Ipoh High Court awards RM822,000 to parents in medical negligence case
Judicial Commissioner Moses Susayan made the ruling in favour of Zuasnita Baharudin, 45, and Hishamuddin Shaharum, 58, after the defendants had admitted liability in the matter.
According to court documents, the couple brought their son, Hiejjaz Fadzlie, to the hospital on April 5, 2018, with symptoms of fever, cough, and difficulty breathing.
Despite clear signs of respiratory distress, medical intervention was delayed, and the treatment administered was inadequate, with no proper escalation to a specialist facility.
The child suffered for over a month with multiple complications before succumbing to septic shock and passed away on May 21, 2018.
Zuasnita and Hishamuddin subsequently filed a lawsuit, naming 44 defendants — including several doctors, Hospital Raja Permaisuri Bainun (HRPB), and the government.
Delivering his judgment on damages, Moses said the case was marked by 'exceptional neglect and inaction,' which led to the child's prolonged suffering and inflicted deep emotional trauma on his parents.
"Despite the child's worsening condition, there was no documented discussion between specialists regarding stabilising and transferring the child.
"There was no structured medical plan by any of the 44 defendants to stabilise and manage the child's condition effectively.
"The parents were kept in the dark about the child's deteriorating condition and the need for a transfer until two weeks after admission.
"The child was left under the care of medical officers only, without proper specialist intervention, despite clear signs of deterioration," he said in his 59-page judgment uploaded on the Judiciary Department's website yesterday.
The court subsequently awarded RM22,180 in special damages, RM300,000 in general damages, and RM500,000 in aggravated damages.
However, the court disallowed the plaintiffs' claim for vindicatory damages, as it failed to meet the required legal threshold of proving that the defendants' conduct was outrageous, oppressive, malicious, or unconstitutional.
The court also awarded RM101,333.85 in cost to the plaintiffs.
The plaintiffs were represented by lawyer Ranjit Singh while senior federal counsel Masriwani Mahmud@Mamat appeared for the defendants.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Borneo Post
23 minutes ago
- Borneo Post
State Govt supports setting up Sabah's first children's hospice
Liew (third left) witnessing the presentation of a mock cheque for RM200,000 raised from a public collection and the fund-raising dinner, by the president of the Malaysian Medical Association (MMA), Dato' Dr Kalwinder Singh Khaira (fourth left) to the Vice-President of the Malaysian Association of Paediatric Palliative Care (MAPPAC), Dr Ng Su Fang. Looking on from right are Founder of Sepeda Amal Borneo cum Organising Chairman, Dr Timothy Cheng, President Elect of the Malaysian Medical Association (MMA), Datuk Dr Thirukanavarasu Rajoo, eight-year-old cancer patient Ashton Jacob, MP for Bentong, Young Syefura Othman, and chairman of MMA Sabah Branch, Dr Brandon Patrick Senagang (left). KOTA KINABALU (Aug 1): The State Government supports the vision of the Malaysia Medical Association (MMA) and Malaysian Association of Paediatric Palliative Care (MAPPAC) to establish the state's first children's hospice, said Chief Minister Datuk Seri Panglima Haji Hajiji Haji Noor. 'The State Government recognises the importance of palliative care for children. Addressing these challenges will be an important step in our ongoing efforts to strengthen healthcare equity and uphold our commitment to people-centred development,' he said. The initiative by the MMA in collaboration with MAPPAC to raise funds and awareness to build the Children Hospice in Sabah through the SEPEDA Amal Borneo 2025, a cross-Borneo cycling campaign, is a noble effort, he said at the SEPEDA fund-raising dinner at the Hilton Hotel here today. Tourism, Culture and Environment Minister Datuk Seri Panglima Christina Liew delivered his speech. 'Children with serious and life-limiting illnesses deserve not only medical attention, but also dignity, comfort and a sense of peace – wherever they are, whether in hospital or at home. 'Their families need support, understanding, and the assurance that they are not walking this arduous journey alone. 'Nationwide, an estimated 80,000 children are in need of such care, and right here in Sabah, around 9,000 children live with life-limiting and non-curable illnesses. 'These young children and their families deserve not only medical care, but compassion, dignity and support throughout their journey,' he said. The Chief Minister noted that while progress has been made, access to specialised paediatric palliative care can still be limited in certain parts of Sabah, particularly in rural and interior areas. 'I was told that at the moment, paediatric palliative care is provided solely by a dedicated team at the Sabah Women's and Children's Hospital, Likas, since 2013. The unit receives more than 100 referrals a year and this number is increasing,' he said. In this regard, Hajiji lauded the dedication of the Ministry of Health for continuing to develop this service in Sabah as well as the MAPPAC for its efforts to bring free home-based palliative care services to communities across Sabah. He also congratulated the 17 cyclists from around the world for embarking on this challenging journey in the name of charity, having cycled from Sandakan one week ago and arrived in Kota Kinabalu yesterday. 'This cross-Borneo cycling campaign is not just a show of endurance; it is a journey of compassion and hope. By raising both funds and awareness for the establishment of the children's hospice in Kota Kinabalu, you are helping to build a lifeline for children and families in need,' he said. He said the MMA's leadership in this cause reflects a deep commitment to public service, extending beyond the clinic and the hospital, which is a testament to what the medical profession stands for. 'In this regard, I applaud the MMA's efforts and synergy in serving communities and in this regard, expanding resources to paediatric palliative care, complementing the government's role for a more inclusive and compassionate Sabah,' he said. 'The impact of your initiative will enrich the fabric of our society and significantly enhance the overall well-being of our communities. On behalf of the State Government of Sabah, I thank you for your exemplary efforts,' he said.
