Virginia student's suspension for not reporting classmate with bullet sooner is 'appalling,' judge says
The judge ruled Monday in favor of the child's mother, Rachel Wigand, after she sued St. John the Apostle Catholic School for breaching its contract when administrators suspended her son in September for a day and a half.
The child, who was identified in the lawsuit as A.W., received the same suspension as the student who allegedly brought the bullet to class.
"A suspension on a child's academic record is permanent. When you're enrolling children in subsequent educational places, they ask you that question: has your kid ever been suspended? What happened to her child was so absurd," said attorney Tim Anderson, who represented Wigand.
"It wasn't fair that the mom was going to have to answer that question, yes, for the remainder of this child's academic career," he said.
The child was in class, preparing to take a standardized test, when another student pulled out a bullet and showed it to him. Anderson previously told NBC News said the child took the test, which lasted about an hour and a half, went to another class, and then told the principal.
It was about two hours between the child seeing the bullet and him alerting the principal, Anderson said. School administrators called the police, and officers found the bullet in the student's bag, according to Anderson.
Judge Vivian Henderson said to see the child punished for trying to do the right thing was "appalling, for a lack of a better word, for this court."
"Especially in an environment where ... younger and younger kids are being forced to make adult-like decisions without clear boundaries or parameters," Henderson said in a recording of Monday's hearing provided to NBC News by Anderson.
She said "the unfortunate victim in this matter" was Wigand's son.
An attorney for the school had said in closing arguments that it is written in the school's handbook and in the tuition contract that St. John the Apostle has the right to impose "a more or less severe form of discipline." The attorney also argued that it is stressed in school that safety incidents need to be reported immediately.
The attorney said the decision to send Wigand's son home "was clearly harping back on that lesson and trying to impose a lesson of 'Hey, this is why it's important.'"
Anderson said the school could have put the child in detention or imposed another type of in-school disciplinary action.
The Catholic Diocese of Richmond said while it disagrees with the court's decision, it respects the legal process.
"Our focus continues to be providing enriching and Christ-centered learning experiences for our students, and we are hopeful this conclusion will bring all parties involved an opportunity to move forward," a spokesperson said in a statement.
Wigand previously told NBC News that her son had wanted to stay anonymous when reporting the incident, but the school took that away when he was suspended.
Anderson said Tuesday the child has been bullied since the incident, and Wigand plans on enrolling him and her other children in a new school.
This article was originally published on NBCNews.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
Wife of slain NYPD Officer Didarul Islam gives birth to their third son
The wife of slain New York Police Officer Didarul Islam, one of five people fatally shot at a midtown Manhattan high-rise last month, has given birth to a son, police announced Monday. Arham became the third child of Didarul and Jamila Islam, and they're all boys, Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch said in a statement Monday afternoon. "Out of tragedy, a new life has entered this world," she said. "Arham joins his two big brothers, Ahyan and Azhaan. Together, they will carry forward their father's legacy of service and courage." Mayor Eric Adams said he was with members of Islam's family at the hospital when Jamila was in labor Sunday. "I know how special Arham's birth is for this family that is still dealing with heartbreak after losing their hero," he said on X. "Our entire city stands with them and is here to support them." Islam, 36, was working in the lobby of the 44-story building on Park Avenue on July 28 when, police say, Shane Tamura, 27, of Las Vegas, walked in and immediately opened fire using a semiautomatic rifle. Tisch said afterward that Islam was working in the lobby of the building with the department's permission under a program that allows officers to provide security off-duty but in uniform. On Monday she noted his formal title: Detective First Grade Didarul Islam. Adams said on MSNBC last month that Islam was the first Bangladesh-born NYPD officer to be killed in the line of duty. After the attack, Adams said that those who knew Islam said he 'believed in living out the life of a godly person.' Tamura also shot a security guard and two civilians in the building before he fatally shot himself, authorities said. Adams said Tamura, who completed a cross-country drive just before the attack, was trying to target the headquarters of the NFL, which has offices in the Park Avenue building, but entered the wrong set of elevator banks and never made it to the league's offices. Two officials familiar with the matter told NBC News that the shooter, who played football in high school in Southern California, left a note at the scene that said he wanted his brain studied for chronic traumatic encephalopathy, or CTE. The neurodegenerative disorder associated with head injuries can cause changes in behavior and cognition, and it has been diagnosed in hundreds of NFL players after their deaths. Tamura, who never made it to the NFL, had a "documented mental health history," Las Vegas police said. Muhammad Mainul Islam, who identified himself as Didarul Islam's cousin, told NBC News the officer was dedicated to providing for his family and raising his children. 'When he had time, and especially his off days, he went to the mosque with his two kids,' he said. Islam was assigned to the 47th Precinct in the Bronx. Patrick Hendry, president of the Police Benevolent Association, said after the attack: 'He went out every single day to provide for his family, whether it was overtime or whatever he had to do." Tisch said in her statement Monday that the newborn, his mother and his brothers are part of the NYPD fabric. "Jamila, Ahyan, Azhaan, and now, Arham will forever be part of the NYPD family," she said. This article was originally published on Solve the daily Crossword
NBC News
13 hours ago
- NBC News
Food influencers injured after car slams into restaurant as they filmed
Two food influencers narrowly escaped after a car drove into the Houston restaurant where they were filming a review. The dramatic video posted on Patrick Blackwood and Nina Santiago's YouTube channel shows glass flying as the car barrels into their table. The pair managed to escape with only a few cuts and bruises. They spoke to NBC News' George Solis about their experience.
