Debunked: Asylum seekers are not exempt from income tax for a year after they are allowed to work
The claim, which was shared in a recruitment video for an anti-immigration group, appears to be a misunderstanding of a plan to charge working asylum seekers that are in accommodation provided through the International Protection Accommodation Scheme (IPAS).
The claim was shared in a video featuring a man wearing a 'MÉGA'cap, which stands for Make Éire Great Again — a slogan used by some Irish fans of Donald Trump.
Shouting at a crowd, he talks about migrants who want to 'impose their sharia law' and says Irish people now slaves.
'Jim O'Callaghan, not three months ago, came out on RTÉ — I only watch it to see what I'm catching him out on — but he came out and said some IPAS residents are currently employed. They may be asked to contribute to society in a year's time. Where's my tax-free year? I have to pay through the nose for everything.'
The post containing the speech is a recruitment video for anti-immigration group Síol na hÉireann. It is unclear if the man in the video has a connection with Síol na hÉireann, which has previously
been investigated
by the Advertising Standards Authority for using footage of assaults in its recruitment material.
The Journal
has previously debunked posts by this group, including multiple
false
claims
about black people attacking white people in Ireland.
As of writing, one version of the video have been viewed more than 232,300 times on Facebook, and more than 22,000 times on X. Both were posted on 10 August.
The claim made in the video is said to stem from an appearance by Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan on RTÉ.
The Journal
was unable to find an appearance matching the description, and a spokesperson from O'Callaghan's office said that they were unfamiliar with what the man in the video was speaking about.
It seems likely that the video confuses O'Callaghan with Colm Brophy, who is a Minister of State at the Department of Justice.
Advertisement
Brophy has spoken publicly about plans to charge working asylum seekers for their accommodation. (O'Callaghan's office confirmed he supports the plan).
However, these plans have little resemblance to what was being talked about in the video other than some shared terminology, such as uses of the term 'contribution'. The government's plans are not about changing how IPAS applicants are taxed.
Rather, these plans involve
charging asylum seekers
who are entitled to work for accommodation in IPAS centres as a way to reduce the cost of the international protection system to the government.
Currently, asylum seekers in Ireland can be granted permission to work if they have been waiting more than 6 months for the first decision on their application.
The Sunday Independent reported
that one proposal says that 11,400 people in IPAS centres are estimated to have an income and would be eligible to pay the fee.
So, what has this got to do with a 'tax-free year'? Not much, it appears.
'Applicants for international protection are subject to the same system of taxation as all other people resident in Ireland,' a spokesperson for the Department of Justice told
The Journal.
'There is no exemption from income tax for applicants under the International Protection Accommodation Scheme who have an entitlement to work in Ireland,' Revenue said in response to the online claims.
Claims that asylum seekers or other foreign nationals have preferential treatment in Ireland are commonly spread by anti-immigration groups.
Thai year,
The Journal
has previously debunked claims that immigrants get
shorter prison sentences
than Irish citizens; that
traffic rules
do not apply to non-Irish people; that the Irish government pays Ukrainians to
repair their cars
or has spent
€200,000 per car
to help isolated Ukrainians; and that taxes go toward subsidising
foreign-owned businesses
.
Want to be your own fact-checker? Visit our brand-new
FactCheck Knowledge Bank
for guides and toolkits
The Journal's FactCheck is a signatory to the International Fact-Checking Network's Code of Principles. You can read it
here
. For information on how FactCheck works, what the verdicts mean, and how you can take part, check out our Reader's Guide
here
. You can read about the team of editors and reporters who work on the factchecks
here
.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
It is vital that we surface facts from noise. Articles like this one brings you clarity, transparency and balance so you can make well-informed decisions.
We set up FactCheck in 2016 to proactively expose false or misleading information, but to continue to deliver on this mission we need your support.
