Trump Can Keep Using Troops in LA for Now, Appeals Court Says
President Donald Trump can continue to use National Guard troops to respond to protests in Los Angeles as a legal challenge over his use of the military proceeds, a federal appeals court ruled.
In a win for the White House, a three-judge panel in San Francisco on Thursday said the Trump administration can keep using California National Guard troops to respond to the situation. In effect, it doesn't change the situation on the ground in Los Angeles, where the federal government has been deploying the military for more than a week.
Thursday's decision isn't the final ruling on the matter and is likely to be immediately challenged. California could appeal the ruling to the US Supreme Court, or a bigger panel in the same appeals court. The lower court that had ordered the federal government to return control of the troops to the state will also hold a hearing on Friday.
California and the Trump administration have been sparring over the federal government's response to the protests, including the deployment of thousands of the state's National Guard troops and hundreds of Marines.
California and its Democratic governor, Gavin Newsom, have blasted Trump's deployment as a 'power grab' and an unnecessary intrusion on the work of local officials to police the protests. Lawyers for the state also have said it's 'terrifying' that Justice Department lawyers said the presidents actions can't be second-guessed by the courts, and argue that the deployment sets a dangerous precedent.
The Trump administration has maintained that the president has the power to unilaterally federalize National Guard troops when he determines there is a 'rebellion' or 'invasion' that necessitates military intervention. And presidents are permitted to call up the state troops when 'regular forces' are unable to enforce federal law.
The appeals court judges said Trump likely acted lawfully when he federalized the National Guard, but they objected to arguments raised by Justice Department lawyers that his decision cannot be reviewed by the courts.
'We conclude that it is likely that the President lawfully exercised his statutory authority,' the appeals court said in a unanimous ruling late Thursday.
The judges also stressed that the decision is limited to whether Trump was allowed to call for the deployment, but does not address 'the nature of the activities in which the federalized National Guard may engage.'
The appeals court panel, which heard arguments Tuesday by lawyers from both the Justice Department and California, is comprised of two judges appointed by Trump and one by former President Joe Biden. The court stepped in last week at the administration's request to pauses US District Judge Charles Breyer's order declaring that Trump's deployment without California's consent was 'illegal.'
Trump issued a proclamation authorizing their deployment on June 7 and said protests in the city against his deportation initiative represent a form of 'rebellion' against the authority of the federal government. In court filings, lawyers for the administration cited reports of violence and threats against federal property and officers conducting immigration enforcement.
Breyer said in his June 12 ruling he was troubled by the idea that a protest against the federal government on its own could 'justify a finding of rebellion.'
The case is Newsom v. Trump, 25-3727, US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit .
This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Print
15 minutes ago
- The Print
Trump can't end wars. He's more interested in commercial deals
The fate of this meeting was always hanging by a thread. US President Donald Trump had announced well before the talks that Iran would not be allowed to have nuclear weapons. At the same time, the US was preparing a hurried evacuation of its embassy in Iraq and had allowed its military dependents to leave locations around the Middle East due to 'heightened security risks'. When Oman's foreign affairs minister Badr Albusaidi announced the sixth round of US-Iran nuclear talks in Muscat on 12 June, he would have had an inkling of the events that would follow. Two days later, he declared that the meeting had been called off. Wading into war Far from staying out of the Israel-Iran war, the US has waded deep into it by laying down conditions that are unacceptable not only to Tehran but also to several other regional and middle powers. A nuclear-armed Shia-dominated Iran is certainly not favoured by the Sunni-dominated Arab world, which incidentally is tied in uneasy knots with Israel through the Abraham Accords. However, Arab states, which once considered Israel a potential ally in their contestations against Iran, are now sceptical about US-Israel objectives. Soon after the Israeli attacks, the UAE waived visa fines for overstaying Iranian citizens, and the Gulf states condemned Israel's unprovoked attack on Iran. The Arab states are well aware of the camaraderie between the US and Israel, and their deep sense of solidarity in combating Iran's nuclear programme. It is no secret that the two powers jointly seek a regime change in Iran, which will herald the beginning of a new state with a pliant, pro-US head of state in Tehran. Due to the total trust deficit between the US and Iran, war is now Trump's only path to achieve this objective. On Thursday, however, officials from the two countries are reported to have held a rare telephonic conversation to find a diplomatic solution as Israel's attacks intensify. Trump had a window of opportunity to continue US-Iran talks and offer a better alternative to war. It is unlikely he was not aware of Israel's war preparedness. By bringing Iran to the negotiating table in Muscat as scheduled, Trump could have bargained for time and sent a message to Israel about whose decision would prevail on regime change in Tehran. Now, driven