Death of man who drowned in Douglas Harbour was accidental
The inquest heard Mr Scott had phoned his friend to ask if he could borrow some fishing equipment and was told he could collect it from the other man's boat, the Manx Maiden.CCTV footage showed him arriving at the harbour shortly before 09:45 GMT carrying a black bag, which he left on the pier near to his own vessel. He was then captured walking along to the area his friend's vessel was berthed before climbing down a harbour ladder to get onto the boat.
The inquest was told that Mr Scott had a "difficult relationship with alcohol" and had gone for a drink at the nearby Old Market Inn shortly before making his way to the harbour.Toxicology reports showed his alcohol levels were more than twice the legal limit for driving at the time of his death.He was reported missing on the morning of 9 November by his then partner who had not heard from him.Evidence from a diver who recovered Mr Scott's body from the harbour stated lead rope, a fire extinguisher and two bags containing fishing tools and safety equipment, including a lifejacket, were found on the seabed in the area.The items were spotted beside a piece of the lower section of a harbour ladder, which was rusty and had broken off, the inquest was told.In her evidence, Mr Scott's mother Joan Scott described her son as a sociable person who was "kind and considerate"."My life will never be the same without Lee. I hope he rests in peace in heaven," she added.Mr Brooks said he was "satisfied" that Mr Scott had been able to board the boat on 8 November to collect the items but had fallen into the harbour when attempting to climb off the vessel carrying them.Given the weight of the equipment, his intoxication levels, and the likelihood that the lower part of the ladder was already missing at the time, he had lost his footing and was weighed down by the items after falling into the water, he added.He concluded the death was accidental.
Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Press and Journal
an hour ago
- Press and Journal
Exclusive: Death inquiry to probe man's 12th floor plunge from Aberdeen high-rise
An inquiry will probe the death of an Aberdeen man who was abducted and tortured before plummeting from the 12th floor of a block of flats. Jamie Forbes, 37, was brutally beaten and savagely attacked with a hammer by 38-year-old Lee Smith, who was convicted of culpable homicide and jailed for eight years last December. Smith claimed that Mr Forbes stole £40 from him, and he had planned to hold his victim captive in the Elphinstone Court property for three days so he would 'atone' for what he had done. The Press and Journal later revealed that Police Scotland missed opportunities to rescue Mr Forbes during a five-hour period on January 15 last year. Those failures included sending 999 response officers to the wrong floors of the 18-storey building, where Mr Forbes was screaming for help. Following on from a damning report from police watchdog Pirc – which concluded Mr Forbes could possibly have been saved were it not for the series of mistakes and misunderstandings – Scotland's most senior law officer has decided it is in the public interest to hold a fatal accident inquiry (FAI) into the incident. Court proceedings led by a sheriff will examine the full circumstances surrounding Mr Forbes' tragic death. Procurator Fiscal Andy Shanks, who leads investigations of fatalities for the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service, confirmed that work was already underway. 'The Lord Advocate has decided that a discretionary Fatal Accident Inquiry should be held into the causes of Jamie Forbes' death to ensure that there can be a full public hearing of the facts of the case,' he said. 'The Procurator Fiscal has now started work to initiate this inquiry, and there are a number of legal steps which must be taken before it can commence. 'Jamie's family will be kept informed of what will happen next, including timescales for court hearings.' Lyndsay-anne Forbes, Jamie's 35-year-old sister, has tirelessly campaigned for answers, believing her brother's death was entirely avoidable. She told The P&J: 'Jamie did everything we are all taught to do when we are in danger. He screamed and shouted for help, but it never came. 'My brother was so badly let down by a system meant to protect him, all of us, in our moments of need. 'I hope Jamie's FAI leads to measures being put in place to prevent the same mistakes from being repeated, so no one else suffers the traumatic loss of a loved one like we have.' Her brother had 'had a hard life' and 'made some silly decisions,' causing him to fall into a 'black hole,' she added. 'Yes, he was an addict, but it didn't make him any less loved. He matters to me. I have had a broken heart every day since he died.' Miss Forbes also posted a video on TikTok to thank her followers for supporting her campaign. 