Appeals court halts ‘shockwave' attorney-client privilege ruling
What FirstEnergy didn't expect was for a federal judge in Columbus, Ohio, to rule last year that the probe findings weren't shielded by attorney-client or work-product protections.
That's because the utility also made use of the advice for business purposes, U.S. District Judge Algenon Marbley found.
He ordered the company to turn the documents over to plaintiffs lawyers representing a class of investors suing for securities fraud in the wake of the scandal.
The decision sent 'shockwaves' through corporate boardrooms and the legal industry, FirstEnergy lawyers said, and prompted more than three dozen blue chip law firms to sign an amicus brief, opens new tab urging the Sixth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals to intervene.
Should the decision stand, the firms said, it would 'threaten the success of countless internal investigations necessary to the good governance of companies in the United States.' (Left unsaid: their lucrative practices conducting the probes would take a hit as well.)
Exhale, everyone.
Last week, the appeals court ruled, opens new tab that all likelihood, Marbley got it wrong. FirstEnergy is apt to succeed on the merits of its mandamus petition, the panel held, and the investigation documents created by Jones Day and Squire Patton Boggs will indeed be shielded from discovery.
'What matters for attorney-client privilege is not what a company does with its legal advice, but simply whether a company seeks legal advice,' the unsigned August 7 order stated. 'After all, a corporation could hardly justify expending resources on legal advice that wasn't business-related.'
Sullivan & Cromwell co-chair Robert Giuffra, who represents FirstEnergy in the 6th Circuit appeal and underlying securities class action, told me he was pleased that the decision 'reiterates that attorney-client privilege and the attorney work product doctrine apply fully to internal corporate investigations.'
Plaintiffs' lawyer Jason Forge, a partner at Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd, did not respond to a request for comment.
The fight over the internal investigation documents reflects what can sometimes be a tricky question: Must legal advice be the only primary purpose of a privileged communication?
The U.S. Supreme Court in 2023 had the chance to offer guidance in a case involving an unnamed law firm's bid to designate such 'dual purpose' client records as privileged in a tax and cryptocurrency investigation. Rather than weigh in, though, the high court in a one-sentence order dismissed the case as improvidently granted a few weeks after oral arguments.
Internal corporate investigations have been around for decades, and FirstEnergy lawyers point to a 1981 Supreme Court decision, opens new tab to argue the fruits of such probes have consistently been treated as protected communications.
As chronicled by my former Reuters colleague Alison Frankel, the FirstEnergy case began in July 2020. That's when the company disclosed, opens new tab that it had received subpoenas from the U.S. Justice Department in connection with what turned out to be the biggest political corruption scandal in Ohio history. Almost overnight, FirstEnergy's share price plunged from nearly $42 to less than $23, and investors lost billions.
The company went on to admit to paying a combined $64 million to entities controlled by then-Ohio House Speaker Larry Householder and the chair of the state's public utility commission in exchange for favorable legislation and regulatory treatment, Reuters reported.
While FirstEnergy has since resolved much of the legal fallout, including paying $230 million to the U.S. government to settle a federal criminal investigation, it's continued to fight the securities class action by investors, who are seeking $8 billion in damages.
In seeking the internal investigation documents, the plaintiffs argued that FirstEnergy brought in Jones Day and Squire for two business reasons: to assuage its auditor's concerns about certifying the company's U.S. Securities and
Exchange Commission filings and to determine if the utility should fire any of its executives. The special master and the trial judge agreed that the investigations were not sparked by litigation fears but were intended to provide business advice.
The appellate panel – judges Jeffrey Sutton, Alice Batchelder and John Nalbandian, who were appointed by Republicans George W. Bush, George H.W. Bush and Donald Trump -- disagreed, writing that the lower court "gets it backwards.'
Precedent requires considering 'whether a communication primarily seeks 'to render or solicit legal advice,' irrespective of a company's reason for wanting that legal advice,' they held.
Moreover, the work-product doctrine, which covers documents prepared in anticipation of litigation, also likely applies. Here, the 'flood of legal and regulatory actions prompting FirstEnergy's investigations explains why,' the panel held.