to the wall, a desperate Iran may consider attacking US bases and military installations in the region. It may even target American and Israeli personnel anywhere in the world, thereby forcing Washington to respond with deterrence or counterattacks as a security measure. Far from stopping the war, Trump finds himself drawn even deeper into it. Iran may also block the Strait of Hormuz, a lifeline for an energy–starved Europe, already deprived of Russian oil and gas. Since its cyber attack on Saudi Arabia's oil installations in 2012, Iran has sharpened its capabilities through short and medium-range and surface-to-surface missiles. These can be used to target oil infrastructure platforms, pipelines, commercial vessels, navigation and radar equipment, and ports in the region. Can Trump's America sit back and leave Europe to its fate in the Gulf, as it tried doing in the Russia-Ukraine conflict? Also read: What India must learn from Israel's air strikes on Iran — clarity, speed, precision Trump's promises Israel's objective of dismantling Iran's nuclear capabilities will be incomplete until the Fordow Fuel Enrichment Plant, spread over 54,000 square feet and buried deep under a mountain near Qom, is totally destroyed. This can be done only by the GBU-57A, a 30,000-pound precision-guided 'bunker buster' bomb, mounted on a US B-2 bomber. It is only a matter of time before Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu compels Trump to use the ultimate weapon, which will force Iran to surrender and facilitate a regime change. Such an intervention, which can be authorised only by the President of the United States, will probably please Israel, but not before seriously eroding Trump's credibility as one who will 'end wars'. His resolve to end wars and not get involved in the kind of battles America fought in Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan will evaporate into thin air. Trump's path to power was paved with promises of 'making America great again' and ending wars around the world. In fact, the Russia-Ukraine and Israel-Hamas conflicts were the only major ongoing wars during his campaign. 'I'm not going to start a war, I'm going to stop the wars,' Trump said, addressing his supporters immediately after winning the second term. In his first 100 days in power, his focus was on undoing his predecessor's policies. He wanted to hunt down illegal immigrants and oust them from the US in humiliating handcuffs, streamline federal institutions, and consolidate as many constitutional powers as possible. Recently, the president wondered whether he could appoint himself the head of the Federal Reserve. Trump's resolve to make America great again implies that it has lost its sheen. Assuming that he is right, the American president should know that the country was great for several reasons. It was 'a land of opportunities' and had the ability to keep the dollar powerful as a globally accepted currency for trade settlements. Above all, America was the global superpower that could successfully intervene in conflicts and flashpoints even in a multipolar world, with emerging economies and hegemons contesting its position of eminence. Trump's priority should be to keep America out of wars rather than make feeble attempts to stop them. As of now, he seems to have failed. A US president who is interested in making commercial deals instead of using the country's economic, political, and military muscle to prevent global conflicts cannot end wars. Seshadri Chari is the former editor of 'Organiser'. He tweets @seshadrichari. Views are personal. (Edited by Prasanna Bachchhav)
Indian Express
17 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Iran-Israel War News Live Updates: On conflict day 8, Israel strikes HQ of Iran's key nuclear project site, says military; IEAE confirms damages to Khondab reactor
Iran-Israel War Live News Updates: The Israeli military on Friday said that they attacked multiple facilities in Iran in overnight strikes, including the headquarters of a key nuclear weapons development site. In a statement, the Israeli military said that their targets for overnight strikes included the headquarters of SPND for research and development of nuclear weapons project. The International Atomic Energy Agency has confirmed damages to building at the Khondab Heavy Water Production Plant including its distillation unit, a day after stating that no damages were 'initially visible' Casualty count: In fresh strikes, Iranian missiles targeted a hospital and residential structures in Tel Aviv, wounding over 200 people on Thursday night. According to AP, Israel's air campaign has targeted several nuclear and military sites, killing senior generals and nuclear scientists. A Washington-based Iranian human rights group reported that at least 639 people have been killed in Iran, including 263 civilians, and over 1,300 injured. In retaliation, Iran has launched around 400 missiles and hundreds of drones, killing at least 24 people in Israel and wounding hundreds. Trump's 2-week deadline: After his ominous statement regarding launching strikes against Iran, US President Donald Trump said that he will decide in two weeks whether the US military will directly get involved in the Israel-Iran conflict or not, given the 'substantial chance' for renewed negotiations over Tehran's nuclear program. Earlier, Trump left the G7 summit in Canada a day early as the conflict between the two Middle Eastern countries deepened, but said that his hasty exit from the summit had nothing to do with negotiating a ceasefire between the nations. Live Updates 13:36 (IST) 20 Jun 2025 Israel News LIVE Updates: What we know about Israel's secretive nuclear weapons program Though Israel has never officially confirmed possessing nuclear weapons, experts widely regard it as the Middle East's worst kept secret, reported CNN. 