Tesla moves to stymie shareholder lawsuits after Musk pay saga
[NEW YORK] Tesla took a step to prevent future shareholder lawsuits like the one that blocked a record-setting pay package for chief executive Elon Musk.
The automaker late on Friday (May 16) disclosed changes to its corporate bylaws that will require investors to own at least 3 per cent of the company's shares in order to 'institute or maintain a derivative proceeding'. The move was taken on Thursday, according to a regulatory filing.
The change comes days after Texas governor Greg Abbott signed legislation enacting a series of changes to the state's corporate law, including allowing companies to adopt ownership thresholds that must be met for shareholder derivative claims. Abbott and other Republican leaders in the state have touted the measure as a method for enticing more businesses to incorporate in the state.
Tesla did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Musk shifted Tesla's incorporation to Texas last year after a judge in Delaware struck down a 'moonshot' package of stock options for Musk.
The compensation agreement, approved by shareholders in 2018, was initially worth US$2.6 billion and spiked to US$56 billion by the time it was voided in early 2024. Plunging and soaring with the company's fortunes, it has been valued in excess of US$100 billion when the shares have climbed.
The package was challenged by a shareholder who argued that Tesla's directors didn't make proper disclosures about the terms and performance benchmarks required. Delaware Chancery Court chief judge Kathaleen St J McCormick agreed, finding that Musk had undue influence over the process and that Tesla's board, which includes longtime friends and associates, was rife with conflicts of interest.
Tesla has appealed that decision to the Delaware Supreme Court, a process that could still take months. Shareholders voted last year to re-ratify the prior package, part of a symbolic effort to bolster Musk's legal case.
Tesla disclosed in a regulatory filing last month that the board had established a special committee to consider compensation matters involving the CEO. BLOOMBERG
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
40 minutes ago
- Business Times
China's biotech moment ignites a 60% stock rally that beats AI
China's biotechnology stocks have shaken off a four-year slump to be among the hottest performers in Asia this year and funds are tipping further gains. The Hang Seng Biotech Index has surged more than 60 per cent since the start of January amid investor enthusiasm over a pair of billion-dollar deals involving foreign firms licensing Chinese drugs. Share gains at two highly anticipated listings of local producers have further burnished the sector's appeal. 'China biotech is no longer just an emerging story – unlike 10 years ago – it is now a disruptive force reshaping global drug innovation,' said Yiqi Liu, senior investment analyst at Exome Asset Management in New York. 'The science is real, the economics are compelling, and the pipeline is starting to deliver.' The surge in China-listed biotech firms is further evidence that the mainland is becoming a centre for global innovation. The rally in the sector this year outpaces the 17 per cent gain in China's tech stocks that was driven by the release of DeepSeek's breakthrough artificial-intelligence app in January. A major reason for the share gains were two mega-sized licensing deals. Pfizer said on May 19 that it had agreed to pay a record US$1.25 billion to license an experimental cancer drug from China's 3SBio, and also invest US$100 million in the firm's shares. Two weeks later, Bristol-Myers Squibb said it would pay Germany's BioNTech as much as US$11.5 billion to license a cancer drug that BioNTech had itself licensed from China's Biotheus in 2023. Some of the gains in biotech shares this year have been stratospheric. 3SBio has surged 283 per cent, topping a Bloomberg gauge of global biotech stocks. RemeGen, which develops antibody drugs, has climbed more than 270 per cent after saying it was approached by multinational pharmaceutical firms for potential licensing deals. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up China's growing influence through pharmaceutical mergers and acquisitions and deal-making is also causing investors to take note. In the first quarter alone, the value of such deals involving local players doubled from the year before to US$36.9 billion. That amount made up more than half the global total of US$67.5 billion. Chinese biotech companies are having 'their own DeepSeek moment', said Dong Chen, chief Asia strategist at Pictet Wealth Management in Hong Kong. There is more upside from here, he said. Investor interest in biotech – which involves the use of living organisms to make medicines and other products – can be seen in the big runup at recent initial public offerings. Shares of Duality Biotherapeutics, which develops cancer treatments, more than doubled on their first day of trading in Hong Kong on Apr 15. Jiangsu Hengrui Pharmaceuticals, the nation's largest drugmaker by market value, saw its stock jump 25 per cent on its May 23 debut, even after being issued at the top end of the marketed range. Duality has now risen 189 per cent since its IPO, while Jiangsu has gained 31 per cent. Still, some say the rally may be getting stretched. 