Protection orders and police ‘failing victims of GBV'
Protection orders are failing to protect women from being abused by their partners in gender-based violence (GBV) cases, despite restraining orders.
This is according to advocate Brenda Madumise-Pajibo, director of the feminist organisation, Wise4Afrika.
Wise4Afrika takes legal action against police
Madumise-Pajibo said her organisation had filed papers in the high court suing the police on behalf of the family of Sasha Lee Monique Shah, who was killed after police failed to confiscate her husband's gun as stipulated in an interim protection order.
'We are currently assisting the family to sue the police because they failed to seize the gun from the man. The order was issued by the Pinetown Magistrate's Court on 22 September 2022, while she was killed in October 2022 in Umhlanga, north of Durban,' Madumise-Pajibo said.
'We are in the process of launching litigation against the police. For now, I cannot divulge much information about this litigation.'
ALSO READ: Are police winning the war on gender-based violence?
Madumise-Pajibo was also concerned about the case of Gugu Nkuna from Phola near Ogies in Mpumalanga, whose former partner reportedly assaulted her and tried to rape her a few days ago, even though she had a protection order against him.
Protection orders not protecting victims
She said the two cases were evidence that protection orders were not protecting GBV victims from their abusers.
'There is something wrong here because the court will issue the order as expected, but the police are failing to enforce what the order requires.
'I think we need the government to establish a specialised unit which will only focus on GBV cases. What I have realised is that some of the police officers don't even read the court order documents, while those who read them seem not to understand or they are ignorant.'
ALSO READ: GBV: Convicted Western Cape rapist on the loose a 'direct threat to women's safety'
Nkuna told The Citizen that she obtained a protection order against her former partner in 2023, but he continued abusing her. When she reported the matter to the police, they did not take any action. She said during the recent attack, she was rescued by community members who phoned the police as the man stripped her naked, demanding to have sex with her.
GBV activist Sihle Sibisi from Kwanele Foundation said the police had let Nkuna down. 'She must open a case against them because they failed her by not taking action against the guy for violating the protection order. She must find a lawyer and open a case against them,' said Sibisi.
'The woman did what was needed to stop the abuse, but law enforcement agencies failed her.'
Nkuna's legal representative, Mabu Marweshe from Marweshe Attorneys, said they would open a criminal case of defeating the ends of justice against the officers who refused to assist her.
'It is very unfortunate.'
NOW READ: Grief claims grandfather after granddaughter's burial
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
Top 10 stories of the day: KT Molefe denied bail
Here's your daily news update for Wednesday, 20 August 2025: An easy-to-read selection of our top stories. News today includes controversial businessman Katiso 'KT' Molefe will remain behind bars after his bid for bail failed on Wednesday. Meanwhile, Parliament's Police Portfolio Committee Chairperson Ian Cameron and two other DA members fell victim to an attempted hijacking in Cape Town. Furthermore, Kaya FM has suspended broadcaster Sol Phenduka with immediate effect. Weather tomorrow: 21 August 2025 Extremely high fire danger conditions are expected in all provinces except Gauteng and the Western Cape. There will be rough seas between the Western Cape and the Northern Cape, but conditions will be mostly warm nationwide. Full weather forecast here. Stay up to date with The Citizen – More News, Your Way. DJ Sumbody murder: Katiso 'KT' Molefe remains behind bars as bail denied Controversial businessman Katiso 'KT' Molefe will remain behind bars after his bid for bail failed on Wednesday. Molefe appeared in the Alexandra Magistrate's Court to hear the outcome of his bail application. Controversial businessman Katiso Molefe appears for bail application at the Alexandra Magistrate's Court in Johannesburg on 6 August 2025. Picture: Nigel Sibanda /The Citizen The alleged mastermind was arrested alongside three hitmen in connection with the murder of South African artist Oupa John Sefoka, widely known as DJ Sumbody. CONTINUE READING: DJ Sumbody murder: Katiso 'KT' Molefe remains behind bars as bail denied De Lille dissolves SA Tourism board – but Outa calls her decision 'disgraceful' Tourism Minister Patricia de Lille has dissolved the SA Tourism board with immediate effect over what she called unlawful decisions. De Lille informed the board of her decision on 19 August, following consideration of their written representations as to why the board should not be dissolved. Minister of