First Nation launches legal action over Alberta oilsands cleanup fund
Social Sharing
A First Nation in northeast Alberta is challenging the provincial government in court over its approach to ensuring oilsands companies pay to clean up their operations.
The Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation filed an application this week for a judicial review of the province's 2024 decision to renew the rules for the Mine Financial Security Program (MFSP), saying it failed to meaningfully consult and is ignoring ACFN's concerns about infringement on Treaty rights.
The program collects deposits from energy companies to make sure they cover the cost of remediating oilsands and coal mine sites after they're decommissioned.
About a third of ACFN members live in the community of Fort Chipewyan, Alta., downstream from oilsands operations.
The ACFN's legal application, filed on April 1, argues the MSFP is "grossly inadequate for achieving its intended purpose," and the province hasn't addressed recommendations and concerns raised during a recent review.
"Without a properly funded program, industry will be able to walk away from their leases — leaving the mess behind for First Nations communities to live with," acting ACFN Chief Hazel Mercredi said in a statement.
The MFSP was criticized in 2021 by provincial auditor general Doug Wylie, who found that the government holds just $1.5 billion in security on mining liabilities of $31.5 billion.
A subsequent report from researchers at the University of Calgary's School of Public Policy in 2023 estimated liabilities at anywhere between $45 billion to $130 billion, with just $2 billion in reserve.
Ryan Fournier, press secretary for Environment Minister Rebecca Schulz, told CBC News in a statement that the province made "effective changes" to the MFSP last year.
"These were designed to ensure mine operators provide security to cover reclamation without unfairly targeting the energy sector."
Fournier said the government is reviewing ACFN's legal action, but can't comment further while it's before the courts.
Environmental law organization Ecojustice is representing ACFN.
Ecojustice lawyer Matt Hulse said their position is the government is failing in its obligations to ACFN under Treaty 8.
"We're also saying the decision is unreasonable because keeping such a flawed program does not actually uphold the purposes of Alberta's environmental legislation."
The legal application asks for action including a declaration that the province breached its duty to consult ACFN, and an order to amend the MFSP within six months, addressing the Nation's concerns.
It also seeks a judge's order requiring the province provide ACFN "an independently verified estimate of total oilsands liabilities and supporting analysis."
The judicial review is scheduled to be heard in the Fort McMurray Court of King's Bench on May 21.
ACFN also filed a lawsuit last year against the Alberta Energy Regulator, alleging negligence and a failure to live up to Treaty obligations after multiple tailings leaks at Imperial Oil's Kearl facility.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Observer
19 minutes ago
- National Observer
Saskatchewan premier resists call to bring in military to fight wildfires
Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe is resisting an Opposition call to bring in the military to combat wildfires that have forced thousands from their homes. In a statement Thursday, Moe's office said they recognize the Canadian Armed Forces can play a key role in specific areas, such as aerial evacuations, but said that's not what Saskatchewan needs right now. 'Currently, Saskatchewan's greatest areas of need are for water bombers and firefighting resources, which the military is not able to provide,' it said. His office noted it is keeping in touch with the federal government and is getting help from other provinces to fight the fires, along with supports from the Canadian Red Cross. Marshals are patrolling evacuated communities to prevent looting. Earlier Thursday, the Opposition NDP called on Moe to call in the military, as has been done in Manitoba. "Every available resource in our country must be deployed to fight these fires. We cannot afford to leave help on the table," NDP Leader Carla Beck wrote in a letter to Moe. Saskatchewan is battling 25 active fires and estimates 400 structures have burned. Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe is resisting an Opposition call to bring in the military to combat wildfires that have forced thousands from their homes. Steve Roberts, with the Saskatchewan Public Safety Agency, said there has been little rain for a month, and rain is what's needed. "Weather continues to be problematic," Roberts told an online news conference Thursday. "Rain will be a big turning point for these fires but until then we're dug in doing the best we can." More than 30,000 people in Saskatchewan and Manitoba have been forced to flee their homes ahead of scores of wildfires in recent days, more than 18,000 from Manitoba alone. Smoke from the Prairie wildfires has drifted as far east as Newfoundland and Labrador, and as far south as Florida in recent days, prompting health warnings in some regions. The major evacuation zones are in and around La Ronge, Sask., where 7,000 have been forced out, and in the city of Flin Flon, Man., where all 5,000 city residents along with another thousand in the surrounding vicinity have had to leave. The Canadian Red Cross set up an emergency evacuation centre in Regina providing meals and a place to stay. Darin Cook was waiting outside the centre with his family for a taxi to a hotel. He said they took a bus Thursday at midnight from Stanley Mission, northeast of La Ronge. 'There were fires all along the highway, a lot of hotspots all over,' he said. 'Everyone was in a rush (to get out).' Fred Cook, also from Stanley Mission, said it was extremely smoky. He's planning to stay with his daughter in Regina, he added. 'It's pretty hard for the kids (to leave), especially the babies,' he said. The fires have also displaced about 6,700 in the Pimicikamak Cree Nation in north-central Manitoba. Pimicikamak Chief David Monias said additional help is coming to his community after he joined other First Nations leaders in calling for adequate equipment and resources. Monias said in a post on social media a crew of 30 to 35 structural firefighters, along with six pumpers, tankers and command teams, are being deployed to the community. Manitoba has 27 active wildfires, a third of which are out of control. Provincial officials said weather and firefighters from Manitoba and elsewhere are keeping the fires from overrunning communities for now. 