Restoring sea floor after mining may not be possible, researchers warn
Particularly coveted are potato-sized nodules containing cobalt, nickel, copper and manganese, that are found in abundance on the seabed in the central Pacific Ocean.
Companies eager to vacuum up these polymetallic nodules say they can do it with minimal risk to the deep-sea environment.
But ocean defenders have battled against what they see as the advent of an industry that will threaten isolated ecosystems that are not yet well understood.
That threat was underscored by European scientists who presented findings this week on the sidelines of a meeting in Kingston, Jamaica of the International Seabed Authority, which is trying to finalize future rules for seabed mining.
"If we remove nodules from the seabed, we do not know what we lose, only that it's lost forever," was one of the conclusions of DEEP REST, a sea floor conservation research project.
The DEEP REST study cautioned against using seabed restoration "as a management action for impacted habitats."
"So far, all the restoration operations we have attempted within our DEEP REST project have been short-term. And what we observed, is that in the given time, that is to say a few years, the ecosystems do not recover," said Jozee Sarrazin, a researcher at the French Institute for Ocean Science, or Ifremer.
"If restoration is possible, it will take a very long time, and at the moment we don't have the data to be able to say if that will be 100 years or 1000 years," the DEEP REST coordinator told AFP.
Despite the pressure, the cold, the total darkness, and the lack of nutrition sources at the bottom of the ocean, it is teeming with life.
The number of species who live on the deep seabed is not yet known but estimated to be in the millions.
Soft corals, sea anemone
Broad swathes of the Pacific Ocean where polymetallic nodules are found shelter fauna such as sponges, soft corals or sea anemones.
The fauna "only exists in these areas because they need the hard substrate of the nodule to attach," said Matthias Haeckel of the German research center GEOMAR, which presented results of the MiningImpact project in Kingston this week.
Vacuuming up these nodules and spreading sediment over the impacted areas reduces population densities, biodiversity and the functioning of ecosystems, MiningImpact's study found.
"To make the story short, in the end, we're talking about recovery times of thousands of years," Haeckel said. The nodules themselves form over millions of years.
Some research on restoration efforts is underway but the results are not yet in.
"We designed artificial nodules made of deep-sea clay and we placed them at different sites" at depths of about 4,500 meters (14,700 feet), Sabine Gollner, a biologist at the Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research, told AFP.
"But when you take into account the slow growth rates in the deep sea, the slow processes, it will take quite some more years to find out if restoration is effective and to what degree," she said.
Massive deposits of sulfide -- a type of mineral deposit found in underwater vents that spit out seawater heated by magma -- should be off-limits, the researchers suggest.
These types of underwater geysers are teeming with astonishing and unique biodiversity.
"If we extract massive sulfides near active vents, we know what we lose, and we must prevent loss," the DEEP REST study says.
But according to Gollner, it would be good to incorporate restoration goals into the mining code being negotiated by the International Seabed Authority's member states.
"It's good to include it but with a clear statement that at this moment in time, it cannot be taken into account to reach agreed environmental goals," she said.
"For example, a contractor shouldn't be allowed to use that argument to mine a larger area."
