A ‘violation of democracy' people in North can't vote in presidential election, Dáil hears
The presidential election in the autumn must be the last one that excludes citizens in the North and those living abroad from voting, the Dáil has heard.
Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald said 'the President is not just president for the 26 counties, but for the entire Irish nation, regardless of the separation imposed upon us by partition'.
It is an injustice and 'a violation of democracy that Irish citizens in the six counties and those living abroad are denied the right to vote for their president', she said.
Ms McDonald was speaking as she introduced a Sinn Féin motion to implement the recommendations in 2013 of the Convention on the Constitution to extend voting rights in presidential elections to all Irish citizens on the island of Ireland.
READ MORE
The motion also calls on the Government to 'progress proposals that would extend the right to vote in presidential election to the diaspora' as well.
The Sinn Féin leader said Armagh won the Sam Maguire cup last year but 'you can be a champion of Old Ireland and yet be prevented from voting for the President of Ireland'.
Irish people living in the North can run in the presidential election and become President as Mary McAleese had done but 'you're barred from voting for yourself'.
Ms McDonald said the Northern Assembly passed a motion supporting extending the right to vote in the presidential election to all citizens resident on the island of Ireland.
'That was a powerful democratic message, one which reaffirms the principle of equality enshrined in the Good Friday Agreement,' she said.
Her party introduced legislation in 2014 to extend voting rights that passed second stage. A referendum had been set for May 2019, but it was postponed by the government and 'nothing has happened' since.
The commitment 'has even been dropped from the current programme for government. The Government's inertia cannot be allowed to continue'.
Her party colleague Rose Conway-Walsh said '141 countries allow enable their diaspora to vote' and it is 'absolutely mind-boggling' that Irish citizens in the North cannot vote.
Sinn Féin's Seán Crowe said 'Ireland does not end five miles from Dundalk or at the shores of Lough Foyle'. His party colleague Denise Mitchell said 'the President is the representative of the Irish nation and that nation does not just stop at an imaginary line that was dreamt up by the British and imposed on us over 100 years ago'.
The Government did not oppose the motion but Minister of State for the Diaspora Neale Richmond said he had a 'real fear' because extending the franchise requires a referendum and they should 'not underestimate the challenge constitutional change brings'.
They had to win the debate and 'to be quite frank, we have had two referendums in the past 12 to 14 months that most people in this chamber backed, and we got a fair kicking on them'.
Mr Richmond said 'it is not simply about naming the date' for a referendum. 'It is about formulating a campaign. It is about presenting a very clear question to the people that will show what happens if they vote for this. It will show how people will be facilitated to vote, how we will capture the citizens abroad.'
Labour TD Ciarán Ahern said a 'welcome first step would be the establishment of a special Oireachtas committee to tease out these issues and make substantive policy recommendations.
'There is cross-party consensus on the principle of extending the franchise for presidential elections but, as we saw with the repeal referendum, holding committee hearings in advance makes a substantial impact on informing the public debate.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
Offences against the State Act renewed without vote
Sinn Féin has insisted that it would have abstained on the renewal of the Offences against the State Act but it was ultimately not put to a vote after the party's Justice spokesperson was outside the Dáil chamber when it was passed. Matt Carthy had "stepped out" for a few minutes during the debate on the emergency measures that are renewed by the Oireachtas annually. When he returned, to an almost empty Dáil, he was told by the Ceann Comhairle Verona Murphy that the matter had been dealt with. Earlier, he had told the Dáil that the emergency legislation, which dates back 90 years, should not be used on an ongoing basis. Mr Carthy called for the the introduction of a modern legal framework to tackle organised crime and to protect jurors. Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan said that he has accepted in principle the recommendations from a independent review group. It called for the repeal of the Act along with the establishment of a non-jury court on a standing basis. It would be available when ordinary courts were inadequate. However, he said this would have to be approached with the utmost caution and he indicated that the new system may not be in place before the Offences against the State Acts are due for renewal again next year. The Minister said that so called 'dissident republicans', who have their origins in the Provisional IRA and the INLA, continue to pose a threat, the Dáil has heard. Despite the progress towards peace made over the years, they continue to seek to return to the fruitless violence of the past, he said. "They have remained resolute in their opposition to democracy and rule of law and all that the Good Friday Agreement stands for; and they remain wedded to brutality and criminality," Minister O'Callaghan said. He said that it is also important not to lose sight of the threat from violent extremism and international terrorism. The Minister added that terrorism - particularly jihadist and lone actor attacks - remains a key risk to the EU's internal security. Ireland is not immune from the threats arising in this changed security environment, and the country must have the capability to deal with them, the Minister said.