'FirstEnergy, simply put, faced an onslaught of civil and criminal investigations while pursuing internal investigations.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Four cities where Americans can find a cut-price mansion… for less than a regular home elsewhere
The American dream may be about owning a modest family home with a white picket fence, but some have grander ambitions. For those with dreams of owning their own mansion - defined as a home of at least 5,000 square feet - four cities have emerged as the best place to bag a deal this year. Across the country the median mansion will set you back $1.4 million, but in Buffalo, Indianapolis, Cleveland, and Memphis, it could cost less than $1 million, according to a new report from Zillow. In Buffalo, New York, median mansions are available for $825,500, and in Indianapolis, similar-sized homes are on the market for an average price of $965,500. In Cleveland, Ohio, and Memphis, Tennessee, buyers can bag a palatial pad for an average price of $995,200 and $996,700, respectively. Home prices have surged more than 50 percent in the years following the pandemic, and this is notable in the mansion market too. In June 2021, nearly half of all US mansions were valued at less than $1 million, according to Zillow. Today, just 30 percent are under the million-dollar threshold. 'Home prices surged during the pandemic, pushing even starter homes into million‑dollar territory in hundreds of cities,' Kara Ng, senior economist at Zillow, said. She continued: 'Especially on the coasts, champagne tastes require champagne budgets, but in some parts of the country, a million dollars still buys serious square footage. 'More room to roam, including outdoor space, became a must-have during the pandemic, and those preferences have held true.' By contrast, buyers would need a cool $4.5 million for the average mansion in four of California's major metros. The median mansion in San Jose is currently valued at $6.5 million, according to Zillow figures. San Francisco's averagely-priced mansions are listed at $4.9 million, mansions in Los Angeles are $4.7 million and in San Diego they are only slightly cheaper at $4.6 million. Experts at Zillow warned those looking to purchase such a large home should also keep in mind the costs of maintaining it. Larger properties can come with higher property taxes, utility bills and insurance premiums. In addition, Zillow recommends budgeting for annual upkeep of somewhere between 1 to 4 percent of the home's value. It comes as the US housing market is cooling overall with 33 out of the 50 largest metro areas seeing price cuts, and some falling more rapidly than others. The pace and severity of the slowdown varied in July, according to new data from In particular, the South and West shifted decisively in favor of buyers due to rising inventory, deeper price cuts, and homes spending longer on the market. The housing market in the Northeast and Midwest remains steadier. 'The housing market has cooled modestly in 2025, prompting our lowered outlook for home sales and price growth,' said Danielle Hale, chief economist at 'But the extent and persistence of rebalancing really varies across the country, and, regionally, homebuyers and sellers are likely to experience a very different market.'
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Best friend of girl, 11, who went missing 29 years ago issues direct plea to suspect after arrest
For 29 years, loved ones of Trudy Appleby have waited in agony for answers about what happened to the bright and spirited 11-year-old, who was last spotted climbing into a stranger's car in 1996 - and never seen again. On Thursday, their fight for justice took a major step forward with the arrest of Jamison Fisher, 50, who was first named as a person of interest five years ago. Fisher is accused of kidnapping Trudy, strangling her, and dumping her body - but police have yet to reveal what evidence led to the charges. The most agonizing question of all still remains: where is Trudy? She was last seen alive near her home in Moline, Illinois, on August 21, 1996, but her body has never been found. For Trudy's childhood best friend, Amber Dunlap, the news of Fisher's arrest struck like a bolt from the blue. She told the Daily Mail how she dropped to her knees at work, overcome with tears, when her mom told her about the stunning development - a moment that brought relief, anger, and grief all at once. Seeing Fisher's mugshot for the first time made her physically sick. 'I saw his face and I threw up,' she said. 'Any human being who can harm a child is not human. 'I've always taught my kids that monsters are real, but they don't look like storybook monsters. They look like people.' But Fisher's arrest is only part of the story. Dunlap knows that the only thing that will bring this haunting chapter to a close for Trudy's loved ones is finding her remains - and she is pleading directly with the man accused of killing her. 'Tell us where she is. That way, we can give her the proper burial she deserves. 'She was an innocent child. Please do the right thing.' Fisher has been charged with three counts of first-degree murder and one count of concealment of a homicidal death. He has not yet entered a plea, but previously denied wrongdoing when he was first identified as a person of interest in 2020. He is being held in the Scott County Jail, where he was already in custody on unrelated narcotics charges. Last month, his son, Edward J. Fisher, 19, died in a drowning accident along the Mississippi River. Dunlap said that now Fisher understands the pain of losing a child, he should end the Appleby family's suffering by confessing. Trudy's mom, Brenda Gordon, died without ever getting answers about her only child's fate. She was killed in 2014 at age 53 after being struck by a drunk driver. Trudy's father, Dennis Appleby, is 77. Dunlap said she is desperate for Dennis to get answers in his lifetime. 