Standing Rock appeals dismissal of latest Dakota Access Pipeline lawsuit
The Standing Rock Sioux Tribe is asking the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals to review a federal judge's decision to dismiss its latest lawsuit against the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers over the Dakota Access Pipeline.
Standing Rock filed the lawsuit in October, asking the court to find the pipeline must be shut down because it still lacks an easement authorizing it to pass under the Missouri River's Lake Oahe reservoir, which is regulated by the Army Corps.
'The Corps of Engineers has not earned the trust of our Tribe,' Standing Rock Chairwoman Janet Alkire said in a statement last week announcing the appeal. 'We cannot rely on the Corps to properly evaluate DAPL, so we are continuing our legal efforts to protect our water and our people from this dangerous pipeline.'
Greenpeace seeks reversal of verdict, arguing jury wanted to 'punish' someone for pipeline protests
The Army Corps originally granted the easement to the pipeline's developer in 2017, but Boasberg revoked it in 2020 after finding the agency had issued the permit without completing the full environmental review required by federal law. The matter was brought to him through a lawsuit the tribe filed against the Army Corps in 2016.
Boasberg at the time directed the Corps to withhold making a decision on the easement until it completes a full environmental impact study. He also ordered the pipeline to be shut down, though that demand was later reversed by an appellate court.
Five years later, the Army Corps still has not finished the environmental review. It published a draft in late 2023.
Standing Rock in its latest suit argues that keeping the pipeline open without an easement is a violation of federal law. The tribe also alleges the Army Corps is at fault for a number of other regulatory violations related to the pipeline.
In court filings, Standing Rock has said it intends to present new evidence related to the pipeline's safety. The pipeline company has indicated previously it does not consider that information credible.
U.S. District Court Judge James Boasberg tossed the suit in March, finding that the courts cannot intervene in the matter until the Army Corps wraps up its environmental study.
'No matter its frustration with Defendants' sluggish pace, it is not yet entitled to a second bite at the apple,' he wrote in his March order.
Boasberg previously indicated that while the agency works on the study, it has the option of enforcing its property rights since the pipeline is operating on federal land without authorization.
'The Corps has conspicuously declined to adopt a conclusive position regarding the pipeline's continued operation, despite repeated prodding from this Court and the Court of Appeals to do so,' he wrote in a 2021 order.
Standing Rock leaders say they hope the D.C. Circuit will overturn Boasberg's decision to dismiss the case.
In her statement, Alkire said the tribe fears the Army Corps' study will 'whitewash' the pipeline's risk to the surrounding environment.
The pipeline crosses Lake Oahe just north of the Standing Rock Reservation. The tribe opposes the Dakota Access Pipeline as a threat to its sovereignty, water supply and cultural heritage sites.
Federal judge dismisses Standing Rock's latest lawsuit over Dakota Access Pipeline
Alkire also underscored the tribe's dismay over a March jury verdict that found the environmental group Greenpeace at fault for damaging the pipeline developers property and business as part of its protests against Dakota Access Pipeline. The jury ordered Greenpeace to pay the company, Energy Transfer, roughly $667 million.
Standing Rock has criticized the verdict as based on a false narrative that Greenpeace, and not Standing Rock and other tribes, led the protests.
'We saw Energy Transfer's efforts to re-write history as we know it and lived it in their lawsuit against Greenpeace,' she said.
In April, another federal judge ordered the Army Corps to pay North Dakota $28 million in connection to the anti-pipeline protests, finding the agency's actions had wrongfully forced the state to pay millions policing the protests and cleaning up the aftermath.
The Dakota Access Pipeline passes through unceded land previously recognized as belonging to the Sioux Nation in 19th century treaties with the U.S. government.
