logo
Asylum seeker wins immigration appeal to have case reheard after changing his nationality from Iranian to Afghan halfway through the case

Asylum seeker wins immigration appeal to have case reheard after changing his nationality from Iranian to Afghan halfway through the case

Daily Mail​3 days ago
An asylum seeker has won an immigration appeal after changing his nationality from Iranian to Afghan halfway through the case.
The migrant initially told the Home Office that he left Iran 'illegally' and if he returned would be in danger of persecution because he was an ethnic and religious minority.
However, this claim was dismissed.
He later appealed the matter, claiming he was actually from Afghanistan and had been forced to leave due to problems his family faced with the Taliban.
The unnamed migrant said if he were to return he would suffer a decline in his mental health which would breach his human rights.
A hearing with a First-tier Tribunal judge took place but due to an 'administration oversight', the migrant and his solicitors did not attend and so his appeal was dismissed.
He has since appealed this decision and an Upper Tribunal judge has now ruled that his case should be reheard because his in-person evidence was of 'critical importance' to testing credibility.
The Upper Tribunal heard the man arrived in the UK in August 2012 and claimed asylum the following month.
File image: The migrant initially told the Home Office that he left Iran 'illegally' and if he returned would be in danger of persecution because he was an ethnic and religious minority
His claim was refused in 2015, and despite his attempts to appeal the decision, he was unsuccessful after it was found that he 'lacked credibility' and 'failed to establish a well-founded fear of persecution in Iran'.
The man remained in the UK and in July 2021 told the Home Office that he feared persecution upon return to Iran on account of his Baluch ethnicity, his Sunni Muslim faith, and the fact that he had left Iran illegally.
He stated that his brother's involvement in smuggling activities would place him at risk if he returned, and that his 'serious underlying mental health conditions' would impact his reintegration into Iran, which he claims would breach his human rights.
The tribunal said that he submitted a witness statement in advance of an appeal hearing which spoke of an alternative reason why he needed protection.
The judgement said the man 'now claims to be a national of Afghanistan' and had left the country when he was 17.
He stated that he had left Afghanistan due to problems his family faced with the Taliban, and told of how his father, brother, and sister still live there.
The man then explained that he left Afghanistan in 2011 before travelling to Iran, Turkey, and then the UK.
The judgment states: 'He stated that, upon claiming asylum in the UK, he falsely asserted Iranian nationality out of fear of being returned to Afghanistan.
File image: The unnamed migrant said if he were to return he would suffer a decline in his mental health which would breach his human rights
'He now claims that, if returned to Afghanistan, he would face ill-treatment at the hands of the Taliban.'
The man again said that his mental health issues would constitute 'very significant obstacles' to his reintegration in Afghanistan, and so his removal would breach his human rights.
Deputy Upper Tribunal Judge Sara Anzani decided that the matter should be heard afresh by the First-tier Tribunal.
The judge said: 'This was a protection appeal in which the [man's] credibility was central to the determination of the claim, thereby rendering his oral evidence of critical importance.
'Furthermore, there was evidence before the Tribunal of the [man's] documented mental health difficulties, which required careful consideration in the context of procedural fairness.
'The Judge's reasoning fails to reflect adequate engagement with these issues, or with the question of whether the appeal could be fairly and justly determined in the [man's] absence.
'For these reasons, I find that the Judge did not address all relevant material considerations and failed to properly assess whether refusing the [man's] readjournment request would compromise his right to a fair hearing.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Plea for ice queen Gillian to break her Salt Path silence: EPHRAIM HARDCASTLE
Plea for ice queen Gillian to break her Salt Path silence: EPHRAIM HARDCASTLE

Daily Mail​

time5 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Plea for ice queen Gillian to break her Salt Path silence: EPHRAIM HARDCASTLE