The Journal
an hour ago
- The Journal
Men who abuse women 'not only tolerated, they are celebrated', Dáil hears
The Journal / YouTube THE ISSUE OF domestic abuse dominated Leaders' Questions today following the publication of a report by Women's Aid, which showed record demand for their services last year. Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon delivered a passionate speech arguing that the problem needs to be reframed as a men's issue. He agreed with Labour leader Ivana Bacik that Ireland is now dealing with an epidemic of domestic abuse and railed against the notion that domestic abuse is only perpetrated by 'monsters'. He also argued that social media is 'supercharging' domestic abuse. 'This didn't happen by accident. We've allowed this violence to grow, and I'm fearful about where it is headed, because we're now living in a culture where perpetrators of abuse are not only tolerated, they are celebrated. 'They are the President of the United States and sports stars with multi-million euro contracts. 'Influencers poison our young men with misogyny packaged as self-help. This network of anti-women communities online, full of grifters, abusers and con men, is flooding social media with hate and as a State, we're doing almost nothing to stop it,' he said. Gannon also referred to the case of Irish woman Jill Meagher, who was raped and murdered by a stranger in Australia in 2012. 'Her husband, Tom, wrote about the monster myth. In that book, he explained to us that abusers are often thought of as monsters, broken, unrecognisable, but they're not. 'They're often our colleagues, our neighbours, our friends, and that myth lets all of us off the hook. 'Like the man shouting at a woman in a bar, the hand on her back that she didn't invite, the so called jokes about rape being shared in WhatsApp groups. That is how violence is normalised. 'The epidemic of men's violence against women continues to be framed as a woman's issue across all facets of society, but minister, make no mistake, men's violence against women is a crisis for men to be part of solving. Advertisement 'We've created a society where there is such a pervasive sense of male violence against women that we've had to coin the phrase femicide to describe the epidemic. Even the very term allows men to evade accountability for this ongoing crisis. 'As men, we need to do more than shake our heads. We need to call it out when we see it, because to be silent is to be complicit,' Gannon said. The issue was raised also raised by Sinn Féin and Labour, with Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald telling the Dáil that all the statistics are going in the wrong direction. In the last year, reported instances of physical abuse were up 22%, sexual abuse increased by 30%, emotional abuse was up 15%, and economic abuse was up 5%. A third of women who reached out to Women's Aid for help were subjected to abuse by an ex-partner. 'Behind these statistics are real women and their children, real lives shattered,' McDonald told the Dáil. 'The report reflects that government must do a far better job to achieve zero tolerance of violence against women.' Labour leader Ivana Bacik acknowledged that progress has been made in recent years, noting the establishment of the government's domestic abuse agency Cuan, but she said, despite this, the scale of domestic abuse in Ireland has reached epidemic levels. She also said the suite of laws in place to deal with domestic violence, while welcome, are 'ineffective' if gardaí are not adequately equipped to respond to women who report domestic abuse in the first instance. The Women's Aid report today highlighted a huge shortfall in the garda response to domestic abuse, with 44% of women surveyed saying they found the garda response 'unhelpful'. Responding to Bacik, Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan acknowledged that not all gardaí have specialised training to respond to domestic abuse, however, he maintained that women who are then referred to specialised garadaí have a positive experience. The Justice Minister agreed with Gannon on the idea that domestic abuse needs to be reframed as a men's problem. 'This is a societal issue, in fact, it's more of an issue for men and boys than it is for women, because regrettably, my sex are the sex that perpetrate this violence against women to the large extent. 'So we have to start warning boys and young men about the unacceptability of using violence in a relationship,' O'Callaghan said. He added that pornography 'must be having an extraordinary impact on young men, because it presents women in a very submissive, malleable manner'. 'And we just need to warn people at a young age, [through] education that it is so unacceptable to use violence in a relationship. So not all the solutions are through the criminal justice system.' Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Dublin transport contactless payment system not operational until 2029, says minister
