Tender for €9m school phone pouches plan is shelved in favour of 'storage solution' plan
The €9 million spend was among the most contentious
measures announced in Budget 2025 last October
.
Earlier this year, tender documents were
issued seeking the contract for the
'Provision of Secure Mobile Phone Pouches for Students in Post Primary Schools'.
This tender process was subsequently cancelled by the Department of Education following advice from the Chief State Solicitor's Office and a new process was put in train.
Speaking in the Dáil today, Tánaiste Simon Harris said this was a 'pragmatic and sensible way to proceed' and that schools would still be able to seek funding for lockable pouches or an alternative solution later this year.
'Guidance will soon be provided by circular to all schools on putting in place policies to ensure schools are mobile phone-free zones during the school day,' Harris said.
Further guidance will be provided to post-primary schools, outlining the terms, conditions and mechanisms for post-primary schools to apply for funding to enable them purchase secure mobile phone storage solutions.
'Schools will now be able to apply for funding for what phone storage solution works best for them. Examples already include the pouches you referenced, but also lockable boxes or cubbies, drop off and collection at the school office, what works best for the school.'
Advertisement
He added: 'I think this is a pragmatic and sensible way to proceed.'
Harris also said that this funding arrangement would be available for schools in autumn 2025.
'We're now going to very shortly see a new procurement process published in the coming days,' he said.
An application process will be open to post-primary schools soon, and the issue of funding will commence shortly thereafter.
In a statement to
The Journal
earlier this week, the Department of Education said that there will be no delay in allowing schools apply.
'The department had commenced a tender process for the provision of mobile phone pouches earlier in the year. Following advice received from the Chief State Solicitor's Office, the department took the decision to cancel this process. A new procurement process will be published in the coming weeks,' the department said.
'This central procurement arrangement will be available to schools in autumn 2025. This will not delay schools in applying for and accessing the funding process for phone storage solutions, which will be open to schools soon.'
When the plans were announced last year, some teachers and parents
were critical of the measure
, suggesting the money could be spent better elsewhere – and that teenagers will find workarounds to the phone restrictions.
At the time, then-education minister Norma Foley said it was 'a health and wellbeing measure' to improve student learning outcomes, sociability and mental health within schools.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Older renters face rising costs on slim pensions, while the Government is silent on the issue
According to the last census, between 2016 and 2022, the number of over-65s renting from a private landlord increased by 83 per cent to almost 17,000 households . With landlords now permitted to reset rents to market rates on new leases every six years from March 2026, older tenants are a particularly vulnerable cohort of renters. In 2023 the Residential Tenancies Board reported that nearly three-quarters of older renters (45+ years old) belong to skilled, semi-skilled and manual occupations. In 2021, renters over 65 were also likely to be spending more than 35 per cent of their disposable income on rent. Given rent inflation since then compared to increases in the likes of the State pension, this percentage is likely to be higher now, and when rents are allowed rise to the 'market rate', this will increase significantly. Unsurprisingly then, according to Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI) data , if home ownership continues to fall the poverty rate among over-65s will more than double from 14 to 31 per cent . Given that Ireland's welfare model needs people to be homeowners by retirement so they can then afford to live on a modest State or personal pension, the obvious question is: how are these renters aged over 65 going to pay their rent on retirement when their salary or income drops in many cases by 50 per cent or more? The median disposable income for a single over-65 household was €20,067 in 2024 ; the average rent for existing tenancies nationwide in 2024 was €17,280 annually (and €20,160 for new tenancies). READ MORE What is most likely to happen is the rental payments of older tenants will be supplemented using the Housing Assistance Payment (HAP), otherwise known as the taxpayer. Already over half a billion euro a year , the more rents rise, the greater the State's HAP bill, with its use reducing supply in the private sector and driving up rents. The Dáil's Public Accounts Committee recently said that HAP and its sister Rental Accommodation Scheme ' do not provide the State [with] long-term assets and are not effective long-term solutions to social housing needs '. No different from any other tenants, but far more vulnerable, a lack of security of tenure is much more serious for older renters more than half of whom also have long-term health issues. In Bantry, Co Cork earlier this summer an 88-year-old woman faced eviction from her home of six years. She did find alternative accommodation after her case was raised in the Dáil by Independent TD Michael Collins. Not many get that treatment, however. Research by the housing charities ALONE and Threshold showed that the private rental sector is also unsuitable for older tenants because of a lack of choice, a lack of suitability of accommodation for their needs (made worse by poorly considered recent reduced design standards), a lack of affordability and the aforementioned lack