detailed in the Bill's financial memorandum'.
Her comments came in a letter to Holyrood's Criminal Justice Committee, which is due to scrutinise the legislation the Alba MSP has put forward.
She went on to state there was 'insufficient detail' on how proposals to provide support to those involved in prostitution to help them change their lifestyle 'would work in practice', including how long such measures would be available for and what the costs would be.
Regan's member's Bill also sets out to criminalise those buying sex while decriminalising those selling it.
Under the proposals, those convicted of buying sex could be fined up to £10,000 if the case was prosecuted in the sheriff courts – with these courts also able to impose jail sentences of up to six months.
Brown stressed that while the Scottish Government backed the 'underlying intent of the Bill to challenge men's demand and to tackle commercial sexual exploitation', she added there were still 'significant questions and concerns regarding the measures within the Bill and how they would work in practice, the extent to which they would deliver on the policy intent, and the associated financial implications'.
Her comments came after a paper published last week by the Scottish Government said evidence was 'limited' on the impact of these 'challenging demand approaches'.
In the wake of that, sex worker safety charity National Ugly Mugs urged MSPs to 'pull the plug' on Regan's 'misguided and dangerous' Bill.
Chief executive Lynsey Walton said: 'Sex worker groups, alongside leading NGOs like Amnesty and the World Health Organisation, have long warned that criminalising the purchase of sex only serves to make life more difficult and dangerous for sex workers, while having no impact on trafficking and exploitation.
'We are pleased that the Scottish Government has now accepted that the international evidence backs this up.
'MSPs now need to pull the plug on Ms Regan's misguided and dangerous legislation, and focus on supporting sex workers' rights to work safely and free from stigma.'
Regan has been contacted for comment.
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
National childcare register, CCTV trial and mobile phone ban declared in major Australian safety reform
Childcare workers will be added to a national register, after state and territories met with the commonwealth, agreeing to establish the database, new mandatory safety training, a CCTV trial, and a ban on personal mobile phones in centres. The commonwealth has announced it will put $189m towards the safety overhaul, for which the government says work will begin on immediately. The CCTV pilot trial is expected to set up at 300 centres across the country. States and territories had said before Friday that the meeting must result in immediate and concrete actions to improve child safety. The education minister, Jason Clare, said the CCTV trial will begin from October or November. The safety training regime for childcare employees will be rolled out early next year. 'Is it everything that we need to do? No, of course, it's not, but it's the next thing that we must do,' Clare told a press conference. Governments have been under immense pressure after a series of horrific allegations of abuse in childcare settings were uncovered in recent months. Clare said all levels of government and industry needed to step up to improve standards. 'Over the course of the last few weeks, we have made some changes to keep our kids safe but not enough and not fast enough … We have all got to step up here if we are serious about keeping our kids safe, that means the Australian government stepping up, states and territories stepping up and regulators stepping up and it means the people who run our centres stepping up as well.' The ministers also agreed for commonwealth officers to complete an extra 1600 spot visits – something that had been flagged by the government. The commonwealth has conceded reforms have been too slow, with some recommendations to improve childcare safety dating back to the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse in 2015. It had made a series of recommendations for early childcare services and pushed to nationalise the working with children check system. Earlier in August, the state, territory and federal attorneys general held a meeting to discuss working with children checks, agreeing to take a more nationally consistent approach. However, they didn't agree to one national system, meaning checks in some states will remain stronger than others. The government also recently named 37 childcare centres that were not meeting standards, following legislation passed through parliament in July. Clare, said those centres will risk losing access to the childcare care subsidy if standards do not improve within six months, under the commonwealth's new powers. 'I think most parents would accept the argument that if taxpayers money will be invested to operate in early education and care centre we expect them to meet the standards and keep our kids safe. Fundamentally that is what the legislation is all about, 37 centres on notice already. There are more to come.' On Wednesday, Victoria released the findings of a snap review by the former South Australian premier Jay Weatherill and senior Victorian bureaucrat Pam White. It made 22 recommendations, all accepted by the Victorian government, but half are directed at the federal government.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Indonesia working on details of plan to treat 2,000 people from Gaza amid concerns about right to return
