Batohi not worried about Omotoso's deportation as NPA plans to bring Gupta brothers back to SA
National Director of Public Prosecutions (NDPP) Shamila Batohi says the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) is committed to bringing back Nigerian pastor Timothy Omotoso and the Gupta brothers to face justice.
Batohi appeared before Parliament's Standing Committee on Public Accounts (Scopa) on Wednesday, where she faced tough questions about the NPA's performance in handling high-profile corruption and criminal cases.
ALSO READ: 'There is no state capture in NPA': Ramaphosa to meet Batohi after infiltration claims
The failure of the South African government to secure the extradition of Atul and Rajesh Gupta from the United Arab Emirates (UAE) continues to cast a shadow over the NPA's efforts to prosecute state capture cases.
The NPA has also recently come under intense public scrutiny following the acquittal of Omotoso and his two co-accused in a rape trial that spanned eight years.
Gupta brothers' extradition
During the meeting, Investigating Directorate Against Corruption (IDAC) head Andrea Johnson rejected any suggestion that the South African government had mishandled previous efforts to bring the Gupta brothers back to the country to face several charges.
She explained that the government has yet to receive a response from the UAE clarifying the reasons for the extradition request being denied.
'When the UAE decided not to extradite the Guptas, we wrote to them; 12 note verbales later, we still don't have any response from the UAE about why the extradition failed. Safe to say that they have asked us to resubmit,' Johnson said.
READ MORE: A national embarrassment? 'Scorpions 2.0' bill pitched to save failing NPA
'How do you resubmit when you've submitted a full set of papers that have been properly checked, even by themselves?'
'It does put you in somewhat of a predicament – do you send these papers so that they are a so-called 'failed attempt' again?'
Johnson confirmed that a new extradition request would be submitted for the Gupta brothers to the UAE.
'We've taken a decision to submit new applications with additional matters. The country also can't wait while the NPA has to follow legal processes.'
'So, having taken that into account, the public interest, and the interest of justice, we'll submit new applications not just on the Estina and Nulane matters. We're going to apply for extraditions in relation to other state capture matters.'
Watch the meeting below:
The Gupta brothers, who were arrested in Dubai in 2022, stand accused of playing a central role in state capture during former president Jacob Zuma's tenure.
One of the key cases in which they are implicated is the Nulane Investment fraud case and Vrede Dairy Farm matter.
Batohi explains NPA's appeal on Omotoso
Later in the meeting, Batohi told the committee that while the NPA is appealing Omotoso's acquittal, the process could take years.
She also downplayed public concern following Omotoso's deportation last month.
The NDPP explained that if the televangelist had remained in South Africa as a free man, it could have further distressed his victims, who have already expressed their disappointment with the outcome of the trial.
'The fact that he has had to flee from South Africa means he has not been able to live his life the way that he would like to.'
READ MORE: Batohi explains why NPA did not investigate prosecutors in 2021 Omotoso trial
Batohi expressed hope that Omotoso could be returned to face justice if the appeal is successful.
'Nigeria is a country that we do have an extradition treaty with, and they are also multi-lateral treaties that we can draw on to hopefully bring him back when we do.'
'We have been successful with many extradition applications across the world. The UAE is the one that sticks out, and we have had challenges with that.'
She added that the NPA would await the outcome of the appeal process.