'I cannot stop crying, and it's happy tears,' she told them, adding it was the first 'win' her ongoing campaign for answers had secured in 18 months. On the day that Mr Forbes died, concerned members of the public, who had heard a man screaming for help, made repeated calls to 999. Officers arrived on the scene around 10.25am on January 15 2024, but gave up the search for the source of the distress only 40 minutes later, when they left the area. Five hours later, at 3.30pm, Mr Forbes' lifeless body was discovered on the ground outside the block of flats. An independent regulator investigated Police Scotland's handling of the incident. The Press and Journal obtained the confidential findings in a report by the Police Investigations Review Commissioner (Pirc). It revealed that a witness told a 999 call handler that shouting was coming from the 'top half' of the high-rise, but the operator incorrectly recorded it as the 'bottom half'. It meant door-to-door inquiries focused on floors five, six, seven and eight, not the 12th floor where Mr Forbes was being kicked, punched and repeatedly struck with a hammer. Other findings included: A now-former Tillydrone resident, Gail Thomson, 26, called 999 after hearing Jamie Forbes' cries for help, and previously said she 'pinpointed exactly' where to find him. 'I told them where I was standing. I said there were two people – one on the balcony and somebody at a window from so many floors down from the top,' she explained. Miss Thomson said today that she would be happy to give evidence to the FAI, if called upon. 'Finally, it'll be looked into properly, and hopefully something will be done about it,' she said. 'I'd like to help. I told the police where Jamie was. They just needed to listen properly and then go and look there. They didn't, so that cost Jamie his life. 'I hope the FAI will hold the police accountable for their failures.' Mr Forbes' killer Lee Smith already had a lengthy criminal record going back to 2003 before he pled guilty to the reduced charge of culpable homicide. He had earlier been sent to prison three times for violent crimes and was roaming free on two bail orders in separate, unrelated criminal court cases when he killed Jamie. The deadly incident occurred less than a month after a court appearance. Key witness Gail Thomson has revealed what she told Police Scotland after seeing Jamie Forbes crying out for help
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Paul Weller sues former accountants after being dropped over Gaza statements
Musician Paul Weller is suing his former accountants after they stopped working with the singer after public statements alleging Israel was committing genocide in Gaza, according to a legal letter. The former frontman of The Jam has filed a discrimination claim against Harris and Trotter after the firm ended their professional relationship after more than 30 years. In a pre-action letter seen by the PA news agency, lawyers for Weller say the singer-songwriter was told in March that the accountants and tax advisers would no longer work with the 67-year-old or his companies. According to the letter, a WhatsApp message from a partner at the firm included: 'It's well known what your political views are in relation to Israel, the Palestinians and Gaza, but we as a firm are offended at the assertions that Israel is committing any type of genocide. 'Everyone is entitled to their own views, but you are alleging such anti-Israel views that we as a firm with Jewish roots and many Jewish partners are not prepared to work with someone who holds these views.' Lawyers for Weller claim that by ending their services, the firm unlawfully discriminated against the singer's protected philosophical beliefs including that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza and that Palestine should be recognised as a nation state. Weller said: 'I've always spoken out against injustice, whether it's apartheid, ethnic cleansing, or genocide. What's happening to the Palestinian people in Gaza is a humanitarian catastrophe. 'I believe they have the right to self-determination, dignity, and protection under international law, and I believe Israel is committing genocide against them. That must be called out. 'Silencing those who speak this truth is not just censorship – it's complicity. 'I'm taking legal action not just for myself, but to help ensure that others are not similarly punished for expressing their beliefs about the rights of the Palestinian people.' Weller will donate any damages he receives to humanitarian relief efforts in Gaza, the legal letter also states. Cormac McDonough, a lawyer at Hodge Jones and Allen, representing Weller, said that his case 'reflects a wider pattern of attempts to silence artists and public figures who speak out in support of Palestinian rights'. Mr McDonough added: 'Within the music industry especially, we are seeing increasing efforts to marginalise those who express solidarity with the people of Gaza.'