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
3 days ago
- New York Post
Stop anti-Trump judges, it's still the economy, stupid and other commentary
From the right: Stop Anti-Trump Judges 'The judiciary's credibility will continue to suffer until elected lawmakers set reliable restraints to thwart Judge [James] Boasberg's next intrigue,' fume The Washington Times' editors. The DC Circuit judge months back took issue with ICE deporting illegal migrants determined to be Tren de Aragua members, and even 'ordered the government to 'turn the planes around' while they were over international waters.' Then, after the Supreme Court in April 'concluded this inferior magistrate had no right to weigh in at all,' he nonetheless 'said he would levy criminal penalties on the administration lawyers who purportedly disobeyed' him. Last week, the DC Circuit Court of Appeals rebuked him, slamming that threat as an abuse of discretion. But 'the judiciary rarely punishes its own wayward members'; it's up to Congress to do something about these out-of-control judges. Liberal: It's Still the Economy, Stupid New data from The Economist/YouGov finds that 'Americans remain deeply pessimistic about the U.S. economy,' warns the Liberal Patriot's John Halpin. We have 'more than 70 percent of Democrats and half of independents' foreseeing 'higher inflation in the next six months,' while 40% of Republicans 'expect inflation to be lower.' Bottom line: 'Like President Biden before him, President Trump and his administration have not yet shown or convinced most Americans (even many of their own partisan voters) that they have a grip on the overall economy and rising costs.' And: 'Until the green shoots on jobs and prices turn into firm growth, expect Americans to remain dour on the economy and willing to punish those in power, of either party.' Harvard prof: Teachers Must Fight AI Overuse His students have 'told me that after relying on AI to draft their papers and emails, their ability to write, speak and conduct basic inquiry is slipping away,' Alex Green reports at The Wall Street Journal. Profs who don't resist 'the rampant overuse of AI' bear the blame. 'Students must gain the ability to synthesize information. They must be able to listen, read, speak and write — so they can express strategic and tactical thinking.' That's what they're losing. 'The human possession of these skills will never become irrelevant if we value life, society and governance. For students to grow into professionals who have those skills, they must first develop them.' But what it'll take for teachers 'to defend that right . . . I do not know.' Foreign desk: The End Is Near for Maduro 'Nicolás Maduro, the dictator of Venezuela, is on the ropes,' cheers Arturo McFields at The Hill. The feds set an unprecedented '$50 million reward' for his capture, and the Pentagon is preparing options for the 'use of military force against drug cartels' with the Maduro-linked Cartel de los Soles already 'designated as a foreign terrorist organization.' Secretary of State Marco Rubio says Venezuela's narco-terrorist state is 'no longer a law enforcement issue' but 'a national security issue.' Good: 'After nearly 25 years of the Chavista regime, the situation in Venezuela is worsening every day. International collaboration is needed to end a tragedy that represents a clear and present danger to Latin America and the U.S.' Libertarian: How to Save Social Security Most Americans 'don't understand how' Social Security works, but happily 'the public gets that there is a problem, and some are open to changes,' notes Reason's J.D. Tuccille. Sadly, some 55% 'think Social Security is supposed to 'largely replace seniors' income after they retire,' '; in fact, it's meant 'to make sure seniors don't fall into poverty.' Most people would be better off diverting 'the money they currently surrender as payroll taxes to retirement savings plans like the 401(k),' and 'younger Americans may be open to the idea,' as they are more likely than Boomers to support cutting benefits over raising taxes. A Social Security program 'that's rightly recognized as a safety net is on its way to replacement by private planning.' — Compiled by The Post Editorial Board
Forbes
5 days ago
- Forbes
How The B Corp Community Is Adapting To Life In 2025
B Corp accreditation has long been seen as a benchmark for environmental and ethical business practices, but with all the economic and geo-political upheaval in recent years, is there still a place for it in the new world order? The chief executive of B Lab UK, Chris Turner, said that while some businesses may be tempted to roll back on issues like sustainability, B Corps have made clear commitments on issues like climate change. Turner added that there are now over 2,600 B Corps in the U.K., which is the largest and fastest-growing B Corp community in the world, in an interview. He said recently published data from B Lab UK's 2024 brand awareness survey revealed a high recognition across the U.K. The survey also found almost two-thirds (63%) of respondents saying they use the certifications to help them make decisions on which businesses to buy from or work for, up from 58% in 2023 and 56% in 2022. The survey also found nearly three-quarters (74%) of the public agree or strongly agree that consumers can impact environmental sustainability through their purchases. And around two-thirds (65%) felt the same about impacting social change. 'We also have more than 3,000 companies backing our Better Business Act campaign,' he added. 'Momentum in the U.K. is still very strong, which is clearly a positive sign.' Turner said B Corps can act as a 'counter-narrative' because they have a clear purpose and are likelier to stay the course, while others roll back on some initiatives. 'There are also some businesses out there who are still doing the same work, but not talking about it as much, or changing some of the language they use,' he told me. 'I don't necessarily think that's a bad thing,' he added. 'The most important thing is the work gets done and the positive impact gets delivered.' Turner said the B Corp movement has seen rapid growth in the last few years, with many brands telling a compelling story about why they are adopting business models with a purpose. 