Switch 2 ‘Zelda' Dethrones ‘Expedition 33' On Metacritic, Which Doesn't Count
The Nintendo Switch 2's The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom made headlines yesterday when it officially became the highest-scored game on Metacritic of 2025, dethroning Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, probably the most significant GOTY contender to date.
I'm here to say no, that doesn't count.
While this is may be subjective, I'm here to give my position that a re-release that is mainly just a graphical upgrade of an already-existing game does not deserve the actual honor of pretending its 95 is actually a true toppler of Expedition 33's 93. And now, Breath of the Wild has just become tied at 93.
Does Tears of the Kingdom itself deserve its 96 on Metacritic for its initial release? I'd argue that's debatable, but overlooking that, at least it's an actual game release. Tears of the Kingdom's Switch 2 'edition' is not. Nope, sorry.
Also, there's another fact being overlooked here. To get that 95 average for Tears, it's only based on nine reviews. Nine. That's four 10s, a 9.5, three 90s and an 80. That's it. And the tied-for-second Switch 2 Breath of the Wild has 11 reviews.
Most major releases of games will end up anywhere from 50-150 scored reviews, and in this case, that very much includes Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, which has 84 reviews averaged for its second-best 93 metascore (not to mention it's wildly high 9.7 user score based on 16,000 ratings).
FEATURED | Frase ByForbes™
Unscramble The Anagram To Reveal The Phrase
Pinpoint By Linkedin
Guess The Category
Queens By Linkedin
Crown Each Region
Crossclimb By Linkedin
Unlock A Trivia Ladder
The current top 10 list for the year is:
I will give smaller indie games a pass on having fewer reviews given the context of their scale, but these Zelda upgrades? Get off this list.
Why do I care so much? Well, I am the number one Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 defender, where that game has probably already become one of my favorites of all time. And I will not have its honor besmirched by an upgrade of a Zelda game that came out two years ago. I normally will dismiss all 'remastered' or reissued games from lists like this, and this is no exception. Remakes are a different story, but no, Expedition 33 is still on top here, I don't care what the list says.
Follow me on Twitter, YouTube, Bluesky and Instagram.
Pick up my sci-fi novels the Herokiller series and The Earthborn Trilogy.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
8 minutes ago
- Forbes
Today's Wordle #1525 Hints And Answer For Friday, August 22nd
It's finally Friday! TGIF. Not only is it the end of the work week, it's also 2XP Friday, meaning competitive Wordle players get to double their points, for good or ill. I hope everyone has a terrific weekend! Let's dive right in. Looking for yesterday's Wordle? Check out hints, clues and the answer right here. Wordle is a daily word puzzle game where your goal is to guess a hidden five-letter word in six tries or fewer. After each guess, the game gives feedback to help you get closer to the answer: FEATURED | Frase ByForbes™ Unscramble The Anagram To Reveal The Phrase Pinpoint By Linkedin Guess The Category Queens By Linkedin Crown Each Region Crossclimb By Linkedin Unlock A Trivia Ladder Use these clues to narrow down your guesses. Every day brings a new word, and everyone around the world is trying to solve the same puzzle. Some Wordlers also play Competitive Wordle against friends, family, the Wordle Bot or even against me, your humble narrator. See rules for Competitive Wordle toward the end of this post. Today's Wordle Hints And Answer Wordle Bot's Starting Word: SLATE My Starting Word Today: BLAME (237 words remaining) The Hint: Shabby. The Clue: This Wordle has a double letter. Okay, spoilers below! The answer is coming! . . . Every day I check Wordle Bot to help analyze my guessing game. You can check your Wordle score with Wordle Bot right here. BLAME wasn't a very good opening guess, leaving me with 237 possible solutions. HOIST was even more unlucky, only slashing that down to 19. Luckily, TARDY—while not the Wordle—left me with just one possible solution: RATTY for the win! Huzzah! Both the Bot and I get 0 points for guessing in four and 0 for tying. 2XP Friday does us no good, since 2x0=0. Our August totals remain: Erik: 8 points Wordle Bot: 15 points "Ratty" comes from rat + the adjective suffix -y. It first appeared in the early 19th century meaning "infested with rats" or "resembling a rat." By the mid-1800s it had taken on figurative senses like "shabby, mean, contemptible," influenced by the negative associations of rats. Later, it also came to mean "bad-tempered or irritable" (20th c.). Be sure to follow me for all your daily puzzle-solving guides, TV show and movie reviews and more here on this blog!
