MP Tom Rutherford Calls For Inclusive Student Sport After Homeschooled Athlete Denied Medal
In a powerful show of support for home-schooled students, MP for Tauranga Tom Rutherford has called for greater inclusivity in student sport following a meeting with 13-year-old mountain biker Amelia Twiss and her mother, Toni.
Amelia, a talented young athlete, placed second in the North Island Secondary School Mountain Biking Championships. However, she was denied her medal—not because of her performance, but because she is home-schooled.
'This is unfair,' Rutherford wrote in a post shared on his official Instagram account. 'Every young athlete deserves recognition for their achievements, no matter how they receive their education.'
Rutherford has since written to Sport and Recreation Minister Mark Mitchell, urging a review of School Sport New Zealand (SSNZ) regulations that currently exclude home-schooled students from full participation and recognition in student sport.
'With more than 10,000 home-schooled students across New Zealand, this affects many young Kiwis. Sport should be inclusive for all our young people. I'm committed to helping make that happen,' he added.
HESSA (Home Educators Student Sports Association) welcomes MP Rutherford's advocacy and applauds his commitment to fairness and equity in youth sport. His stance reflects growing public concern over the systemic exclusion of home-schooled domestic students from school-sanctioned competitions—despite these students being legally recognised under the Education and Training Act 2020.
'Sport is a powerful connector. It builds confidence, fosters friendships, and allows students to be part of a wider sporting community,' said Mel Ewart, Chair of HESSA. 'Denying home-schooled students the chance to compete as equals alongside their peers is not just unfair—it's harmful.'
Currently, home-schooled students are only permitted to participate in individual student sports, but not to compete officially. In team sports such as futsal, table tennis, and hockey, home-schooled students may only join through composite school teams, which are often excluded from championship events while homeschool-only teams are not allowed.
'These restrictions limit access to sport not just nationally, but also at local and regional levels—cutting students off from the weeknight and weekend sports that many of us take for granted.' said Ewart. 'This isn't just about medals—it's about belonging,' Ewart continued. 'When home-schooled teens are excluded from student sport, they're also excluded from connection, development, and opportunity alongside their friends and peers.'
HESSA is calling for a student sport system where every young person—regardless of their education pathway—can play, compete, and thrive.
To that end, HESSA will be presenting a parliamentary petition in early July, asking that Sport NZ funding be made conditional on allowing home-schooled students to compete in student sport.
'We're calling on every Kiwi who believes in fairness to stand with us,' said Ewart. 'Sign the petition. Help us end sports exclusion for good.'
The petition is available at https://our.actionstation.org.nz/p/sportforall
The Home Educators Student Sports Association is the national body representing the rights of approximately 11,000 home-schooled domestic students to engage and compete in student sport. HESSA's current strategic focus is to ensure equal sporting opportunities for secondary-aged home-schooled students.
As of 1 July 2024, there were 3,956 secondary-age home-schooled students, 1.3% of the national secondary-aged student body who are excluded from equitable access to student sport.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
2 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Doffing his cap to history