As the King prepares to head to Scotland for his summer break, my mole reports Prince Andrew is still on the guest list for a Balmoral holiday. Andrew had been feeling chipper when the White House announced Jeffrey Epstein didn't keep a little list of 'clients' and the FBI has closed its investigations. But, with Trump's second thoughts about releasing documents, Andrew's anxiety continues. It hasn't helped that he has received a reminder from the King that events don't allow him to return to royal duty. Is there no redemption for the disgraced duke? Why the delay in elevating Nigel Farage to the Privy Council? Elected to lead a party of five MPs (now down to four) the honour would normally have followed fairly swiftly as with the leaders of Plaid Cymru (four MPs) and the DUP (five). The last dither was when Jeremy Corbyn became Labour leader. He got the nod in the end because doing otherwise would risk the King appearing to snub a particular party. With Farage being touted as a potential next PM, the Palace is feeling similarly jittery. Membership carries the right to be briefed on confidential 'Privy Council terms' at times of national importance. You have to turn up of course. Kemi Badenoch missed a briefing about the Afghan data breach in March and so knew nothing about it until last week. Might Trump remember old pal Farage when visiting the King? The US embassy will, as is customary, have the right to suggest names to the state banquet guest list which could see Nigel don the nosebag at Windsor Castle. He didn't make the cut last time and will be hoping for better now he's an MP. And if Farage does get in, will he be seeking Queen Camilla 's guidance about boltholes for a sneaky Woodbine? Muteness from Gillian Anderson, pictured, about her role in The Salt Path, with author Raynor Winn disputing claims it has misleading details about her life. 'Were [Gillian] to break her silence,' writes The Spectator's Alexander Larman, 'it would be a rare chink in the armour of this ice queen, sex therapist and, it would appear, all-round Renaissance woman. Just a tinge of vulnerability... would make the Magnificent Anderson that bit more human, and therefore likeable.' Expressing sympathy for married Andy Byron, 50, forced to resign after he was caught on camera cuddling his company's HR chief Kristin Cabot, 52, at a Coldplay concert, writer Flora Gill remarks: 'Am I the only one who thinks it's kind of refreshing, seeing a man publicly cheat with an age-appropriate woman for once? I know this means the bar is absurdly low, but she's not in her twenties, so that's something.' Her late journalist father, AA Gill, famously left Flora's politician mother Amber Rudd after his affair with South African model and journalist Nicola 'The Blonde' Formby, over a decade his junior. , who famously bit a bat's head off on stage believing it was a rubber toy, later stipulated what he wanted on his gravestone: 'Bats taste like sh*t.'

Ed Miliband's ‘eye-watering' wind subsidy increase to hit energy bills
Ed Miliband's ‘eye-watering' wind subsidy increase to hit energy bills

Telegraph

time5 minutes ago

  • Telegraph

Ed Miliband's ‘eye-watering' wind subsidy increase to hit energy bills

Ed Miliband will ramp up 'eye-watering' subsidies for offshore wind farms to tempt developers to build in UK waters – adding costs to household bills. Under the revised scheme, Mr Miliband will offer international developers up to £116 per megawatt hour for the power they generate from the farms – far above the wholesale price of power, which last year averaged around £72. The extra money will be added to power bills via a levy, inflating costs for households, industry and businesses. The levy adds an estimated £24 a year to the average domestic power bill via a system known as contracts for difference. The sum was already expected to rise as the number of offshore and onshore wind farms expands and more solar plants are built. The higher prices will accelerate that increase. The subsidies will also inflate costs for UK industry and business, which already face some of the world's highest energy costs. The move comes as Mr Miliband faces a growing struggle to fulfil his pledge to decarbonise the UK power grid by 2030. He is also facing increasing political challenges, with Nigel Farage's Reform UK warning it would scrap new offshore wind contracts if it wins power. A report published by the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (DESNZ) said the sharply increased prices were essential to overcome rising costs faced by offshore developers. 'Renewable technologies continue to face macroeconomic uncertainty and supply chain constraints – this is particularly true for wind technologies. 'The Government is continuing with the strategy of setting strike prices meaningfully above expected [electricity market] clearing prices.' Claire Coutinho, the shadow energy secretary, said: 'These are eye-watering prices – the highest in a decade and way above the average cost of electricity last year. 'And this is before the hidden extra costs of grid, storage and wasted wind – all of which end up on our energy bills. 'Ed Miliband can't cut bills by £300 like he promised because he will always put his net zero zealotry above the economy and the cost of living. Cheap energy must come first.' The price rise for wind developers follows the disastrous cancellation of key wind farm projects seen as essential for the UK to meet its renewables and decarbonisation targets. The massive Hornsea 4 wind farm was cancelled by Ørsted earlier this year, arguing it could never be profitable. Hornsea had a capacity of 2.4 gigawatts (GW) – one of the largest yet planned but the company said the £85 per megawatt hour subsidy on offer from the Government was too low. Another project, Norfolk Boreas, was also cancelled by developers Vattenfall due to low prices. 'Definition of insanity' If Mr Miliband wants to meet his targets he must triple offshore wind to about 50GW by 2030, double onshore wind to 30GW and nearly triple solar power to 47GW. But the rising cost of borrowing for renewable developments plus inflation across the industry is putting all such targets in jeopardy. Ashley Kelty, from Panmure Liberum, said the cancellation of such major projects had spooked Mr Miliband into offering ever higher prices – but he predicted it would not work. 'It's lunacy to think it could meet his targets. Supply chain constraints and rising costs means the build-out will be even slower. 'These high prices will also drive up bills. Renewables are not cheap by any metric. The gas needed to supply stable baseload will have to be imported at high cost – which is also passed through to consumers. This is the clear definition of insanity.' A DESNZ spokesman said the newly published 'strike prices' were the maximum that might be paid and the auction – when developers offered their own prices – could see lower final prices. 'Our recent reforms will ... secure the best possible price for consumers while securing the clean energy we need to get us off the fossil fuel roller-coaster,' he said. Richard Tice, Reform's energy spokesman, said: 'With inflation these offshore wind prices mean a 15pc increase on last year. 'They are also well over double the forecast six months ago by the climate change committee. The cost of getting to net zero will be much higher than even my worst fears. Reform will stop this negligent madness by scrapping net stupid zero.' Kathryn Porter, an energy analyst, said: '[Mr Miliband] keeps insisting that renewables are cheap. After 35 years of subsidies, offshore wind is now massively more expensive than using gas to generate electricity. 'This is definitive proof that renewables are not cheap, and will not lower bills. If the auction clears anywhere near these maximum levels consumers will be facing 20 years of huge additional levies loaded onto their bills.'

