Province suspends loan program at Alberta's largest cattle industry lender after inspections
The Alberta government has suspended a loan program at Picture Butte Feeder Cooperative, the province's largest cattle financing cooperative, after an inspection alleged a number of financial mismanagement and regulatory issues.
The suspension could mean "a significant and unprecedented disruption" to members of the cooperative and their farming operations, according to one former official. The news comes as many Alberta ranchers are already worried about the financial impact of U.S. tariffs.
The Picture Butte Feeder Cooperative, which formed in 1991, is part of the province's Feeders Association Loan Guarantee (FALG) Program, which helps livestock producers get easier access to loans. The cooperative is based in "Feedlot Alley," located in southern Alberta.
The FALG program has been in place in Alberta since the Great Depression, and is intended to provide "relatively easy access to low interest, leveraged financing backed by a government guarantee," according to the province.
In January, Alberta Minister of Agriculture and Irrigation RJ Sigurdson signed an order that stated the province would prohibit the cooperative from issuing further advances to its members under the program.
The province's claims were attached to an affidavit for Tony Ankermann, who was vice-chairman of the cooperative, dated Feb. 18.
They include that the cooperative allegedly accepted ineligible feeder members, used guaranteed loan proceeds for improper purposes, provided more advances than allowed and obstructed provincial inspections, among other violations.
In response to the order, the cooperative sought court approval to appoint a restructuring officer, Alvarez & Marshal, to oversee its operations and work toward lifting the loan suspension.
A number of board members resigned after the order was issued, while the remainder were set to resign upon the appointment of a restructuring officer, according to documents on Alvarez & Marshal's website.
"In seeking the appointment of a restructuring officer, PBCF's intentions are to make the changes necessary within PBFC to ensure that PBFC is best positioned for continued operational success going forward, ideally with the support of the ministry and lenders," Ankermann wrote in the affidavit.
Alvarez and Marsal consultants are now acting as if they were the PBFC board and staff while they handle business affairs, according to a statement from Alberta Agriculture and Irrigation.
According to information posted to Alvarez & Marshal's website, PBFC owes a little more than $281 million to its lenders under the credit agreement, which it says is approximately the same amount the PBFC lent to its members.
As of Aug. 31, 2024, the PBFC had a total of 227 active and inactive members, according to Ankermann's affidavit.
Provincial inspections
According to information posted to Alvarez & Marshal's website, a letter was delivered to the cooperative that stated the inspection and investigation section of Alberta Agriculture and Irrigation conducted inspections of PBFC between Sept. 7, 2023 and May 15, 2024.
That inspection turned up the alleged violations, which triggered the suspension of the cooperative's loan program.
Those findings were disputed.
The PBFC had sought to seal Ankermann's affidavit, writing that it "contains a copy of the report and compliance memorandum, each of which reference certain findings of the ministry that are subject of significant dispute by certain parties."
"The contents of the report may also be the subject of further legal proceedings by various parties, including PBFC," reads a bench brief posted to Alvarez & Marshal's website.
According to a statement from Alberta Agriculture and Irrigation, there is no formal process for disputing a ministerial order under the Feeder Associations Guarantee Act. However, affected parties could consider applying for a judicial review.
A spokesperson for Sigurdson declined an interview request, writing in a statement that "to protect the confidentiality of Albertans, Agriculture and Irrigation has a policy to not make compliance records public."
"Twice per year, Agriculture and Irrigation inspects feeder associations that participate in the Feeder Association Loan Guarantee Program to ensure compliance with its rules," wrote Darby Crouch in an email.
The Alberta government has agreed to guarantee 15 per cent of PBFC's loan facility, Ankermann's affidavit states. It goes on to say that the government guaranteed to cover up to $60 million, but reduced that to $50.25 million on July 17, 2024.
Possible 'significant and unprecedented' disruption
Given the order, Ankermann's affidavit states that PBFC is presently unable to provide quick and reliable access to funding for members. In seeking a restructuring officer, Ankermann warned about impacts should members be unable to access funding or obtain financing elsewhere.
Given the ministerial order, the PBFC said its members cannot currently access financing that it said is "critical to many members' operations and livelihoods."
"If … PBFC is unable to satisfy the compliance requirements [laid out in the order], there will be a significant and unprecedented disruption to the members and their respective farming operations," the affidavit reads.
"This has the potential of creating a ripple effect throughout the Picture Butte area, considering that PBFC is the largest feeder association in Alberta."
It goes on to state that "rumours are spreading throughout the Picture Butte community about the order and PBFC" and that "urgent attention is required to bring stability and restore confidence in PBFC."
Curtis Vander Heyden, vice chair of Alberta Cattle Feeders Association, an advocacy organization for beef producers, wrote in an email that there was currently "stress and concern" in two ways when it came to the situation.