My oldest boy wanted to please his dad when he was young and one way to his dad's heart was through rugby. My husband never enjoyed actually playing rugby, but he had a love for the game. He would get the kids up in the early hours of the morning to watch a game or go to a game at the stadium, there was regular screaming at the screen about a losing Highlanders side, poor refereeing, or legendary All Black tries. It was a culture in our house, but it was also a wider family culture too. I was raised as if rugby were a religion, watching it but being schooled on the fact that the art of rugby surged through our veins and that we have an extensive history and ownership with the game. My great uncle was a bit of a rugby legend and, in fact, we have others who come from Ōtākou, clearly we were made for the game. Thomas Rangiwahia Ellison was born in 1866 and was to become one of New Zealand's most famous rugby sons. About 1881 he was introduced to rugby football by his cousins at Ōtākou — Jack Taiaroa, who was to become a prominent member of the first New Zealand rugby team in 1884, and Riki Taiaroa, who later joined Ellison in the touring Native team of 1888-89. In 1882, Tom was sent to Te Aute College, Hawke's Bay, where he played for the senior team in 1883 and 1884. His first international honours came with the New Zealand Native Football Team, a professional side, which toured Great Britain and Australia in 1888-89. Initially a forward and later a wing, Ellison played half-back for Pōneke in 1891, and from that experience developed the wing-forward, or flanker, position to block interference with passing from the base of the scrum. The system was quickly adopted throughout New Zealand; it was superseded by the eight-man scrum in 1932. In 1893, Ellison captained the first official New Zealand team and he proposed that the uniform be a black jersey with silver fern monogram — this was similar to the old Native team uniform — and in 1901 it became the familiar All Black uniform. In 1902 he published The Art of Rugby Football , an early rugby coaching manual. Eventually, Ellison took a keen interest in Kāi Tahu land claims: he was appointed an interpreter in the Native Land Court in 1886 and stood three times for the Southern Maori seat in Parliament. From 1891 he worked as a solicitor and, from 1902, as a barrister in the Wellington law firm Brandon, Hislop and Johnston, he was admitted to the Bar, one of the first Māori to attain that distinction. He became a familiar figure commuting to work from Eastbourne in one of the first motor cars seen in Wellington. Ellison died a young man in 1904 and was buried at Ōtākou. I grew up with these legendary stories about our great rugby players and our family have produced many more talented players. It's probably a fair call to say, it's an Ellison thing — he momo. So, circling back to my son, a descendant of all that rugby whakapapa, who, like most Kiwi lads, started playing rugby when he was 5. I will confess that I was fairly unenthusiastic about the whole thing. Cold Saturdays, injuries, intense sideline parenting and the perceived culture of it all just didn't flick my switch. However, I made all efforts to support him. The thing is, my son wasn't a natural rugby player. He struggled to keep up, he wasn't overly interested in the game and, like the rest of my children, he really doesn't have that competitive killer attitude that is required on the field ... I mean, I was just happy he was getting a run. However, apart from one year that we put him into football, he played rugby, year in, year out. Ultimately, he just loved the brotherhood, the team camaraderie, the banter, the laughs and he really got a kick out of his team winning and his team-mates doing well. I think perhaps the coaches got a laugh, too, out of coaching my son, as he was pretty entertaining. He went away to his Māori boys boarding school in the North Island a few years ago now, as he is in his last year. He continued to play the game at school, and I just assumed it was expected that he did. He naturally got taller and leaned out, he trained a bit at school and kept in it. He took on basketball too and loves the game but still played rugby. He said his life would flash before him on a Saturday as massive boys with killer attitudes would come running at him. In some regards, I am glad I have never had to watch this rugby warfare with my beautiful boy in the middle of it. Through all his rugby trials and tribulations, he said the one thing he wanted was to make his dad proud and get that 1st XV cap, and he has done it. In two weeks' time he gets his wish, presented with his cap by his pōua (grandfather) at his school. So, with that, my son gets to acknowledge the journey in the game, the injuries, the wins, the losses, the growth, his brotherhood, his tūpuna, his dad and, finally, his cousin Taiaroa, also a descendant of these Ōtākou rugby legends, whose amazing rugby talent has been halted by cancer. This is my son's salute.
