Family accused of $200 dine-and-dash wins massive libel settlement: ‘Allegations were entirely false'
The bar for justice is high.
A well-off Irish family was awarded nearly $100,000 in damages after being falsely accused of skipping out on the bill at a bar in the UK.
'The allegations were entirely false,' Peter Girvan, the barrister representing the defendants, declared during a court hearing in Belfast on Friday, the Daily Mail reported.
The incident occurred in July 2024 after Peter and Ann McGirr, along with their children Peter Jr. and Carol were blasted over 'shocking behavior' in a deleted Facebook Post by the management at The Horse and Jockey in Tideswell, Derbyshire.
The bosses had reportedly uploaded CCTV footage of the alleged 'dine-and-dashers,' who they accused of leaving without paying their $200 tab, the BBC reported.
The Tyrone residents, who reportedly run a successful engineering firm, had reportedly ordered 10oz ribeye steaks with all the trimmings, two ham steaks and several glasses of ale and lager, per the Daily Mail.
These false allegations were subsequently circulated in at least four different newspaper reports, the court heard.
Outraged over the wrongful accusations, the family sued The Horse and Jockey for libel on the grounds that these claims caused severe embarrasment and reputational damage.
'These articles contained serious and defamatory accusations that the plaintiffs had engaged in dishonest and criminal conduct by deliberately absconding without settling a bill of approximately £150 (around $200),' Girvan declared. 'The plaintiffs had not engaged in any such conduct, and the statements made by the defendants had no factual basis.'
As compensation for the defamatory claims, the bar was forced to pay approximately $99,500 and also foot the bill for the defendants' legal expenses.
Horse and Jockey representatives also accepted that there was 'no basis whatsoever' for the allegations and apologized to the defendants.
In a statement read on the family's behalf outside court, the McGirrs' solicitor said that they had been 'vindicated' by the outcome and were 'very satisfied with the settlement,' the Daily Mail reported.
Following the verdict, the couple's daughter Carol McGirr expressed her relief on Facebook, stating, ''10 months later.. thank god it's all over and our names are cleared.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
43 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Gary man gets 70 years for killing marijuana dealer
A Gary man got 70 years Friday for killing a marijuana dealer. Tyrone Reno, 34, was convicted last month of murder in the Nov. 15, 2021, death of Quintez Johnson, 31, plus a gun enhancement. He faced up to 85 years. Johnson's two kids, aged 8 and 6, were in the apartment when he was shot. At trial, jurors viewed footage of an unmasked man running down a stairwell just after Johnson's death. They returned a guilty verdict after 15 minutes. Reno has said he is innocent and plans to appeal, his lawyer Natalie Williams said in court Friday, asking for a 45-year sentence. During lengthy remarks, Deputy Prosecutor Milana Petersen said Reno killed Johnson over cash and a 'little bit of weed.' She ultimately asked for 75 years. Johnson's mother, emotional on the stand, said her grandson still wouldn't eat spaghetti because it was the last dinner he ate with his dad. She expressed empathy for Reno's family. My son would have helped you, she told Reno. 'I just want to know why,' she said. 'He would have done anything you asked.' Earlier in the hearing, Petersen questioned Detective James Nielsen on videos from Reno's Facebook account. They showed him holding guns, money with rap music playing, or smoking. Williams objected throughout – saying they were posted in 2022 or later. His Facebook account was deactivated around the time of Johnson's death, she said. The lawyer argued there was no proof he was in a gang, a point Judge Salvador Vasquez agreed. Posting videos on Facebook with guns, money or rap music was not proof he lived a violent life. It was a false conjecture, she argued. Gary Police responded that day to an apartment building on the 1300 block of W. 5th Avenue for a homicide. Detectives found a trail of marijuana up the stairs to an open Pringles inside a third-floor apartment. Johnson was lying on the sofa. He had been shot twice in the head. There were no signs of struggle. Security cameras showed a Black man — later identified as Reno — arriving at Johnson's apartment, then fleeing about three minutes later. He had a handgun and a backpack with marijuana. Police believe Johnson was shot around 2 p.m. While a patrolman was writing a report at the Gary Police Station, 555 Polk St., a man who matched the one seen on the video walked by him and a colleague. He was wearing the same clothes, including a Black hoodie with white lining and brown tag. The other officer approached him. Reno gave his name, but he wasn't arrested, since the man in the video wasn't identified yet. Police learned Johnson started selling marijuana a month earlier to help pay his bills. Reno was arrested two years later. Investigators used 'facial recognition software' to help match security footage outside the Gary Police station to the man seen on camera at Johnson's apartment, court filings show. That left some questions on the software's accuracy. State lawmakers recently passed legislation to tighten standards for witness identification on photo lineups. It requires police to tell witnesses a suspect might not be in the lineup, cutting pressure to pick a photo; 'filler' photos – the non-suspects — have to look as close to a suspect as possible, and a witness' 'confidence' will have to be recorded. It also requires police to corroborate an identification by facial recognition software with other evidence. The law goes into effect July 1. mcolias@
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Ariel Winter Puts Her Life On The Line To Help Catch Online Child Predators