'At the same time, the story that's been playing out alongside that momentum is the need to raise the bar for purposeful business,' said Turner. 'The urgency of the challenges we face means our whole mission as a movement is about how B Corps can lead the way and show what businesses can, and should, be doing.' 'What's really exciting about where we are now as a movement is how those things are coming together. It willbe vital over the next couple of years, as all B Corps move on to B Lab's new standards and we bring new businesses into the movement, to continue going forward and making the progress needed.' Tribe Impact Capital's co-founder and chief impact officer, Amy Clarke, said that sustainability has always faced a certain degree of resistance and has previously had to pivot and adapt as circumstances change. Clarke added that it feels like sustainability is in another 'adaptation phase' at the moment, but one that she hopes will address the root of the world's challenges. 'This is only going to further help sustainability evolve into what it really should be about, which is the common good,' she told me. 'And what the B Corp standards have done is say 'we have this incredible program of assessment in place that has really helped us communicate to the broader world what businesses which trade in the currency of forces for change look like'.' 'This is fundamentally about who you are. It has turbo-charged our credibility and enabled us to attract new employees and clients, who have seen we have not bowed at the first sign of major trouble and, if anything, we have stood up even taller.' And the global B Corp impact manager at Intrepid Travel, Rochelle Turner, said the B Corp movement helps create a framework for businesses and identify opportunities to make improvements, in an interview. Turner added that it also gives businesses like Intrepid Travel the opportunity to be part of a wider community, highlight how you can be a successful business and positively create purpose and impact. She said a recent staff survey showed that more than four-fifths (80%) of its staff say they like working for a company with a purpose, adding that happy staff mean higher retention rates and happy customers. 'We are a better business because we have followed many of the principles of the B Corp framework, and also through thinking about how we operate in all the different aspects we do to create positive impact in our business,' Turner told me.
Yahoo
6 days ago
- Yahoo
JD Vance blames Secret Service over raising of Ohio river level to accommodate VP's birthday kayaking trip
Vice President JD Vance's office said the Secret Service requested that water levels in an Ohio river be raised to accommodate a birthday kayaking trip and the Republican was unaware. Vance was on a family vacation in south-western Ohio last week, and spotted by locals kayaking down the Little Miami River on his birthday on August 2, when he turned 41. The Secret Service requested that Army Corps engineers change the outflow of Caesar Creek Lake, which feeds into the river, to 'support safe navigation' of Vance's security detail, The Guardian first reported. An anonymous source told the newspaper the request was also made to create 'ideal kayaking conditions' for the vice president, according to the report. A source familiar with the matter denied that claim to The Independent. During a Secret Service scouting mission of the area with local public safety officials ahead of Vance's trip, one of the boats ran aground, the source said. The decision to raise the water levels was made for security reasons, the source claimed. The vice president was unaware the water level had been raised, according to a Vance spokesperson. 'The Secret Service often employs protective measures without the knowledge of the Vice President or his staff, as was the case last weekend,' the spokesperson told The Independent. A Secret Service spokesperson previously told The Independent it coordinated with the Ohio Department of Natural Resources and Army Corps of Engineers to ensure that Vance's security detail could 'operate safely with appropriate water levels during a recent visit.' In early August, aligning with the dates Vance was in the area, there was a sudden increase in the river level and a corresponding drop in Caesar Creek Lake's water surface elevation, according to public data on the U.S. Geological Survey website. Army Corps of Engineers spokesperson Gene Pawlik said that a request was received to 'temporarily increase outflows from Caesar Creek Lake to support safe navigation of U.S. Secret Service personnel.' Critics said it appeared hypocritical of Vance to receive 'special treatment' for his family vacation in the beauty spot when his administration has overseen drastic job cuts in the National Park Service. 'It's outrageous for the Army corps of engineers to spend taxpayer money to increase water flow in a river so @VP can go canoeing when budget cuts to the National Park Service have severely impacted family vacations for everyone else,' ethics lawyer Richard Painter, who served in George W. Bush's administration, reacted in a post on X. Certain accommodations have been made for the vice president's family on other trips around the globe. During a recent trip to Italy, the Roman Colosseum was closed to the public so that his wife, Usha, and their children could take a tour, sparking anger among some tourists. The Taj Mahal also was closed to visitors during the Vance family's visit to India. Protesters have also frequently crashed Vance's family vacations in the six months he has been in office. After word spread that Vance and his family planned a day out at Disneyland in California last month, hundreds turned out to protest at the theme park, to condemn the Trump administration's immigration raids across the state. In March, protesters lined the streets near the ski resort the vice president was staying at with his family in Vermont. Vance is soon headed for the U.K. countryside hotspot of the Cotswolds on his next family vacation, where he is expected to rent a quaint rural cottage. Solve the daily Crossword
