
Plans for primary-care hub on site of Baggot Street hospital on hold amid residents' fears it may include methadone clinic
Several appeals have been lodged with An Bord Pleanála against the recent decision of Dublin City Council to grant planning permission for a proposed new medical centre to be located at the rear of the main hospital building on Baggot Street Upper.
The HSE is hoping to develop the new primary-care centre, including a pharmacy, in vacant buildings that form part of the former Baggot Street Hospital site at the junction of Haddington Road and Eastmoreland Lane.
The red-brick building, known formally as the Royal City of Dublin Hospital, has been closed as a hospital since 1987.
The new facility, to be known as The Haddington Road Primary-Care Centre, will incorporate an existing three-storey Victorian building and a newly constructed building up to six storeys in height.
However, the HSE has separately appealed against a condition imposed by Dublin City Council as part of the grant of planning permission to omit one floor of the proposed development because of the local authority's serious concerns about the height of the structure.
The HSE claims the requirement to omit one of the six storeys would have minimal impact on the overshadowing of neighbouring properties but would make the development of the primary-care centre 'unfeasible'.
The council's ruling is also being appealed against by several local residents and business owners, including the Pembroke Road Association.
Although the residents' group recognised the need for a new primary-care centre in the area, it criticised its proposed height, which it said would be 'disruptive' and 'entirely excessive'.
Together with other individual appellants, the Pembroke Road Association also expressed concern that a methadone clinic is being considered as part of the new facility.
The group claims the layout of the proposed centre with an entirely separate pharmacy 'would indicate a methadone dispensing service'.
ADVERTISEMENT
However, Dublin City Council said any issue of the medical centre being used for dispensing methadone was under the remit of the HSE's operational governance and healthcare regulations rather than planning control.
Planning files submitted by the HSE make no reference to any type of drug-treatment clinic being proposed.
The HSE said it had identified a need to provide a new primary-care centre in a modern purpose-built building to serve the healthcare needs of the local community in the Baggot Street and Sandymount areas.
The new facility will provide a range of services including public-health nursing, occupational therapy, physiotherapy, social work, speech and language therapy and dietetics, as well as a pharmacy.
Separately, council planners expressed concern about the lack of any future plans for development of the former hospital building, which it described as 'a sensitive protected structure' and asked the HSE to re-examine its potential reuse.
However, the HSE said a report into the potential use of the building for use for healthcare purposes, which was carried out in October 2022, had concluded that it would 'present a number of serious challenges in terms of structure, fire safety, access, services, conservation, cost and time'.
The HSE claimed the proposed development would not involve any works that would affect the special character of the protected structure or result in the removal of significant original fabric or features of interest.
The HSE's chief executive, Bernard Gloster, informed the Department of Health last year that the former hospital is surplus to its needs as it is no longer deemed suitable for delivering public healthcare services.
Last month, the HSE indicated the building is to be sold on the open market as no state agency wanted to use the premises. whose condition has deteriorated over the years.
However, the HSE said the absence of a confirmed use for the buildings should not hinder the development of the proposed primary-care centre.
Council planners said a masterplan for the entire site would have been better 'in terms of a meaningfully developed site rather than the current proposal'.
'The redevelopment of part of this site without consideration of this structure is worrying and is not considered planning best practice,' they added.
The council said it has included 'robust conditions' to the grant of planning permission as the response of the HSE to a wide range of concerns raised over the plans was 'disappointing'.
'Minimal alterations were made which did not address these concerns,' it observed.
The council acknowledged that they might affect the functionality of the new facility but said it had to ensure the amenity of adjoining structures and the future development potential of adjoining sites was protected.
It also expressed disappointment with the delay by the HSE in disposing of the main hospital as it had a detrimental impact on the fabric of the building that was being protected.
A ruling by An Bord Pleanála on the various appeals is due by early October.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Independent
5 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Tipperary mental health nurses celebrated on International Nurses Day
Today at 05:15 International Nurses Day was recently marked at one of its residential care centres in Clonmel by the HSE's mental health services in the South Tipperary area. The occasion, observed around the world, coincides with the birth date of Florence Nightingale. She is credited as the founder of modern nursing. Alongside celebrating the nursing professions, the day also supports raising awareness of the challenges faced in healthcare. At Haywood Lodge in Clonmel, International Nurses Day was highlighted over two days last month, with a focus placed on the dedication, resilience and compassion of its nursing staff. A lunch and a special presentation of certificates and gifts, held in the main lobby, featured as part of the celebrations. Opened in 2012, the purpose built Haywood Lodge is comprised of two units - East and West House - each containing 20 en-suite bedrooms. The East House is for residents under the care of the HSE's South Tipperary Psychiatry of Later Life team. The West House is a dedicated Rehabilitation and Recovery unit. All resident bedrooms and living spaces in Haywood Lodge are built around two internal courtyards. Each bedroom has an external door that leads directly to a garden area. Speaking at the International Nurses Day occasion in Haywood Lodge, its assistant director of Nursing Lisa Grant said, 'We have an excellent reputation in provision of healthcare and associated supports here in Haywood and we are conscious of the great support we receive from the surrounding community 'Marking International Nurses Day ties in with our implementation on site here of the 'HSE workplace health and wellbeing initiative', which began as a management initiative led out by my colleague clinical nurse manager 3 Kate Beaton.' 'It is also an opportunity to highlight the importance of nurses, promoting their wellbeing and raising awareness of the nursing profession. "Our Haywood 'Wellness at Work' committee, chaired by clinical nurse manager 2, Karen Hally, with recreational nurse coordinator Aisling Carroll as PRO, also recognises and appreciates the hard work, dedication, and commitment of our nurses, who in working with health care assistants and other HSE staff provide compassionate care and support to our residents,' added Ms Grant.