NBC News
13 hours ago
- NBC News
What's behind the TikTok accounts using AI-generated versions of real Latino journalists?
A network of nearly 90 TikTok accounts has been using artificial intelligence to create fake versions of high-profile Spanish-language journalists and spread falsehoods online for potential financial gain. Over a third of the accounts used AI-generated versions of Jorge Ramos, one of the best-known Latino journalists in the United States, to front fabricated news stories. One of them featured an AI avatar of Ramos falsely claiming that President Donald Trump's son Barron Trump stormed into the United Nations to denounce the deportation of his mother, first lady Melania Trump. "I never said that," Ramos himself said in Spanish last month when he debunked the false narrative in a TikTok video posted on the account of this new independent news program. Ramos launched the show, 'Así Veo las Cosas,' on social media this year following his exit from Univision in December after nearly 40 years at the network. "There are things that are impossible to stop, and we can't stop artificial intelligence right now," Ramos said in his video. "There are tons of videos of me where I'm supposedly saying things I have never said." The accounts point to the challenge of stopping or controlling the surge in fake images and misinformation as AI technology advances and is increasingly used by those who want to spread false information online. Alexios Mantzarlis, director of the Security, Trust, and Safety Initiative at Cornell Tech, Cornell University's graduate campus in New York City, found 88 TikTok accounts that routinely used AI-generated versions of Ramos and other Latino news anchors from the Spanish-language networks Telemundo and Televisa to spread misinformation online targeting Spanish-speaking audiences in the United States. NBC News reviewed the contents of the 88 accounts before TikTok shut them down after it learned of Mantzarlis' findings. Most of the 88 accounts were created this year and used AI avatars of Ramos, Noticias Telemundo and NBC News anchor José Díaz-Balart and Televisa anchor Enrique Acevedo. (Telemundo and NBC News are owned by NBCUniversal, a subsidiary of Comcast Corp.) Their AI avatars, some of which were more realistic than others, were used to front false stories about divisive topics such as immigration, as well as conspiracy theories about Trump, Jeffrey Epstein and Sean "Diddy" Combs. The most recent videos posted by the now-deleted accounts had the AI avatars talk about a fabricated story of an orca attack that went viral and a nonexistent curfew for children based on a false law authorizing the abduction of children in the United States. The comments on a video about the false storyline fronted by Acevedo's AI avatar showed that while some users seem to have identified the content as false, other expressed distress over it, suggesting they believed the misinformation being spread. "These deepfakes hijack my voice, my image, and — more importantly — the trust I've built with audiences over the years. I'm leaning on transparency, calling them out publicly, but the scale of this threat is bigger than any one journalist," Acevedo told Mantzarlis, who wrote about his findings on his . A TikTok spokesperson told NBC News in a statement that the company 'banned these accounts for violating our Community Guidelines and continue[s] to vigilantly protect our platform from harmful misinformation and deceptive AI-generated content." Mantzarlis said there are probably hundreds more such accounts on the platform. He first began researching the trend more than six months ago. In March, Mantzarlis discovered a network of nearly 40 TikTok accounts posing as Telemundo and Univision that used AI-generated content and the voices of well-known professional journalists to spread misinformation about topics that tend to go viral on social media. The accounts went undetected for about a month before TikTok shut them down. But the trends Mantzarlis found on TikTok have evolved as more social media platforms integrate AI tools into their apps, making it easier to generate credible AI avatars, he told NBC News. Based on his research, Mantzarlis said the creators behind such TikTok accounts are constantly trying different ways to generate content that creates large viewership numbers to accumulate at least 10,000 followers — which is the minimum required to monetize videos under TikTok's Creator Rewards Program. The creators have 'determined that sensationalist news in Spanish, targeting a U.S. audience, does numbers, so they'll try to feed that niche,' he said. That's why some of them have even used AI-generated versions of non-native Spanish speakers — including a Brazilian journalist and comedians from 'The Daily Show,' an American satirical TV program — to spread Spanish-language misinformation. Mantzarlis said he found "very strong evidence" suggesting that such TikTok accounts are being built up to garner enough followers to monetize their videos. The monetized TikTok accounts are then sold to other people "who can change the topic and theme and find another niche' they can profit from. Mantzarlis found an encrypted chat group managed by Brazilian TikTok creators who claimed to sell monetized social media accounts that came pre-loaded with AI-generated clickbait content. In it, he saw someone claim to be selling a monetized TikTok account named "Tv Telemundo" for 300 Brazilian reals, or about $55. The account had posted AI-generated news and religious content to gain 11,000 followers under the previous name. The account now shares AI-generated wellness content. Marta Planells, Telemundo's vice president of digital news and streaming, told NBC News that the network has been reporting TikTok accounts impersonating Telemundo and their anchors for over a year. Once the accounts are reported, Planells said, TikTok has been proactive in shutting them down. But when that happens, more accounts come up, she added. Even after Mantzarlis published his research last week based on the initial sample of 88 TikTok accounts, he found six other accounts publishing misinformation fronted by AI avatars of real Latino journalists. TikTok also shut down those accounts. TikTok did not tell NBC News whether any of the accounts Mantzarlis identified were part of the Creator Rewards Program. TikTok claimed in a company report published this year to have proactively removed more than 94% of the content that it identified as violating its policies about AI-generated content and misinformation. Despite the efforts to remove false content, Ramos still encouraged his followers on TikTok to remain "vigilant, because misinformation is everywhere." "There are tons and tons of fake videos that appear to be real," he said. "This, of course, creates a lot of confusion."
