How a new law in Maharashtra could criminalise dissent
Framed as a tool to fight 'urban Naxalism', Maharashtra's Special Public Security Bill has sparked outrage for its sweeping powers. Critics say it criminalises dissent, bypasses due process, and could turn peaceful protest into a punishable offence
In December 2024, just a day before the winter session of the Maharashtra Assembly ended, the Eknath Shinde-led government tabled the Maharashtra Special Public Security (MSPS) Bill — a controversial law ostensibly crafted to target 'urban Naxals' and their support networks.
But what the government describes as a necessary security measure, civil society groups have called 'draconian', 'unconstitutional', and 'a danger to India's democratic fabric'. As many as 12,000 objections and suggestions were submitted by April 1 in response to the Bill. Now, a broad coalition of political parties and grassroots organisations is preparing to march in protest at Mumbai's Azad Maidan on June 30.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
7 minutes ago
- Hans India
Vice Presidential poll: BJP likely to go for tried, tested pick
New Delhi: As the Election Commission formally set in motion the process of electing the next vice president by appointing a returning officer, the BJP-led alliance is set to start consultation for its pick for the key constitutional position amid indications that the Opposition will also join the fray. In the electoral college that comprises members of the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha, the ruling National Democratic Alliance (NDA) has a clear majority as its strength is nearly 425 out of the current total of 782 MPs, making its nominee a clear favourite to fill in the position left vacant by the abrupt resignation of Jagdeep Dhankhar. While the brain trust of the BJP is yet to begin deliberations, there is a strong view within the party and its allies that the party leadership will prioritise organisational rootedness and political commitment over an excessive focus on experiment that has at times made them look outside their own pool of experienced talent, as was the case with Dhankhar in the 2022 polls. Having started his political career as a Janata Dal MP in 1991, Dhankhar later joined the Congress as parties of socialist stock declined. He then shifted his allegiance to the BJP, where his political activities were nominal. It was as a senior advocate in the Supreme Court that he caught the attention of the BJP leadership, which led to his appointment as West Bengal Governor in 2019 and then as vice president in 2022 following a tenure that was marked by his frequent run-ins with the government led by Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee, a key opposition leader. Dhankhar's streak of outspokenness and unconventional style as vice president gradually soured his ties with the government, and the final straw came when he accepted an opposition-sponsored notice on July 21 for a motion to remove Justice Yashwant Varma. It caused dismay in the ruling alliance and almost derailed the official efforts for a bipartisan move in the Lok Sabha. He was to resign hours later. Several leaders of the BJP and its allies are of the view that the NDA this time is unlikely to follow the instincts that made it pick Dhankhar and will be more conventional in its search for his successor. While the prevailing view is that the BJP will pick one from its ranks, someone like Harivansh, a JD(U) MP, is also being talked about as a probable candidate for the trust he has built with the government in his nearly seven-year term as Rajya Sabha deputy chairman. The vice president is the ex-officio Chairman of the Upper House, a key position in shaping Parliament's proceedings and thus guiding the government's agenda. The BJP-led central government has generally avoided entrusting allies with key independent positions. TDP's Gajapathi Raju was the first ally leader to be made a governor recently since the National Democratic Alliance came to power in 2014. "When the talk is yet to begin even within the party, it is futile to speculate about the probable candidates. Though political wisdom suggests that the upheavals wrought by Dhankhar will weigh heavily in any future decision," a BJP leader said. With assembly polls set to be held in Bihar in October-November and key states like West Bengal, Tamil Nadu and Kerala, besides Assam, next year, electoral considerations are expected to be a factor as well. Opposition parties have indicated their keenness to contest the poll to send out a political message, irrespective of the outcome. They had contested against Dhankhar too, putting up Margaret Alva for the August 6, 2022, election. In a statement, the EC said on Friday that in consultation with the Ministry of Law and Justice and with the consent of the deputy chairman of Rajya Sabha, it has appointed Secretary General of the Upper House, P C Mody, as the returning officer for the vice presidential election.
Indian Express
7 minutes ago
- Indian Express
In Manipur, extending President's Rule is not a solution
In February this year, the N Biren Singh-led government's failure to stanch ethnic violence since May 2023 prompted the Centre to intervene and impose President's Rule in Manipur. The provision is intended as a temporary mechanism to ensure the governance of a state in which there has been a 'failure of [the] constitutional machinery'. It is not designed to be a permanent solution or a substitute for a popular government. President's Rule is a means to an end, not the end by itself. In this context, the government's move to extend President's Rule by another six months, scheduled in this Parliament session, raises questions about whether the Centre's efforts so far have significantly advanced the objective of restoring normalcy in the state. While it is reassuring that no major episode of violence has occurred since last November — when 22 people were killed over 11 days, most of them in Jiribam district — it is also true that there has been little progress in the dialogue between the Meitei and Kuki-Zo communities. Three key issues require urgent resolution: Free movement, the relocation of internally displaced persons, and the circulation of weapons. In early March, Home Minister Amit Shah had called for unrestricted movement across Manipur in an effort to reverse the segregation of the two communities. However, that initiative collapsed on its very first day. According to this newspaper, fresh negotiations are now underway between the government and Kuki militant groups under the Suspension of Operations (SoO) agreement to reach a deal that would allow free movement of people and goods. On relocation, former Manipur Chief Secretary P K Singh announced earlier this month that efforts are being made to resettle those displaced by the conflict in three phases, with the goal of completing the process by the end of the year. As per estimates from the Manipur Home Department, around 57,000 people continue to struggle in over 280 relief camps across the valley and the hills. Finally, despite the Governor's efforts to curb the circulation of illegal weapons, roughly 3,000 looted arms are still unaccounted for. It is only natural for the people of Manipur to feel increasingly restless over the continued absence of a popular government. This is why the NDA's Meitei and Naga MLAs have also been campaigning for months to push for its restoration, while Kuki-Zo groups are wary of the prospect of another partisan leader at the helm. The Centre may believe that extending President's Rule is in the state's best interest for now, but it needs to move with urgency to restart the political process. Simultaneously, it must take steps to curb the influence of militant groups on both sides that could derail attempts at reconciliation. Peace — and the return of the mediating role of politics — must no more be held hostage to entrenched ethnic rivalries.
United News of India
17 minutes ago
- United News of India
Ghost of another Rs 200 crore scam resurfaces in Uttarakhand
Dehradun, July 25 (UNI) As the alleged Loni Urban Multi State Credit Thrift Cooperative (LUCC) Society scam raised tempers in Uttarakhand's political circles, another purported Rs 200 crore mutual fund scam has resurfaced. Opposition Congress alleged that BJP government has failed to take action against the businessman and his wife responsible for allegedly cheating the public of more than ₹200 crore. Congress attacked the BJP-led Uttarakhand government alleging that a series of financial scams, and the swindling of the hard earned money of the people have taken place in the past few years. Congress alleged that similar to the LUCC scam, a company had laundered the hard-earned money of the investors in Uttarakhand during the Covid-19 days. Congress' Uttarakhand chief spokesperson Garima Mehra Dasauni alleged that the wife of a former government advisor ran a company which collected more than ₹200 crore from the people promising handsome returns through fixed deposits (FD) and recurring deposit (RD) accounts of the investors. "However it was discovered later that 40-50 thousand fake FD and RD accounts were created by the firm and investors did not get the promised amount resulting into a public outcry. Victim investors are still clueless as to where their money has gone," she said. "Investors are still waiting for their money" alleged Dasauni. She questioned if Uttarakhand government will reveal exact amount people of the hill state were cheated by the firm and whether it was involved in money laundering. UNI PRI SSP
