Inside a fired fitness trainer's legal fight against Fisher Island
The big picture: The island community — accessible only by boat or helicopter — is one of the wealthiest ZIP codes in America and a source of palace intrigue, legal fights and celebrity gossip.
Driving the news: Shebah Carfagna, who says she was the only Black woman working as a trainer on Fisher Island, alleges in a lawsuit filed last year that the club "terminated her because she is a black woman who objected to her mistreatment."
District Judge Rodolfo A. Ruiz II in January dismissed two counts from the suit and sent another to arbitration.
A fourth count — alleging the club's actions "demonstrate an intent to discriminate against Carfagna on the basis of her race" — remains pending.
Carfagna, who worked on Fisher Island for 14 years through her Panache Fitness brand, alleges that the club:
Directed clients away from her and her life partner, a Black man who also works on Fisher Island as a trainer.
Prevented her from teaching certain classes she was certified to teach.
Withheld payments owed to her and harassed and intimidated her.
The other side: Fisher Island Club issued a statement to Axios denying the allegations and saying it ended its business relationship with Panache Fitness "for legitimate business reasons."
"The Club is disappointed that last year Ms. Carfagna filed a lawsuit alleging that this decision was unlawful," the club said.
"However, the Club is committed to continue to address such allegations through the appropriate legal channels as the allegations are unfounded and without merit."
The club ended its contract with Panache Fitness in April 2024, alleging that Carfagna offered virtual fitness classes without club approval and that trainers and guests had complained about her, according to Carfagna's lawsuit.
In her lawsuit, filed last June but not previously reported, Carfagna argues her firing was retaliation for raising concerns about a "hostile" work environment.
The club's reasons for firing her were "entirely contrived," her lawsuit says.
Zoom in: The club allowed white trainers to hold virtual classes, the lawsuit says.
The wife of a Fisher Island board member attended Carfagna's virtual classes and emailed the club to ask that Carfagna be hired back, the suit says. (In a legal filing, Fisher Island attorneys did not dispute this.)
Carfagna said the club's complaints were inconsistent with her "impeccable" reputation and said many other club members sent emails to management opposing her firing.
What they're saying: Carfagna's attorney, Jonathan Minsker, tells Axios that Fisher Island Club's actions are "both shameful and illegal."
"Ms. Carfagna did not want this fight, and she did not ask for it, but she will not be bullied," he said in a statement. "She intends to fully vindicate her rights and hopefully prevent the Club's management from doing this to others."
What's next: Fisher Island this month filed a motion asking the judge to rule in its favor on the lawsuit's sole remaining count, which would end the suit.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
26 minutes ago
- CBS News
Target fires hundreds of Little Village warehouse employees apparently for medical loan scheme
Hundreds of Target workers in Chicago appear to be out of a job after a scheme to not pay back medical loans offered by the company. An internal investigation found team members violated the company's ethics at the Little Village warehouse. A Block Club Chicago report says the firings all stem from the company's medical loan program, which gave out loans of more than $3,00 to cover expenses. But a loophole let some workers pay back just $50 of the loan and get the remaining balance erased. Up to 700 employees may have been fired; the scheme cost the company $1 million. Target told CBS News Chicago there are now measures in place to prevent this from happening again.