of security. The combination of facing old age surviving on a reduced income with little certainty about how long you might be allowed to remain in your home is the embodiment of precarious living. Although each local authority is required to prepare a Housing Need and Demand Assessment for their area to let them know the number and type of housing they will need for the next decade, there is no specific requirement to incorporate issues relating to ageing and tenure-specific concerns. There is nothing in the Programme for Government on housing and older person, aside from an outline of support for people to live in their own homes, which is commendable, but only potentially useful if you have your own home. For those who do own their own home, there has been a relentless nudge campaign to suggest that many may be living in a house that is too big for their needs. This type of analysis sees houses as physical units and not as homes with spaces for pets, hobbies and even gardening, and their owners as pieces on a chessboard to be moved around, perhaps into a glorified shed in their back garden. Taxation has been suggested as a method of encouraging owners of larger properties with few full-time occupants to move to smaller accommodation. But as the Conservatives found out with the introduction of Poll Tax in England in 1990, just because you own a big house doesn't mean you are wealthy. Many a British older person was landed with a huge property tax bill based on the value of their house which had increased through no fault of their own, but with no assessment of their ability to pay it. Moreover, who is anybody to tell an older person that their house is too big for their needs, likening their owners to that awful term bed blockers in hospital ? Many houses occupied by older people might be quiet as a Buddhist temple during the week but busier than Dublin Airport at the weekend when children and grandchildren come to visit. Others do the State a favour by reaccommodating boomerang offspring who return to the nest when policy failure means they can't afford to buy or rent anywhere themselves. Downsizing is itself a rich person's game. The lack of bridging finance to allow someone to fund the purchase of one property while simultaneously selling the current one means the seller must have the financial means to fund the new purchase up front. In addition, the smaller the gap between the value of the property being sold and the one being bought means older people are less likely to trade down. Interesting options are beginning to spring up like Cohousing Ireland's housing for over 55s , but they are just starting and need the co-operation of banks. Whether a homeowner or particularly a renter, older people all face increasing pressures: to move, to find somewhere to live, to afford to live, and ultimately to solve an ongoing housing crisis that is not of their making. Government is silent on the issue. Dr Lorcan Sirr is senior lecturer in housing at the Technological University Dublin
Irish Post
13 hours ago
- Irish Post
Tánaiste calls on Russia to agree to full ceasefire in conflict with Ukraine
TÁNAISTE Simon Harris has called on Russia to agree to a full ceasefire and end its conflict with Ukraine. Mr Harris was speaking after a meeting between US president Donald Trump and Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin in Alaska. Reports since the meeting suggest Mr Trump now favours a peace deal instead of a ceasefire, with the president posting on his Truth Social account on Sunday that 'big progress' had been made. Meanwhile, Mr Putin has reportedly demanded Ukraine hands over control of the eastern Donetsk region in return for the freezing of front lines. While welcoming Mr Trump's commitment to ending the conflict, Mr Harris said Russia needed to agree to a full and unconditional ceasefire or risk further EU sanctions. "As a first step, we call on Russia to agree to a full and unconditional ceasefire," said Mr Harris on Saturday. "Ukraine also needs strong and credible security guarantees that will ensure its long-term security. "This matters not just for Ukraine but also for Europe's future security. "Ireland, with our EU partners, stands ready to impose additional sanctions and maintain firm and coordinated pressure on Russia. "We must never forget the impact of this war on the people of Ukraine, their enormous suffering, and the generational scars that this war will leave, particularly on so many young people." 'Russia remains the agressor' Mr Harris also called for Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy to be fully involved in negotiations to end the conflict. President Zelenskyy is due to meet Mr Trump in Washington on Monday, along with other European leaders. "We must remember that Russia remains the aggressor in this conflict, and can end its aggression at any time," said Mr Harris. "President Zelenskyy and his government must be involved in all decisions on how the conflict ends. "Ireland will continue to work with EU partners to achieve a just and lasting peace that fully respects international law, including Ukraine's sovereignty and independence, and the inviolability of its borders." Following the Alaska summit, Mr Zelenskyy said on Twitter/X that he supported Mr Trump's proposal for a trilateral meeting between Ukraine, the USA and Russia. "Ukraine emphasises that key issues can be discussed at the level of leaders, and a trilateral format is suitable for this," he posted. However, in a subsequent post, he wrote: "We see that Russia rebuffs numerous calls for a ceasefire and has not yet determined when it will stop the killing. This complicates the situation. "If they lack the will to carry out a simple order to stop the strikes, it may take a lot of effort to get Russia to have the will to implement far greater [measures] — peaceful coexistence with its neighbours for decades."