© 2025 AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sustainability Times
6 days ago
- Sustainability Times
'This Is Deliberate Destruction': Hawai'i's Reefs Hit by Record Acid Surge as Locals Accuse Authorities of Sacrificing Ocean Life
IN A NUTSHELL 🌊 Ocean acidification near Hawai'i could reach levels not seen in thousands of years, threatening marine life. near Hawai'i could reach levels not seen in thousands of years, threatening marine life. 🔬 Researchers use high-resolution models to predict significant changes in ocean chemistry through the 21st century. through the 21st century. 🐠 The study highlights the potential for coral adaptation , but warns of unprecedented challenges to reef ecosystems. , but warns of unprecedented challenges to reef ecosystems. 🧪 Ongoing research aims to explore impacts on Hawai'i's fisheries and identify strategies for sustaining coral reefs. The oceans surrounding Hawai'i, known for their vibrant coral reefs, are facing an alarming threat from ocean acidification, a phenomenon exacerbated by increasing carbon dioxide levels. Recent studies reveal that these waters could soon reach acidity levels not seen in thousands of years, posing a severe risk to marine ecosystems. This development is particularly concerning for the Hawaiian Islands, where coral reefs play a crucial role in biodiversity and the local economy. As researchers continue to study these changes, there is an urgent need for action to protect these precious marine environments. Ocean Acidification: A Growing Threat to Hawaiian Waters The increasing acidity of the world's oceans presents a significant risk to marine life, particularly coral reefs. As oceans absorb more carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, their pH levels decrease, leading to a more acidic environment. A recent study conducted by oceanographers from the University of Hawai'i at Mānoa indicates that acidification levels near the main Hawaiian Islands could reach unprecedented levels within the next three decades. This rise in acidity is particularly detrimental to marine ecosystems, as it weakens the shells and skeletons of sea creatures like corals and clams, making them more susceptible to other environmental stressors. Despite these challenges, there is hope. Some marine species have shown signs of adaptation to the changing conditions, offering a glimmer of optimism for the future. The research highlights the importance of understanding these changes and developing strategies to protect Hawaiian coral reefs and sustain marine ecosystems. By providing critical insights, the study aids scientists, conservationists, and policymakers in their efforts to safeguard these vital habitats for future generations. 'They Stole Our UFO and Made It Scarier': Pentagon Officials Furious as China Unveils Alien-Looking Surveillance Drone Copy Modeling the Future: Predicting Acidification Around Hawai'i Advanced modeling techniques have been employed by researchers to predict future ocean acidification near the Hawaiian Islands. Led by Brian Powell from the University of Hawai'i, the research team utilized high-resolution computer models to project changes in ocean chemistry through the 21st century. Their projections are based on various climate scenarios that reflect different levels of carbon dioxide emissions, offering a comprehensive view of potential outcomes. According to Lucia Hošeková, the lead author of the study, significant increases in ocean acidification are expected in the surface waters around the main Hawaiian Islands, even if carbon emissions stabilize by mid-century. The extent of these changes varies depending on the emission scenario, with high-emission scenarios posing the greatest threat to coral adaptation. The concept of 'novelty' was introduced to describe the difference between projected acidification and historical conditions, revealing that windward coastlines are likely to experience the most dramatic changes. 'They're Hiding Something Under the Ice': Scientists Clash After Bizarre Radio Signals Emerge from Deep Beneath Antarctica Unexpected Changes: Shifts in Coral Environments The study's findings regarding future levels of ocean acidification were unexpected, as they highlight conditions far beyond the natural variations that coral ecosystems are accustomed to. Tobias Friedrich, a co-author of the study, emphasized the unprecedented nature of these projections for Hawaiian waters. While corals have shown some ability to acclimatize to slightly elevated acidity, the magnitude of projected changes poses significant challenges to their adaptability. Researchers acknowledge that the impact on corals will depend on the global climate scenario that unfolds. In the best-case scenario, corals may still be affected, but the situation could be manageable. This underscores the need for ongoing research to examine the combined effects of various stressors on corals. The study serves as an initial step in understanding the complex changes affecting corals and other marine organisms, with a focus on how these changes vary across the Hawaiian Islands. 'This Jet Will Shatter Laws of Physics and Privacy': X-59 Sparks Outrage as NASA Pushes Supersonic Silence into Civilian Skies Looking Ahead: Future Research and Resilience The research team is committed to further investigating the future changes in Hawaiian waters, specifically focusing on heat stress, potential refugia for coral reefs, and the impacts on Hawai'i's fisheries. By continuing to explore these areas, scientists aim to develop strategies that promote resilience and long-term sustainability for coral ecosystems. Reference: 'Patterns of Ocean Acidification Emergence in the Hawaiian Islands Using Dynamically Downscaled Projections' by L. Hošeková, T. Friedrich, B. S. Powell, and C. Sabine, published in the Journal of Geophysical Research: Oceans. DOI: 10.1029/2024JC021903. The future of Hawai'i's coral reefs hinges on our ability to mitigate the impacts of ocean acidification and climate change. As researchers delve deeper into understanding these environmental challenges, the question remains: what innovative solutions will emerge to protect these invaluable ecosystems for generations to come? This article is based on verified sources and supported by editorial technologies. Did you like it? 4.5/5 (21)
