Govt reviews global judiciary appointment systems amid reform push
Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Law and Institutional Reform), Datuk Seri Azalina Othman Said, said the study aimed to ensure that judicial appointments in the country are carried out more transparently, independently, and in accordance with the principles of the Federal Constitution.
"This study has been conducted in an inclusive manner through joint engagement sessions with the judiciary, the Malaysian Bar Council, Members of Parliament from both the government and opposition blocs, higher education institutions, constitutional experts, civil society organisations, and the public.
"This approach aims to ensure that the appointment process is implemented more transparently, independently, and in line with the principles of the Federal Constitution," she said in a written parliamentary reply last night.
She added that the government remains committed to upholding the separation of powers and ensuring that key national appointments, including those of superior court judges, are made in accordance with the Federal Constitution and existing laws.
This follows the Malaysian Bar's rally for judicial independence on July 14, after claims of judicial interference arising from documents allegedly leaked from Judicial Appointments Commission meeting minutes.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Borneo Post
4 hours ago
- Borneo Post
TYT Sarawak honoured by inaugural bencher recognition from nation's legal fraternity
Wan Junaidi accepts the plaque from ICM president Tun Arifin Zakaria (right), witnessed by ICM Exco Sarawak Tan Kee Heng, who is also the event's organising chairman. — Information Department photo KUCHING (Aug 3): Yang di-Pertua Negeri Sarawak Tun Pehin Sri Dr Wan Junaidi Tuanku Jaafar has been formally inducted as the first Honorary Bencher of the Inns of Court Malaysia (ICM). The recognition signifies his contributions to the legal fraternity in the country. 'Thank you to all of those who are involved in giving me this honour of being the first bencher for the ICM. 'I feel humbled by the recognition that you gave me,' he said in his special address delivered during the ICM Grand Dining 2025, held in conjunction with the inaugural benching ceremony at a hotel here on Saturday night. Adding on, Wan Junaidi reflected on his time in public office, particularly his 13-month tenure as Minister in Prime Minister's Department in charge of Parliament and law, during which he successfully amended the Federal Constitution three times – a feat he described as 'unprecedented'. 'It never before been done. 'It was historical in a sense because the law that I brought to Parliament would require amending the Constitution to make it effective,' he said. Among the amendments was the enactment of the anti-defection law, also known as the 'Anti-Hopping Law'. In this regard, Wan Junaidi said he had insisted that the provision be embedded in the Federal Constitution to ensure its legal permanence and resistance to political changes. 'Even though the government actually proposed that it must be the Act of Parliament, I wanted it to be more permanent in a sense, so it could not be amended by a simple majority in Parliament. 'So I advised the government that I must amend the constitution so that it would require the two-thirds majority under Article 159.' Under Article 159(3) of the Federal Constitution, any Bill seeking to amend the Constitution – unless specifically exempted – must be passed in both the Dewan Rakyat (Lower House) and Dewan Negara (Upper House, or Senate) with the support of not less than two-thirds of the total number of members. The second amendment, he said, was to formally recognise the Malaysia Agreement 1963 (MA63) in the Constitution. 'While MA63 has long been cited in public discourse, I have observed that many lack a clear understanding of its content. 'The Agreement itself, signed on the July 9, 1963, comprises two pages and two clauses. 'Still, it also involved other documents like the Inter-Governmental Committee (IGC) Report and Cobbold Commission Report – all part and parcel of the whole documentation that became the treaty between Great Britain and Malaya for the formation of Malaysia,' he elaborated. Wan Junaidi added that because MA63 had not been incorporated into the Constitution, it could not serve as a valid basis for Sarawak and Sabah to negotiate with the federal government over the fulfilment of the terms set out in the Agreement. 'So for the last 58 years, we never got anything, for reasons that the treaty was never recognised by the Constitution.' This, he pointed out, was also followed by an amendment to Article 161A of the Constitution, which reverted the power to determine native status to the Sarawak government. At the federal level, Wan Junaidi was hailed as the driving force behind efforts to revive the Parliamentary Services Act, aimed at restoring Parliament's institutional independence following its repeal in 1992. 'That was the reason why it was, the reason, the regularity of my action in amending the constitution during that time,' said the Sarawak's Head of State. Honorary Bencher lead legal fraternity Tun Dr Wan Junaidi Tuanku Jaafar
New Straits Times
2 days ago
- New Straits Times
Sosma reform: Suhakam seeks bail rights, shorter detention, and transparency
