Pakistan's Defence Minister Admits ‘Hybrid Rule', Says Army Too Holds Power In Civil-Military Setup
This marks the second time in a week that Asif, currently serving in Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif's cabinet, has acknowledged the presence of a hybrid arrangement.
Pakistan's Defence Minister Khawaja Asif, a senior leader of the ruling Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) and a close aide of former Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif, has openly stated that the country is operating under a 'hybrid model" of governance in which the military holds a fair share of power.
This marks the second time in a week that Asif, currently serving in Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif's cabinet, has acknowledged the presence of a hybrid arrangement. Analysts have long criticised this setup as a 'fixed government to serve subsidiary interests," rather than a genuine power-sharing model.
Asif's remarks came during an interview with Arab News aired on Friday evening and are being widely interpreted as confirmation that the Sharifs' PML-N is functioning with the endorsement of Pakistan's powerful military establishment.
Describing the hybrid civil-military structure as a shared arrangement, Asif said: 'This is a hybrid model. It's not an ideal democratic government. So, this hybrid arrangement, I think it is doing wonders. This system is a practical necessity until Pakistan is out of the woods as far as economic and governance problems are concerned."
He further argued that if such a model had been implemented in the 1990s, when Nawaz Sharif was twice elected prime minister, Pakistan might have avoided prolonged friction between civilian and military leadership. 'The confrontation between the military establishment and the political government would retard the progress of democracy," he added.
The defence minister's statement has reignited debate over the PML-N's political trajectory and its now-contradictory past slogan of 'vote ko izzat do" (give respect to the ballot). Critics argue that Asif's frank admission cements the perception that the PML-N has aligned itself firmly under the military's umbrella, abandoning its previous anti-establishment stance.
Former Prime Minister Imran Khan, a long-time rival of the Sharifs, has repeatedly claimed that the general elections held on February 8 were the 'Mother of All Rigging" and accused the PML-N and its coalition partner—the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) led by Bilawal Bhutto Zardari—of being 'mandate thieves."
Following Asif's admission, political observers say the future of Pakistan's democratic institutions remains precarious. 'This (Trump-Munir) meeting has lifted the thin, see-through veneer of 'elected'. What the world has known for quite a while is now in the open… where is the centre of power in Pakistan and who is in control of real state powers? The political allies (military) in power have presented themselves as the 'government' now," remarked political analyst Dr Rasul Bakhsh Rais, reported news agency PTI.
He further noted: 'Khawaja Asif and others now have to seek some legitimacy to praise the merits of the hybrid model, which actually doesn't mean a mixed but a fixed government to serve subsidiary interests."
Dr Rais described the current political system as the third iteration of a hybrid regime since Imran Khan's ouster in 2022. Unlike previous periods under General Ziaul Haq and General Pervez Musharraf, both of whom built new political alliances, this time, he said, major parties like the PML-N and PPP have willingly assumed the role of 'political facade."
He concluded that the military's orchestration of electoral victories for the PML-N and PPP has reduced them to mere appendages of the establishment. 'Now, the priority of the Sharifs and Zardaris as well as the military establishment is to neutralise the third force — Imran Khan's PTI — which is perceived as a danger for all of them," he said.
Senior journalist Matiullah Jan also weighed in with sharp criticism on X: 'What a fall from grace for a politician. This defence minister takes oath to defend the constitution which makes no mention of the so-called hybrid form of government." He added, 'The fact is that this system is not even a hybrid system but a pure and simple dictatorship with political pygmies at the heels of affairs."
