Sydney Sweeney American Eagle campaign sparks controversy over alleged Nazi and eugenics symbolism
@americaneagle
I saw Sydney Sweeney wearing a pair of American Eagle jeans and a tank top, so I bought a pair of American Eagle jeans and a tank top. ♬ original sound - American Eagle
Several TikTok videos criticizing the campaign went viral, with comments suggesting the visuals echoed disturbing historical ideologies. One user wrote, 'Nazis went out of style, little over 60 years ago. SS doesn't stand for Sydney Sweeney.' Another added, 'Blonde hair, blue eyes, HOLDING A GERMAN SHEPHERD!!! What were you all thinking?' Critics also reacted strongly to a clip where Sweeney crosses out 'genes' and writes 'jeans' on a billboard, calling it 'subtle 1930s Germany.'
However, the campaign also drew praise from conservative commentators who viewed the criticism as overblown. Some claimed the backlash was part of a culture war, with X users defending Sweeney as a symbol of traditional values and rejecting accusations of racism. Sydney Sweeney, who has largely avoided sharing her political views, has expressed support for LGBTQ+ rights and reproductive choice in the past.
Marketing expert Dr. Amelie Burgess from the University of Adelaide suggested that the controversy was likely an unintentional result of poor creative oversight and lack of diversity on AE's marketing team. She noted that provocative messaging without cultural awareness can lead to unintended associations. Burgess added that while the backlash may hurt the brand temporarily, the long-term impact depends on how both American Eagle and Sweeney respond moving forward.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
9 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Stephen Colbert weighs in on Sydney Sweeney's controversial American Eagle Ad
Stephen Colbert is poking fun at the backlash surrounding Sydney Sweeney's recent American Eagle ad, which has sparked a fierce cultural debate. The Late Show host addressed the controversy on Wednesday night's episode, jokingly calling the uproar yet another example of the internet being 'mad about something.' The ad, which features the Euphoria actress posing in denim with a voiceover referencing her 'genes,' uses a wordplay comparing 'genes' and 'jeans.' While some viewers saw it as a lighthearted marketing ploy, critics online accused the brand of promoting racist, pro-eugenics messaging due to its focus on a white, blonde, blue-eyed model. Colbert aired the ad before mocking the outrage: 'Just like Sydney Sweeney, I also carry the gene for sexy commercial scratchy voice — I get it from my uncle on my mother's side.' He continued, 'Some people are seeing something sinister… suggesting the ad promotes eugenics, white supremacy, and Nazi propaganda. That might be a bit of an overreaction — although Hitler did briefly model for Mein Kampfort Fit Jeans.' He ended with a punchline: 'How do you say 'badonk' in German?' Not everyone appreciated Colbert's lighthearted take. Some fans pushed back on social media, arguing that the concerns over racial representation in advertising are valid. Comments ranged from accusations of tone-deafness to critiques of the brand's decision to cast only a blonde, blue-eyed model. The controversy has drawn comparisons to a 1980s Calvin Klein ad featuring a young Brooke Shields, which faced similar backlash for perceived sexualization and messaging. Even the White House got involved, with spokesman Steven Cheung tweeting that the ad's backlash represents 'cancel culture run amok,' linking it to broader voter discontent from the 2024 election. The ad continues to spark conversation about media, race, and branding in pop culture.
Express Tribune
18 hours ago
- Express Tribune
American Eagle apology over Sydney Sweeney ad goes viral amid backlash
A viral apology attributed to American Eagle has reignited controversy surrounding its Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans campaign. The statement, widely shared on social media, includes references to Sweeney's appearance and marketing tone. While many have labeled the message as satirical, American Eagle has not confirmed whether the apology is official, parody, or user-generated. The message includes lines such as 'we underestimated her blue eyes, blonde hair, and general hotness,' which many found to reinforce the very criticisms aimed at the campaign. 🤔Fake or not, this American Eagle 'apology' for Sydney Sweeney's ad has us laughing! With stock soaring 10%, are fans rejecting the woke outrage? #SydneySweeney #AmericanEagle — anonymous (@unveriified) July 30, 2025 The ad series, featuring slogans like 'Genes are passed down… My jeans are blue,' has been criticized for blurring the lines between playful wordplay and outdated messaging around beauty standards and genetic traits. In response to mounting criticism, the company disabled comments on LinkedIn and quietly replaced some campaign visuals with imagery featuring a woman of color. However, no formal public statement has been issued by American Eagle regarding the backlash or the viral apology post. Despite the debate, the 'Sydney Jean' product sold out rapidly following the campaign's launch, and the brand saw a 10–18% uptick in stock value. Proceeds from the limited-edition item are being donated to the Crisis Text Line, a nonprofit offering mental health and domestic violence support. The apology, authentic or not, has added a new layer to the conversation, highlighting the sensitivity of brand messaging in today's media climate and the speed at which unofficial content can shape public perception.
Express Tribune
19 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Sydney Sweeney's 'great jeans' ad sparks comparisons to Brooke Shields' 80s Calvin Klein campaign
Sydney Sweeney's new campaign with American Eagle has stirred debate online, with critics drawing comparisons to Brooke Shields' controversial Calvin Klein advert from 1980. The tagline, 'Sydney Sweeney has great jeans,' has been called out for its double meaning, with some viewers noting a perceived reference to 'great genes.' In the campaign video, Sweeney reclines while buttoning her jeans, saying, 'Genes are passed down from parents to offspring, often determining traits like hair colour, personality and even eye colour. My jeans are blue.' Sydney Sweeney x American Eagle, oh my god. — Sydney Sweeney Daily (@sweeneydailyx) July 24, 2025 Critics argue that, when delivered by a blond, blue-eyed actress, the message veers uncomfortably close to themes associated with eugenics. The ad's style also reminded many of Shields' Calvin Klein commercial, which featured the then-15-year-old saying, 'You want to know what comes between me and my Calvins? Nothing.' That ad faced backlash for its suggestive tone and the sexualisation of a minor. American Eagles ad campaign with Sydney Sweeney is right out of Calvin Klein's ad history with Brooke Shields — Marlin, Esq (@nostalgiafkninc) July 24, 2025 Social media users have reacted strongly, with some describing the American Eagle ad as 'very uncomfortable' and 'not even artistic or original.' Others suggested the campaign deliberately mimicked Shields' ad to provoke attention, especially given its link to the Crisis Text Line nonprofit. While some defended the ad as harmless fashion marketing, others found the echoes of past controversies troubling. 'I was naive, I didn't think anything of it,' Shields recalled of her own experience in a 2021 Vogue interview, noting how public reaction surprised her.
