More than 12,000 family violence intervention orders issued in Victoria with crucial words missing
Thousands of family violence intervention orders in Victoria have been issued with crucial words missing, with the state government planning to rush a bill through parliament to ensure the orders are complied with.
The attorney general, Sonya Kilkenny, on Monday announced the discovery of a 'printing error' affecting family violence intervention orders made in the magistrates and children's courts between 15 November 2024 and 5 March 2025.
She said the complete wording of the courts' orders was missing in printed copies of the orders for service on respondents.
About 11,815 magistrates court orders and 685 children's court orders were affected by the printing error, a source told Guardian Australia.
The missing words were: 'the court orders that the respondent must not'.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
Kilkenny said the orders made during the period were valid and both Victoria police and the Department of Justice and Community Safety had assured her the error 'has not affected anyone's safety to date'.
But the government will on Tuesday introduce the family violence protection amendment bill 2025 to parliament to ensure the printing error does not affect the protection or enforceability of the orders.
'The Victorian government is acting out of an abundance of caution to make sure that respondents continue to comply with those orders, and that perpetrators are held to account,' Kilkenny said.
'My focus is ensuring that an error like this is never repeated and stamping out the unacceptable failures that allowed it to occur. All options are on the table to ensure this never happens again.'
In a statement, the magistrates court said the issue includes interim, final, extension and variations of family violence intervention orders.
'The order made by the court is valid, but any copy of the order printed between these dates contains the error and is not a true copy of the order,' it reads.
'We acknowledge this may cause concern and apologise for the error. The safety of affected family members and clarity for all court participants has been our priority as we worked to rectify this issue.'
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
The court said any family member or respondent affected by an order who would like a complete copy of their order should contact the MCV Service Centre.
The government intends to fast-track the bill through both Houses of Parliament on Tuesday, though in the upper house they will require the support of either the Coalition or seven crossbenchers for it to pass.
A spokesperson for Victoria police said the issue 'does not affect the validity of orders issued by the court nor the ability of Victoria police to continue to enforce intervention orders and importantly hold perpetrators of family violence to account'.
'Victoria police is working closely with Court Services Victoria to ensure that court proceedings involving victims of family violence are not impacted,' they said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
4 days ago
- Scottish Sun
‘Concerning' rise of Victorian STI that can trigger heart disease, brain damage and death – are you at risk?
Symptoms of the historical STI explained - and how to protect yourself from infection STI ALERT 'Concerning' rise of Victorian STI that can trigger heart disease, brain damage and death – are you at risk? CASES of a sexually transmitted infection that was rampant during the Victorian era have seen a "concerning" surge in England. Diagnoses of syphilis - which can trigger heart disease and brain damage in its later stages - have been on the upward trajectory, with 13,030 recorded in 2024. Advertisement 1 Syphilis diagnoses continued to rise between 2023 and 2024 This figure - which includes early and late-stage syphilis diagnoses and complications from the infection - marks a 5 per cent increase from 2023, when 12,456 syphilis diagnoses were detected. Data published by the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) shows a 1.7 per cent rise in early-stage syphilis diagnoses between 2023 and 2024, jumping from 9,375 to 9,535. "The number of syphilis diagnoses was the largest annual number reported since 1948," the health watchdog wrote in its report. Early diagnoses of the historical STI decreased slightly among gay and bisexual men, from 6,435 to 6,330. Advertisement But there was a sharp increase in infectious syphilis diagnoses among heterosexual men - rising by 23.8 per cent from 1,115 to 1,380. "However, taking into account all diagnoses of syphilis - including late stage or complications such as ocular and otosyphilis - there were an additional 850 diagnoses amongst women who have sex with men, 931 diagnoses among heterosexual men and 1,172 diagnoses among gay and bisexual men," UKHSA said. Syphilis is most commonly passed on through unprotected sex with someone who's infected. You can get the infection if you come into contact with an ulcer on their penis, vagina, bottom, or inside their mouth. Advertisement It's also possible for it to be transmitted from a mum to her baby through the womb, which can increase the risk of miscarriage, premature birth and stillbirth. Symptoms of the STI can take about three weeks to appear after infection and can be subtle, coming and going over time, making them hard to spot. What is Gonorrhoea It can crop up as painless sores or grey-ish warty growths, most commonly on your penis, vagina or around your anus. Syphilis can also cause a rash that spreads from the hands and feet to the rest of the body, as well as white patches in the mouth, flu-like symptoms and hair loss. Advertisement Sometimes the symptoms can improve or go away completely, but if you have not been treated the infection is still in your body. This means you can still pass