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Why did Casey-Louise die? Heartbreaking photos show girl, 13, cradling her baby sister - amid mystery over her tragic final hours as teen arrested over 'her rape and murder' is bailed
The teenage boy suspected of the rape and murder of 13-year-old Casey-Louise Horrocks is back home behaving 'like he doesn't have a care in the world,' according to neighbours. The schoolgirl was found by paramedics 'unresponsive' last Monday night. She died later in hospital. West Yorkshire Police arrested the boy, who lives in Huddersfield, West Yorkshire, on suspicion of Casey-Louise's rape and murder and the alleged rape of another local girl, aged 16. He was released on conditional police bail pending further enquiries on Friday, August 15. A neighbour said: 'I saw him come home on Friday lunchtime and he can't have spent more than 15 minutes in the house before he was heading out again. 'He left through the gate and jogged away, probably off to meet his mates. 'He is acting like he doesn't have a care in the world.' Another local said: 'He is well known in the area and you would think he would be keeping a low profile under the circumstances. 'I mean, a young lass has died and I think he should show a bit more respect. Maybe stop in and not go out so much.' Today new photographs of Casey-Louise, including one of her cradling what is believed to be her baby sister, Mia, were posted by friends and relatives on a tribute site online. A link to the site, posted on Facebook by Anthony Barton Funeral Directors, encouraged people to share memories, poems and pictures of the 'bright, caring soul who touched the lives of everyone around her.' Among those leaving their 'thoughts' was Casey-Louise's 'best mate', named Cole, who wrote: 'RIP Casey you'll be missed so much. Can't believe you left us so early your (sic) flying with the angels now, fly high love you lots my thunder buddie in the sky.' Her Auntie Dani added that she missed her 'so much,' saying: 'Forever 13. Love you so much bubba xxxx.' While Paula Mills wrote: 'Fly high with the angels beautiful girl. I hope there's an amazing afterlife waiting for you where all your hopes and dreams come true. #foreveryoung#forever13.' While another contributor added: 'You've left a massive hole in the lives of all who had the pleasure of knowing you. Sweet dreams Casey, you'll be sadly missed xx.' In a statement, Mossley Hollins High School, in Manchester, where Casey-Louise was a pupil, said they were 'heartbroken' at the death of the 'big-hearted' youngster. 'We are heartbroken by the loss of Casey‑Louise, a one-of-a-kind young person who brought spirit and warmth wherever she went,' the statement said. 'Casey was bright, full of character, always full of life, and never afraid to be herself. Those lucky enough to know her saw what a big heart she had. 'She was funny, sweet, had a smile that could brighten anyone's day and will be deeply missed by our school community. 'This heartbreaking news has deeply affected our community and as we come to terms with this loss, our thoughts are with Casey-Louise's family, loved ones and all those impacted at this incredibly difficult time.' Pupils will be offered emotional support when they return in September, the statement added. Casey-Louise was found unresponsive by emergency services just after 11.30pm last Monday, August 11. She was taken to hospital but died in the early hours of the following day. A postmortem was inconclusive and it is understood police are awaiting the results of toxiocology tests and a second autopsy to try and establish her cause of death. Originally from Manchester, Casey-Louise was in local authority care when she died. She had been living in Liverpool and was just visiting Huddersfield at the time of her death. Friend Tina Cooper also set up an online fundraiser for the youngster's funeral. So far more than £2,000 has been donated. She said: 'Casey was a vibrant happy 13-year-old with all her life ahead of her. 'Our hearts go out to Casey's family. No one should have to bury their child. Let's help her family send their daughter on her final journey with dignity.' Detective Chief Inspector Stacey Atkinson, of West Yorkshire Police's Homicide and Major Enquiry Team, previously said: 'A post-mortem was not able to determine how she died, and we continue to treat her death as unexplained at this time, pending more enquiries. 'Those enquiries are complex and are likely to be lengthy as we work to fully understand the circumstances of the girl's death. Specially trained officers are supporting her family at this time.' The news of Casey-Louise's death has sent shockwaves through the town. Huddersfield MP Harpreet Uppal said: 'This is a tragic case and my thoughts remain with the 13-year-old teenager and her family and friends. I have been in contact with the police and I am being updated on the investigation.'