Over 5,000 readers like you support us. If you can, please consider setting up a monthly payment or making a once-off donation to keep news free to everyone.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Cormac O'Keeffe: Tension mounts in Ireland's real-life spy drama
It has all the ingredients of Netflix spy drama, but the 'Agent Cobalt' story concerns real investigations, real threats, and real people. Trying to figure out what actually happened, weighing up differing accounts and perspectives, and trying to present a clear and accurate picture is quite a challenge. Interested observers would be advised to bear that in mind. It is also worth stressing there are few areas where gathering and analysing information is more difficult than in the shadowy and secretive world of national security and intelligence. This is particularly so in Ireland, with its long, and embedded, culture of secrecy. Cobalt Revealed Back in October, The Sunday Times ran a dramatic front-page headline: 'Revealed: Putin has an agent in the Oireachtas'. The story, by their experienced security correspondent John Mooney, sent shockwaves through the Oireachtas and dominated the airwaves for some time. The report said: 'The Irish military and security services have identified a politician in the Oireachtas who has been recruited by Russian intelligence as an agent of influence and whose clandestine connections to Moscow remain intact.' The story, and related articles, described the politician as a person who could influence policy and political narratives, using his own networks and outlets. The most serious of allegations against the politician related to him allegedly offering services, such as making introductions, including, it was reported, to loyalist paramilitaries. The Sunday Times detailed how Garda security and intelligence and military intelligence both came across the politician during counter-intelligence surveillance they were conducting on suspected Russian intelligence officers in Ireland, including the military attache to the Russian Embassy — Sergey Prokopiev. It is also thought British intelligence were aware. The Sunday Times had details on travels the politician took and of alleged meetings with Russian agents, in Ireland and abroad. Most of the meetings and contacts appear to relate to the period 2019 and 2020, but the Garda and Military monitoring continued. After the stories, there was intense speculation as to who was 'Agent Cobalt' and there was widespread commentary on social media. Government leaders, including the Taoiseach and the Justice Minister were briefed about the politician, who has never commented. No Agent Cobalt Last Tuesday The Journal ran a story, headlined: 'There is no Agent Cobalt'. It added: 'Garda investigation clears Irish politician of being a Russian Agent.' The story, by Niall O'Connor, an experienced security journalist and former garda, said the investigation had 'exonerated' the politician. It said: 'The politician has been sent confirmation from the detectives investigating the case that nothing has been found to suggest that he ever spied for Russia or worked with Russian agents.' The report said sources spoken to said that, while Russian agents tried to approach the politician, 'nothing came of it'. The story said the first approach was in Eastern Europe when the politician was on a work trip and that his drink was spiked by a female agent. It said the politician contacted gardaí on his return about the incident. The second approach was by a purported 'trade attaché' at the Russian Embassy, apparently a reference to Prokopiev. The Journal referred to a meeting between detectives from the Special Detective Unit and the politician, accompanied by his legal representatives — held after the October Sunday Times articles. It said detectives told the politician that 'nothing untoward had been found' to suggest he had given information to Russia. The article said it was understood that the politician was 'sent confirmation of this in writing'. Garda HQ Intervenes On publication of the story, media sought a comment from the Garda Press Office. In the meantime, inquiries by the Irish Examiner among security sources found that they were adamant that no such letter was issued and that no statements would be given to a suspect that they were in the clear or that the case was closed. Later, Garda HQ issued a statement, stating the investigation was not finished. It said: 'An Garda Síochána is continuing an ongoing active criminal investigation into this matter. An Garda Síochána has no further comment.' The Irish Examiner understands that the message sent out was coming from the very top layers of the organisation. Next episode The Garda statement, and inquiries conducted by the Irish Examiner, indicate that all sides in this case are absolutely certain of their positions and the integrity of their work. It is expected that The Sunday Times will publish more details this weekend and that The Journal may too, either before or after, with additional information to support their respective accounts. It seems clear that this matter could gather momentum. The issue of the existence of a 'document' or 'letter' may come more to the fore, sparking pressures for publication. Then there is the meeting in question and the position of the multiple witnesses at that. Is it possible that it is all down to a misinterpretation or misrepresentation of what was said? If the politician and/or his legal representatives decide to speak, it may well become a political issue, even with the Oireachtas on holidays. That might put pressure on Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan and Taoiseach Micheál Martin to comment. That is unlikely to be something the outgoing commissioner — departing at the end of next week — or the new commissioner — staring on 1 September — would want. Expect more twists and turns.