it on and you're at risk of getting serious problems later on. Drug-resistant gonorrhoea UKHSA's report also included data on other STIs, including gonorrhoea. The health watchdog said there was a 16 per cent drop in gonorrhoea cases, with 71,802 diagnoses of the infection in 2024, compared to 85,370 in 2023. Advertisement The fall has been greatest in young people aged 15 to 24 years where there was a 36 per cent reduction in diagnoses - but UKHSA noted that it is too soon to conclude whether this trend will continue. However, it flagged there has been "a concerning acceleration" in diagnoses of antibiotic-resistant gonorrhoea. While most gonorrhoea infections can be treated effectively with antibiotics, certain strains don't respond to the drugs and "present significant treatment challenges". The STI is usually treated with a single dose of the antibiotic ceftriaxone, given as an injection or tablets at GP surgeries or a sexual health clinics. Advertisement But in some cases this isn't effective, as the bacteria has developed the ability to survive and multiply even when exposed to the antibiotic. "Ceftriaxone resistance is particularly concerning as this antibiotic serves as the primary treatment for gonorrhoea infections," UKHSA noted. Symptoms of syphilis and its stages The symptoms of syphilis are often mild, making them difficult to spot. They also tend to change over time, and come and go, so it is easy to presume you aren't infected, even when you are. The most common symptoms of the infection include: Small sores (ulcers) on your penis, vagina, or around your bottom (anus) – these are usually painless and you may only have one of them Sores in other areas, including in your mouth or on your lips, hands or bottom White or grey warty growths most commonly on your penis, vagina or around your anus A rash on the palms of your hands and soles of your feet that can sometimes spread all over your body – this is not usually itchy White patches in your mouth Flu-like symptoms, such as a high temperature, headaches and tiredness Swollen glands Patchy hair loss on the head, beard and eyebrows These signs may not appear until three weeks (or more) after you're infected. Sometimes the symptoms can improve or go away completely, but if you have not been treated the infection is still in your body. This means you can still pass it on and you're at risk of getting serious problems later on. Potential complications include: Heart problems like angina, aortic aneurysm and heart failure Brain problems like fits (seizures), memory problems, personality changes and dementia Nerve problems like shooting pains, pins and needles, joint pain and gradual damage the joints Problems with the skin, bones, testicles, liver and any other organ Syphilis tends to happen in stages. Primary stage - between two to 12 weeks after exposure (patients develops painless sores on the genitals that might heal on their own) Secondary stage - between one to six months after the primary stage (patients may develop itchy rashes on the skin) Latent stage (patients show no signs but remain infectious) Tertiary stage (patients may develop complications) Some of these problems may not appear for many years after being infected with syphilis. At any point in the infection, syphilis bacteria - Treponema pallidum - can invade the nervous system and affect the brain, eyes or ears. This may cause headaches, brain swelling, strokes, and mental changes. Eyes may become sensitive to light or swollen, or sight may be affected and people may also experience hearing loss, dizziness, or tinnitus if the infection reaches their ears. Source: NHS, WHO, CDC "Although numbers remain low, ceftriaxone-resistant gonorrhoea cases are being detected more frequently." It said 14 cases reported in the first five months of 2025, which is greater than the number of cases reported for the whole of 2024 - 13 cases. Advertisement "Six of the 14 cases in 2025 have been extensively drug-resistant cases, which means that they were resistant to ceftriaxone and to second-line treatment options. "Most ceftriaxone resistant cases are associated with travel to or from the Asia-Pacific region, where the prevalence of ceftriaxone resistance is high." UKHSA warned early this year that treatment-resistant STIs run the risk of one day becoming "untreatable". Despite infections of some STIs dipping, cases still remain high and continue to significantly impact young people, gay and bisexual men, and some minority ethnic groups, UKHSA said. Advertisement It urged people to use condoms with new or casual partners to use a condom and get tested regularly, whatever their age or sexual orientation. As many STIs don't cause noticeable symptoms, people often pass them on without realising it. STIs are usually easily treated with antibiotics, but many can cause serious health issues if left untreated. Chlamydia and gonorrhoea can cause infertility and pelvic inflammatory disease, while syphilis can cause serious, irreversible and potentially life-threatening problems with your brain, heart, or nerves. Advertisement Dr Hamish Mohammed, consultant epidemiologist at UKHSA, said: 'Levels of STIs in this country remain a big threat to sexual wellbeing. "These infections can have a major impact on your health and that of any sexual partners – particularly if they are antibiotic resistant. "If you've had condomless sex with new or casual partners – either in the UK or overseas - get tested for STIs and HIV at least yearly, even if you don't have symptoms. "Regular testing protects both you and those you're having sex with. Advertisement 'From August, eligible people will also be offered vaccination to reduce the risk of gonorrhoea and we expect to see the immunisation programme have an impact on diagnoses of this infection in coming years – please take up the vaccine if you are offered it.'