Batohi defended the institution, urging the public 'not to lose faith' in the country's prosecutorial system amid growing criticism of the NPA's handling of high-profile cases – the corruption case involving former Cabinet minister Zizi Kodwa.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
15 minutes ago
- IOL News
‘RAND-FIXING': BANKS HAVE THEIR DAY IN COURT
The Constitutional Court in Johannesburg will for four days, starting on Tuesday, hear arguments relating to allegations of Rand-fixing, following an appeal by the Competition Commission. Image: Timothy Bernard / Independent Newspapers THE Competition Commission has hauled some of the country's top banks to the apex court over allegations that they conspired with each other to manipulate the foreign exchange rate in respect of the US Dollar and the Rand. The commission turned to the Constitutional Court for leave to appeal the Competition Appeal Court (CAC) judgment handed down in January last year in which it upheld the appeal by the majority of the respondent banks accused of price-fixing. The Constitutional Court is due to hear legal arguments over four days. In June 2020, the Commission had referred the case regarding the alleged rand fixing against 28 local and foreign banks to the Competition Tribunal. The banks were ordered by the Tribunal in March 2023 to file their answering affidavits in response to the Commission's complaint referral, but objected to the Tribunal order and appealed it to the CAC. The CAC, in its judgment last year, released 17 banks from the complaint referral before they answered the allegations against them and restricted the Commission's case to only the four respondent banks. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ In its current application for leave to appeal, the Commission is appealing the CAC order to the Constitutional Court against 13 banks. These banks include Standard Bank of South Africa, Nedbank Limited and FirstRand Bank Limited, while the bulk are foreign banks. The Commission said this appeal will provide the Constitutional Court with an opportunity to pronounce on whether the South African competition authorities have jurisdiction to investigate and prosecute firms that are based outside of the Republic whose anti-competitive conduct affects the South African economy. In April 2015, the Commission initiated a complaint against various financial entities centred on allegations of price-fixing and market division in the trading of the USD/ZAR currency pair. The anti-competitive practices are alleged to have taken place between September 2007 to at least September 2013. According to the Commission, the general terms of the conspiracy included that the banks' traders would participate, actively and passively, in frequent and regular communication and contact with one or more traders employed by or representing competing banks when engaging in trading the USD/ZAR currency pair. The Commission subsequently referred the complaint to the Tribunal in February 2017. The banks took exception to the original referral. Those objections were adjudicated by the Tribunal in 2019 and considered again on appeal before the CAC in 2020, which ordered that the Commission file a new referral affidavit to substitute for and replace all the complaint referral affidavits. In accordance with the 2020 CAC order, the Commission filed its complaint referral anew in June 2020.
The Citizen
an hour ago
- The Citizen
From Uber's arrival to driver's death: A decade of government failure on taxis
South Africa's transport sector's war is killing the innocent – and the state is watching. On Wednesday night, Mthokozisi Mvelase was shot dead and his vehicle was set alight at Maponya Mall in Soweto. He had been in Johannesburg for two weeks and an Uber driver for just three days when his life was gruesomely ended. The next day, a minibus taxi was set alight in what was clearly the Soweto community's angry response to the killing of the Uber driver. This incident encapsulates South Africa's current social and economic state: youth unemployment, taxi industry lawlessness, mafia tactics in the transport sector, police inertia and the government's lack of urgency in addressing citizens' safety and transport concerns. In the background, President Cyril Ramaphosa's government and former president Thabo Mbeki's foundation were at odds over the National Dialogue that the president insisted was starting on Friday at the University of South Africa in Pretoria. The already fragile national convention did start with the government's side of the invitees turning up. However, the community of Soweto continued protesting in the streets, burning tyres and blockading Chris Hani Baragwanath Road all the way up to the N1. ALSO READ: 'Minister, please step in': Turf war between taxis and e-hailers as mall shuts down and taxi burns The battle between the South African National Taxi Council-affiliated minibus taxis and the e-hailing industry is as old as the e-hailing industry itself in South Africa. The arrival of Uber was met with violent opposition by the now almost-defunct metered-taxi industry. Gruesome deaths and injuries became common occurrences and when the generally feared minibus taxi bodies joined the metered taxi industry, it became a one-sided bullying parade in which the e-hailing drivers were sitting ducks. Throughout the many years of violence since Uber first entered the South African market in 2013, the government has acted as it always has: a disinterested middleman who looked away even when the bully killed their victim. It got so bad that it is alleged that taxi patrol vehicles would stop cars they suspected to be e-hailing cars and ask the driver – a man – to kiss a suspected passenger – a woman – to prove that the car was transporting family and not operating as an e-hailing service. Government intervention remained minimal and ineffective. While former president Jacob Zuma's government responded too slowly in enacting laws to govern the arrival of e-hailing in the transport sector, the ANC gave up on ensuring that the neglected minibus taxi industry was regularised after it came into power. ALSO READ: Santaco denies reports of enforcing limits on private vehicle use [VIDEOS] The industry had been allowed to grow into a huge uncontrolled monstrous law unto itself. The justification was that the government cannot control what they did not build. And because it would require real effort to bring the industry under government control, it was far too easy and convenient to simply look the other way. And that is why South Africa is where it is right now. But the community knows how to make the government stop looking away: burn things down and disrupt the rest of the economy that keeps on going while they suffer in a war which is not of their own creation. When burning tyres block roads, an ambulance fails to get to a dying patient on time, life-saving medication cannot be delivered to clinics, a teacher fails to get to school and workers cannot get to work. A company in Sandton is less productive because it is understaffed. But, worst of all, the poor get poorer. It is about time those who only want to talk South Africa's problems to death gave way to those who want to save Mvelase's life and livelihood. NOW READ: Forget Uber and Bolt, we may soon have a Gauteng e-hailing service
Daily Maverick
12 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
After the Bell: New reform tracker helps answer the question, ‘Will SA be okay?'
