logo
Beyond subsidies: How India's EV sector can achieve long-term success

Beyond subsidies: How India's EV sector can achieve long-term success

Time of India16-05-2025

Imagine a toddler learning to ride a bike. For a while, training wheels provide necessary support, preventing tumbles and building confidence. But eventually, those wheels must come off to achieve true balance and speed. India's EV market, long bolstered by subsidies, now faces a similar moment of truth.
The launch of the Faster Adoption and Manufacturing of Hybrid and
Electric Vehicles
(FAME) scheme a decade ago marked a pivotal moment in India's journey towards electrifying transportation. The government's demand side subsidies played a crucial role in propelling EV sales, with penetration rising from below 1% in 2015 to 7.5% in 2024. The ambitious target of achieving 30% EV penetration by 2030 seems within reach, with projections of 2 million EV sales by FY 2025. However, as this milestone nears, it's worth questioning whether continuing subsidies is the best way forward.
The hidden costs of subsidies: Distorting the market and stifling innovation
While subsidies have undeniably provided the EV sector with a vital initial boost, long-term dependence on them carries significant hidden costs. Over time, subsidies distort the market by undermining competition and stifling innovation. When manufacturers know their products are propped up by government support rather than market forces, the incentive to innovate, reduce costs, or improve efficiency diminishes. The goal should not be to make electric vehicles more affordable through perpetual financial aid, but through technological breakthroughs that drive innovation and lower costs sustainably.
The real risk is the creation of a "subsidy trap". Over time, both consumers and businesses grow accustomed to these financial incentives, making it harder to remove subsidies when needed. Moreover, this reliance on subsidies breeds complacency, slowing the growth of the EV sector and limiting its ability to adapt to changing market demands. This dependency ultimately hinders the sector's potential to compete on its own merits.
The government's stance: EVs are ready to stand alone
The Indian government itself recognises that this dependency is unsustainable. As recently stated by the Minister of Commerce and Industry, Piyush Goyal, the government aims to phase out purchase subsidies after March 2026, urging the industry to become self-sufficient. Though this has raised concerns among stakeholders, it is a necessary shift towards building a sustainable, market-driven EV ecosystem.
The government's position is clear: The EV sector in India is ready to fly without the wings of subsidies. Existing incentives and policies have successfully provided the necessary initial momentum. The next phase of growth must be driven by the sector itself, aligning with a global trend where many advanced economies are reducing subsidies as their EV industries mature.
Beyond subsidies: A smarter, sustainable approach to EV Promotion
So, what is the alternative? The solution lies in creating a level playing field where EVs can compete fairly with traditional internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles.
Firstly, instead of direct purchase subsidies, the government should focus on incentivizing domestic manufacturing of EVs, batteries, and charging infrastructure. The
PM E-Drive Yojna
is a great step to accelerate
EV adoption
and build nationwide charging infrastructure. The PLI scheme further strengthens the sector and boosts domestic manufacturing. These initiatives would make Indian EVs more competitive globally and align with the 'Make in India' campaign, positioning India as a leader in EV manufacturing.
Secondly, the government should promote innovation through tax incentives for research and development (R&D), encouraging new technologies and improving safety standards. This would transition the focus from financial aid to building a sustainable, self-reliant ecosystem that fosters long-term growth.
Thirdly, to make EVs more affordable for Indian buyers, the government must focus on bringing parity among various competing technologies. Battery as a service (Baas) is one such solution. By separating the battery from the vehicle - which accounts for 40-50% of an EV's total cost— battery swapping can significantly lower upfront costs of EVs. Additionally, the process of battery swapping cuts downtime by enabling quick replacement of depleted batteries with fully charged ones in under five minutes, making it beneficial for commercial vehicles that cannot afford long charging times.
However, despite its clear benefits, battery swapping has not received a level playing field compared to traditional fixed charging. EV drivers, many of whom come from lower economic backgrounds, face an 18% GST when replacing batteries, which adds a significant financial burden on them. The high GST on standalone battery purchases—18%—compared to the 5% GST on batteries sold as part of an EV, creates a major discrepancy. This not only burdens users financially, but also hampers the growth of battery swapping services and overall EV adoption.
A bold step toward a sustainable future
Phasing out subsidies is not an abandonment but a necessary step toward a competitive and innovative EV industry. Gradually removing financial support will push manufacturers to innovate, optimize, and compete without subsidies. As India prepares for a subsidy-free future, embracing self-sufficiency will allow the EV sector to grow into a globally competitive force.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Setback for India: Jairam Ramesh after US general praises Pakistan's terror fight
Setback for India: Jairam Ramesh after US general praises Pakistan's terror fight