The Journal
19 hours ago
- The Journal
'We don't know the taste of sleep': Gaza City in peril as Israel plans to seize control
CONDITIONS IN GAZA City are rapidly deteriorating as Israel plans to capture full control of the city and force out its residents, with Palestinians in the area describing ever-worsening hardships. Israeli attacks killed at least 40 people in Gaza yesterday, according to Gaza's Civil Defence Agency. At the same time as Israel's fatal attacks on Gaza continue, Israel is planning to seize full control of Gaza City, forcing Palestinians to southern parts of Gaza. Earlier this week, the Irish government joined 26 other countries in a collective statement decrying that suffering in Gaza has reached 'unimaginable levels'. 'Famine is unfolding before our eyes. Urgent action is needed now to halt and reverse starvation,' said the statement, signed for Ireland by Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris. 'Humanitarian space must be protected, and aid should never be politicised,' it said. Gaza's civil defence spokesman Mahmud Bassal said conditions in Gaza City are rapidly deteriorating, especially in the Zeitun neighbourhood, with residents having little to no access to food and water amid heavy Israeli bombardment. Advertisement The spokesman added that about 50,000 people are estimated to be in that area of Gaza City, 'the majority of whom are without food or water' and arelacking 'the basic necessities of life'. In recent days, Gaza City residents have reported more frequent air strikes targeting residential areas, including Zeitun, while earlier this week, Hamas denounced 'aggressive' Israeli ground incursions. Earlier this month, the Israeli government approved plans to seize Gaza City and neighbouring camps, some of the most densely populated parts of the territory. On Friday, the Israeli military confirmed its troops were operating in Zeitun. Ghassan Kashko, 40, who shelters with his family at a school building in the neighbourhood, said: 'We don't know the taste of sleep.' He said air strikes and tank shelling were causing 'explosions… that don't stop'. Hamas said in a statement that Israeli forces had been carrying out a 'sustained offensive in the eastern and southern neighbourhoods of Gaza City, particularly in Zeitun'. It said the military was targeting the area with warplanes, artillery and drones. The Israeli plan to expand the war has received international condemnation as well as domestic opposition. UN-backed experts have warned of widespread famine unfolding in Gaza, where Israel has drastically curtailed the amount of humanitarian aid it allows in. Related Reads Baby girl killed with her parents in Israeli airstrike on Gaza 'They're too malnourished to treat': Marion McKeone meets an NHS nurse working in Gaza According to the civil defence agency, at least 13 of the 40 Palestinians killed yesterday were shot by Israeli troops as they were waiting to collect food aid near distribution sites in the north and in the south. Israel has killed more than 61,000 Palestinians since October 2023. Former President of Ireland Mary Robinson denounced Israel's takeover plan this week and also took aim at world leaders who are not doing enough to try to stop the devastation in Gaza. 'Governments that are not using all the tools at their disposal to halt the unfolding genocide in Gaza are increasingly complicit,' Robinson said. 'Political leaders have the power and the legal obligation to apply measures to pressure this Israeli government to end its atrocity crimes,' she said. 'This is all the more urgent in light of Prime Minister Netanyahu's Gaza City takeover plan. President Trump has the leverage to compel a change of course. He must use it now.' Additional reporting by AFP Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