The Indonesian government is working on plans to treat 2,000 people from war-ravaged Gaza, holding a series of inter-ministerial discussions to discuss logistics, legality and foreign policy implications relating to the highly sensitive proposal, according to a senior government official. Indonesia announced earlier this month that it would provide temporary medical assistance to 2,000 Palestinians from Gaza, with the uninhabited island of Galang identified as one possible site. Located just south of Singapore, the island was once home to a former camp for Vietnamese refugees and most recently the site of a pandemic hospital. In Muslim-majority Indonesia, a nation that has no diplomatic relations with Israel, and has long been a staunch supporter of Palestinian statehood, government officials have been reluctant to provide any details, saying it is just one option being considered. But reflecting a level of seriousness about the proposal, various ministries, including the coordinating security ministry and the ministries of health and foreign affairs have met to discuss how it would be implemented, said Dave Lakono, deputy chair of the parliament's commission I, which oversees defence and foreign affairs. 'These discussions have focused on logistical feasibility, medical readiness, and legal frameworks,' Laksono told the Guardian, 'Commission I has also been briefed on the strategic implications, particularly regarding Indonesia's foreign policy posture and regional stability.' Plans at this stage remain 'exploratory', he said, with Galang island identified as one site due its historical use for humanitarian purposes and existing infrastructure. Other sites, including facilities in West Java and Central Java that have proximity to major hospitals and logistical hubs are also being considered, he said. The Indonesian government appears to be considering several possibilities, with the use of large military hospitals in Jakarta, and also a site in Jordan, a country with which Indonesia's president Prabowo Subinatio has particularly strong relations, also raised during ministerial discussions, according to one senior official with direct knowledge of the talks. Officials acknowledge the plan will be politically delicate, with some national Islamic leaders accusing the government of being 'deceived' by Israel, and questioning what guarantees would be in place to ensure their return. 'One of the issues is how to make sure the right to return of the Palestinians can be respected because we know that many are worried that this kind of policy can be interpreted in other ways,' said Abdul Kadir Jailani, the director general for Asian, Pacific and African affairs at Indonesia's ministry of foreign affairs, stressing that no final decision had been made on Galang. 'So we have to make sure it will be consistent with the principle of international humanitarian law, and in particular how to respect the right to return of the Palestinians.' 'One of the most important things is that we are not going to do that without approval and support from relevant stakeholders, in particular Palestinian authorities and countries in the region,' he added, 'The implementation of this plan has a high level of complexity, particularly in terms of its political and technical aspects.' Indonesia was able to conduct its second humanitarian airdrop on Gaza in two days this week, a move Jailani said was facilitated with support and coordination from neighbouring Jordan. Axios reported this July that Israel's spy agency The Mossad had visited Washington to seek US support in convincing countries to take hundreds of thousand of Palestinians from Gaza, with Indonesia among several countries reportedly receptive to the idea. Any permanent relocation would be hugely controversial in Indonesia, but so far, criticism of the Gaza plan has been relatively muted in the south-east Asian country. 'At the moment there are so many issues in the headlines so the Gaza issue to be honest is not that widely reported in the media,' said political analyst Kennedy Muslim. 'It's not a major issue in Indonesia at the moment.' Parliament member Laksono stressed that any measures to accept Palestinians from Gaza would be temporary, with coordination with agencies such as Unrwa and ICRC to establish clear documentation, medical records, and repatriation protocols. 'Our objective is to provide care, not resettlement, and to support their eventual return once conditions in Gaza allow,' he said. 'This is a delicate undertaking, and we are fully aware of the geopolitical sensitivities involved.'
The Sun
5 hours ago
- The Sun
Labour has lost control of our borders entirely – why can't our Government crack down on asylum rules?
Lunatic asylum FAR from smashing the gangs, Labour has lost control of our borders entirely. For months ministers have insisted they have been cutting the use of hotels for illegal migrants. 1 In fact, numbers in them have gone UP in the last year. — another record — as 51,000 arrived on small boats. That's a 38 per cent increase in just 12 months. At the current rate, 181,000 may have come here illegally by the next election. The figures also reveal thousands are being quietly placed in blocks of flats among families in cities across the country, adding to the housing crisis. Worse, there is clearly widespread abuse of the legal migration system. More than HALF of asylum claims are from foreigners granted a student or work visa only to suddenly claim persecution in their home country when it expires. It should be obvious that anyone who comes here as a student or to work should be automatically banned from claiming asylum later. Sweden has cracked down on asylum rules. It has made language and culture tests harder, ramped up deportations and put failed asylum seekers in detention centres. Why can't our Government do the same? Cry freedom LUCY Connolly should never have served a year behind bars alongside drug dealers and murderers for a nasty tweet. What she published during last year's riots may have been unpleasant. But mum Connolly clearly immediately regretted the post and swiftly deleted it Her crime was never worthy of a 31-month sentence. As a comparison, Palestinian Hamas supporter Abu Wadee, who arrived illegally on a small boat and posted calls for the slaughter of British Jews, got just nine months. Childminder Lucy, also denied bail, has become a symbol for those who believe she was a victim of politically motivated two-tier justice. Did she really deserve her life and family to be so devastatingly torn apart? White trashed WHAT is the plan to help white, working class kids do better at school? Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson should be concerned by yet another overall fall in the GCSE pass rate. More concerning is the catastrophic performance of poor, white children — especially boys. Many will now join the ranks of the one million 16 to 24-year-olds currently not in work, education or training,