First, he understands some members that own cattle financed by PBFC can't currently advance additional funds to cover feed costs, he said. Second, he believes others have security deposits or approved funding tied up and can't use it to purchase livestock.
"We want to ensure [the FALG program] remains viable and available to producers," Vander Heyden wrote in an email.
CBC News sent emails to all of the cooperative's most recent board of directors listed in the receivership documents. Some declined to comment, while others have yet to respond.
George L'Heureux, a spokesperson for the Feeder Association of Alberta — the umbrella organization to which feeder associations in Alberta belong — said the provincial board was working with all parties involved to come to a timely resolution.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Toronto Sun
2 days ago
- Toronto Sun
GOLDSTEIN: Carney can't fix Canada's underperforming economy on his own
Get the latest from Lorrie Goldstein straight to your inbox Prime Minister Mark Carney delivers a press conference at Rideau Hall after his cabinet's swearing-in ceremony on May 13, 2025 in Ottawa. Photo by Andrej Ivanov / Getty Images Prime Minister Mark Carney's pledge to make the Canadian economy the strongest in the G7 is the equivalent of attempting to turn around the Titanic before it hits the iceberg. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS ONLY Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. SUBSCRIBE TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. REGISTER / SIGN IN TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account. Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments. Enjoy additional articles per month. Get email updates from your favourite authors. THIS ARTICLE IS FREE TO READ REGISTER TO UNLOCK. Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments Enjoy additional articles per month Get email updates from your favourite authors Don't have an account? Create Account An indication of the enormity of this task is to look at the performance of the G7 countries in real Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per capita, which measures economic output per person, adjusted for inflation, and is a widely accepted metric of a nation's prosperity and standard of living. Low economic growth as measured by real GDP per capita has been a longstanding problem in Canada. Under Carney's predecessor, Justin Trudeau (who appointed Carney to chair his economic growth task force in September 2024), Canada recorded the worst record of economic growth since the government of R.B. Bennett in the depths of the Great Depression. According to Jake Fuss, director of fiscal studies for the Fraser Institute writing in The Hub last year, Canada's real GDP per capita grew by 1.9% in the Trudeau years. Your noon-hour look at what's happening in Toronto and beyond. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. Please try again This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. That was lowest in the G7, which includes the U.K., Germany, France, Italy, Japan and, most alarmingly, the U.S., our largest trading partner, where real GDP per capita grew by 14.7% during the same period. University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe, also writing in The Hub last year, noted real GDP per capita in the U.S. is now almost 50% higher than in Canada – unprecedented in modern history. Read More In the Liberals' 2022 budget, then-finance minister Chrystia Freehand warned that unless this trend is reversed, 'the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development projects that Canada will have the lowest per-capita GDP growth rate among its (38) member countries' from 2020 to 2060. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. Carney's announcement of proposed legislation on Friday – which he wants passed before Parliament adjourns from the summer – to reduce federal barriers to interprovincial trade, increase labour mobility and streamline government approvals for nation building infrastructure projects, are all aimed at increasing economic growth. But they all depend on co-operation by and among the provinces. And the reality is that decades of inaction on these issues has cost the Canadian economy an estimated $200 billion annually, increased the cost of goods and services to Canadians by up to 14.5% and reduced GDP growth by up to 8% annually. At the meeting between Carney and Canada's premiers and territorial leaders last week in Saskatoon to address these issues in the face of the threat posed to the Canadian economy by U.S. President Donald Trump's tariffs, all the participants paid lip service to working together on these issues. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. A supply depot servicing the Keystone XL crude oil pipeline lies idle in Oyen, Alta., Feb. 1, 2021. Photo by Todd Korol / REUTERS / FILES But the one premier not present – B.C.'s David Eby, who was on a trade mission to Asia – promptly rejected any new pipeline crossing his province's territory, as did many Quebec politicians when it comes to their province. Any new pipelines will also be opposed by environmental organizations and some (although not all) Indigenous groups who, while they do not have veto power over such projects, must be meaningfully consulted under Canadian law. Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has cited the enormous economic damage caused by Canada's failure to build pipelines. Had the Northern Gateway, Energy East and Keystone pipelines been built (Keystone was killed by then-U.S. president Barack Obama), she said, Canada would be producing 2.5 million more barrels of oil per day. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. 