Location :
New Delhi, India, India
First Published:
June 21, 2025, 21:38 IST
News world Pakistan's Defence Minister Admits 'Hybrid Rule', Says Army Too Holds Power In Civil-Military Setup
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Israel-Iran Trade Fresh Blows as US Bombers Fly Over Pacific
Israel and Iran launched new strikes in a second week of hostilities, with the Isfahan nuclear facility targeted again, as Donald Trump deepened uncertainty about his readiness to join the conflict. The US military dispatched several B-2 bombers and refueling tankers over the Pacific Ocean from a base in Missouri, according to several media reports. The move is a possible sign that the planes are being positioned for a possible strike, although the Wall Street Journal cited officials saying that no order has been given to ready an operation. Israel warned the US it didn't want to wait the 'two weeks' the president laid down as his timetable for deciding whether to join the strikes, Reuters reported, citing two anonymous people. That warning was delivered in a 'tense' phone call with Trump officials on Thursday. On Saturday, Israeli jets attacked Iran's Isfahan site for the second time, targeting a centrifuge production section, the Israel Defense Forces said. There were no leaks of hazardous material, Iran's semi-official Fars News reported. Israeli jets later on Saturday targeted military infrastructure in southwest Iran. The IDF earlier said it had identified missiles launched from Iran and was working to intercept them. Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz said Saeed Izadi, who led part of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps' overseas arm linked to financing and arming Hamas in Gaza, was killed in the Iranian city of Qom. Behnam Shahriyari, another IRGC member linked to supplying Lebanon's Hezbollah and other militias, was also killed, along with a third commander, according to an Israeli military official. Separately, Yemen's Houthi militants said they will target US vessels and battleships in the Red Sea if the US gets involved to support the Israeli attack on Iran, according to a statement published on a Houthi spokesperson's official Telegram account. After stepping up threats against Iran earlier this week, Trump appeared to dial back tensions Thursday, saying that he would hold off for now to give diplomacy a chance. On Friday, he hinted at shortening the deadline, but also suggested he 'might' support a ceasefire while talks were underway. Iran has demanded the attacks stop before it enters negotiations, something Israel has refused to do. 'I'm giving them a period of time,' Trump told reporters in New Jersey, after meeting earlier Friday with his national security team. 'I would say two weeks would be the maximum.' Foreign ministers from the UK, France and Germany met their Iranian counterpart in Geneva on Friday. They made little apparent headway. 'Iran doesn't want to speak to Europe. They want to speak to us,' Trump said. 'Europe is not going to be able to help them.' French President Emmanuel Macron, in a post on X Saturday, said he spoke with his Iranian counterpart Masoud Pezeshkian and that he would accelerate the negotiations. Macron also reiterated his position on Iran's nuclear program, saying that Iran needed 'to provide full guarantees that its intentions are peaceful.' Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi said Iran is ready to hold another meeting with the Europeans in the near future, the state-run IRNA news agency reported. No follow-up meeting has yet been scheduled and there was no agreement on where or in what format such talks would take place, according to a European official. The proposals made by the Europeans were unrealistic, Reuters cited an unidentified Iranian official as saying. Oil prices fell on Friday following a Reuters report that Iran is ready to discuss limitations on uranium enrichment, though they're still up significantly from before the conflict. A jittery week ended with losses in stocks as investors weighed geopolitical and trade developments. The dollar had its best week since February. The Iranian judiciary's Mizan news agency reported on Saturday that 430 people were killed and more than 3,500 wounded since the war began June 13. In Israel, at least 24 people have been killed and hundreds injured, the Associated Press reported. Araghchi was in Istanbul on Saturday to attend a summit of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, according to state-run TV. He is also scheduled to meet Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan on the sidelines. 'Israel is dragging our region into instability with the backing of western powers,' Erdoğan told the summit. Before a two-month-old negotiation process with the US was suspended in the wake of Israel's attack, Tehran had signaled its willingness to accept some restrictions on its enrichment activities. Israel and the US have said the Islamic Republic shouldn't be allowed to enrich uranium at all. 'We don't know how we can trust them anymore,' Araghchi said of possible talks with the US, in an interview with NBC on Friday. 'What they did was in fact a betrayal to diplomacy.' Most experts say a successful strike against the subterranean nuclear enrichment site at Fordow would require American participation, since Israel doesn't have the kind of munitions — like the most powerful bunker-buster bombs — with the ability to penetrate that deep underground. But there's a debate on the issue, with some claiming Israel has the necessary tools. Trump repeated his stated belief that Iran was a matter of weeks from getting a nuclear bomb when Israel attacked, and again dismissed US intelligence findings that Iran's leadership wasn't seeking to do so. He is due to attend a national security meeting again on Saturday. While some argue that US participation would shorten the war by eliminating Fordow quickly, others say it would escalate the conflict and risk spreading it to the wider region, including neighboring Gulf states. 'This war flies in the face of the regional order the Gulf countries want to build, which is focused on regional prosperity,' Anwar Gargash, a senior diplomatic adviser to the United Arab Emirates' president, told reporters in a briefing Friday. 'There are many issues in the region, if we choose to tackle everything with a hammer nothing will be left unbroken.' With assistance from Skylar Woodhouse, Valentine Baldassari, Samy Adghirni, Jordan Fabian, Chris Martlew, Akayla Gardner, Donato Paolo Mancini, Golnar Motevalli, Asli Kandemir, Ellen Milligan, Iain Rogers, Hadriana Lowenkron, Sara Gharaibeh and Fadwa Hodali. This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Israel Hits Isfahan Nuclear Site as US Sends Mixed Signals
