US appeals court to rule on Trump's Los Angeles troop deployment
June 17 (Reuters) - A federal appeals court will hear arguments on Tuesday on President Donald Trump's authority to deploy the National Guard and Marines to Los Angeles amid protests and civil unrest, days after a lower court ruled that the president unlawfully called the National Guard into service.
The lower court's ruling last Thursday was put on hold hours later by the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which will consider the Trump administration's request for a longer pause during its appeal.
U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer in San Francisco had ruled that the Republican president unlawfully took control of California's National Guard and deployed 4,000 troops to Los Angeles against the wishes of Democratic California Governor Gavin Newsom. Trump also ordered 700 U.S. Marines to the city after sending in the National Guard, but Breyer has not yet ruled on the legality of the Marines' mobilization.
Breyer said Trump had not complied with the law that allows him to take control of the National Guard to address rebellions or invasions, and ordered Trump to return control of California's National Guard to Newsom, who sued over the deployment.
Trump's decision to send troops into Los Angeles sparked a national debate about the use of the military on U.S. soil and inflamed political tensions in a city in the midst of protest and turmoil over Trump's immigration raids.
Political unrest spread to other parts of the country over the weekend, when a gunman assassinated a Democratic lawmaker in Minnesota and large protests took place in many other cities to coincide with a military parade that celebrated the U.S. Army's 250th anniversary on the same day as Trump's 79th birthday.
California's lawsuit, filed on June 9, argues that Trump's deployment of the National Guard and the Marines violate the state's sovereignty and U.S. laws that forbid federal troops from participating in civilian law enforcement.
The Trump administration has denied that troops are engaging in law enforcement, saying that they were instead protecting federal buildings and personnel, including U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers.
The Trump administration argues that the law gives the president sole discretion to determine whether a "rebellion or danger of a rebellion" requires a military response and that neither the courts nor a state governor can second-guess that determination.
In Thursday's order, Breyer said the protest fell far short of qualifying as a rebellion.
"The Court is troubled by the implication inherent in Defendants' argument that protest against the federal government, a core civil liberty protected by the First Amendment, can justify a finding of rebellion," Breyer wrote.
The three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit that will hear the case consists of two judges appointed by Trump in his first term and one judge who was appointed by Democratic President Joe Biden.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Powys County Times
11 minutes ago
- Powys County Times
Trump departs G7 early as Israel-Iran conflict shows signs of intensifying
President Donald Trump has abruptly left the G7 summit, departing a day early on Monday as the conflict between Israel and Iran intensifies and the US leader has declared that Tehran should be evacuated 'immediately'. World leaders had gathered in Canada with the specific goal of helping to defuse a series of global pressure points, only to be disrupted by a showdown over Iran's nuclear programme that could escalate in dangerous and uncontrollable ways. Israel launched an aerial bombardment campaign against Iran four days ago. At the summit, Mr Trump warned that Tehran needs to curb its nuclear programme before it is 'too late'. He said Iranian leaders would 'like to talk' but they had already had 60 days to reach an agreement on their nuclear ambitions and failed to do so before the Israeli aerial assault began. 'They have to make a deal,' he said. Asked what it would take for the US to get involved in the conflict militarily, Mr Trump said on Monday morning: 'I don't want to talk about that.' But by Monday afternoon, Mr Trump warned ominously on social media, 'Everyone should immediately evacuate Tehran!' Shortly after that, Mr Trump decided to leave the summit and skip a series of Tuesday meetings that would address the ongoing war in Ukraine and global trade issues. As Mr Trump posed for a picture on Monday evening with the other G7 leaders, he said simply: 'I have to be back, very important.' Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, the host, said: 'I am very grateful for the president's presence and I fully understand.'
Sky News
12 minutes ago
- Sky News
Israel-Iran live: Missiles launched at Israel after fresh attacks on Tehran and western Iran
'Evacuate Tehran!': Trump's G7 exit, Macron swipe and warning to Iran - a recap Donald Trump has been busy on the global stage today - here's a reminder of what he's been saying about the Israel-Iran conflict. 'Evacuate Tehran!' The US president seemingly issued a warning to residents in Tehran shortly before midnight in the UK last night, saying: "Everyone should immediately evacuate Tehran!" Trump has pinned his warning to the residents of Iran's capital to the top of his Truth Social profile today. Trump leaves G7 early - and dismisses Macron's explanation Trump went on to leave the G7 summit of world leaders in Canada early. After he left, French President Emmanuel Macron said he thought it was because Trump was going to work on peace negotiations in the Middle East - something Trump took issue with. Trump, again writing on his own social media platform Truth Social, said: "Publicity seeking President Emmanuel Macron, of France, mistakenly said that I left the G7 Summit, in Canada, to go back to D.C. to work on a 'cease fire' between Israel and Iran. "Wrong! "He has no idea why I am now on my way to Washington, but it certainly has nothing to do with a Cease Fire. "Much bigger than that." 'Gloves are off' The US leader also spoke to reporters aboard Air Force One, as he flew back to Washington DC. Trump said he wanted a "real end" to the conflict, "not a ceasefire", and warned that if US troops were harmed by Iran, then the "gloves are off". 'They know how to reach me' Then, shortly before midday in the UK, Trump was quick to point out he hadn't reached out to Iran for peace talks, instead saying: "If they want to talk, they know how to reach me."