'That's $55 billion a year worth of GDP value, which is worth $17 billion to my government alone and about an equal amount to the federal government.' RECOMMENDED VIDEO The Carney government does have more direct control of some issues it can move on to boost Canada's economic growth. For example, it can introduce taxation policies that encourage businesses to invest in new technologies that boost productivity, as well as increase competition. It can lower Canada's immigration levels so that increases in population do not exceed the rate of economic growth, which reduces GDP per capita. It can reduce government spending. On that issue, Carney says he intends to reduce the growth rate in the operational costs of the federal government under Trudeau from 9% annually to less than 2%. But Carney's election campaign platform also outlined $130 billion in new spending over four years with total deficits of $224.8 billion. While Carney says most of that will be spent on infrastructure, it's 71% higher than the $131.4 billion in deficit spending the Trudeau government predicted during the same period in its fall economic statement in December 2024. Finally, of course, Carney needs to negotiate a deal on tariffs with Trump. lgoldstein@ Olympics Sunshine Girls NHL Ontario Sunshine Girls


Calgary Herald
02-06-2025
- Calgary Herald
Leong: Hudson's Bay is dead but its aspirations can live on to help build Canada
Article content Article content Of course, much has changed in the 115 years since the publication of Bryce's book. Article content The Hudson's Bay Company managed to survive decades of colonial conflicts; a transformation from a quasi-governmental commercial monopoly to a pure business in a competitive marketplace; several global economic crises, including the Great Depression; and two world wars — somehow finding a way to adapt and meet the various challenges of the day. Article content Alas, it was the strains of retail coupled with what's been described by some as an unhealthy corporate union that eventually caused HBC to spiral into insolvency after more than three-and-a-half centuries as a going concern. Article content In 2008, The Bay was taken over by a U.S. private equity firm that might not have had the necessary desire, interest or expertise to keep the Hudson's Bay Company alive. Article content HBC had become just another company — the latest in a long line of historic department stores and retailers in Canada and the United States whose stories have come to a sudden end over the last few decades. Article content Article content In the The Bay's final hours, watching last-minute shoppers rummaging for a good liquidation deal amid the dregs of a dwindling stock of merchandise, it might have been difficult to trace the long path through the company's history to the same but very different corporate entity — The Governor and Company of Adventurers of England, trading into Hudson's Bay — that held great power and sway over North America and the course of its history. Article content The path behind might be hard to see but it's there. And so is the path forward but sadly, HBC won't be the one to navigate it. Article content Given the current political context and an uncertain trade relationship with the United States, Canadians are expressing a newfound desire for nation-building projects and interest in reconnecting with national institutions. Article content It seems fitting that HBC's and Canada's economic motivations after the company's surrender of Rupert's Land in 1870 very much mirror the rekindled current of nationalism we are experiencing now in 2025.

CBC
23-05-2025
- CBC
Alberta's largest cattle industry lender to restart loan program after province lifts order
The Alberta government says loans will resume at Picture Butte Feeder Cooperative, the province's largest cattle financing co-op, now that it's compliant with the rules on feeder associations. The PBFC is part of the province's Feeders Association Loan Guarantee (FALG) Program , which helps livestock producers get easier access to loans. Earlier this year, then-minister of Agriculture and Irrigation, RJ Sigurdson, signed an order that stated the province would prohibit the co-op from issuing further advances to its members under the program. An inspection had alleged a number of regulatory and financial mismanagement issues. The entire board subsequently resigned, and a restructuring officer, Alvarez & Marsal, was appointed to oversee PBFC's operations and work toward lifting the loan suspension. The order was rescinded on May 1, according to the province. "The co-operative, working under Alvarez and Marsal Canada's sound management, has brought its operations into compliance with the rules governing feeder associations. It is now compliant with the rules on feeder associations and is being operated soundly," reads a statement from the Office of the Minister of Agriculture and Irrigation. "On Monday, May 26, producers can confidently apply for and receive loans from the PBFC as it resumes full operations. "The government will continue to provide oversight of and advice to the PBFC — and other feeder co-operatives — to ensure the Feeder Associations Loan Guarantee Program continues with its success." An 'exceptionally trying time' The Feeder Association of Alberta, the provincial umbrella organization, said the past few months have been "an exceptionally trying time for the many members of PBFC that have had their operations put on hold through no fault of their own." "We recognize the pace of business has no sympathy for interruptions and acknowledge the very tough financial position members were placed in," the organization wrote in a release issued Thursday. George L'Heureux, a spokesperson for the Feeder Association of Alberta, said it will be "business as usual" starting Monday morning, with normal lending scheduled that day. "For the producers, boots on the ground, it's been very challenging … waiting and not knowing is huge, and not being able to do business as usual was quite a hardship on quite a few," he said. The co-op will still be run by the receiver for the time being. According to Alvarez & Marsal, a new local supervisor, Cody McBride, has been appointed. Efforts are underway to run a fair and transparent election to appoint a new board of directors, the receiver added. The co-operative is based in "Feedlot Alley," located in southern Alberta.