'It's terrible to lose a child, and [Fisher] knows that pain now. The only difference is he knows what happened to his son, while we're still waiting. 'If he has any feelings at all, he will put us out of our misery.' Dunlap was just 13 when Trudy disappeared. The pair were inseparable, spending every waking minute of their free time together, to the point where they saw each other as sisters rather than friends. Police said Trudy had asked her father if she could go swimming with a friend on the nearby Campbell's Island, but her father said no Dunlap was with Trudy the night before she disappeared. That night was spent like any other: rollerblading in the street, eating hot dogs and mac and cheese, teasing Dunlap's younger brother, and playing on the Super Nintendo. There was nothing unusual about Trudy's behavior. She was her usual happy and spunky self. Dunlap walked her home. Their neighborhood felt safe then. Cul-de-sacs and tree-lined streets. 'Love you. See you tomorrow,' Dunlap called out as she watched Trudy go inside. Trudy returned the sentiment - but tomorrow never came. 'I never in a million years thought that would be the last time I saw her,' said Dunlap. Early the following morning, at around 9:30am, Trudy was seen climbing into a silver or gray box-style car driven by an unknown white male, thought to be in his 20s. She was wearing a black, one-piece swimsuit, spandex shorts, blue tennis shoes, a t-shirt and carrying a beach towel. Police said Trudy had earlier asked her father if she could go swimming with a friend on the nearby Campbell's Island, but he said no. Phone records indicated she had made arrangements to go anyway behind her parents' backs, according to investigators. What happened to Trudy after that is still not clear. The moment Dunlap realized something was wrong came in a phone call from Trudy's panicked dad, asking if she'd seen her. Dennis knew the girls had plans to meet that morning, but Dunlap told him she never showed. 'As soon as I got off the phone with her dad, I turned to my mom and said, 'Somebody's got her! Somebody took her!'' said Dunlap, through tears. 'I knew she never would've run off, and there were so many things that didn't add up. I knew right then that something terrible had happened.' Dunlap was questioned by the police. They believed Trudy had run away and suspected she knew where her friend was hiding. Dunlap insisted she didn't. While the search continued, Dunlap spent every day after school sitting at the end of Trudy's driveway, hoping she'd come skipping down the road - as she often did - but that wish never materialized. The days stretched into weeks, weeks into months, months into years, and years into decades - and Dunlap is still waiting to bring Trudy home. For a long time, investigators seemed to be at an impasse. However, in 2017, the case gained momentum. That year, police publicly identified William 'Ed' Smith as a person of interest, claiming he may have been the last person to be seen with Trudy in the grey or silver car. A witness saw Smith on the day of Trudy's disappearance in a vehicle near his home on Campbell's Island, police said. A girl in the passenger seat matched Trudy's description. The following year, the FBI seized a boat they believed could be involved in the case. The vessel was swabbed for DNA, but the results of the search were never disclosed. Then, in 2020, two more persons of interest entered the fold: Jamison Fisher and David Whipple. Whipple - a registered sex offender, convicted of sexually abusing a 10-year-old girl - was Smith's son-in-law, and Fisher was a lifelong family friend of the Smiths, police said. Smith died in 2014 and Whipple in 2022. Authorities said previously that Fisher was likely the last person alive who knew what happened to Trudy. The backyard of Fisher's home was excavated in 2023, but nothing was found. The Moline Police Department refused to back down in the case, voicing certainty that Trudy's killer would be brought to justice. Then, on Wednesday, Fisher was indicted by a grand jury for murdering Trudy and disposing of her remains. Though she long ago conceded Trudy was likely no longer alive, the details of how police believe she was killed were hard for Dunlap to hear. She has been haunted by an image of Trudy being strangled, and imagining how terrified she must've been in her final moments, desperately fighting for air. But she is ready for answers, no matter how painful the truth may be. 'We just want Trudy home and justice to be served,' said Dunlap. 'We will never get closure. Our lives will never be normal again, but at least we'd be able to move forward.' Moline Police Chief Darren Gault said his department will continue to work tirelessly to find Trudy. As Fisher moves towards trial, detectives will be chasing all new leads, no matter how big or small. He credited the breakthrough of Fisher's arrest - coming one week before the 29th anniversary of Trudy's disappearance - to decades of rigorous investigative work, which has included hundreds of interviews, numerous executed search warrants, vehicle seizures, and multiple excavations. '28 years, 11 months, and 23 days. That's how long the family of Trudy Appleby has waited for a resolution to her disappearance. That's 10,584 days,' Gault said during a press conference on Thursday. 'That is the time it has taken to stand before you and say what we long had hoped we could say: We have made an arrest in the murder of Trudy Appleby.' Gault acknowledged that nothing can bring Trudy back, but Moline PD is committed to 'seeking the truth for Trudy and her family and to ensuring that justice is served.' Each year, Trudy's family hosts a candlelight vigil in Moline on August 21, praying for answers and trying to keep her story alive. This year, the solemn gathering will look very different from each of the 28 before it. 'It's going to be more emotional,' said Dunlap. 'In previous years, we've had police share new information, but nothing like this.'
