Dharmasthala SIT probe mired in uncertainty with 2 officers' request to exit & govt's attempt at retention
In an order on 19 July, the Siddaramaiah-led government had said that Director General of Police Pronab Mohanty would lead the team, and would be assisted by three IPS officers—M.N. Anucheth, S.K. Soumyalatha and Jitendra Kumar Dayama.
Bengaluru: The special investigation team (SIT) formed to probe allegations of rape, murder and mass-burials in Dharmasthala is embroiled in controversy even as it is yet to begin its investigation in the matter, with two officers requesting to be replaced, ThePrint has learnt.
The person added that one officer said that they would rather face disciplinary action than getting entangled in the politics of the case, since it allegedly involves members of one of the most influential and wealthiest families in the state.
On 3 July, a former sanitation worker of Dharmasthala temple had alleged that he was coerced to bury, burn or dispose of 'hundreds' of dead bodies, adding that most of these bodies were those of women who appeared to have been victims of rape and torture.
According to people aware of the developments, the government is still trying to convince the officers to continue in the SIT as their exit would send the 'wrong message' to the public. 'It's like they are doomed if they do, and doomed if they don't,' said the person quoted above, requesting anonymity.
The concern that the two officers requesting to opt out have shared is that they would be subject to extreme scrutiny and political pressure due to the nature of the case and those allegedly involved.
'If they find something, they will face political pressure to alter it or water it down. And if they don't find anything as expected by those opposing the powerful family, then they will be judged as sellouts. It's that sort of a case where doing anything or nothing will be equally damaging,' the person told ThePrint.
Also Read: The dead speak in Dharmasthala. Sinister story behind temple town's mass graves, unearthed
'No changes'
Mohanty is the DGP (Internal Security Division), while Anucheth, who was serving as Joint Commissioner (Traffic) was transferred as Deputy Inspector General (Recruitment) on 14 July. Soumyalatha serves as Deputy Commissioner of Police (City Armed Reserve Headquarters), and Dayama is Superintendent of Police (Internal Security Division).
Mohanty told ThePrint that as far as he was aware, there were no changes to the SIT.
On Wednesday, the government released another order in which it named 20 police officers who will be part of the SIT. But the confusion with respect to the team has delayed the commencement of the probe on top of the initial delay by the Dakshina Kannada Police. The police filed an FIR on 4 July, and the former sanitation worker even made a statement before a Belthangady court on 10 July. But the district police made no progress.
The former sanitation worker had offered to take the police to the burial sites, but the latter showed no interest in even finding out if the claims made by the former were true or not.
On the afternoon of 16 July, he sat in a car while his lawyers waited on the road by the Nethravathi river, expecting the police to arrive. Media personnel and townsfolk watched from across the bridge, but the police never showed up. The complainant waited for 30 minutes and left.
In a statement last Wednesday, the Dakshina Kannada Superintendent of Police said that there were credible intelligence inputs that the witness was likely to abscond after the digging of the graves. He also said that the police officers have put in a request to carry out brain mapping, fingerprint scans and narco tests on the complainant. Even the skeletal remains that the complainant handed over to the police were not sent to the forensic science laboratory and were kept in a hospital for medical opinion.
The delays in the SIT probe have not helped. Karnataka Home Minister G. Parameshwara has further fuelled confusion by saying that all officers (IPS-level) will remain in the SIT for now.
'If someone has requested the DGP or commissioner, they will be replaced. For whatever reason, the people in that committee, if they give a convincing reason not to be in it, they will be replaced,' Parameshwara told reporters Tuesday. He, however, claimed that he was aware of this information only through media reports and that none of these requests had reached him officially.