India Today

time27 minutes ago

  • India Today

Setback for India: Jairam Ramesh after US general praises Pakistan's terror fight

Congress leader Jairam Ramesh questioned the Indian government on Wednesday over recent remarks by a top United States military official praising Pakistan's counter-terrorism efforts. Taking to X, Ramesh wrote, 'Recently, the head of the US Central Command called Pakistan a 'great partner in the counter-terrorism campaign'. What will our Prime Minister and his ovation say to this? Is this not a diplomatic setback for India?'advertisementHis statement followed US Central Command chief General Michael Kurilla's testimony before the House Armed Services Committee, where the outgoing commander described Pakistan as a 'phenomenal partner' in counter-terrorism comments came at a time when India had been actively campaigning to expose Pakistan's support for cross-border terrorism, particularly after the deadly terror attack in Jammu and Kashmir's Pahalgam in April. During the hearing, General Kurilla urged Washington not to adopt a zero-sum approach in South Asia, stating that the US must maintain strategic relations with both India and Pakistan."We need to have a relationship with Pakistan and with India. I do not believe it is a binary switch that we can't have one with Pakistan if we have a relationship with India,' he said. 'We should look at the merits of the relationship for the positives that it has.'advertisementKurilla's remarks came even as India stepped up diplomatic efforts to hold Pakistan accountable for its alleged role in the Pahalgam attack, which killed 26 people on April 22. In response, India carried out precision air strikes on terror infrastructure across the border in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir on May military escalation ended on May 10 after the Directors General of Military Operations from both countries reached an officials, including External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar, had reiterated that India would not accept any equivalence between victims of terrorism and the perpetrators. New Delhi also expressed concern over multiple international responses that appeared to hyphenate India and Pakistan during the brief military Kurilla, who is expected to retire later this summer, also spoke about Pakistan's role in combatting the Islamic State's regional affiliate, ISIS-Khorasan, also known as IS-KP. He acknowledged efforts by the Pakistani military and army chief General Asim Munir in countering the terror Watch

Centre reduces basic custom duty on major imported crude edible oils from 20% to 10%
Centre reduces basic custom duty on major imported crude edible oils from 20% to 10%

India Gazette

timean hour ago

  • India Gazette

Centre reduces basic custom duty on major imported crude edible oils from 20% to 10%

New Delhi [India], June 11 (ANI): The central government on Wednesday reduced Basic Custom duty (BCD) on major imported crude edible oils from 20 per cent to 10 per cent. The Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution said in a release that the Centre has reduced the Basic Customs Duty on crude edible oils - crude sunflower, soybean, and palm oils - has been reduced from 20% to 10% resulting in the import duty differential between crude and refined edible oils from 8.75% to 19.25%. This adjustment aims to address the escalating edible oil prices resulting from the September 2024 duty hike and concurrent increases in international market prices. An advisory has been issued to edible oil associations and industry stakeholders to ensure that the full benefit of the reduced duty is passed on to consumers, the release said. It said 19.25 % duty differential between crude and refined oils will help to encourage domestic refining capacity utilization and reduce imports of refined oils. By lowering the import duty on crude oils, the government aims to reduce the landed cost and retail prices of edible oils, providing relief to consumers and helping to cool overall inflation. The reduced duty will also encourage domestic refining and maintain fair compensation for farmers. The revised duty structure will discourage the import of refined palmolein and redirect demand towards crude edible oils especially crude palm oil, thereby strengthening and revitalizing the domestic refining sector. 'This significant policy intervention not only ensures a level playing field for domestic refiners but also contributes to the stabilization of edible oil prices for Indian consumers,' a release said. A meeting with leading Edible Oil Industry Associations and industry was held under the Chairmanship of Secretary, Department of Food and Public Distribution, and advisory was issued to them to pass on the benefits from this duty reduction on to consumers. Industry stakeholders are expected to adjust the Price to Distributors (PTD) and the Maximum Retail Price (MRP) in accordance with the lower landed costs with immediate effect. The Associations have been requested to advise their members to implement immediate price reductions and share the updated brand-wise MRP sheets with the Department on a weekly basis. DFPD shared the format with edible oil industry for sharing the reduced MRP and PTD data. 'The timely transmission of this benefit to the supply chain is imperative to ensure that consumers experience a corresponding decrease in retail prices,' the release said. This decision comes after a detailed review of the sharp rise in edible oil prices following last year's duty hike. The increase led to significant inflationary pressure on consumers, with retail edible oil prices soaring and contributing to rising food inflation. (ANI)

