Broadcast error fuels Philippine poll fraud claims
"God Comelec! It's Atty.Vic's name but Bam's face?" reads a Facebook post shared May 13, 2025, referring to candidate Vic Rodriguez and newly elected Senator Bam Aquino.
"Did you swap their votes? You panicked while switching votes so you made this mistake?"
The post includes a news graphic titled: "Bilang Pilipino 2025 Senatorial Race". It depicts votes received by six Senate bets.
However, the pictures and names do not match. The candidate ranked first, for example, has incumbent Senator Christopher Go's photo but is labelled Willie Revillame.
Similar posts rocketed across Facebook and TikTok a day after the archipelago nation's mid-term vote, which was largely defined by the explosive feud between President Ferdinand Marcos and impeached Vice President Sara Duterte (archived link).
The dozen senators chosen nationally will form half the jury in Duterte's July trial that could see her permanently barred from public office (archived link).
Comments on the posts indicate some people believed the graphic was proof Comelec rigged the votes.
"Comelec's deception busted," one reads.
Another says "Garcia must be held accountable," referring to poll body chairman George Garcia.
A keyword search on Google for "Bilang Pilipino 2025" found the faulty graphic in News5's live election night broadcast on Facebook (archived link).
AFP reviewed the original segment before it was edited out of the larger live stream. According to the anchors, the graphic showed unofficial results, with 58.89 percent of votes transmitted.
Local media ABS-CBN and GMA News also aired the results around the same time. The top six candidates and their corresponding votes are consistent with the pictures and tallies in News5's graphic (archived here and here).
News5 has since apologised for the name mix-up, which it attributed to a "graphics error".
"For a few seconds at around 9:15 p.m., we showed a tally of the partial, unofficial results for the senatorial contest that had the correct ranking and photos of candidates. The names, however, did not match," the broadcaster said in a Facebook statement published May 15 (archived link).
"Measures will be taken so that this does not happen again."
AFP has debunked more election-related misinformation in the Philippines here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
an hour ago
- CBS News
New Jersey Democratic gubernatorial primary candidate who most focused on local issues has best chance to win, pundit says
The race to become the next governor of New Jersey heated up on Tuesday as voters hit the polls for the major parties' respective primaries. With Democratic Gov. Phil Murphy term-limited, six Democrats and five Republicans are now vying for the state's top job in a race that could shape the future of the Garden State. As of June 1, more than 6.5 million New Jerseyans were registered to vote, setting the stage for a high-stakes election year. According to the New Jersey Division of Elections, more than 500,000 votes have already been cast, including mail-in voting. Turnout is always a huge factor in primary battles and it's possible a crowded field could mean a winner takes as little as 20% of the vote and the candidates have to decide how manage the political divide. The Democratic candidates The candidates in the Democratic field are Newark Mayor Ras Baraka, Jersey City Mayor Steven Fulop, Reps. Josh Gottheimer and Mikie Sherrill, Sean Spiller, the head of New Jersey Education Association, the state's largest teacher's union, and former State Senate President Steve Sweeney. Sherill voted Tuesday morning in Montclair, Baraka voted in Newark, Fulop cast his ballot in Jersey City, and Gottheimer cast his in Tenafly. "I did my first train station at 7 a.m. today, hit bunch of diners. Great energy," Gottheimer said of the reception he received. Dislike of President Trump vs. pocketbook issues Matthew Hale, associate professor and the MPA Program Chair for the Department of Political Science and Public Affairs at Seton Hall University, said the makeup of Democratic voters in New Jersey is more toward the center. "Democrats in New Jersey are centrist. Republicans are for the most [part] in New Jersey, they like things in the middle. You can do whatever you want as long as your yard is clean and as long as you take care of your neighbor, take care of your hometown," Hale said. The Democratic candidates have each tried to top each other in their opposition to Donald Trump, and the president has in many ways defined the race, but political experts say while national issues like immigration will be a factor, voters will likely take the local approach. "All of [the candidates] think that Donald Trump is the worst thing that has ever happened to America, so they are all gonna fight over that," Hale said. "I think pocketbook issues are really important. I think clearly Trump is gonna be part of the story and people are gonna say this one hates Trump, this one loves Trump, but give me my tax break, and how do I get that?" Hale said. Hale said the candidates know they cannot make their message only about the president. "It's just a question of, what are the other things that you're going to be talking about? Are you going to be talking about taxes? Are going to be talking about affordability? You're talking about lowering the cost of living in New Jersey?" Hale said. Voters say they want their issues addressed Voters turned out Tuesday in the hopes of making a difference. "Crime reduction, trauma-informed care. It's important to build up the morale of the community," one woman said. "Economic development is one of the top priorities on my mind," a man said. "I wanted to make sure I voted so that my community is represented by somebody who is looking out for the single moms, is looking out for the elderly, is making sure everybody is being presented and helped in the community," another woman said. The actual ballot is different this year. The so-called "county-line" ballot, which gave party favorites prominent ballot spots, is gone, giving challengers a greater chance. "The county line, we have competitive races. That's the biggest effect. I do think down the line, in the future, there could be a lot of effect. We're going to see candidates at the Assembly level, the Senate level, who are more partisan, because we don't have the county line anymore," Hale said.
Wall Street Journal
2 hours ago
- Wall Street Journal
Ukraine's Drone Attack Points to a U.S. Vulnerability
Imagine this: Beijing launches a surprise invasion of Taiwan. As U.S. forces mobilize to respond, something far worse unfolds here at home. Sleeper agents—Chinese operatives who entered the U.S. months or years earlier—activate. In basements and garages across the country, they've been quietly assembling first-person-view drones from commercially available parts for a few hundred dollars each.
CBS News
2 hours ago
- CBS News
How Burlington County prepared for New Jersey primary election – new voting equipment, more locations
Tuesday is primary day in New Jersey, and many voters walked inside the Hainesport Municipal Building in Burlington County to cast their ballots Tuesday. For many, it was only a matter of minutes until they were back outside heading to their cars in the parking lot. The race with the most attention is the Democratic and Republican primary for governor. "It was just a piece of cake, just walk right in," Terry Horner said. "It was very quick, in and out," James Cosby said. "Now, it was easy peasy, they seemed to have solved a lot of the issues," Ted Costa said. This is a primary and not a presidential year or a general election, so turnout is expected to be much lower than the last election in November. READ MORE: Where do you vote for New Jersey's 2025 primary election? Find your polling location Costa said as he waited to cast his ballot for President Trump in November, he had to wait four hours before he was able to vote. Chopper 3 captured the crowds of voters stuck in line for hours in Burlington County seven months ago. From Hainesport to Medford and Evesham, voters complained about technical issues and not enough machines. CBS News Philadelphia New Jersey's attorney general also successfully sued to extend the deadline and add an extra hour of voting in Burlington County. "By the time we got in and we thought this isn't so bad, well you had to go all the way down to the back of the building then go all the way back, it was just crazy," Horner recalled. County leaders called the chaos "unacceptable" and vowed a "top to bottom review" to prevent a similar experience. CBS News Philadelphia followed up to see if any changes were made. According to a county spokesperson, several improvements have been implemented since November: Two new early voting locations were opened, bringing the county's total up to nine. Additional polling locations were added in some voting districts. New voting equipment, which includes ballot marking devices and tabulators, was purchased. Additional poll worker training was offered, and the superintendent of elections continues to offer voters tutorials on the voting equipment. More information technology workers have been deployed to polling locations to assist with tech issues and reduce response times. Cosby said the changes were obvious and very much needed. "Oh, I think it should have been addressed a long time ago," Cosby said, "but they seem to be doing a pretty good job here."