'Bears, mostly healthcare specialists, plan to take profit at this point, and some investors prefer the healthcare laggers with capability of constant dividend payout and stable revenue growth,' Bank of America analysts including Ethan Cui in Hong Kong wrote in a research note this month. Some investors also said they viewed the rush of recent licensing deals as a one-off, and they were refusing to grant valuation multiples to the companies, the analysts wrote. Talent returns While the recent ratcheting up of trade tensions between the US and China has been a negative for many mainland firms, it's also resulted in talent flowing back to China and creating more research-and-development capability, according to Nicholas Chui, a Chinese equity fund manager at Franklin Templeton in Hong Kong. Jefferies is also bullish, saying the increase in US tariffs is unlikely to prove an obstacle to Chinese biotech firms. Many of the Chinese biotech companies already have US partners and are therefore considered as service providers rather than product exporters, said Cui Cui, head of Asia healthcare research at the company in New York. BLOOMBERG
New Paper
an hour ago
- New Paper
Singapore start-up on a green mission to keep mobile phones in use for longer
Singaporeans are replacing their phones every 2.7 years, contributing to some 2.9 million mobile phones being stowed away, a new study shows. But one Singapore start-up is hoping to change this and keep phones in circulation for five years here. This will be even longer than the global smartphone replacement cycle of 3.5 years on average. Cinch plans to meet this target by renting out instead of selling the devices to consumers, ensuring that the returned units at the end of the rental period are refurbished to get a new lease of life with another user. "We're trying to extend the useful life of these devices beyond the average refresh rate," said Mr Mahir Hamid, chief executive and co-founder of Cinch, which commissioned the study to better understand consumer behaviour. Its study, conducted between late 2024 and early 2025, involved interviews with firms that handle e-waste and used devices, as well as a survey of 500 Singapore-based respondents. Fresh from raising US$28.8 million (S$37 million) in funding led by Monk's Hill Ventures, Cinch is now actively pursuing consumers, letting them pay a monthly fee to rent the latest premium models of phones, laptops and other devices. Cinch will also foot 90 per cent of the repair cost of devices damaged due to accidents. For instance, the latest Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge with 512GB storage is available from Cinch for a rental fee of $70 a month over two years. At the end of two years, consumers would have paid $1,680. The same model can be bought from Samsung for $1,808. An Apple iPhone 16 Pro Max with 512GB storage can be rented from Cinch for $120 a month over 12 months. This will amount to a total of $1,440 at the end of the year. The same model costs $2,199 upfront from the Apple store. Customers can also buy direct from Samsung and Apple with an interest-free instalment plan, but it would require them to have a credit card from specific banks such as DBS, OCBC or UOB. "There is a massive segment of the population for which a $2,000 to $3,000 purchase can be a significant proportion of their monthly salary," said Mr Hamid. "A subscription model allows them to access the premium device." Cinch, which has been operating here since 2023, has been leasing mostly to businesses such as those in the retail, logistics, information technology and public relations sectors. Around 10,000 devices such as laptops, smartphones and tablets have been leased, most of which were returned and refurbished for a second or third customer. "Every refurbished unit needs to be as good as new," said Mr Hamid. "If it doesn't meet our standards, it doesn't go back into circulation." He said that all returned devices undergo a professional diagnostic sweep and complete data wipe so users do not have to worry about privacy leaks. Customers can buy their rented devices from Cinch if they wish, but it would likely cost more than buying from retailers such as Shopee or Lazada, said Mr Hamid, urging users to rent instead. Cinch has also partnered with waste management firm Alba Group since the start of 2025 to collect