Lt General BKGM Lasantha Rodrigo, Commander of Sri Lanka Army reaches India
Lt General BKGM Lasantha Rodrigo, Commander of Sri Lanka Army reaches India

India Gazette

timean hour ago

  • India Gazette

Lt General BKGM Lasantha Rodrigo, Commander of Sri Lanka Army reaches India

New Delhi [India], June 12 (ANI): Lieutenant General BKGM Lasantha Rodrigo, Commander of the Sri Lankan Army, is officially visiting India from 11th to 14th June 2025. This visit is set to enhance bilateral military cooperation and explore new avenues for collaboration, particularly in the areas of training and capability enhancement, said a statement from Ministry of Defence on Wednesday. It underscores the continued efforts of both nations to further strengthen and deepen their longstanding defence partnership. The first day of the visit began with a solemn wreath-laying ceremony at the National War Memorial in New Delhi. Lieutenant General BKGM Lasantha Rodrigo paid tribute to the brave soldiers who made the ultimate sacrifice in service to the nation. Following the wreath-laying, Lieutenant General BKGM Lasantha Rodrigo was given a formal Guard of Honour in the South Block Lawns. The ceremonial event, attended by senior officials of the Indian Army, marked a significant gesture of respect and a symbol of the enduring friendship between the two nations. The Guard of Honour was followed by a series of high-level meetings beginning with an in-depth interaction with Lieutenant General NS Raja Subramani, Vice Chief of the Army Staff of the Indian Army. Both the military leaders discussed wide-ranging issues, including aspects of bilateral defence cooperation and regional security concerns. Later, Lieutenant General BKGM Lasantha Rodrigo was briefed on Operation Sindoor and India's security perspective. He was also briefed by other senior officers of the Indian Army on matters of mutual interest. Lieutenant General BKGM Lasantha Rodrigo thereafter met Admiral Dinesh K Tripathi, Chief of the Naval Staff, Air Chief Marshal Amar Preet Singh, Chief of Air Staff and Rajesh Kumar Singh, Defence Secretary. These meetings provided an opportunity for the exchange of views on broader defence and security issues, focusing on matters of mutual interest. Lieutenant General BKGM Lasantha Rodrigo also planted a tree at the Manekshaw Centre, symbolising the time-tested relationship of the Indian and Sri Lankan Armies. On 12th June 2025, Lieutenant General BKGM Lasantha Rodrigo is scheduled to visit Jaipur and meet Lieutenant General Manjinder Singh, General Officer Commanding-in-Chief, South Western Command. The General Officer will grace the Passing Out Parade at the Indian Military Academy (IMA), Dehradun, as the Reviewing Officer on 14th June 2025. This visit will mark a poignant return to his alma mater, where he was commissioned in December 1990, with the 87th Course of the IMA- an experience that laid the foundation of his illustrious military career. His presence at the Academy will rekindle memories of his formative years, now brought full circle as he would review a new generation of officers. Adding a personal and emotional dimension to the ceremony, Brigadier RMSP Rathnayake of Sri Lanka Army, will also be in attendance to witness his son, Foreign Officer Cadet RMNL Rathnayake, being commissioned with the current course. This confluence of legacy and leadership underscores the enduring spirit of camaraderie and leadership connect between the two Armies. Lieutenant General BKGM Lasantha Rodrigo's visit to India is marked by a series of productive engagements, aimed at furthering the defence relationship between Sri Lanka and India. The visit not only highlights the commitment of both nations to strengthening their military ties but also underscores their shared focus on regional security and peace. (ANI)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store