'The weather over the last couple of days has improved our ability to get some pretty good progress done on these fires," said Kristin Hayward with the Manitoba Wildfire Service. 'We have had cooler temperatures, a little bit higher humidity (and) winds generally have been low to moderate. We are expecting that general trend to continue.' In Winnipeg, police say they will help out to protect evacuees who are unfamiliar with large urban centres and could be prey for exploiters or scammers. The leader of the organization that represents the northern First Nations that have been evacuated said some of the main concerns are around drug and human trafficking and sexual violence. 'This is proactive effort and not reacting until after it happens. This is making that step to make sure our people are protected,' said Grand Chief Garrison Settee of Manitoba Keewatinowi Okimakanak. Manitoba and Saskatchewan declared states of emergency last week to allow various levels of government to co-ordinate resources and support. In northern Alberta on Thursday, the approximately 1,300 residents of the town of Swan Hills were allowed to return to their homes about a week after fleeing from a wildfire. But about 340 kilometres west in the County of Grande Prairie, people were ordered out. Earlier this week, officials with the Municipal District of Opportunity, which covers a dozen small rural communities in northern Alberta, confirmed that roughly half of the structures in Chipewyan Lake had been destroyed by a wildfire on the weekend. Marcel Auger, reeve of the district, said on social media Tuesday that 38 structures were destroyed, including the community health centre, water treatment plant and homes. Chipewyan Lake has 75 people. Liam Buchart, a fire weather specialist with Natural Resources Canada, says wildfires on the Prairies became severe more quickly than normal this week. "The second half of May dried out slightly earlier than normal across a lot of the Prairies," he said. "We're at our second-largest area burned for this time of year in the last decade at least."
Global News
6 hours ago
- Global News
Scott Moe faces call to bring in military as Saskatchewan wildfires rage
As wildfires continue to devour buildings and force thousands from their homes in Saskatchewan, the Opposition NDP is calling on Premier Scott Moe to ask for help from the military. NDP Leader Carla Beck, in a letter to Moe Thursday, questioned what the premier was waiting for. 'Every available resource in our country must be deployed to fight these fires. We cannot afford to leave help on the table,' Beck wrote. 'I still remember the wildfires of 2015 and then-premier Brad Wall's decision to bring in the military and call for a co-ordinated national response.' Moe has not ruled out asking for federal aid but has said Saskatchewan does not need Ottawa's assistance. Provincial fire officials say the abilities of federal firefighters are limited and usually only brought in to battle blazes that are contained. Story continues below advertisement Saskatchewan is currently receiving firefighter assistance from other provinces and the United States. More than 30,000 people in Saskatchewan and Manitoba have been forced to flee their homes ahead of scores of wildfires in recent days. 1:57 Northern Saskatchewan wildfire evacuees face uncertainty and loss Manitoba Premier Wab Kinew has already asked for, and is receiving, help from Canada's military. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Smoke from the fires has drifted as far east as Newfoundland and Labrador and as far south as Florida in recent days, prompting health warnings in some regions. The major evacuation zones are in and around La Ronge, Saskatchewan, where 7,000 have been forced out, and in the city of Flin Flon, Man., where all 5,000 city residents along with another thousand in the surrounding vicinity have had to leave. Story continues below advertisement 2:10 U.S. sends reinforcements to combat wildfires threatening Manitoba The fires have also displaced about 6,700 in the Pimicikamak Cree Nation in north-central Manitoba. The leader of Pimicikamak Cree Nation said additional help is coming to his community after he joined other First Nations leaders in calling for adequate equipment and resources. Chief David Monias said in a post on social media Thursday morning that he spoke with Kinew and fire officials about his concerns that the remote First Nation lacks suitable fire suppression resources. Monias said a crew of 30 to 35 structural firefighters, along with six pumpers, tankers and command teams, are being deployed to the community. 'This is no ordinary response,' Monias wrote in his post. 'This is a coalition of nations, communities and protectors coming together in unity, shoulder to shoulder, to confront that threat that has uprooted lives, chased families from their homes and loomed over our lands for more than two weeks.' Story continues below advertisement They are to join firefighting crews from the province and the United States who are already on the ground, Monias added. Aid is also coming for those displaced. 1:49 Wildfire evacuees wishing for more communication The federal and provincial governments announced Wednesday that they will match every dollar donated to the Canadian Red Cross for wildfire disaster relief and recovery efforts across Manitoba and Saskatchewan. Manitoba and Saskatchewan declared states of emergency last week to allow various levels of government to co-ordinate resources and support.
CBC
6 hours ago
- CBC
Ontario to make Ring of Fire a special economic zone 'as quickly as possible': Ford
Ontario Premier Doug Ford says the province intends to designate the mineral-rich Ring of Fire as a special economic zone as quickly as possible. He says he and several ministers will consult all summer with First Nations about the new law that allows the Ontario government to suspend provincial and municipal rules before making the designation. The law seeks to speed up the building of large projects, particularly mines. First Nations are livid about the new law and say it tramples their rights and ignores their concerns. The province passed Bill 5 on Wednesday despite several weeks of First Nations protests throughout the province and at Queen's Park. Critics also say the bill guts protections for endangered and threatened species.