and recycle devices that can no longer be refurbished for new leases. During recycling, valuable materials such as precious metals and plastics are extracted from the e-waste. Singapore generates more than 60,000 tonnes of e-waste a year, according to a report by the National Environment Agency in 2018. This is equivalent to 73 mobile phones disposed of per person in Singapore. Slowing down the device replacement cycle will reduce the overall volume of electronic waste that needs to be collected, sorted and processed, an Alba spokesperson told The Straits Times. "Alba supports efforts like Cinch's to keep electronic devices in circulation for a longer period, as it aligns with our mission to reduce e-waste and promote a circular economy in Singapore," said the spokesperson. The leadership team of Cinch, which has been operating in Singapore since 2023. PHOTO: CINCH The leasing of laptops, smartphones and tablets has become a standard practice among some businesses, as it allows them to access the latest technology without incurring huge upfront costs. Leasing is also a way of reducing depreciating assets. Leasing firms typically cover a device's configuration, maintenance, repair and eco-friendly disposal. Telcos Singtel and StarHub have been leasing devices to businesses since 2020 and 2021 respectively, while M1 does so only as part of a more comprehensive suite of tech services. Singtel started leasing devices to consumers in 2018, but ceased the programme in 2022. Mr Keith Leong, Singtel's managing director of enterprise, said consumers find that they get better value from buying devices bundled with mobile plans. But businesses in sectors such as government, infocomm and aviation continue to lease from Singtel. While the device leasing meets the specific needs of some businesses, many consumers still choose to buy devices as it gives them full ownership and control, which can be cost-effective over the long run, said Mr Leong. "Ultimately, both models provide valuable pathways to equip a mobile workforce effectively," he said. Other rental firms such as Circular and have also been in the market since 2021 to wean consumers from device ownership. Apart from renting out phones, laptop, and gaming consoles, also rents out home appliances such as digital door locks and washing machines. Leasing an iPhone 16 Pro Max with 512GB storage space would cost between $69 and $82 a month for two years from Circular, depending on the phone's condition. The same model would cost between $92 and $99 a month for two years from Cinch's adviser Arvin Singh said that Netflix and Grab have proven that ownership of storage discs and cars, respectively, is not essential. "Netflix for many years now has disrupted ownership of DVDs and hardware... So I think it's not a strange concept for consumers. When it comes to phones, maybe a bit more education is required," said Mr Singh. However, Ms Tracy Tsai, vice-president analyst of consulting firm Gartner, said that phones cannot be compared to DVDs, cars or bicycles as phones carry confidential personal data. The cost-effectiveness of renting also comes into question if users upgrade frequently, she added. "But if users want to chase the latest phone every year, renting might be less of an issue."
Straits Times
4 hours ago
- Straits Times
Guggenheim's Rosenfield revives Danish brand selling $581,000 watches
The UJ-3 has an instantaneous jump mechanism at midnight that keeps the moon phase accurate to within one day every 14,000 years. PHOTO: URBAN JURGENSEN LOS ANGELES – Urban Jurgensen, a Scandinavian watch brand with a history dating back more than 250 years, is now being revived, thanks to a partnership between an American-based finance family and independent watchmaker Kari Voutilainen. Its first three watches were officially launched in Los Angeles on June 5 – the result of 3½ years of research and development. The timepieces range in price from about US$125,000 (S$160,000) to more than US$400,000 and are marketed under the slogan, 'Time well spent'. 'We are bringing expert Swiss watchmaking and exquisite craftsmanship together with the Scandinavian heritage of the brand, so people can appreciate it all in a modern way,' says Mr Alex Rosenfield, who co-owns the brand with his father, Mr Andy Rosenfield, and Mr Voutilainen. The younger Mr Rosenfield's background is in fashion and beauty marketing, and his father is a philanthropist and the president of the financial services firm Guggenheim Partners. The three timepieces represent the revival of a brand that traces its roots to 1773, when Danish watchmaker Jorgen Jurgensen started creating his own pocket watches – far away from the watchmaking heartlands of Switzerland and France. Later, his son Urban took over the helm. A master of mechanics and crafts, Urban built some of the finest pocket watches of the time. The