KUALA LUMPUR: The Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (Suhakam) has outlined five core reforms it hopes will emerge from ongoing stakeholder consultations on the Security Offences (Special Measures) Act 2012 (Sosma). The commission is also asking the government to release draft amendments before they are tabled in Parliament. Secretary-general Altaf Deviyati said the commission's longstanding concerns include extended detention without judicial oversight, restricted access to bail, limited access to legal counsel during initial detention, and broad discretionary powers granted to enforcement agencies. "We believe these provisions not only challenge Malaysia's international obligations but are also inconsistent with the Federal Constitution," she told the New Straits Times. Among Suhakam's proposals is the reinstatement of judicial discretion in granting bail, particularly for non-violent and non-terrorism-related offences. The commission also calls for the maximum initial detention period to be shortened from the current 28 days, which it views as excessive. Altaf said access to legal counsel must be guaranteed from the point of arrest, and that the right to a prompt and public hearing should be assured. "Currently, detainees are waiting far too long just to get their first hearing," she added. Finally, Suhakam recommends narrowing Sosma's application to truly exceptional and well-defined national security threats. "Ordinary criminal offences should be addressed under existing laws," Altaf said. Its secretary-general said that Suhakam has been participating in engagement sessions through the Parliamentary Special Select Committee since November last year. "Public consultation is essential in any democratic law-making process," Altaf said, adding that transparency will ensure a more balanced approach between national security and fundamental liberties. Altaf said that the commission acknowledges Malaysia's security needs but maintains that amendments must address ongoing and potential human rights violations. Beyond legislative changes, Suhakam also advocates for systemic reforms to prevent abuse under Sosma and similar laws. These include strengthening internal and external oversight, creating an independent complaints mechanism, and improving judicial training and awareness of human rights standards. "We also need greater transparency in how laws like Sosma are enforced, including the regular publication of arrest data," Altaf said. She added that Malaysia should ratify international human rights treaties such as the United Nations Convention Against Torture (UNCAT) and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) to reinforce protections against arbitrary detention and mistreatment.
The Star
3 days ago
- The Star
13MP outlines five strategies to build nation state, says Economy Ministry
KUALA LUMPUR: The 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP) has outlined five strategies to accelerate the formation of a nation state, which forms the main foundation to ensure harmony and national stability. According to the 13MP document released by the Economy Ministry on Thursday (July 31), the strategies include strengthening integration and unity; reinforcing patriotism and national identity; enhancing effective diplomacy and Malaysia's image on the international stage; increasing public participation in sports; and enhancing excellence in sports at the global level. To strengthen integration and unity, a Malaysian Harmony Charter will be developed as the primary guide for inter-religious and inter-ethnic relations and harmony, alongside intensified nation-building programmes. The role of politicians, media practitioners, academia, non-governmental organisations (NGOs), and civil society organisations (CSOs) in nurturing harmony will be empowered by facilitating the sharing of accurate information with the public. "The National Integration Research and Training Institute will be upgraded into a centre of excellence to expand research and training activities related to unity," the document stated. Efforts to reinforce patriotism and national identity will focus on producing creative works and content that highlight national identity and character to instil love for the country among the people. An index to measure the level of patriotism will be developed as a guide in designing more comprehensive and effective programmes and interventions. "The appreciation of the Rukun Negara and the Federal Constitution will be enhanced through various educational and awareness initiatives to ensure these principles continue to be valued and practised by all citizens," it added. Good manners, spiritual values, and humanitarian aspects, including those based on the principles of Maqasid Syariah, along with a culture of integrity and volunteerism, will also be enhanced. The National Service Training Programme will be improved through a combination of nationhood and basic military training components. Efforts to enhance effective diplomacy and Malaysia's image on the international stage will focus on expanding the country's involvement in international cooperation, including through soft power and showcasing Malaysia's uniqueness to the global community. The strategy to increase public participation in sports involves empowering sports associations, private companies, NGOs, and communities to organise various sports and fitness activities while expanding access to sports facilities, especially in rural areas. Under the fifth strategy, efforts to enhance the excellence of national athletes at the international level will continue, with sports training centres to be equipped with modern technology facilities to enable athletes to be trained in various disciplines and expertise. "The hosting of the Southeast Asian (SEA) Games in Malaysia in 2027 will be leveraged to raise national excellence and expand community involvement in sports and volunteerism," the document noted. Three selected targets have been set for building a nation state throughout the 13MP period until 2030: increasing the National Unity Index score from 0.629 to 0.800; the Malaysian Sports Culture Index from 56.3 to 59.0; and the number of athletes ranked in the world's top eight from 96 to 140. The document highlighted achievements during the 12MP, including an increase in the National Unity Index score from 0.567 in 2018 to 0.629 in 2022. Additionally, Malaysia's ASEAN Chairmanship in 2025 will serve as a platform to champion the principle of ASEAN centrality, while recognition as a BRICS partner country enables Malaysia to make meaningful contributions to advancing the Global South agenda. The outstanding achievements of national athletes on the world stage have also raised the country's image as well as national pride and patriotic spirit, reflected in the increase in the Malaysian Sports Culture Index score from 52.0 in 2021 to 56.3 in 2024. – Bernama