(Edited by Mannat Chugh)
Also Read: Witness protection for Karnataka Dalit who 'buried scores of women for Dharamsthala temple authorities'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
30 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Trump contradicts Netanyahu, warns of 'real starvation' in Gaza as aid deliveries pick up
US President Donald Trump warned Monday that the people of Gaza are facing "real starvation", as aid agencies sought to take advantage of an Israeli "tactical pause" of some military operations to rush in food aid. Trump said the UK and European Union would back new food centres in Gaza that would be easier to access -- "where the people can walk in, and no boundaries".(AFP) Speaking in Scotland, Trump contradicted Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who has dismissed famine fears as Hamas propaganda. Trump said the United States and its partners would help set up food centres to feed the more than two million Palestinians in Gaza facing what UN aid agencies have warned is a deadly wave of starvation and malnutrition. "We're going to be getting some good strong food, we can save a lot of people. I mean, some of those kids -- that's real starvation stuff," he said at a news conference with UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer. "We have to get the kids fed." Trump's remarks came after Netanyahu declared on Sunday that "there is no starvation in Gaza, no policy of starvation in Gaza." US food centres The United States already backs food centres under the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, but the GHF's operations have come under repeated criticism, with the UN saying hundreds of Palestinians have been killed by Israeli troops while trying to access its sites. The Foundation has also been accused by aid groups of facilitating Israel's military goals. Trump said the UK and European Union would back new food centres that would be easier to access -- "where the people can walk in, and no boundaries". The war in Gaza has dragged on for almost 22 months, creating a dire humanitarian crisis exacerbated by an Israeli blockade on supplies imposed from March to late May. The easing of the blockade coincided with the beginning of the GHF's operations, which effectively sidelined Gaza's traditionally UN-led aid distribution system, and which have been criticised as grossly inadequate. United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres on Monday welcomed steps to reduce restrictions to lifesaving aid, but said it "is far from the solution to end this nightmare." In recent days, the UN and humanitarian agencies have begun delivering more truckloads of food after the Israeli military declared a daily "tactical pause" in the fighting and opened secure aid routes amid mounting international outrage. Jamil Safadi said he had been getting up before dawn for two weeks to search for food, and Monday was his first success. "I received about five kilos of flour, which I shared with my neighbour," said the 37-year-old, who shelters with his wife, six children and a sick father in a tent in Tel al-Hawa. Other Gazans were less fortunate. Some complained aid trucks had been stolen or guards had fired at them near US-backed distribution centres. "I saw injured and dead people. People have no choice but to try daily to get flour", said 33-year-old Amir al-Rash. Israel's new tactical pauses apply only to certain areas, and Gaza's civil defence agency reported 54 people killed in Israeli attacks on Monday. The Israeli defence ministry's civil affairs agency COGAT said the UN and aid organisations had been able to pick up 120 truckloads of aid on Sunday and distribute it inside Gaza, with more on the way on Monday. Basic supplies Jordan and the United Arab Emirates have begun airdropping aid packages, while Egypt has sent trucks through its Rafah border crossing to an Israeli post just inside Gaza. Germany on Monday said it would work with Jordan to airlift aid for Gaza and coordinate with France and Britain. The UN agency for Palestinian refugees, UNRWA, cautiously welcomed Israel's recent moves but warned Gaza needed at least 500 to 600 trucks of basic food, medicine and hygiene supplies daily. "Opening all the crossings and flooding Gaza with assistance is the only way to avert further deepening of starvation," UNRWA said. Netanyahu has denied Israel was deliberately starving civilians, but on Monday two local rights groups, B'Tselem and Physicians for Human Rights, accused the country of "genocide" -- a first for Israeli NGOs. The amount of aid entering the territory still falls far short of what is needed, say experts, who have called for a permanent ceasefire, the reopening of more border crossings and a long-term, large-scale humanitarian operation. "We're one-and-a-half days into these new measures. Saying whether or not it is making a difference on the ground will take time," Olga Cherevko, a spokeswoman for the UN's humanitarian agency, told AFP from Gaza. The war in Gaza was sparked by Hamas's October 7, 2023 attack on Israel, which resulted in the deaths of 1,219 people, most of them civilians, according to an AFP tally based on official figures. Israel's retaliatory campaign has killed 59,921 Palestinians, also mostly civilians, according to the health ministry in the Hamas-run territory.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Beed sarpanch murder case: Court rejects Walmik Karad's discharge plea