'Israel is unique among nuclear-armed states as it neither confirms nor denies its nuclear capability,' notes the International Institute for Strategic Studies. According to the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI), Israel is one of nine nuclear-armed nations, alongside the US, Russia, China, the UK, France, India, Pakistan, and North Korea. Israel hasn't signed the 1970 Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty and opposes the creation of a WMD-free zone in the Middle East. However, it has ratified the 1963 Limited Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, which bans nuclear tests in the atmosphere and oceans. (With inputs from CNN) 13:18 (IST) 20 Jun 2025 Israel News LIVE Updates: Iran's Red Crescent says five hospitals damaged in Israeli strikes Five hospitals in Iran have been damaged amid Israeli airstrikes, according to Pirhossein Kolivand, head of the Iranian Red Crescent Society. In an interview with state-affiliated IRNA on Friday, Kolivand said the facilities were not directly targeted but suffered damage from nearby blasts — shattering glass and causing breathing issues for patients due to smoke. He added that the incidents would be reported to international prosecutors. Under international humanitarian law, attacks affecting medical facilities are considered violations. (With inputs from CNN) 12:51 (IST) 20 Jun 2025 Iran Israel News LIVE Updates: US, UK hold talks on Iran-Israel conflict US Secretary of State Marco Rubio and UK Foreign Minister David Lammy met in Washington on Thursday to discuss diplomatic efforts to contain the growing crisis. The meeting comes ahead of planned talks between Iran and European powers aimed at reviving nuclear diplomacy and preventing wider escalation. Rubio and Lammy reaffirmed their shared position that Iran must "never develop or acquire a nuclear weapon,' according to a statement from the US State Department. The UK Foreign Office also confirmed that Lammy will meet on Friday in Geneva with the European Union's top diplomat and foreign ministers from France and Germany. The goal is to engage directly with Iran's foreign minister to de-escalate the situation. (With inputs from Reuters) 12:31 (IST) 20 Jun 2025 Iran Israel News LIVE Updates: IAEA says key buildings damaged at Iran's Khondab site The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has information that key buildings at Iran's Khondab heavy water research site were damaged in Israeli strikes, including the distillation unit, it said in an X post on Friday. The information was an update on an assessment from Thursday, in which the IAEA said the reactor has been hit but there were no radiological effects. (Reuters) 12:26 (IST) 20 Jun 2025 Iran Israel News LIVE Updates: Countries evacuating citizens from Iran and Israel Countries around the world are taking measures to evacuate their citizens from Israel and Iran as the two nations enter the seventh day of their air war and airspace in the region remains closed. A week of Israeli air and missile strikes against its major rival has wiped out the top echelon of Iran's military command, damaged its nuclear capabilities and killed hundreds of people, while Iranian retaliatory strikes have killed at least two dozen civilians in Israel. Here are some of the countries whose citizens have left. Australia Austria Bulgaria China Czech Republic France Germany Greece India Italy Japan New Zealand Poland Portugal Serbia Sierra Leone Slovakia South Korea Taiwan United States Vietnam (Reuters) 12:21 (IST) 20 Jun 2025 Iran Israel News LIVE Updates: Iranian not prepared for talks while Israeli attacks continue, says Foreign Ministry Iranian Foreign Minister Araqchi tells State TV, "Iran not prepared for talks with anyone while Israeli attacks continues." (Reuters) 12:17 (IST) 20 Jun 2025 Iran Israel News LIVE Updates: Israeli defence minister warns Hezbollah against joining conflict with Iran Israeli Defence Minister Israel Katz warned Lebanon's Hezbollah to exercise caution on Friday, saying Israel's patience with "terrorists" who threaten it had worn thin. The head of Iran-backed Hezbollah, Naim Qassem, said on Thursday that the Lebanese group would act as it saw fit in the face of what he called "brutal Israeli-American aggression" against Iran. In other statements, the group has made no explicit pledge to join the fighting and a Hezbollah official told Reuters last week that the group did not intend to initiate attacks against Israel.
Hindustan Times
27 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Israel army says it hit weapons research centre in Tehran during overnight strike
Israel's military said Friday it struck dozens of targets in Tehran overnight, including what it called a centre for the "research and development of Iran's nuclear weapons project," in the eighth day of war between the two foes. In a statement, the army said it had "completed a series of strikes in the heart of Tehran: dozens of targets were struck, including military missile production sites and the SPND (Organisation of Defensive Innovation and Research) headquarters for research and development of Iran's nuclear weapons project." According to the Israeli military the SPND headquarters "is used for research and development of advanced technologies and weapons supporting the Iranian regime's military capabilities." The army said that during the night on Thursday more than 60 fighter jets struck dozens of military targets. "Among the targets were sites producing missile components and facilities manufacturing raw materials used in casting missile engines," it added. Israel, claiming that Iran was on the verge of developing a nuclear weapon, launched air strikes against its arch-enemy a week ago, triggering deadly exchanges. European foreign ministers will hold talks Friday with their Iranian counterpart, hoping to reach a diplomatic solution to the war as US President Donald Trump mulls the prospect of US involvement.