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Western US ranch four times bigger than New York City goes on sale for $79.5M
Here's a home where the Buffalo roam — but you're going to need about $80 million of you want to join them. A giant Western ranch four times bigger than New York City and twice the size of London has hit the market. Central Wyoming 's sprawling Pathfinder Ranches totals over 916,000 acres and includes fully working cattle ranches, a main lodge, and a church. The main home has original hardwood floors, stone and wood walls, and beamed ceilings, and is for sale with local luxury realtor Michael Swan from Swan Land Company. The price tag is a cool $79.5 million. 'The sale of Pathfinder Ranches represents an unprecedented opportunity to own and operate one of few remaining large cattle operations in the American West,' Ryan Lance, President of Pathfinder Ranches, told the Daily Mail. 'Pathfinder represents a piece of our country's pioneering spirit and a chance to make a real contribution to both modern ranching practices and conservation.' The ranches span four counties and cover around 1 percent of Wyoming. The land is nestled between the Ferris, Pedro and Green mountain ranges, and it counts the Pathfinder Reservoir and a section of the Sweetwater River as part of its property. The property is one of the largest working ranches in the Rocky Mountains. The ranch is also home to the nation's first habitat conservation bank for sage-grouse — the largest ever approved by the US Department of the Interior's Fish and Wildlife Service. The nine-bedroom, 7.5-bath lodge was designed with an open layout, a full bar, a game room, gourmet kitchen, and floor-to-ceiling windows that frame the Ferris and Pedro Mountains. The land hosts 12 ranches in total, hosting approximately 3,400 cows, 180 bulls and 130 saddle horses. The listing reads: 'Pathfinder Ranches is a testament to stewardship. 'Past stewards have worked this ground, building healthy soil, nurturing wildlife habitats, and protecting fragile species such as the greater sage-grouse through thoughtful grazing practices and regenerative efforts. 'This property is a true king maker.' The listing continues: 'The next owner will inherit a legacy, with the chance to make a lasting impact on the land, the industry, the culture, and the state of Wyoming; to experience the simple wealth of clean air and wide-open spaces; and to immediately take their place among the major players in the cattle world.' The ranch's broker, Scott Williams, said a ranch like this is not built overnight, but 'takes generations of grit, vision, and dedication.' 'This legacy property is about impact on the land, the industry, the culture, and the state of Wyoming,' he said. Pathfinder is larger even than the fictional 'Yellowstone' Dutton Ranch from Taylor Sheridan's famous television series, which is somewhere between 775,000 to 825,000 acres. Meanwhile, another Wyoming ranch with ties to Ernest Hemingway listed in early June. Set against the stunning Bighorn Mountains, the ranch Hemingway used as a writer's retreat was listed for $29 million. The historic Spear Ranch, which dates back to the 1800s, is celebrated for its tranquil seclusion, breathtaking vistas and deep ties to both literary and Western heritage. It spans over 300 acres of pristine landscape and includes a 7,500-square-foot New England–style main residence, multiple guest cabins and a collection of rustic outbuildings. A nearby guest retreat is where Hemingway sought solitude and completed the first draft of A Farewell to Arms in 1928. Ranches are all the rage in recent months. In New Mexico, a ranch more than half the size of the state of Rhode Island recently sold after being listed for a nine-figure sum. The 540,000-acre Great Western Ranch was put on the market for $142 million in 2024 by the Horton family, the development dynasty that spent the last decade building the mammoth property. In July, the asking price had dropped to $115 million, but the actual selling price remains unclear.