Finally, we are getting a live report card to help us answer this question. Last week, I was asked to be MC at the two launches of the Business Leadership SA Reform Tracker. It has a rather grand title. But, unlike so many other names in the economic and political space, it does what it says on the tin. It is tracking our reforms. Not quite minute by minute, but not far off. As someone who identifies as a 'journalist' and watches everything that happens as much as I can, I'm often asked certain questions by people I bump into, or audiences I speak in front of. The questions are wide-ranging, from 'who should I vote for' to 'should I emigrate', to 'will our economy start to grow now that…' I could go on. But in reality, they're the same question. Everyone who asks me one of those questions is asking something much more fundamental. They're asking, really: 'Will South Africa be okay?' It was a question summed up incredibly well by my old journalistic colleague and friend, Jan-Jan Joubert. He wrote a very well-researched answer and published it as a book. There is something almost peculiar to the South African middle class about this question. I don't think people in New Zealand or, dare I say it this particular Monday, Australia ask themselves this. Or people in the UK or Spain — despite the fact that in both those countries there are serious economic and political problems. But, considering the era of State Capture we have come from, I think it's fully understandable. I mean, look around. In Johannesburg, the mayor blames the DA for the state of the city while he himself has not appointed a finance head, or someone to actually manage the roads. That pothole that you see twice a day? There is actually no one in charge of fixing that right now. Our economy is still growing incredibly slowly, and it seems that people are putting more energy into arguing about the definition of employment than actually making changes that will result in more jobs. Just this weekend we saw a liar, someone who was central to the Guptas, who has been able to use the Hawks to have his ex-wife literally locked up in jail, still mouthing off about the state of the ANC? Malusi Gigaba should be in court. Not being given interview after interview as the chairperson of a portfolio committee in Parliament. But as we all know, there are virtually no Zondo prosecutions. And institutions such as Transnet are still battling to recover from State Capture. Progress However, it's important to note that there is progress. Finally, we are getting a live report card to help us answer the question: 'Will South Africa be okay?' Last week, I was asked to be MC at the two launches of the Business Leadership South Africa Reform Tracker. It has a rather grand title. But, unlike so many other names in the economic and political space, it does what it says on the tin. It is tracking our reforms. Not quite minute by minute, but not far off. Now, when I was at school, my reports were written in quite dry, dull text. They were very different from my tests, in which red was a prominent feature. Here, you get red, yellow and green. So at a glance, you can see how we are doing. But you can also click on each little tile and read what has been written about that sector. It might be that there is progress but still work to do; the story might be a lot more complicated than a single colour can indicate. And, wonderfully, there is also a way for you, perhaps as someone working in one of these sectors, to send some feedback. You might know that something has changed, or that in fact there has been more progress than the tracker is showing. Now, as a journalist, it's tempting to look for the red and start to get a little stroppy with a few politicians. Journalistic instincts But Dr Stuart Theobald, the founder and chairperson at Krutham who put the whole thing together, tells me that we should just wait a little before people like me go back to our journalistic instincts. He acknowledges that, yes, some reforms have stopped because of political problems, or opposition. And some have just failed. But some have been stopped deliberately, because the reform no longer makes sense. In other words, yes it's stopped — but for a good reason. So, if you are interested, it does make sense to actually go a little deeper into each sector, just to see how things really are. I know that one of the reasons you really read this is because you are searching for an answer to that question: 'Will South Africa be okay?' I mean, there is a lot to be worried about. Just as there is in the US, or China, or many, many other places right now. It might be worth just checking in with this tracker from time to time. Perhaps put it on your browser dashboard or something.