Contactless payments across Dublin's bus, tram and railway public transport networks will not be fully operational until 2029, Darragh O'Brien has told an Oireachtas hearing. The first testing phase of the 'next-generation ticketing' contactless payments system will be introduced in 2027 in a 'controlled area within Dublin across bus, rail and Luas', the Minister for Transport told Wednesday's Oireachtas hearing on 2025 transport estimates. A second phase is scheduled to run in summer 2028, with a third one to follow in 2029, he said. 'Obviously how we roll it out will be dependent on the first phase – if that goes well and the testing of that is robust and we don't require many system changes,' Mr O'Brien said in response to a query on the system from Green Party leader Roderic O'Gorman. 'By 2027 to 2029 we would have the system fully operational.' READ MORE The Minister said he was investigating whether it was possible to 'shorten the distance' between the first two testing phases, but he could not give a commitment on that. 'It is a roll-out of, effectively, a whole new contactless ticketing system that's going to be with us for a generation and will make a very significant change.' A National Transport Authority report published this year stated contact payments on public transport would take about three years to deliver. Spanish company Indra is responsible for the introduction of the contactless system across bus, tram and rail services. Asked by Fine Gael TD Grace Boland whether the Government planned to maintain the 90-minute €2 fare beyond the end of this year, Mr O'Brien said it was his 'intention to keep that'. The Minister also referred to the extension of free travel for five- to eight-year-olds from September and extending student travel fares to 25-year-olds. Anecdotally, recent fare reductions have resulted in more people taking public transport, the Minister said. However, it was difficult to quantify how many people were opting for bus or rail as a result of such price cuts, he said. Recently published data showed more than one million public transport journeys are now taken in Dublin daily. The Oireachtas committee also heard how the number of electric-vehicle (EV) charging points across the State remained far behind the European Union average. At present, there are seven EV charging posts for every 10,000 people, compared to an EU average of 20 per 10,000 and 13 per 10,000 in the UK, Sinn Féin's Pa Daly told the committee. People needed to have 'confidence that the battery will take them far enough, but also that they'll be able to recharge around the State', Mr Daly said. He also cited a recent warning from the Climate Change Advisory Council that the Government did not support access for lower-income families to EVs, which jeopardised emissions targets. Acknowledging that the number of charging points was below the EU average, Mr O'Brien said his department was addressing the shortfall and investigating EV grant options for lower and middle-income families and for rural dwellers. Asked if this would include grants for second-hand EVs, Mr O'Brien said it would. Earlier on Wednesday, the Minister told Newstalk Breakfast radio he did not expect the State would hit its projection of one million EV users by 2030, but said numbers would most likely reach 630,000-700,000 by the end of the decade. Responding to concerns from Mr O'Gorman regarding the 'almost systematic removal of references to cycling in this programme for government', Mr O'Brien told the committee the TD could 'be absolutely assured that this Government is as committed as the last to continue the real advancements that were made over the last five years in the provision of active travel schemes'. In addition to the Government's commitment to spend €360 million on public transport infrastructure, Mr O'Brien said his department would seek additional funds through the updated National Development Plan to improve 'active travel'.