Israel and Iran launched new strikes in a second week of hostilities, with the Isfahan nuclear facility targeted again, as Donald Trump deepened uncertainty about his readiness to join the conflict. Israeli jets attacked Iran's Isfahan site for the second time, targeting a centrifuge production section, the Israel Defense Forces said. There were no leaks of hazardous material, Iran's semi-official Fars News reported. The IDF earlier said it had identified missiles launched from Iran and was working to intercept them. Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz said Saeed Izadi, who led part of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps' overseas arm linked to financing and arming Hamas in Gaza, was killed in the Iranian city of Qom. Behnam Shahriyari, another IRGC member linked to supplying Lebanon's Hezbollah and other militias, was also killed, along with a third commander, according to an Israeli military official. Iranian state TV said five members of the IRGC were killed in the western province of Lorestan on Saturday. After stepping up threats against Iran earlier this week, Trump appeared to dial back tensions Thursday, saying that he would hold off for two weeks to give diplomacy a chance. On Friday, he hinted at shortening the deadline, but also suggested he 'might' support a ceasefire while talks were underway. Iran has demanded the attacks stop before it enters negotiations, something Israel has refused to do. 'I'm giving them a period of time,' Trump told reporters in New Jersey, after meeting earlier Friday with his national security team. 'I would say two weeks would be the maximum.' Foreign ministers from the UK, France and Germany met their Iranian counterpart in Geneva on Friday. They made little apparent headway. 'Iran doesn't want to speak to Europe. They want to speak to us,' Trump said. 'Europe is not going to be able to help them.' Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi said Iran is ready to hold another meeting with the Europeans in the near future, the state-run IRNA news agency reported. No follow-up meeting has yet been scheduled and there was no agreement on where or in what format such talks would take place, according to a European official. Oil prices fell on Friday following a Reuters report that Iran is ready to discuss limitations on uranium enrichment, though they're still up significantly from before the conflict. A jittery week ended with losses in stocks as investors weighed geopolitical and trade developments. The dollar had its best week since February. Araghchi was in Istanbul on Saturday to attend a summit of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, according to state-run TV. He is also scheduled to meet Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan on the sidelines. 'Israel is dragging our region into instability with the backing of western powers,' Erdoğan told the summit. Before a two-month-old negotiation process with the US was suspended in the wake of Israel's attack, Tehran had signaled its willingness to accept some restrictions on its enrichment activities. Israel and the US have said the Islamic Republic shouldn't be allowed to enrich uranium at all. 'We don't know how we can trust them anymore,' Araghchi said of possible talks with the US, in an interview with NBC on Friday. 'What they did was in fact a betrayal to diplomacy.' Most experts say a successful strike against the subterranean nuclear enrichment site at Fordow would require American participation, since Israel doesn't have the kind of munitions — like the most powerful bunker-buster bombs — with the ability to penetrate that deep underground. But there's a debate on the issue, with some claiming Israel has the necessary tools. Trump repeated his stated belief that Iran was a matter of weeks from getting a nuclear bomb when Israel attacked, and again dismissed US intelligence findings that Iran's leadership wasn't seeking to do so. He is due to attend a national security meeting again on Saturday. While some argue that US participation would shorten the war by eliminating Fordow quickly, others say it would in fact escalate the conflict and risk spreading it to the wider region, including neighboring Gulf states. 'This war flies in the face of the regional order the Gulf countries want to build, which is focused on regional prosperity,' Anwar Gargash, a senior diplomatic adviser to the United Arab Emirates' president, told reporters in a briefing Friday. 'There are many issues in the region, if we choose to tackle everything with a hammer nothing will be left unbroken.' With assistance from Samy Adghirni, Jordan Fabian, Chris Martlew, Akayla Gardner, Donato Paolo Mancini, Golnar Motevalli, Asli Kandemir, Ellen Milligan, Iain Rogers, Hadriana Lowenkron, Fadwa Hodali and Skylar Woodhouse. This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Trump ‘BETRAYS' Thousands Of Stranded Afghans As Pakistan Scales Up Deportations
/ Jun 22, 2025, 02:08AM IST Afghan refugees stuck in Pakistan are waiting to move on to a third country. DW met one family who thought they were about to head to the US before this month's abrupt shift in US policy and President Trump's travel ban for Afghans. Pakistan, meanwhile, is scaling up deportations.