1News
14 hours ago
- 1News
'Run it' goes underground: Backyard version of tackle game live streamed
Another "run it straight" event took place in a backyard last night, taking a more scaled-down approach to the controversial craze. After having its event at Barfoot & Thompson Stadium in Kohimarama cancelled last month, Up the Guts NZ decided to go ahead in a nondescript backyard, believed to be in Auckland, and livestream it over social media. The craze involves two people running at and crashing into each other at speed. Last week, 19-year-old Ryan Satterthwaite died after he received a serious head injury while playing a game based on the dangerous trend with friends in Palmerston North. Similar events have received backlash, with health officials and brain injury advocates concerned about the dangers of the activity. ADVERTISEMENT With public venues cancelling the events, it appears to have moved onto private property. Participants collide at last night's event (Source: Instagram) Last night's event took place under a gazebo at an address believed to be in Auckland. While only a small crowd of people gathered to watch, more than 13,000 tuned in over social media. Participants squared off from each side of the property, in the hope of winning a $5000 cash prize. In the livestream, one of the announcers could be heard saying he was looking for some "massive hits tonight". A $500 cash prize was awarded to the participant with the biggest hit. In a difference to other events, all participants wore headgear and mouthguards. They also ran at each other from a much closer distance. ADVERTISEMENT Up the Guts NZ and its organiser, Kimami Ngaluafe, both claimed it was being held to 'raise awareness for mental health and suicide in our neighbourhoods'. Two participants collide at last night's event. (Source: Instagram. ) According to NZ Herald, Ngaluafe said Up the Guts had implemented greater safety measures. 'For example, we have half the running distance to minimise collision impact. Mouthguards, headgear and shoulder protection are compulsory here. We have on-field spotters, first-aiders and medics on-site. Participant safety is our No. 1 priority,' he said. 'But not only that, our biggest goal is to raise awareness for mental health and suicide. Mental Health New Zealand stats show the Māori and Pasifika, especially our men, have the highest rates of suicide in this country, particularly our young males aged 15 to 24 years old.' 1News has approached Ngaluafe for comment on last night's event. Mouthguards and headgear won't prevent brain injury, expert says ADVERTISEMENT Brain Injury NZ Vice-President and AUT associate professor with the National Institute for Stroke and Applied Neurosciences, Kelly Jones, said the footage from last night's event was 'pretty hard to watch'. She said that things like mouthguards and headgear wouldn't limit the risk of a brain injury to those participating in the activity. Brain Injury NZ Vice-President and AUT associate professor with the National Institute for Stroke and Applied Neurosciences, Kelly Jones (Source: Supplied) 'The brain is a soft, jellylike substance surrounded by fluid within a hard casing, being our skull. 'If the head is travelling along at speed and comes to a sudden stop, the brain can keep travelling and slam into the skull. That's where we see brain injuries ranging from concussion through to more moderate and severe traumatic brain injuries. 'Mouthguards are designed to protect mouths and teeth – they do that very well. But mouth guards and headgear do not protect against brain injuries. They're not going to stop the brain moving inside the scalp and potentially being bruised.' She criticised the call for 'massive hits'. ADVERTISEMENT 'Mouthguards and headgear with 'massive hits' are not going to prevent brain injury.' Stacey Mowbray of Headway said Ryan Satterthwaite's death was an 'absolute tragedy' but wasn't surprised it happened. (Source: 1News) Jones said that wearing mouthguards and headgear could even have a 'reverse effect'. 'The wearer thinks, oh, I can really go all out, give it my all because I'm protected.' She said there was 'no way' to reduce the risk of brain injury in these activities, 'We've got two people running straight towards each other, and people are looking for massive hits. The risk of brain injury cannot be eliminated.' Jones also said it was 'interesting' to see the organisers used the event to promote mental health awareness. ADVERTISEMENT 'Having a concussion, which is a mild form of traumatic brain injury, through to more severe injury, does heighten the risk of problems with mood, anxiety, depression and risk of suicide. 'They're likely complex relationships, but we know that they exist, so it's interesting to hear that the spin on that has been to promote means health. 'I don't see how this activity will achieve that.' Teen's death sparked warnings, condemnation Ryan Satterthwaite, 19. (Source: Ryan Satterthwaite was at a 21st party when he and his friends decided to have some 'harmless fun' and have a go at their own imitation of a 'run it game'. He suffered a serious head injury while being tackled and was taken to the hospital by his friends. He died on the evening of 26 May. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon called Satterthwaite's death an 'absolute tragedy'. ADVERTISEMENT 'It's incredibly tragic for the young person involved, for their family, for their friends. It's a good reminder for people to take personal responsibility, for individual responsibility, to think about the activity,' he told Newstalk ZB. 'But I'd also say to adults and sports influencers and celebrity influencers, or whatever it is driving this sort of craze, they should be thinking and reflecting very strongly right now.' Pete Satterthwaite, Ryan's uncle, called the activity 'utter stupidity'. 'Don't do it, it's utter stupidity. It seems like a bit of harmless fun, and as a teenager, I probably would have been doing the same thing with my friends, but no one gives any thought to the consequences," he said. Ryan Satterthwaite, 19, suffered a serious head injury while playing a game based on the controversial craze. (Source: 1News) 'They can have all of the medical supervision they like. They can have all the tackling practice that they like, but nothing is going to prevent serious injuries from happening." He called on athletes and others who were influential in the space to speak out against participating in the activity. ADVERTISEMENT 'I am hoping that out of this, we'll get some All Blacks, some rugby league players to stand up and express what a dumb idea that this particular game is,' he said. NZ Rugby urged people not to participate in similar events. 'Those wanting to play contact sports should register for a school or club team and learn in a controlled and safe environment how to tackle safely and the art of evasion.'