The Independent
15 minutes ago
- The Independent
Trump ‘not looking for a ceasefire' with Israel-Iran as he blasts DNI Tulsi Gabbard: ‘I don't care what she said!'
President Donald Trump on Tuesday angrily pushed back on his own director of National Intelligence's assessment of Iran's nuclear program's status, telling journalists aboard Air Force One that he did not care about her belief that Tehran was not actively working on constructing a usable nuclear weapon. Speaking to reporters on the way back to Washington after making an early exit from the 2025 Group of Seven leaders' summit in Alberta, the president was asked about Tulsi Gabbard 's March testimony before the House Intelligence Committee in which the DNI said the U.S. Intelligence Community had assessed that Iran was not then working to build a nuclear weapon despite continuing work on uranium enrichment. Trump told CNN's Kaitlan Collins that he believed that Iran had been 'very close' to a working bomb, but when Collins pointed out what Gabbard had said to Congress just three months ago, Trump became irate. 'I don't care what she said — I think they were very close to having one,' he said. During her March 26 appearance before the House panel, Gabbard said the USIC had continued to 'assess that Iran is not building a nuclear weapon' as as she told House members that Ayatollah Ali Khamenei — Iran's Supreme Leader — had 'not authorized the nuclear weapons program that he suspended in 2003.' 'We continue to monitor closely if Tehran decides to reauthorize its nuclear weapons program,' Gabbard added. Trump also told the reporters traveling with him that American 'gloves' would come 'off' should Iran hit American soldiers stationed in the Middle East in retaliation for anything Israel has done since the two countries began exchanging fire last week. 'We'll come down so hard if they do anything to our people,' Mr Trump said. 'The gloves are off. I think they know not to touch our troops.' The president had made an early exit from the G7 gathering, where he had been expected to remain until late Tuesday, after issuing a dire warning to residents of Iran's capital. Writing on Truth Social on Monday evening, he groused that Iranian leaders had not 'signed the 'deal'' Trump had 'told them to sign' as part of talks held over the last few months over the Islamic Republic's nuclear weapons program. He called the situation 'a shame' and 'a waste of a human life' and reiterated the longtime American position that Tehran 'CAN NOT HAVE A NUCLEAR WEAPON.' 'I said it over and over again! Everyone should immediately evacuate Tehran!' Trump added. Roughly an hour later, White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt informed reporters late Monday that Trump would be returning to Washington after participating in the G7 'family photo' with other world leaders, with his early departure allowing him to 'attend to many important matters.' In a separate post on X, Leavitt said Trump would depart following a dinner with his fellow G7 heads of state and government, attributing the move to 'what's going on in the Middle East.' In response to shouted questions from reporters about why he's leaving the G7 early Trump said, 'I have to be back'. Gathering with other leaders for a customary photo ahead of dinner Monday, the president added, 'You probably see what I see and I have to be back as soon as I can.' His ahead-of-schedule return from Canada comes amid questions over whether the United States would join Israel 's days-old effort to cripple the Iranian nuclear program by destroying nuclear sites, targeting scientists for assassination, and taking out military leaders and much of Iran's military capabilities. While Israeli forces claim to have had significant successes in taking out numerous targets associated with Iranian nuclear weapons research and development, one obstacle that remains is the Fordow enrichment facility, located deep inside a mountain near the city of Qom. Because the facility is deep underground, successfully destroying it would require dropping so-called 'bunker-buster' munitions into the facility from heavy bomber aircraft. Israeli forces do not possess such weapons, but the United States does. Trump, who has long boasted of his record in keeping American forces out of what he calls 'endless wars' in the Middle East, and has sought to redirect American foreign policy in a more isolationist direction not seen since the period leading up to the Second World War, has thus far maintained that the U.S. is not involved and has not been involved in Israel's operations against Iran. Earlier in the day, Trump told reporters that he believed he could still broker a diplomatic agreement to curb Tehran's nuclear ambitions despite the Israel effort to accomplish the same by force of arms. 'I think Iran basically is at the negotiating table where they want to make a deal, and as soon as I leave here, we're going to be doing something,' he said. But in the hours following his departure, U.S. defense officials ordered the USS Nimitz carrier group, including five Arleigh Burke -class guided missile destroyers and other support ships along with an entire carrier-based air wing, to depart the South China Sea and join the USS Carl Vinson strike group deployed in the Arabian Sea. The aging nuclear-powered vessel is part of a wider buildup of firepower that has seen dozens of U.S. Air Force refueling planes transfer to Europe, two destroyers in the Mediterranean move closer to Israel, and military families at U.S. bases in the Middle East given permission to fly home for their safety. 'The security situation in Israel, including Tel Aviv and Jerusalem is unpredictable, and U.S. citizens are reminded to remain vigilant and take appropriate steps to increase their security awareness as security incidents, including mortar and rocket fire and armed UAV intrusions and missiles, can take place without warning,' the advisory said.