Yahoo
33 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Why One Gary Barbershop Has Lasted for Generations
This month, in celebration of Black Business Month, Capital B Gary is publishing a series of stories highlighting businesses, business owners, and entrepreneurs in the city. At 12 years old, William 'Bill' Coker came home from the barber college with a haircut he hated. Disappointed, he grabbed the clippers his mother kept in the house and fixed it himself. What began as a personal fix quickly became more: first, he paid people to let him cut their hair, then, before long, kids were paying him for his services. Forty years later, Bill Coker is no longer the boy who once paid for practice cuts. At 52, he presides over one of Gary's most enduring barbershops. Running Billco Barber Shop for nearly three decades, Coker has upheld a tradition that stretches beyond just fades and crisp lineups. In Black communities, barbershops have long served as gathering spaces — places where people come not just to look good, but also to connect. That tradition continues at Billco's, making it both a business and a cultural anchor. 'I didn't know it was going to be my destiny,' Coker said. 'And now I'm actually walking in my destiny.' During his teenage years and into early adulthood, Coker spent as much time as possible perfecting his craft. After spending a year in college, he returned home and worked, while cutting hair as a side hustle. Eventually, he realized he didn't enjoy his job and decided to focus on cutting hair more. Taking a leap of faith, he offered $5 house calls, requiring a minimum of four people. There was just one problem: He wasn't licensed. Then, when a client walked him to barber college, the rest was history. He graduated in 1994 and began working at his mother's salon. 'I think I was chosen to do this; it just came out of my spirit,' Coker said. 'I've always had a passion for it, and I never not wanted to do this.' Coker worked with his mom for a while; together, they opened a shop called Top of the Hill. Yet, wanting to branch out, he set his sights on opening a shop of his own to grow as both a barber and an entrepreneur. He got his feet wet with his first shop, located on 38th Avenue and Broadway, but soon outgrew it. Needing more space, he opened the first big Billco's in the plaza on 11th Avenue and Broadway, with nine barbers. 'That was the best time of my life,' he said. When leasing no longer made sense, he searched for a building he could own. Driving down Broadway one day, he spotted a storefront that once housed a clothing shop called Just for Me. 'This used to be a clothing store called Just for Me,' he said, sitting inside Billco's current home on 24th and Broadway. 'I just thought that was too ironic because I was looking for a building called Just for Me,' he said jokingly. In 2005, he purchased the building. Two decades later, the building houses eight full-time barbers on one side and six suites for small entrepreneurs on the other. 'It's very rewarding to see just the city thrive, and you be a part of it,' he said. Barbershops have long been pillars of Black communities. And Coker wants his barbershop to be just that: a community. 'We've created a family-oriented, righteous atmosphere here,' he said, gesturing around the shop. 'We welcome so many walks of life. I only want to create a positive and pleasant environment.' While the Gary native no longer lives full time in the city, he still dedicates time to the shop and his craft. 'One of my goals as a barber was to work less and make more,' he said. 'When I moved to Houston, I wanted to do something different. I didn't want to be put in a barber box.' That change came when he attended a hair replacement class in Dallas. It opened a new niche, which quickly took off. Today, he visits Gary monthly while balancing his work in Houston, relying on his team to keep Billco's running. Deedra Jones, also known as Dee Dee, is the first face customers see when they walk into the shop. She has been a part of Billco's for almost a decade. Unlike her boss and friend, the 33-year veteran didn't have the immediate call to the craft. She enrolled in barber college in 1991. Her mother paid $1,800 for tuition, and Jones said she didn't want to waste the opportunity or her mother's money. She obtained her license, completed her required hours on Saturdays, and landed a job at a shop seeking a female barber. 'I've never wanted to quit; this has been my only job,' she said. Jones floated between shops in the region before joining Coker, whom she had known for years. 'This is home; I'm done,' she said, calling Billco's the last shop she'll work in. Carl Blakely, another longtime barber, said he returned to Billco's after running his own shop in Michigan City for a decade. 'It's deeper than just trying to get some money from you,' he said. 'I like creating something from nothing. You come in looking one way, and you leave transformed.' Similar to Coker, he started cutting hair as a preteen and has continued for 30 years. A 'student of the game,' as he states, he learned from watching his barber cut hair for hours before his appointment and practicing on friends and family. Through the faith of one family member, Blakely was encouraged to attend barber school before joining his cousin, Bishop, at Billco's years later. Having his cousin working at Billco's, he saw firsthand the community behind the shop and knew that he wanted to be a part of it — especially the jokes and environment they created. Jones and Blakely said Billco's is committed to service first. Customers who can't pay aren't turned away. 'We look out for them to make them feel good about themselves,' Jones said. 'We're not gonna take it as a loss, like we just lost haircut money.' Having built those relationships with clients, they know that they'll come back and take care of it. For Coker and his team, barbering has never been just about hair. It's about community. 'I believe the barbershop is one of the most important things in the [Black] community, next to a church,' Blakely said. The post Why One Gary Barbershop Has Lasted for Generations appeared first on Capital B Gary. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Black Businesses and Urban League Staff Hit After Trump Cuts