company was handed down from generation to generation until the early 1900s, when it was sold and, in the ensuing years under several different owners, its popularity declined. The brand enjoyed a second renaissance when Swiss watch collector Peter Baumberger purchased the company in 1979 and brought British watchmaker Derek Pratt on board to create beautiful pocket watches, some oval in shape – including the Pratt Oval, a rare masterpiece – and others with teardrop-shaped lugs. In 1996, Mr Baumberger hired Mr Voutilainen, the cult Finnish watchmaker, to work on new movements for wristwatches. Those round wristwatches featured design aesthetics such as teardrop lugs, stepped bezels and small subsidiary seconds dials, embracing a Danish minimalist, comfortable and functional design style. Mr Voutilainen says he honed his unique finishing skills, the distinctive techniques that define his work, while at the company. Today, he is one of the most celebrated and award-winning independent watchmakers, known for his mastery of the art of engine turning dials by hand on vintage machines, for his incredibly complex finishes on movement parts and his complicated horological movements. While he was passionate about propelling the brand forward, Mr Baumberger died at the age of 71 in 2010, which ushered in a new set of owners and diminished demand. Then, four years ago, in 2021, Mr Andy Rosenfield, who is also a watch collector, purchased the Urban Jurgensen brand with a small group of investors, with the goal to propel it into a third golden age. (From left) Master watchmaker Kari Voutilainen and Mr Alex Rosenfield, who co-owns the Urban Jurgensen brand with his father and Mr Voutilainen. PHOTO: URBAN JURGENSEN Already an owner of several Voutilainen watches, Mr Rosenfield brought Mr Voutilainen on board, along with his own son Alex, to act as co-chief executives. While the Rosenfields own 85 per cent of the business, Mr Voutilainen and some family and friends own the remaining 15 per cent. Together, the co-CEOs vowed to return Urban Jurgensen to its former glory but with a modern twist. 'Our goal is to take our Danish spirit and to create a brand that feels joyful and welcoming. The watches were designed by Kari to be appealing to both men and women,' says the elder Mr Rosenfield. 'He designed a new case and lug shape for the watches that make them sit very comfortably on a smaller wrist.' The round cases are 39mm and 39.5mm in diameter and boast either shortened lugs or reinterpreted teardrop-designed lugs to fit nicely on the wrist. The new Urban Jurgensen watches are made in Switzerland. They are powered by in-house movements designed by Mr Voutilainen and made in the Urban Jurgensen workshops in Biel. Two of the three watches are based on a pre-existing Voutilainen calibre that has been adapted. It features a free-spring balance wheel with direct double-wheel escapement. Each is crafted in limited numbers. The UJ-1 watch, for instance, is built in a limited edition of just 75 pieces. Also referred to as the 250th Anniversary watch, it boasts a 39.5mm case and houses a complex gold movement with tourbillon remontoir escapement, which compensates for errors in timekeeping due to the effects of gravity and brings constant force for precision. The watch was inspired by the Pratt Oval, with details such as hand-guilloche finishes, an asymmetric minute track and a gold subsidiary dial. Retailing for 368,000 Swiss francs (S$581,000), it is crafted in either rose gold or platinum and features a hand-finished dial in silver or grey. Three combinations will be offered in runs of 25 of each. The plan is to create just 75 each of the other two watches as well. The UJ-2 watch (105,000 francs) is an elegant time-only watch. Created in cooperation with another top independent watchmaker, Mr Andreas Strehler, the UJ-3 is a perpetual calendar with an instantaneous jump mechanism at midnight that keeps the moon phase accurate to within one day every 14,000 years. It retails for 168,000 francs. The brand expects to make fewer than 100 watches in its first year, then double that in the next. Unlike Mr Voutilainen's namesake brand, which makes about 60 watches a year, Mr Rosenfield says Urban Jurgensen will aim to steadily grow over the course of years, focusing on developing new complications. Currently, the watches are available only directly to consumers online. 'This collection is a tribute to Urban Jurgensen and his unique and extraordinary legacy. It's rooted in everything that defines who we are: precision, artistry and a profound respect for the value of time,' says Mr Voutilainen. 'We want to keep the brand rare, and while we want to grow it, we can't grow too fast. We want to keep building the most sophisticated movements and create watches with a soul.' Bloomberg Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