Epping asylum hotel protesters ‘upset for legitimate reasons', minister says
Epping asylum hotel protesters ‘upset for legitimate reasons', minister says

The Guardian

time5 minutes ago

  • The Guardian

Epping asylum hotel protesters ‘upset for legitimate reasons', minister says

Protesters outside a hotel housing asylum seekers in Epping are 'upset for legitimate reasons', a cabinet minister has said, as police brace for further unrest over the coming days. Jonathan Reynolds, the business and trade secretary, said there was 'huge frustration that is shared by the government' about the asylum system and the pressures it created on housing. Police have issued a dispersal order at Epping following a series of demonstrations outside the Bell hotel, which broke out after an Ethiopian asylum seeker who had recently arrived on a small boat was charged with sexual assault against a local girl. Hundreds of people, many of them local residents, have been participating in the protests. Far-right activists have become involved in promoting them online and have been present, in some cases clashing with police. Police officers are braced for further protests on Thursday evening and over the weekend. Asked whether he was worried about the unrest spreading, Reynolds told Sky News the government, police and other enforcement agencies were 'prepared for all situations'. 'I think what we've got to talk about is: why are people unhappy with, say, the asylum system? Are they reasonable? Are they upset for legitimate reasons? Yes, we share those as a government,' he said. 'That is why we are sorting it out. 'And I understand the frustrations people have, but ultimately, you solve those frustrations and solve the problem by fixing and getting a grip of the core issue, which is what we're doing.' Reynolds said the number of hotels being used to house asylum seekers in the UK had halved from 400 to about 200. Speaking to BBC Radio 4's Today programme, Reynolds said there was 'frustration, huge frustration, that is shared by the government, I think what people felt under the last government was that it was completely out of control'. 'There is clearly more to do but that came from an asylum system where there wasn't a proper grip of it ... We are starting to change that, the number of claims is up, the number of deportations is up, there are fewer asylum hotels.' Reynolds said 'the solution is not putting people in different forms of accommodation, it's about having a system where if people shouldn't be in the UK, they have to leave the UK.' He added that voters were unhappy about the way net migration had continued to rise after Brexit and felt 'that was not the deal that they voted for', saying: 'You can be pro-talent and people coming to the UK and also say there's got to be control, there's got to be limits.' Tiff Lynch, the chair of the Police Federation, which represents rank-and-file officers, warned police could be diverted from neighbourhood duties to keep the peace at protests if the unrest spread over the summer. In an article for the Daily Telegraph, Lynch said the protests in Epping were a 'signal flare' for more and that police officers were being 'pulled in every direction'. 'It is dangerous to assume that they can continue to hold the line indefinitely, without the support they need or the recognition they deserve,' she wrote. Essex police have issued a dispersal order in Epping that is in force from 2pm on Thursday until 8am on Friday. It gives officers the power to tell anyone suspected of committing or planning antisocial behaviour to leave the area or face arrest.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store