Tourism, Patricia de Lille. Picture: Neil McCartney / The Citizen The minister said the board members neglected to address the crucial question of the legality of the process the board used when calling a special board meeting on 1 August, when the unlawful resolution was taken. CONTINUE READING: De Lille dissolves SA Tourism board – but Outa calls her decision 'disgraceful' Ian Cameron, DA colleagues escape hijack attempt in Philippi after police academy visit Parliament's Police Portfolio Committee Chairperson Ian Cameron and two other DA members fell victim to an attempted hijacking in Cape Town. It is understood that Cameron and his fellow DA colleagues Nicholas Gotsell and Lisa-Maré Schickerling were in one car when three unknown men attacked their vehicle with bricks, smashing at least three windows, on the corner of Eisleben and Govan Mbeki Road on Tuesday afternoon. Chairperson of the portfolio committee on police Ian Cameron. Picture: X / @ParliamentZA They were returning from an oversight visit to the police training college in Philippi East when the incident occurred. CONTINUE READING: Ian Cameron, DA colleagues escape hijack attempt in Philippi after police academy visit Increase in inflation of 0.5% expected, but could drift higher The inflation rate increased by 0.5% from 3% in June to 3.5% in July. Economists expected an increase and say it could drift higher towards the end of the year, although not much. However, they are divided about whether the Reserve Bank will cut the repo rate again this year. Jee-A van der Linde, senior economist at Oxford Economics Africa, says the sharp increase of 0.5% is due to municipal tariff increases but the overall inflation outlook remains favourable. He expects that headline inflation will drift to slightly above 4% by the end of the year. Picture: iStock 'There was a risk of an upside inflation surprise, as July is a high-survey month, with municipal tariff increases typically coming in higher than the headline rate. However, the latest outturn does not change our view of inflation, with the benign outlook still intact.' CONTINUE READING: Increase in inflation of 0.5% expected, but could drift higher Kaya FM suspends Sol Phenduka pending an internal investigation Kaya FM has suspended broadcaster Sol Phenduka with immediate effect. 'Kaya 959 confirms that presenter Sol Phenduka has been placed on suspension with immediate effect. This step has been taken pending the outcome of an internal process currently underway,' read a statement shared with The Citizen by Ian Bredenkamp, who handles PR for the station. Sol Phenduka has been suspended by Kaya FM pending an investigation. Picture: solphenduka/Instagram When asked about the reason behind the suspension and its duration, Bredenkamp said they would release a follow-up statement 'once the internal process is concluded'. CONTINUE READING: Kaya FM suspends Sol Phenduka pending an internal investigation Here are five more stories of the day: Yesterday's News recap READ HERE: Rand manipulation saga in ConCourt | Eldos' Nikita laid to rest | RIP Tendai Ndoro
The Citizen
a day ago
- The Citizen
Top 10 stories of the day: Rand manipulation saga in ConCourt
Here's your daily news update for Tuesday, 19 August 2025: An easy-to-read selection of our top stories. In the news today, the Competition Commission says there is evidence that several banks colluded to manipulate the South African rand. Meanwhile, the community of Eldorado Park gathered at the Don Mateman hall for the funeral service of four-year-old Liquethan Nikita Kiewietse. Furthermore, the football fraternity is in mourning following the death of former Orlando Pirates and Zimbabwe international striker Tendai Ndoro, who has died at the age of 40. Weather tomorrow: 20 August 2025 The South African Weather Service (Saws) has warned that a dominant high-pressure system will result in fine and warm to hot conditions over Gauteng, Mpumalanga, North West, Limpopo and northern KwaZulu-Natal from Wednesday until at least Tuesday, 26 August. Full weather forecast here. Stay up to date with The Citizen – More News, Your Way. Competition Commission tells ConCourt rand manipulation saga similar to cartels The Competition Commission on Tuesday told the Constitutional Court (ConCourt) there is evidence that several banks colluded to manipulate the South African rand. Over the next four days, the ConCourt is set to hear arguments in a leave to appeal application brought by the commission after it lost in the Competition Appeal Court (CAC) in January 2024. Tembeka Ngcukaitobi at the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) on 4 September 2023. Picture: Gallo Images / Mlungisi Louw The case dates back to 2017, when the commission referred a complaint against 28 local and international banks to the Competition Tribunal. The complaint alleged that, between 2007 and 2013, banks manipulated the foreign exchange rate between the US dollar and the rand by sharing sensitive information