New Straits Times
an hour ago
- New Straits Times
Health Ministry to present vape ban timeline to Cabinet
KUALA LUMPUR: The Health Ministry will present a timeline for a full ban on the use and sale of electronic cigarettes or vapes to the Cabinet, pending input from health experts. Health Minister Datuk Seri Dr Dzulkefly Ahmad said the ministry is currently awaiting recommendations from the health expert community before taking the next step. "As for a timeline, I cannot provide an exact date. What I can confirm is that we will continue to review and evaluate the matter. "Once the expert community provides its recommendation to the ministry and the minister, we will present it to the Cabinet for consideration," he said at a press conference after Op Selamat Paru-Paru (Op Selamat PaPa) here today. Dzulkefly said the ministry is currently in the educational enforcement phase of the Control of Smoking Products for Public Health Act 2024 (Act 852), which regulates vaping products and is scheduled for full enforcement on Oct 1. He said the ministry now is moving towards a total ban on vape products based on scientific and medical evidence including real-life cases. "I want to reiterate that the issue is not if a ban will happen, but when. It is only a matter of time. "We want this to be executed thoroughly, not hastily, because there are significant legal implications, public health consequences and evidence that must be carefully scrutinised. "We will proceed based on a detailed, evidence-based approach," he said. He said any decision regarding a full ban would also need to consider legal and policy impacts, and the ministry is committed to a measured approach that weighs all relevant factors. Meanwhile, on Op Selamat PaPa, he said as of now, 281,381 premises have been inspected nationwide, and 459 investigation papers have been opened for various offences. Of these, he said, 340 cases were opened under Section 7 for the offence of advertising smoking products. "Another 68 investigation papers were opened under section 14 for selling smoking products not in accordance with the prescribed pricing and conditions. "51 investigation papers were opened under section 15 for manufacturing, importing or distributing smoking products that do not comply with packaging and labelling requirements," he said. He said upon conviction, first-time corporate offenders face a fine of RM20,000 to RM100,000, imprisonment of up to two years, or both. For repeat offences, he said, the penalty increases to a fine of RM50,000 to RM300,000, imprisonment of up to three years, or both.
Borneo Post
3 hours ago
- Borneo Post
Deputy Premier: Wider AED access, greater CPR awareness key to building more inclusive, developed Sarawak
John (third right) and Dr Chou (sixth right) hold an AED unit as Dr Sim (fifth right) looks on during a group photo today. – Photo by Kong Jun Liung KUCHING (Aug 1): Deputy Premier Datuk Amar Dr Sim Kui Hian has called for greater accessibility to automated external defibrillators (AEDs) and increased public awareness of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) as Sarawak moves toward becoming a more inclusive and developed society. He said while having AEDs in public spaces is vital, public understanding of CPR is equally critical in saving lives during emergencies. 'Someone can collapse, and within five minutes, if you don't help them, even if the heart rhythm returns later, the brain may be dead. 'More people must learn CPR and teaching secondary school students is a good start. 'At least they will know what to do at home if their grandparents collapse,' he told reporters after witnessing the handing-over ceremony of AEDs to the Malaysian Red Crescent Society (MRCS) Kuching branch and the Unifor Complex here today. The AEDs were donated by Mindray AED. Dr Sim, who is also State Minister for Public Health, Housing and Local Government, said while AED units can range from RM6,000 to RM8,000 depending on features, basic models suitable for emergencies can cost under RM4,000. 'What we need is a basic AED that delivers a 300 to 360-joule shock. 'But that technology, some of it even can check your respiration and all those things, so it depends on what you need,' he said. On whether the government would provide AEDs in public spaces, Dr Sim said it should be a shared responsibility. 'It's no longer an excuse for public places like hotels or malls to say they can't afford one. It shouldn't be entirely the government's job. 'Everyone must play a part in nation-building. It shouldn't always be up to the government. Public facilities such as hotels and malls should take responsibility. 'There's no excuse anymore to say an AED is unaffordable,' he said. He added that Sarawak is currently reviewing its building ordinance to include requirements for AEDs, fire safety, and sustainability standards under the Green Building Index. 'The building ordinance is being reviewed to bring it up to date with current needs. If we talk about sustainability, our laws must reflect that,' he said. Meanwhile, MRCS Kuching Branch Deputy Chairman Dr Chou Chii Ming highlighted the organisation's ongoing campaign to promote CPR and AED awareness. 'This year, we launched a campaign focusing on CPR and AED education. 'We've partnered with DBKU (Kuching North City Commission) and the state Education Department to conduct training and demonstrations for their staff,' he said. He added that MRCS Kuching has also begun conducting CPR and AED training in secondary schools across the city to equip the younger generation with essential life-saving skills.