The Guardian
6 days ago
- The Guardian
Student protesters face expulsion from University of Melbourne over pro-Palestine office occupation
Two University of Melbourne students have been recommended for expulsion and two for suspension for taking part in a pro-Palestine demonstration at the university's Parkville campus last October. If the decisions are upheld, the students will become the first pro-Palestine student activists for whom suspension and expulsion have been enforced in Australia since the waves of student demonstrations against Israel's assault on Gaza began in 2023. The students intend to appeal against the decision, with one telling Guardian Australia she believed the outcome had been 'prejudged' by the university, which has implemented anti-protest rules that critics have characterised as 'repressive' and an 'authoritarian' overreach. The students were referred to the institution's disciplinary committee after reports they were part of a group of about 20 who, for about 90 minutes on 9 October, occupied the office of an academic they believed was integral to the university's partnerships with the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. The protesters were calling on the university to disband its joint programs with Israeli universities, which have been a target of the global boycott, divestment and sanctions movement since 2004. Footage of the occupation, distributed on social media at the time, showed protesters entering the office with their faces covered by keffiyehs, hoods and masks. The university alleged the students had harassed and intimidated staff who worked in the office, damaged property by placing signs and stickers on some university-owned items including a monitor screen, and writing on and placing stickers on personal items of the academic, including a photo. The students said their demonstration had been peaceful and clearly political, that they had informed people working in the office and nearby that they were protesting and had even offered to turn down the music they were playing so others could keep working. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email One student facing expulsion, Niamh*, who spoke to Guardian Australia on condition that her real name not be used, was found by the disciplinary committee to have been present at the demonstration for no longer than 10 minutes. Documents seen by the Guardian state she was not found to have performed any of the specific actions listed by the university as 'harassing or intimidating' the staff, such as placing stickers or graffiti, but that her presence in the room with others was itself harassment and intimidation, and also constituted improper and unsafe use of university property. The committee said they were recommending Niamh be expelled on the basis of 'the seriousness of the breaches and the nature of the behaviour' and her past alleged breaches of the student conduct code. Niamh said she believed this was a reference to her participation in the 'Mahmoud's Hall' occupation of the Arts West building, a demonstration that led to the university agreeing to additional disclosures about its research project grant arrangements. Niamh appeared to have been identified as being involved in the protest in part by the university tracking her location on campus through her wifi login, a tool that has been the subject of an investigation by the office of the Victorian information commissioner. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion She said she believed the activists had been 'prejudged' by the university council, beginning with the then vice-chancellor, Duncan Maskell, circulating a university-wide email the day after the protest characterising it as 'an attempt to harass and intimidate' the academic. Maskell's email was criticised in an open letter signed by 174 university staff members, which said the comments risked impeding procedural fairness and 'enabled the action to be incorrectly framed by major media outlets as antisemitic'. Maskell did not respond to the open letter. In May last year he implemented new university rules banning 'protest that is not peaceful' and prohibiting protesters who were not university staff or students from entering university grounds. On 3 March his successor as vice-chancellor, Emma Johnston, implemented another suite of rules against protests, including that they may not be held indoors and must not obstruct entries or exits of university buildings. The rules would apply to students and staff and also to 'individual forms of action'. The student union and the National Tertiary Education Union have called the new rules 'an authoritarian approach' that erroneously conflates staff and student discomfort with lack of safety. The Human Rights Law Centre, Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International have urged the university to rescind them. Niamh said Johnston's rules were 'particularly disturbing and hypocritical' and 'a massive betrayal of the values and history of student unionism' given Johnston's own history as the university's student union president in the 1990s, when she advocated for direct action protests including sit-ins. 