
Shelter struggles – Part 2: Late nights or low costs? The toss-up between hostels and PGs for Pune students
For students migrating to Pune every year for higher education, finding the right accommodation is a key concern. While some opt for the structured environment of college hostels, others prefer the freedom that comes with living in private paying guest (PG) accommodations. But what do students really prefer?
Nandita Reghu, 23, a student who lives at Vaidya Girls PG in Baner, shares her experience. 'We're six girls sharing a 2BHK apartment. Two per bedroom, and two in the living room, which is converted into a bedroom. The PG is managed by the flat owner herself,' she said.
For her, PG life offers flexibility and autonomy. 'There are no restrictions. I cook my own food, manage my timings, and inform roommates if I'm returning late. This independence is important to me,' she said. For many like her, the PG setup is a stepping stone toward independent living, despite the additional responsibilities.
On the other hand, college hostels offer affordability and structure, a preferred choice for those seeking convenience and security. Riya Kulkarni, 21, a second-year student, who resides on the Savitribai Phule Pune University campus, said, 'Each room is shared by two students. There are five floors and biometric access. Security is 24/7, and wardens are available on alternate floors.'
She described the hostel as 'safe and budget-friendly,' adding, 'At Rs 6,500 per year, it's economical. But the 10.30 pm curfew and visitor restrictions are strict.' While such rules can feel limiting, students like Riya find reassurance in the predictability and the institutional support that hostels provide.
The cost difference is noticeable. While college hostel fees are around Rs 4,500 to Rs 8,000 per year, PGs in areas like Model Colony, Baner and Aundh cost anywhere between Rs 8,000 to Rs 20,000 per month, often excluding food. The higher cost of PGs is often justified by the added personal space, lenient rules, and prime locations, but it remains a concern for students managing tight budgets.
Another PG resident, Aastha Jain, echoed Reghu's sentiments. 'There's definitely more freedom in PGs. But that comes with responsibility. We manage our own cooking and household chores. It teaches you to be independent,' she said. For many students, this environment helps simulate adult life and develop life skills.
Hostel student Ritesh Pawar, however, disagrees. 'I didn't want the burden of managing groceries or bills. The hostel is conveniently located near various campus facilities, including the library, gym, and classrooms. It saves time,' he said. For Pawar, the convenience of being on campus and having essentials taken care of outweighs the appeal of autonomy.
While hostels remain a popular choice for those seeking routine and safety, PGs are emerging as the go-to option for students who prioritise flexibility and personal space. The choice, in most cases, reflects personal priorities, whether that is academic focus, budget, freedom, or convenience.
'Ultimately, where you stay should help you grow, not just as a student, but as a person,' said Reghu.
As Pune continues to grow as an educational hub, both PGs and hostels will remain integral to student life, each with its own set of trade-offs. With rising student populations and evolving preferences, the debate between PGs and hostels is far from over and increasingly, the answer lies in what a student values most: freedom or familiarity.
Divyaja Kalyankar and Antara Kulkarni are interns with The Indian Express.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Print
4 minutes ago
- The Print
Shivraj Singh Chouhan meets Rajasthan CM, discuss agriculture, rural development schemes
This includes Rs 3,286 crore for wages, Rs 944 crore for material components, and Rs 154 crore under administrative expenses. In response, CM Sharma expressed his gratitude to the Union minister on behalf of the state of Rajasthan. During the meeting, Chouhan stated that the Ministry of Rural Development had recently released Rs 4,384 crore to Rajasthan under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) for the current financial year. New Delhi, Jul 28 (PTI) Union Agriculture and Rural Development Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan on Monday met with Rajasthan Chief Minister Bhajan Lal Sharma and discussed various matters related to the comprehensive development of the rural and agricultural sectors, the ministry said in a statement. The progress of the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (Gramin) was also discussed during the meeting. Chouhan noted that the implementation of this important scheme has been commendable in Rajasthan, with several large-scale surveys being conducted already. He assured that the approval for the construction of additional houses will be granted without delay as soon as the verification of the ongoing surveys is completed. A total of 7.46 lakh houses are to be built in Rajasthan, including those under the PM-JANMAN scheme. The meeting also covered discussions on the National Rural Livelihoods Mission. On agricultural issues, the discussion focused on the implementation progress of schemes such as 'Per Drop More Crop' under the Pradhan Mantri Krishi Sinchayee Yojana (PMKSY), the construction of pond-like tanks to harvest rainwater, and fencing around fields. They also discussed notable agricultural advancements in the Bassi region of Jaipur. CM Sharma expressed interest in establishing agricultural supervisors at the Gram Panchayat level with the help of the central government Other key topics discussed during the meeting included strengthening interstate trade, notifying Rajasthan's superior peanut varieties, and promoting the state's popular castor oil. Sharma also informed Chouhan about the good progress of monsoon in Rajasthan this year, adding that favourable rainfall is expected to yield a significantly better harvest in 2025. Minister of State for Agriculture Bhagirath Choudhary, Agriculture Secretary Devesh Chaturvedi, Rural Development Secretary Shailesh Singh, Director General of ICAR Dr. M.L. Jat, and senior officials from both central ministries and the Rajasthan government were also present. PTI AO NB NB This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.