Participating in the Urban League of Greater Atlanta's Capital Readiness program last year helped metro Atlanta entrepreneur Tamara Fowler secure enough seed funding to expand Wiggle Giggle, her Marietta-based indoor playground business. The 31-year-old married mother of two said she was disappointed to learn earlier this year that the program's $3 million grant funding was canceled due to an executive order issued by President Donald Trump. Trump's March 31 executive action sought to reduce the size of the federal government by eliminating departments that the president deemed 'unnecessary.' One of those departments is the Minority Business Development Agency, a division of the U.S. Department of Commerce that promotes the growth and competitiveness of minority-owned businesses. The MBDA was the agency that awarded the capital readiness grant before the program was effectively eliminated. In May, a federal judge issued an injunction blocking Trump's elimination of the MBDA, but the Urban League said its funding hasn't been restored. READ MORE: Georgia Gubernatorial Candidate: Black Votes 'Critical' to Block Aid Cuts 'I was incredibly disappointed and disheartened,' Fowler told Capital B Atlanta on Wednesday. 'This program has brought a lot of funding and a lot of information to people, and it's free. It's not just for people of color. It's for all people that are in any sort of disadvantaged situation.' Some inflation-weary Black voters who supported Trump in 2024 did so because they thought he would do a better job on the economy than former President Joe Biden. But local Black entrepreneurs, who benefited from the Urban League's capital readiness grant program, say Trump's opposition to similar initiatives aimed at helping minority-owned firms grow and thrive will hurt metro Atlanta small businesses and their employees. The Urban League said that Trump's grant funding cancellation effectively eliminated the group's capital readiness program, which has helped more than 4,700 small business owners participate in the nonprofit's two eight-week accelerator courses and has assisted some entrepreneurs in completing loan and grant applications that many were previously unaware of. Twenty-nine of those businesses have received a total of roughly $6.9 million in contracts, grants, and loan funding as a result. 'The cancellation meant we had to lay off our Metro Atlanta Capital Readiness team and end the programming in progress,' Nancy Flake Johnson, president and CEO of the Urban League of Greater Atlanta, told Capital B Atlanta. 'Our remaining entrepreneurship center team [members] are continuing to support the entrepreneurs in the program as best we can with the much smaller team.' READ MORE: How Georgia's Black Republicans Are Capitalizing on Trump's Election Victory Johnson said the local Urban League was one of 47 grantees nationwide who received funding through the MBDA's grant initiative. 'Almost every state received resources through this program,' she said. 'Government contracting has been a path for small and minority and women and veteran-owned firms to grow their businesses. Without those pathways being intentionally in place, it's going to slow down job creation. It's going to slow down economic growth in underserved communities and neighborhoods across the country.' Atlanta resident Patricia Morgan said she was nearly finished with her Urban League capital readiness training when Trump's order canceling the program came down. 'One of the coaches that I worked with directly was let go,' she told Capital B Atlanta. 'I lost that direct coach that I had that was my procurement contact.' Morgan is the founder of The Executive Learning Labs, a company that offers training and workforce development solutions to government and other small businesses. She said the Urban League's grant cancellation didn't stop her from establishing business connections that she said boosted her company's profits by 120% over the course of about a year. But she's disappointed that other entrepreneurs may not get the same opportunity. 'There are not a lot of programs for us as entrepreneurs that are entering that accelerate phase,' Morgan said. Fairburn resident Kimberly Jones said the Urban League's program helped her Atlanta-based IT consulting firm, KYJ Consulting, land a lucrative contract with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in February. Jones, 55, a former nurse and data scientist for Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, said she began participating in the Urban League's programs last summer after seeing a related post on social media. Her company specializes in work with emerging technologies, such as water intelligence and electric vehicle charging stations. She said the Trump administration is 'doing more harm than good' by eliminating capital readiness grant funding from the MBDA, in part, by reducing competition for lucrative government contracts. 'These prime contractors, they're the same people always winning,' Jones told Capital B Atlanta. 'Now it becomes that monopoly that we try not to have.' READ MORE: Nurses Rally Against Atlanta VA Layoffs, Warn of Risk to Black Veterans U.S. Sen. Jon Ossoff, D-Ga., who is up for reelection next year, recently sent a letter to Trump's U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, urging him to restore funding for the Urban League's program. The 38-year-old Atlanta native, who received overwhelming support from Black Georgians in 2020, said he hasn't forgotten who sent him to Washington, and remains a champion for Black businesses, a value he said Trump doesn't share. 'The Trump administration is making war on Black-owned businesses,' Ossoff told Capital B Atlanta during a recent phone interview. 'They've tried to disband entirely the Minority Business Development Agency. They've canceled this grant that I fought for, for the Urban League of Atlanta to support Black-owned businesses. … I will continue to apply pressure to restore this funding.' White House Spokesman Kush Desai told Capital B Atlanta via email on Monday that the president's trade deals 'have unlocked unprecedented market access for American exports to economies that in total are worth over $32 trillion with 1.2 billion people.' 'As these historic trade deals and the Administration's pro-growth domestic agenda of deregulation and The One Big Beautiful Bill's tax cuts take effect, American businesses and families alike have the certainty that the best is yet to come.' The post Black Businesses and Urban League Staff Hit After Trump Cuts appeared first on Capital B News - Atlanta. Solve the daily Crossword
