
A former Pilot on Air India crash report: Foreign media are misleading the public. Wait for the final report
The people of India have a right to know the truth about what happened to Air India Flight 171. The anxiety and confusion among the public following the release of the preliminary report a few days ago are, therefore, understandable. However, it is equally important to remember that the Air India crash report is exactly what it claims to be: Preliminary. Its primary purpose is to establish what happened. The why and how will be addressed in the final report, which is typically released about a year after the incident. While the public's demand for answers is entirely justified, patience remains essential.
There is a rush in certain quarters to blame the pilots. Why should it come as a surprise that blame is already being directed at them? Within just two days of the crash, self-proclaimed aviation 'experts' flooded YouTube — some even donning captain's uniforms — offering detailed theories about the crash without any proximity to the site or access to verifiable information. Unsurprisingly, many of these theories centred on pilot error.
Yes, pilots — like doctors, engineers, or any other professional — are human beings and capable of mistakes. In this case, however, foreign media have jumped the gun. Some agencies have highlighted a section of the report that refers to an exchange between the pilots about the 'cut-off'. But this is a normal inquiry by a pilot in a situation where, during take-off, power fails to build, and there is insufficient thrust. Moreover, all pilots are trained that, in the event of a total engine failure, the correct procedure involves switching the engine off and attempting a restart. According to the report, the pilots attempted exactly that and almost succeeded. There was a relight on one engine. However, by that time, the aircraft was at too low an altitude, which led to it crashing into buildings. It was already too late.
The real question is: Why did both engines fail? The Digital Flight Data Recorder (DFDR) should provide those answers. It is entirely possible for engines to fail without pilot intervention. Modern aircraft rely on computers to calculate fuel flow and engine performance. It is not impossible for the system to malfunction — perhaps due to incorrect fuel ratio calculations — leading to engine failure. These systems are built with safeguards, but like any complex software, they are not infallible. Remember the case of ANA Flight NH985 from Tokyo Haneda to Osaka Itami, which suffered dual engine failure upon landing? Western investigative agencies often default to blaming the pilots, and similar stories are likely to emerge in the coming weeks.
There is no doubt that the preliminary Air India crash report could have offered more clarity; for instance, it would have been helpful if the details from the Cockpit Voice Recorder (CVR) had been made public. I have worked extensively with CVRs and DFDRs, and I know that while data retrieval is one task, proper interpretation is quite another. It takes a team of trained specialists to extract meaning: What time thrust was applied, whether the engine spooled up, how much fuel was injected — every detail can be examined. Interpretation, however, takes time. This is why we must be patient and allow the final Air India crash report to tell the full story. In the meantime, we must continue to ask the right questions.
Having worked with both Boeing and Airbus, including with their production test pilots, I can say with confidence that these professionals are deeply committed to safety. That said, no system is perfect. There is always scope for improvement — and yes, for error. But that's no reason to mislead the public. This is precisely why pilot federations are coming out strongly in defence of the crew, not simply out of solidarity, but because the facts are being selectively interpreted to sensationalise and unfairly suggest pilot error. One such federation is reportedly considering legal action against The Wall Street Journal for its coverage of the crash.
When I transitioned from the Air Force to civil aviation, I was shocked to discover that the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) had no aviators on its rolls. There may well be brilliant bureaucrats at the helm, but is it too much to ask for a single technical aviation expert? Similarly, there should be certified Boeing 787 pilots on the investigating team. This is one of the key things the Indian aviation ecosystem must urgently address — ensuring that technical expertise is not sidelined.
The writer is the founder of the Federation of Indian Pilots and a former Air Force and Air India pilot
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

The Hindu
14 hours ago
- The Hindu
Senior Living Conclave 2025 held in Chennai
The Senior Living Conclave 2025, organised by The Hindu Group in collaboration with Ashiana Vatsalya, was held on Sunday. The event focused on the growing demand for structured senior living and the need for inclusive, elder-friendly communities. The conclave brought together over 350 participants, including senior citizens, caregivers and industry experts. Sessions addressed retirement living, wellness, assisted care and home-based elder support. Ankur Gupta, joint managing director, Ashiana Housing Ltd., spoke on continuing care retirement communities (CCRC), fall management systems, emergency care services, and the shift toward ageing with autonomy and dignity. He pointed to Tamil Nadu's growing share of senior living projects, particularly in Coimbatore, Chennai, and Kancheepuram. The event was anchored by Radhashiva Mani, a resident of Ashiana Shubham, who shared her decision to move from Kolkata to Chennai. 'Shubham felt right,' she said. 'It was thoughtfully designed for seniors like us with care, comfort and community.' The panel discussion featured other residents of Ashiana Shubham. Resident Ramakrishnan V.V. and his wife spoke about their move and how they adjusted to the new environment. Resident Shantha Mathew shared how she began her own YouTube channel after settling in. Resident L. Balasubhramanian described participating in cultural events and theatre. Resident Ravindra and his wife spoke about the reassurance their move provided to their family. Tamil Nadu currently has an estimated 18 to 25 senior living projects. Common features include anti-skid flooring, grab bars, emergency call systems and in-house healthcare support. Among other amenities are yoga halls, hobby clubs, walking tracks, dining and housekeeping. A site visit to Ashiana Vatsalya was arranged after the conclave for interested participants.
&w=3840&q=100)

Business Standard
2 days ago
- Business Standard
Air India pays interim compensation to kin of 166 Ahmedabad crash victims
The plane crash, one of the worst air disasters in India in decades, involved a Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner operating as Air India flight AI171 Press Trust of India Mumbai

Mint
2 days ago
- Mint
AI-717 plane crash: Air India disburses interim compensation of ₹25 lakh to 166 families
Almost one and a half month after the tragic plane crash in Ahmedabad, Air India on Saturday said that they have disbursed interim compensation of ₹ 25 lakh each to 166 families affected by the AI-717 crash. Releasing an official press release on the website, Air India said that so far AI released the interim compensation to the families of 147 of the 229 deceased passengers and also the 19 who lost their lives at the accident site. "Air India has, so far, released the interim compensation to the families of 147 of the 229 deceased passengers and also the 19 who lost their lives at the accident site," Air India said in a statement. The airliner added, among other things, that the requisite documents of 52 others have been verified, and the interim compensation to those families will be released progressively. The private airliner, run by Tata Group, said that they stands in solidarity with the families affected by the AI171 accident. "We continue to mourn their loss and remain fully committed to providing support during this difficult time," Air India said. Air India also said Tata Group has also registered 'The AI-171 Memorial and Welfare Trust' which is dedicated to the victims of the tragic accident. It added that Tata Trust pledged an ex gratia payment of ₹ 1 crore in respect of each of the deceased and would support for rebuilding the B.J. Medical College Hostel infrastructure. Air India also mentioned that Tata Trust will provide aid and assistance to alleviate any trauma or distress suffered by the first responders, medical and disaster relief professionals, social workers, and governmental staff who provided invaluable institutional support and service in the aftermath of the accident. Earlier on 12 June, Air India flight AI-717 from Ahmedabad to London's Gatwick crashed moments after taking off from Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport. In the tragic crash, 241 passengers and 19 people on ground were killed.