Indian Express
4 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Chandigarh: Mayor Babla about to complete 6 months, House to take up key proposals today
As Mayor Harpreet Kaur Babla nears the completion of her six-month tenure, the 351st General House meeting of the Municipal Corporation, scheduled for Tuesday, is expected to take up key proposals on revenue generation, renewable energy, and civic policy reforms. Elected on January 30 this year, Mayor Babla's leadership will be under close watch as several important agenda items, some new and some recurring are set to be tabled amid growing pressure from both the public and opposition parties. One of the most significant proposals up for discussion for Tuesday meeting is a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with CREST (Chandigarh Renewable Energy and Science and Technology Promotion Society) to implement a 'rent-a-roof' rooftop solar model on nearly 100 buildings within MC jurisdiction. Under this first-time proposal, private developers will install and maintain solar panels at their own expense, and in turn, pay periodic rent to the corporation — projected to earn the MC around Rs 40 lakh annually. The initiative aims to promote clean energy while also supporting the financially stressed civic body. For improving tax compliance, the House will also take up the question seeking list of Chandigarh's top 20 property tax defaulters. Another recurring issue returning to the House agenda is the revised policy for community centre usage. The proposal includes new guidelines for free use by Below Poverty Line (BPL) families, checks on noise pollution during events, and stricter audit protocols. Initially reviewed by a committee, the policy is being placed before the House again for final debate and approval. The civic body is also planning to launch a public-private partnership model to run gyms and fitness centres in 29 community centres, with private operators to be awarded three-year renewable contracts. While the concept has been discussed previously, this marks the first formal tabling of a detailed execution plan. Meanwhile, ahead of the House session, a pre-House meeting was convened Monday at the BJP Chandigarh state office, Kamlam, Sector 33, under the leadership of state president Jitender Pal Malhotra. The meeting was attended by state vice-president Davinder Babla, Mayor Harpreet Kaur Babla, general secretary Sanjeev Rana, and all BJP councillors. The discussions focused on finalising the party's strategy for the House, with emphasis on prioritising public issues, ensuring assertive participation, and communicating the BJP's civic policies effectively during the proceedings. The House meeting comes at a time when the corporation is struggling financially, and repeated Finance and Contract Committee (F&CC) meetings have failed to approve new development projects due to budgetary constraints. Opposition councillors have criticised the ruling party for stalled projects, sanitation concerns, and poor infrastructure management across the city.


India.com
4 minutes ago
- India.com
After Jeetendra, Akshay Kumar hits JACKPOT, sells two apartments for Rs...
After Jeetendra made waves by selling a Rs 855 crore land parcel in Andheri to NTT Global Data Centers, it seems Akshay Kumar is following suit. The Khiladi star is playing a different kind of game, this time on Mumbai's property board. Akshay Kumar has just sold two adjacent apartments in Borivali East for a whopping Rs 7.10 crore. Purchased in 2017 for Rs 3.69 crore, the homes, located in Oberoi Sky City, have appreciated by 92% in just eight years. The deal, according to SquareYards, was registered recently with all the stamp duties and paperwork in place. The first unit, a spacious 1,101 sq ft flat with two car parks, went for Rs 5.75 crore. This alone drew a stamp duty of Rs 34.50 lakh, plus Rs 30,000 in registration charges. Right next to it was a 252 sq ft studio apartment, sold for Rs 1.35 crore, again nearly double the original purchase price of Rs 67.90 lakh. The stamp duty on this was Rs 6.75 lakh. Both units were bought by Pravin and Sabita Shetty, as per the official documents. Who's buying, and how big is the demand? The apartments are part of Oberoi Sky City, a premium project by Oberoi Realty. From August 2024 to July 2025, this single project has clocked Rs 428 crore in sales across 100 units, with the going resale rate at around Rs 47,800 per sq ft. The names involved in these recent deals (buyer or seller) aren't speaking; no comments yet from Akshay or the Shettys. But the paper trail speaks volumes. Is this part of a larger trend? Absolutely. This isn't an isolated sale; it's part of a pattern. In the last seven months alone, Akshay has sold at least 8 real estate assets, both residential and commercial, across Borivali, Worli, and Lower Parel, raking in returns of ₹110 crore+. Some key transactions: In Jan 2025, a 1,073 sq ft Borivali apartment went for Rs 4.25 crore. Jan 31, 2025: Akshay and wife Twinkle Khanna sold a luxury sea-facing apartment at Oberoi 360 West, Worli, for a jaw-dropping Rs 80 crore. In March 2025, another Borivali East apartment was sold for Rs 4.35 crore (84% ROI). Two more units fetched Rs 6.60 crore combined. In April 2025, he sold a commercial office in Lower Parel for Rs 8 crore, bought just five years ago at Rs 4.85 crore. So… why the selling spree? That's the million-dollar (or Rs 110-crore) question. No official word yet, but industry insiders are watching closely.