The Beed Court in Maharashtra rejected the discharge plea filed by Walmik Karad, the main accused in the chilling murder of a Beed sarpanch, Santosh Deshmukh, saying prima facie evidence reflects his involvement in the organised crime syndicate. The Special Judge V.H. Patwadkar heard his plea on July 22 and in the detailed order released this week said, 'The statements of witnesses, electronic, digital, scientific, forensic, evidence etc. prima facie shows complicity of the applicant as it appears he have been member of the organized crime syndicate and was involved in continuing unlawful activities. Therefore, there are sufficient grounds to proceed against the applicant. Hence, the accused is not entitled to be discharged.' Mr. Karad was booked under the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act (MCOCA) along with seven other accused in the murder case of Santosh Deshmukh on December 9, last year. Mr. Karad is known to be a close aide of former agriculture minister and Ajit-Pawar-led NCP leader Dhananjay Munde. The prosecution in the court argued that accused Walmik Karad conspired with co-accused persons, demanding a ransom of ₹2 crores from the officials of the company Avaada Energy Private Ltd. 'Deceased Santosh Deshmukh tried to intervene and prevent the accused persons from closing the work of the company in the village Massajog in Beed. In order to teach a permanent lesson to deceased Santosh Deshmukh, the suspect, along with co-accused persons, allegedly hatched a conspiracy,' said the prosecution in the order. The prosecution also cited that Mr. Karad acted as a director from behind the scenes and got the crime done through co-accused persons. 'Mr. Karad was all the while threatening co-accused persons as to why they failed to do the assigned work as conspired. Video recording, FSL report go to show the complicity of the Karad,' said Special Public Prosecutor Ujjwal Nikam, adding if his name is dropped, then this can pose a problem to law and order. Whereas Karad filed the discharge plea, arguing he was framed falsely for political reasons and also mentioned that his role in the syndicated crime was not specified. He also alleged that the police did not reveal that among the 20 cases filed against him, in almost 15 cases, his name is clear, and the 'Bombay High Court also acquitted him in the appeal stage'.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Govt should phase out trade with China in 10 years, says Akhilesh
1 2 Lucknow: Blaming the BJP-led NDA govt for the collapse of India's foreign policy, Samajwadi Party chief Akhilesh Yadav on Monday said govt should phase out trade with China over the next 10 years for backing Pakistan during Operation Sindoor. Akhilesh expressed gratitude towards Indian armed forces on behalf of his party and the country but questioned govt's claims on the Pahalgam attack and the subsequent events. "We admire the valour of our forces and congratulate them for the manner in which they bravely executed Operation Sindoor. Had they been given a chance, they could have reclaimed PoK as well," Akhilesh told reporters outside the Parliament House. He said India has received top honours from many nations but during Operation Sindoor none of these countries were seen standing with India and added that this was a failure of the Indian govt's foreign policy. India caters to the economic interests of China by way of trade and so it was understandable that such economic activity cannot be stopped abruptly, he said. "But the central govt should chalk out a blueprint to end all trade ties with China in a phased manner," Akhilesh said. "People of India listen to what the central govt says. Be it the beating of Thaalis during Covid or facing demonetisation, people did what the govt asked them. Now govt should come out with a plan to withdraw trade ties with China and people will abide by it," he said. "The problem is that the rich people are getting everything (from China) but fertilizers for farmers are not coming in," he added. Akhilesh said it was not only about Pahalgam, the Centre was yet to give details to the nation about what had happened with regards to action against the terrorists involved in Pulwama attack. "On Aug 14, 2019, a suicide bomber crashed into a bus carrying CRPF personnel in Pulwama killing at least 40 jawans. The question is why are terror attacks taking place when the BJP-led govts are at the helm. Govt must answer this question," he said.