Sunday World
4 hours ago
- Sunday World
Former Sinn Féin leader Gerry Adams donates his €100k BBC defamation case damages
The move was disclosed yesterday by his solicitors The move was disclosed yesterday by his solicitors, almost three months after a High Court jury in Dublin found the former Sinn Féin leader had been defamed by a 2016 BBC programme and a BBC website article containing allegations he sanctioned the murder of ex-party official Denis Donaldson. Mr Adams (76) denied any involvement in the killing and sued over the Spotlight programme and the article. The corporation confirmed in June it would not be appealing the outcome of the case, which has left it facing legal costs estimated at around €3m. A statement issued by Johnsons Solicitors, the law firm that represented Mr Adams, said it could confirm the BBC had discharged the order of the court in relation to damages awarded by the jury. 'Mr Adams said at the outset of his defamation case against the BBC that he intended to donate any damages awarded to good causes,' the statement said. 'Donations have been made to Unicef for the children of Gaza, local An Cumann Lúthchleas Gael, An Cumann Cabhrach, to the Irish-language sector, to the homeless and Belfast-based youth, mental health and suicide prevention projects and others.' An Cumann Cabhrach is an organisation that provides support for families of republican prisoners and IRA volunteers who lost their lives during the Northern Ireland conflict. Mr Donaldson (55), a former Sinn Féin administrator in Stormont, was shot dead at a remote cottage in Glenties, Co Donegal, in April 2006 - four months after he admitted to having been an informer for police and MI5 since the 1980s. At the time, Mr Adams was Sinn Féin president and TD for Louth, but he has since retired from frontline politics. Mr Adams denied any knowledge or involvement in the killing and described the programme as 'a grievous smear'. The BBC argued that words used did not mean that Mr Adams sanctioned the murder and that it had merely published an allegation made by a former British agent, known only as Martin, who infiltrated Sinn Féin and the IRA. It said that it had been left up to viewers and readers to decide. The BBC also argued that Mr Adams was not entitled to damages due to his reputation as having been an IRA leader, something he has always denied. However, a jury found the words meant that Mr Adams sanctioned and approved the murder. It also found the BBC's actions had not been in good faith and that it had not been fair and reasonable to publish the allegation. Mr Adams' legal team said the verdict was a 'full vindication' for their client, while the BBC said it was 'disappointed' with the outcome. After the verdict, Mr Adams said taking the case 'was about putting manners on the BBC', a comment that was described as 'chilling' by Seamus Dooley, the Irish secretary of the National Union of Journalists. Former Sinn Féin president Gerry Adams. Photo: Brian Lawless/PA. Today's News in 90 Seconds - August 19th
Irish Daily Mirror
4 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Town's residents in 'strong opposition' to 'controversial' Mise Eire festival
A number of residents and business owners in Castlebar are 'voicing strong opposition' to the 'controversial' Mise Éire festival slated for a hotel in the town this weekend - launching a petition to have the festival moved. Mise Éire Festival was initially set to take place on August 23 at the Mayflower Community Centre in Drumshanbo, Co. Leitrim, featuring 'live music, talks and workshops celebrating Irish culture, heritage and shared values'. One of the panel discussions is titled Echos of Éire, learning from Ireland's Past to Shape a Resilient Future from figures including far right writer John Waters, Brehon Academy founder Kevin Flanagan and others. But earlier in August, the Mayflower Community Centre in Drumshanbo informed the public that the event would not be taking place at the centre due to terms and conditions not being complied with'. The announcement followed an open letter signed by around 600 artists, musicians and arts workers including The Mary Wallopers, Chris O'Dowd, Fontaines D.C., Christy Moore, Frances Black, Stephen Rea and more being sent to the community centre calling on them to cancel what they called the 'far right' festival. The Mayflower Community Centre in Leitrim (Image: Mayflower Community Centre/Facebook) In a subsequent interview with Shannonside News, one of the festival's organiser Stephen Kerr explained that the festival would still be going ahead in Mayo, just outside Castlebar. He said the 'music and culture' festival would see 'talks and music all day long in three different areas.' Now, a number of residents and business owners in Castlebar are 'voicing strong opposition' to the 'controversial' Mise Éire festival and have launched an online petition to have the festival pulled citing 'significant concerns for public safety'. At the time of writing the petition had amassed over 2,000 signatures. 'Castlebar is a proud, welcoming town, especially at the height of our tourist season,' said one local concerned resident. 'An event shrouded in secrecy, which was already rejected by another community, is not welcome here. We are deeply concerned about the potential for disruption and the damage this could do to our reputation as a safe and inclusive place for families, visitors, and investors.' Christy Moore (Image: Getty Images) In an open letter, the coalition of residents and business owners wrote: 'An event shrouded in secrecy, which was already rejected by another community, is not welcome here. We are deeply concerned about the potential for disruption and the damage this could do to our reputation as a safe and inclusive place for families, visitors, and investors.' 'Further questions remain regarding an 'after-party' planned for an undisclosed rural location near the town. 'It is unclear if organisers have secured the necessary permits or put adequate safety and logistical plans in place, adding to the community's sense of unease. 'Concerned residents are urging local authorities and elected officials to address the lack of transparency and ensure all public safety, licensing, and planning regulations are strictly enforced.' Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