'Her words are irreconcilable with her actions when some of the worst anti-protest rules are being pushed through under her leadership,' Niamh said. 'I would love to see the university take more of an approach of wanting to sit down with their students and wanting to really hear from where their students are coming from and why students around the world feel this urgent moral necessity to stand against … the horrible atrocities we're witnessing in Gaza as well as the West Bank and all of occupied Palestine,' she said. A spokesperson for the University of Melbourne said it would not comment on individual cases 'to protect the integrity of our disciplinary processes''. 'The University of Melbourne has followed its disciplinary processes in accordance with University policy in response to an incident that took place in October 2024,' the spokesperson said. 'This process has not concluded. The University is communicating directly with individuals involved in disciplinary proceedings. Students have the right to appeal decisions made through the University's disciplinary processes.' Last year an Australian National University student who was expelled and a Deakin University student who was suspended for Palestine-related activism had those decisions overturned on appeal. *Name has been changed
BreakingNews.ie
29-05-2025
- BreakingNews.ie
Tipperary woman who slipped on wet hotel floor at wedding awarded €72k
A nurse who slipped on a wet floor at a wedding in a four-star hotel has been awarded €72,000 by a High Court judge. The Tipperary woman who had been wearing stiletto shoes had told the court she was in so much pain after the fall when she exited a lift in Hotel Kilkenny, she thought she was going to die. Advertisement Hotel Kilkenny had contended the woman was wearing 5 inch stilettos and simply lost her balance when her left ankle buckled on the way to the wedding banquet. It denied the floor was wet and slippy. Pamela Kirby (42) Glencarra Lawn, Clonmel, Co Tipperary, had sued Hotel Kilkenny Ltd trading as Hotel Kilkenny, College Road, Kilkenny city, as a result of the fall as she attended the wedding reception of a friend on August 18th, 2018. Mr Justice Tony O'Connor said it was a 'hotly contested claim for damages' but the court was satisfied that on the balance of probabilities Ms Kirby slipped on a clear liquid which was on a tile upon which she placed her shoe while walking across from the lift at the hotel sky lobby. The judge said there was no dispute that Ms Kirby was entitled to attend the wedding reception in high heels. Advertisement He said she was entitled to expect that the floor area which she had to cross did not have liquid or if there was liquid, that there were signs to indicate a wet floor. The hotel side he said had not satisfied the court that it took the necessary care and for those reasons he ruled the hotel was in breach of its duty of care to the woman. The judge said Ms Kirby had satisfied the court that her fall was not caused by a loss of balance due to the wearing of high heels. He noted she had worn them without difficulty to events for six years previously. Mr Justice O'Connor who had viewed CCTV of the incident said other guests took various steps on exiting the hotel lift and the court was not persuaded that another guest would have noticed, alerted others or slipped on the tile in the advance of Ms Kirby coming along. Advertisement The judge also noted Ms Kirby's husband had given evidence that while he attended to his wife after the fall, he noticed the ground looked wet. The judge said Mr Kirby's observations were particularly relevant and his integrity, the judge said was not in dispute. His reply that he did not mention liquid on the floor due to his primary concern for his wife, the judge said was understandable. Mr Justice O'Connor said the credibility and reliability of Mr. Kirby in particular together with the candour of his wife satisfied the court on the balance of probabilities that she slipped on a clear liquid which was situated on a tile where she placed her shoe while walking across from the lift in the sky lobby. In the fall, Ms Kirby dislocated her elbow and later needed a cast and also hurt her leg and the bones in her toes were broken and her leg was also put in a cast. Advertisement Ireland Restaurant manager awarded €17k after being made r... Read More In evidence she told the court she was wearing her own wedding shoes from her 2012 wedding on the occasion. She and her husband had attended the wedding and a drinks reception at the hotel where she had two glasses of wine with ice. The gong for the wedding banquet went at 5:30pm and they went upstairs to the second floor for the wedding meal. She said the other couples got out of the lift first and she followed with her husband. She said she slipped and fell and landed on her right side. 'I was in so much pain, I thought I was going to die,' she told the judge.