, best known for her role as Alex Dunphy on "Modern Family," has taken on a powerful new role off-screen. The 27-year-old actress has teamed up with the nonprofit organization SOSA (Safe from Online Sex Abuse) to help combat the ever-growing problem of online predators targeting young children. Ariel Winter has participated in an undercover sting operation for SOSA's true crime docuseries, "SOSA Undercover," where she played the role of a 12-year-old girl to catch predators attempting to exploit minors online. Winter's involvement in the operation is deeply personal. Reflecting on her own experiences in the entertainment industry with Daily Mail, she shared, 'It's definitely cathartic to be teaming with SOSA, knowing that I can make a difference." The actress continued, explaining that although pretending to be a 12-year-old and interacting with older men can be intimidating, the work is invaluable. "It's validating to put away predators that have been harming children." SOSA, a nonprofit dedicated to protecting minors from online sexual exploitation, partners directly with law enforcement to conduct undercover operations aimed at identifying and arresting child predators. According to Winter, the need for such operations is dire. 'Growing up in the entertainment industry, I've been the girl we are trying to save," she said. "It's vital to me to help protect young women from the experiences I endured in my own life." The dangers of online predators have never been more prevalent, as platforms like social media, gaming apps, and photo-sharing sites make children and teens more vulnerable than ever. Winter explained the difficulty of finding these predators, noting how they often use false identities and carefully conceal their true intentions. 'Finding someone is hard because they don't use their real name or handle, and we have to do research into who these people are," she explained. 'I was surprised by the volume of men out there looking to talk to young girls. It's hundreds of thousands of men.' One of the most shocking realizations for Winter was the normalcy of the predators' appearances. 'These men don't look like predators. They look like the guy next door. They're usually married with children and have pets. They seem nice because they talk about their everyday life, but they're trying to meet with a 12-year-old girl,' Winter shared. She recalled one instance where a man in his 40s tried to take an 11-year-old girl shopping for a new bra. 'That's not normal. It's not good.' The emotional toll of Winter's involvement in these operations has been substantial. 'This whole experience has been heartbreaking because I think of how young these girls are and they're being approached by much older men,' she said before expressing concern for young girls who are often lonely and turn to the internet for companionship, only to fall prey to predators. 'Kids look for online relationships because they're lonely or bored and then they find a male and think that they can connect to them, not realizing they are so much older and are actually predators with bad intentions,' Winter said. Winter's journey into this work is deeply rooted in her own experiences. Having entered the entertainment industry at a young age, she recalled receiving inappropriate messages from older men as early as when she was on a laptop or cell phone. 'The movie and TV industry is a dark place,' Winter said, noting how the trauma she experienced led her to seek therapy. Her partnership with SOSA is a part of her ongoing commitment to helping prevent such abuse. 'I like working with SOSA because it's women helping women,' she said, emphasizing her dedication to continuing this work for as long as she can. Roo Powell, founder of SOSA, praised Winter's efforts, acknowledging that her support is vital for the nonprofit. 'Ariel is boosting our platform, and it means so much to us because we have only five full-time employees and a smaller budget than most libraries. Ariel is getting the word out about SOSA. She has been amazing,' Powell said. 'She will do anything to help us. She helps take out the trash and eats cold cheeseburgers with us.' SOSA's work is critical in protecting children from online predators, and their methods are both highly strategic and realistic. The nonprofit stages undercover operations using decoy houses, where minor personas engage with predators on video calls. These operations are designed to build trust with the predators and provide law enforcement with the critical evidence needed to make arrests. With over 1 million followers on Instagram and TikTok, SOSA has built a thriving online community that not only raises awareness but also provides resources and safety tips to help protect children from online threats. Winter's involvement is helping bring more attention to this important cause, as she uses her platform to spread the word about SOSA's mission to protect children from online sexual exploitation. As she continues her work with SOSA, Ariel Winter is not only shedding light on the prevalence of online predators but also using her voice and experience to protect the next generation from the horrors that she herself faced in her youth.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Wisconsin State Troopers team up with kids for 'Cops & Bobbers' event in Marquette County
MARQUETTE CO., MI. (WFRV) – Michigan State Police troopers from the North Central Region joined local youth last week for the annual 'Cops & Bobbers' event, a community outreach program designed to foster positive relationships between law enforcement and children, while encouraging a love for fishing over crime. Green Bay Police Chief Chris Davis provides details on local immigration enforcement policies According to a Facebook post from Wisconsin State Patrol, the event featured a day of casting lines, reeling in fish, and sharing laughs. Organizers say the goal is to get kids 'hooked' on fishing instead of drugs or delinquency. After what troopers jokingly called a 'reely good steak-out,' participants found a prime fishing spot that led to plenty of smiles and big catches. 'Cops & Bobbers' is part of a statewide initiative to build trust and create lasting memories with local youth. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