1News
16 hours ago
- 1News
'Proper main event' - Parker in talks over next opponent
Joseph Parker, denied another world title shot recently due to the reliably murky dealings of professional boxing, is in negotiations over his next fight which will probably be against an Englishman in the United Kingdom in September. It won't be against Londoner Daniel Dubois, the IBF heavyweight champion who suddenly became ill and unable to fight Parker in Dubai in February, an affliction which coincided with the arrival in Riyadh of WBC, WBA and WBO world champion Oleksandr Usyk. Dubois will fight Usyk to unify the heavyweight championship at Wembley Stadium on July 20 NZT, leaving Parker, ranked No.2 by the WBO behind Usyk, kicking his heels on another world title shot until next year at the earliest should he get through his next assignment. His team are currently talking through the options in terms of opponents and there are several, including former foes Derek Chisora and Dillian Whyte, plus former cruiserweight world champion Lawrence Okolie. Parker's manager David Higgins told 1News: 'We're in negotiations. At this stage all I can say is that it's a big name. It's a proper main event.' ADVERTISEMENT Parker beat Chisora, now 41, twice in Manchester in 2021 and would be the least attractive opponent from a fans' point of view. There would be interest in a rematch against Whyte, however, after the Londoner beat Parker in controversial fashion in 2018 four months after the Kiwi lost his WBO world title to Anthony Joshua in Cardiff. Whyte got the better of an accidental head clash between the pair in the second round at London's O2 Arena, a heavy blow that was ruled a legitimate knockdown by referee Ian John-Lewis. Joseph Parker goes down after a head clash against Dillian White in London in 2018. (Source: Photosport) Parker rallied bravely and sent Whyte to the canvas in the 12th and final round, but effectively ran out of time and his rival was awarded an unanimous decision. Parker has made it clear that he would welcome the chance for revenge against Whyte, who failed a drugs test in 2023 but was last year cleared after he was found to have taken a contaminated supplement. Okolie, considered the fourth best heavyweight in the United Kingdom behind Dubois, Tyson Fury and Joshua, is a 32-year-old former cruiserweight with a 21-1 professional record. ADVERTISEMENT Fights against Whyte and Okolie would have merit for Parker, but the biggest name of the lot, in the absence of the 'retired' Fury, his good friend, would be Joshua, the man who took his world title. Joshua has been inactive since losing to Dubois in London in September last year but is back training and a fight between he and Parker would genuinely be, in Higgins' words, a 'proper main event'. It would clearly be hugely risky for Parker, who is on a hugely impressive six-fight winning streak, including a second-round knockout of Dubois' late replacement Martin Bakole, but he has never been one to shy away from a challenge. Joshua's stocks have fallen significantly since he lost his world title to Usyk in 2021 and the re-match a year later. He regained momentum with a four-fight winning streak that included a stunning first-round knockout defeat of UFC heavyweight Francis Ngannou but was exposed by Dubois at Wembley six months later. Joshua was dropped four times in five rounds by Dubois, the final knockdown coming via a right cross which scrambled his senses. He was once the biggest name in boxing but after such a beating – and that's what it was – Joshua may need a less challenging opponent than Parker, now 36-3 as a pro, as a comeback fight. Whoever it is, Higgins said he would like the contract signed as soon as possible for Parker, 33, to return to Dublin for what is likely to be a 10-week training camp with coach Andy Lee. ADVERTISEMENT 'You never know in boxing,' Higgins said when asked about a time frame. 'Our goal is to get it signed and sealed soon.'