through messaging platforms. CONTINUE READING: Competition Commission tells ConCourt rand manipulation saga similar to cartels SA companies lodge complaint against Truecaller app for violating Popia The community of Eldorado Park gathered at the Don Mateman hall for the funeral service of Liquethan Nikita Kiewietse. Eldorado Park residents have been on high alert after they initially contacted authorities about child abuse in the area. Last Wednesday, South African Police Service (Saps) responded to a complaint that Nikita's stepfather was physically abusing the child. Late four-year-old Nikita's funeral service at Don Mateman hall in Eldorado Park. Picture: Nigel Sibanda /The Citizen Upon arrival, police discovered a man with a young boy and girl. They noticed the girl lying on the bed with visible head injuries, bruises, and a swollen eye. The man was arrested on the spot, and the girl was urgently taken to a nearby medical facility. She was admitted to the intensive care unit (ICU), where she remained for two days before tragically succumbing to her injuries. CONTINUE READING: WATCH: A small coffin, a big loss: Eldorado Park mourns 4-year-old Nikita Former Orlando Pirates striker Tendai Ndoro dies at 40 The football fraternity is in mourning following the death of former Orlando Pirates and Zimbabwe international striker Tendai Ndoro, who has died at the age of 40. Ndoro, affectionately known as 'Fire' during his playing days, passed away on Monday evening after a long battle with illness. Former Orlando Pirates striker Tendai Ndoro has died at the age of 40. Picture: X/@Am_Blujay He had been battling diabetes since 2021. His struggles with the disease led to his retirement from football in 2020 due to vision issues. CONTINUE READING: Former Orlando Pirates striker Tendai Ndoro dies at 40 Amantle Samane's mother tells court she can no longer sleep and wants three life sentences for Simao The Johannesburg High Court on Tuesday heard the victim impact statement from Amantle Samane's mother ahead of the sentencing of Pethe Sara Simao, the Mozambican national who kidnapped, raped and murdered Amantle Samane. Amantle's mother, Ntombi Samane, explained to the court that she had not been able to sleep since her daughter's brutal murder. Pethe Sara Simao appears for murder of six-year-old Amantle Samane at the Johannesburg High Court on 11 August 2025. Picture: Nigel Sibanda/The Citizen 'This incident left me with hatred towards foreigners. When I wake up during the night to relieve myself, I will not sleep when I go back to bed. I will relive the pain and remember everything that happened and the state she was in when she was found,' an emotional Samane told the court. She further told the court that she wished for Simao to get three life sentences. CONTINUE READING: Amantle Samane's mother tells court she can no longer sleep and wants three life sentences for Simao Meet the world's youngest billionaire – Here's how the 20-year-old did it It was rapper 50 Cent who titled his album Get Rich or Die Tryin', and this is what most people in the world do. Becoming a billionaire can take decades, even a lifetime, and this is evident in Forbes' rich list. However, Forbes has revealed that the youngest billionaire in the world is a 20-year-old from Germany, and his net worth is about half of what South Africa's richest man owns. For illustrative purposes. Picture: iStock The youngest billionaire on the list is a 20-year-old Johannes von Baumbach, heir to Boehringer Ingelheim. His three siblings, aged 23, 25, and 27, are also on the youngest billionaires list, each with an estimated net worth of $5.8 billion (more than R102 billion). CONTINUE READING: Meet the world's youngest billionaire – Here's how the 20-year-old did it Here are five more stories of the day: Yesterday's News recap READ HERE: Top 10 stories of the day: Eldorado Park parents abandon bail bid | Limpopo nepotism, payments claims | How much DDP won
IOL News
a day ago
- IOL News
Gift of the Givers and SAPS unite to combat gender-based violence in the Garden Route
Gift of the Givers and SAPS in the Eden Cluster District partner for a GBV campaign. In celebration of Women's Month, humanitarian aid organisation, Gift of the Givers, has partnered with the South African Police Service (SAPS) to launch a gender-based violence (GBV) campaign. The organisation has partnered with the SAPS Eden Cluster District, and the campaign is set to support women across the Garden Route in the Western Cape. Gift of the Givers spokesperson, Ali Sablay, said that with GBV cases rising at an alarming rate and many women still afraid to report abuse, this initiative aims to break the silence and provide tangible support to affected communities. 'The campaign officially kicked off on Monday (August 18) across five SAPS stations and will expand in the coming days to include: Ladysmith, Calitzdorp, Oudtshoorn, Uniondale, Knysna, Plettenberg Bay, Mossel Bay, Riversdale, and Heidelberg,' he said.