France 24
24-07-2025
- France 24
Cook Islands wages war on 'plague' of hungry starfish
These makeshift tools are their best weapons in the war against crown-of-thorns starfish, a coral-munching species eating through tropical reefs already weakened by climate change. The Cook Islands, a South Pacific nation of about 17,000 people, is in the grips of a years-long outbreak, says marine biologist Teina Rongo. "It can completely kill off the entire reef, right around the island," said Rongo, who organises volunteers protecting the reefs fringing the isle of Rarotonga. "I think there seems to be a Pacific-wide outbreak at the moment, because we're hearing other countries are facing similar challenges." A single crown-of-thorns adult can eat more than 10 square metres (110 square feet) of reef each year, squeezing its stomach through its mouth to coat coral in digestive juices. They pose a major threat to Australia's Great Barrier Reef, where scientists have developed robots that hunt down the prickly invertebrates and inject them with poison. "At the moment, you basically kill them by injection," said researcher Sven Uthicke, from the Australian Institute of Marine Science. "It could be vinegar, it could be lime juice or ox bile. "Others are building chemical attraction traps. It's all very promising -- but it's in the development stage." Rongo finds it quickest to pry the feasting starfish loose using a wooden stick cut from the dense timber of the Pacific Ironwood tree. "Basically, we use a stick with a hook at the end," he said. "We've made some modifications over time because we were getting pricked by these starfish. It's painful." Named for their hundreds of venomous spikes, crown-of-thorns starfish have as many as 21 fleshy arms and can grow larger than a car tyre. They are typically found in such low numbers that they are not considered a problem. But sporadically populations explode in a feeding frenzy that rapidly strips the life from reefs. 'Plague proportions ' They spawn in "plague proportions", according to the Australian Institute of Marine Science, and are a major driver of coral loss. From the Red Sea to the Pacific Ocean, crown-of-thorns outbreaks appear to be becoming both more frequent and more severe. "Some argue that the crown-of-thorns has become chronic in the last few decades," said Rongo, talking about the reefs of the South Pacific. Scientists suspect these outbreaks are triggered by a mix of factors, including nutrients leached into the sea from agriculture and fluctuations in natural predators. But the damage they can cause is getting worse as reefs are weakened by climate change-fuelled coral bleaching and ocean acidification. "This is why it's important for us to help the reef," says Rongo. Scuba divers scour the Cook Islands' reefs for hard-to-spot starfish wedged into dimly lit crevices. Once peeled off the coral, the starfish are pierced with a thick rope so they can be dragged back up to a waiting boat. The day's haul is dumped into a plastic chest before the starfish are lugged ashore to be counted, measured and mulched for garden fertiliser. They are known as "taramea" in Cook Islands Maori, which loosely translates to "spiky thing". The volunteer divers working with Rongo and his environmental group Korero O Te Orau -- or Knowledge of the Land, Sky and Sea -- remove thousands of starfish every year. Rongo is spurred by the devastation from the nation's last major infestation in the 1990s. "I was part of that eradication effort. © 2025 AFP
France 24
24-07-2025
- France 24
Walking 7,000 steps a day a huge boost to health: research
The most widely promoted target for people tracking their number of steps is 10,000 -- but that figure reportedly originally came from a 1960s marketing campaign for a Japanese pedometer. To find a more scientific target, an international team of researchers sifted through 57 previous studies that covered 160,000 people. The results published in the Lancet Public Health journal found that walking 7,000 steps a day nearly halved people's risk of early death from all causes, compared to 2,000 steps. The study also looked into health problems not previously covered by research into step counts. Walking 7,000 steps a day was linked to people's risk of dementia falling by 38 percent, depression dropping 22 percent and diabetes decreasing 14 percent. It was also associated with lower rates of cancer and falls, though the researchers warned this was based on less evidence. "You don't need to hit 10,000 steps a day to get major health benefits," Paddy Dempsey, a study co-author and medical researcher at Cambridge University, told AFP. "The biggest gains happen before 7,000 steps, and then benefits tend to level off," he said. While people's speeds vary widely, 7,000 steps adds up to roughly an hour of walking throughout the day. Dempsey emphasised that people already managing 10,000 or more steps should keep it up. But he had a message for people who might find 7,000 steps daunting: "don't be discouraged". "If you're only getting 2,000–3,000 steps a day, aim to add an extra 1,000 steps. That's just 10–15 minutes of light walking spread across the day," he said. Andrew Scott, a researcher at the University of Portsmouth not involved in the study, said that "it demonstrates that overall more is always better". "People should not focus too much on the numbers, particularly on days where activity is limited," he added. The World Health Organization recommends at least 150 minutes of moderate to intense physical activity a week. Nearly a third of people worldwide do not reach this target, according to the WHO.