The Irish Sun
a day ago
- The Irish Sun
The seven major symptoms of ‘aggressive' rare cancer you might notice when using bathroom as HSE say ‘know the signs'
MEN are being urged to look out for the signs of an "aggressive" rare cancer that they might notice when using the bathroom. Some 60 males are diagnosed with penile cancer each year in Ireland. Advertisement 3 The HSE awareness campaign highlights rare penis cancer Credit: GETTY 3 Whether you or a loved one is male, everyone should know the signs Credit: GETTY To coincide with It is aimed at raising awareness of the signs and symptoms of the disease. Early detection significantly improves survival and can help preserve function and appearance. Most men affected are usually in the over 50s age bracket, but it doesn't mean that all men still shouldn't be cautious. Advertisement READ MORE ON HEALTH The new campaign, Know the Signs, features a short with penile cancer survivor Cormac France. The dad-of-four, from . Cormac told the "Because I don't smoke, I didn't think I would be a candidate to get cancer, never mind penile cancer, which is rarer again. Advertisement Most read in Health "Looking back from when I was diagnosed, I did notice, the six months or so previous, that's when the changes really started. HSE chiefs issue warning to jetsetters "With weight loss, chronic tiredness, and as time progressed, the smell from my penis was horrendous, and then the penis started to split." These major symptoms are due to the growth of the The brave father warned male listeners about this deadly disease as he said: "Cancer can reach every part of your body, and people have to realise that." Advertisement MAIN SYMPTOMS TO coincide with Men's Health Week the HSE has launched a new campaign called 'Know the Signs'. Here are some of the main symptoms/signs to look out for: A growth or sore on your penis that doesn't heal within 4 weeks – it may look like a wart or blister Bleeding from your penis or from under the foreskin A foul-smelling discharge under the foreskin (not ejaculation) Swelling or difficulty pulling back the foreskin (phimosis) A change in skin colour on the penis or foreskin to blueish or brown A rash or small crusty bumps on the penis Consultant Urologist and Lead of the National Penile Cancer Service, Mr Ivor Cullen, has shared his concerns about the stigma the rare disease. He said: "Although a rare disease, penile cancer is a very aggressive disease when it has spread. "Penile cancer is, in large part, preventable, yet we're still seeing men present late because of stigma and lack of awareness. "It's a sensitive subject, yes, but early detection makes all the difference, not just for survival, but for preserving function and quality of life.' Advertisement For more information on this rare cancer visit or read their new booklet titled: 'What I Need to Know About Penile Cancer'. It is a guide designed to help men, families and healthcare professionals recognise symptoms early, understand risk factors, and access treatment and support 3 The HSE now have a book to help men catch this deadly disease early Credit: GETTY


The Irish Sun
a day ago
- The Irish Sun
Funding to help alleviate waiting lists suspended at second hospital over ‘potential financial irregularities'
FUNDING to help alleviate waiting lists has been suspended at a second hospital because of 'potential financial irregularities'. The National Treatment Purchase Fund (NTPF) said it had suspended all insourcing work at the public hospital since April 11 and immediately informed the Department of Health and Advertisement The matter had been referred to the HSE's internal audit team. NTPF chief executive Fiona Brady said: 'The board and executive of the NTPF take their responsibilities very seriously and will take whatever actions are necessary to ensure our spend with public hospitals is fully protected for the benefit of public patients. 'Any proven misuse of public money by public institutions will be treated with the gravity it deserves.' The NTPF, which is a body that arranges external treatments for patients on public hospital waiting lists, has come under scrutiny in recent weeks. Advertisement Read more in News It was reported in the Sunday Times that a consultant breached HSE guidelines by referring patients he was seeing in his public practice to his weekend clinics, rather than securing earlier treatment for them by referring them to HSE colleagues. The newspaper said the consultant was paid thousands of euro through the NTPF, and the details were uncovered by an internal investigation by Children's Health The NTPF said on Wednesday that following a meeting of its board, it would immediately recommence insourcing work with CHI after a review of its assurances. But it said that the board and executive 'remain deeply concerned' that there had been a breach of its processes by another public body. Advertisement Most read in The Irish Sun It said governance and oversight across its insourcing work with public hospitals – who until now have been responsible for this internal governance – would increase. As well as notifying the Department of A deadline of Monday June 16 has been given for the completion of these replies. Ms Brady said: 'Insourcing work through the NTPF has delivered benefits to thousands of patients in recent years and has a demonstrable impact on waiting times and waiting-list numbers. Advertisement 'However, it is vital there is public trust and confidence around insourcing with public hospitals. 'It must be remembered that these public hospitals already have clear and established lines of reporting and accountability within the public system and clear obligations to comply with the terms of the signed memorandum of understanding in respect of NTPF-funded work. 'We will now work urgently with the Department of Health and HSE on any additional measures that may be needed to ensure that necessary controls of NTPF-funded initiatives are in place in the public hospitals.' 1 Funding to help alleviate waiting lists has been suspended at a second hospital by the NTPF (stock image) Credit: Alamy Advertisement