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Tom Brady's Change in Physical Appearance Draws Attention
Tom Brady's Change in Physical Appearance Draws Attention originally appeared on Athlon Sports. Tom Brady may be retired from the NFL, but he continues to garner interest, thanks to his body of work during a legendary career. On Friday, Brady drew the attention of fans once again after the NFL posted headshots throughout his incredible career. TB12 played 23 seasons in the pros, 20 with the New England Patriots and his final three years with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Brady, who was selected 199th overall by the Patriots in the 2000 NFL Draft, underwent plenty of physical changes (and hairstyles) throughout his time in the league — having arrived as a 22-year-old and playing his final campaign as a 45-year-old. "Before the rings, during the rings, after the rings," the NFL wrote in the caption of its post, which featured 13 headshots of Brady. Fans took notice of Brady's change in physical appearance through the years, with many noting how he aged well. "This man aged backwards because why does he look so much better in the later years than the younger years," a commenter wrote. Another one said, "bro aged hella well." "man he has the best facials," a fan added. "Nah this man got cloned every year," a supporter remarked. A follower stated, "Bro casually got hotter." "He lost weight around his face and jawline," a social media user noticed. A seventh poster joked, "This is a different person every year." Several fans called out the NFL for not including Brady's long-hair era, which came midway through his career. The seven-time Super Bowl champion's decision is still questioned by many story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jul 26, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
32 minutes ago
- Yahoo
NFL Legend Tom Brady's Preseason Game Outfit is Making Headlines
NFL Legend Tom Brady's Preseason Game Outfit is Making Headlines originally appeared on Athlon Sports. After spending 20 years with the New England Patriots and his final three years in the NFL with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Tom Brady has since retired and moved on to a different role: being a minority team owner for a franchise. Brady became a minority owner of the Las Vegas Raiders after his purchase of a minority stake in the team was approved back in October 2024. According to a report by the Bucs, Brady took approximately a 5% stake in the franchise. Now, amid his busy schedule handling his various businesses and commitments, Brady is in full owner mode. On Saturday, the seven-time Super Bowl champion even made an appearance for the Raiders' preseason game against the San Francisco 49ers. As he arrived at Allegiant Stadium, however, what stood out was his look. Brady entered the stadium wearing a black-and-white Raiders varsity jacket, which grabbed attention for a variety of reasons. Many still can't believe that he's now with the Raiders, considering his iconic careers with the Patriots and Buccaneers. Furthermore, Brady used to dominate the Raiders during his time playing in the NFL. TB12 is 5-1 against the franchise throughout his career. "That just doesn't look right," a commenter wrote. Another one echoed a similar sentiment, writing, "So weird seeing Brady wear Raiders apparel….. I know he's a part owner now just saying it feels weird." "This don't look right," a fan added. A supporter shared, "Raiders Owner since 2002." "The fact that Brady's legacy started against the Raiders, and now he's owning it makes him even more the goat hahah," a follower remarked. A sixth social media user stated, "That jacket is tuff fr." Brady Has Some NFL Restrictions Because of His Raiders Ownership Brady's ownership of the Raiders comes with plenty of challenges. For one, the NFL placed restrictions on his broadcasting work because of his stake in the Las Vegas team, as he is "not permitted to attend in-person or online broadcast production meetings and may not have access to team facilities, players or coaches." Regardless, Brady seems to be enjoying his Raiders ownership and making the most of story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Aug 17, 2025, where it first appeared.
