logo
Shane Lowry's two-stroke penalty at The Open sparks debate: Fair call or too harsh?

Shane Lowry's two-stroke penalty at The Open sparks debate: Fair call or too harsh?

Khaleej Times5 days ago
There seems to have been a lot of noise around the two-stroke penalty imposed on Shane Lowry in the second round of The Open.
Many players, commentators and fans have come to Lowry's defence to say it was, at best, harsh.
Unknown to Lowry, his caddie and playing partners, and, only after officials checked with TV evidence, The R&A decided that a penalty was incurred when Lowry played a practice swing in the rough and the ball moved.
In a statement, the R&A clarified how Lowry had breached Rule 9.4 — Ball Played as It Lies; Ball at Rest Lifted or Moved.
It read, 'During Round Two, Shane Lowry's ball was seen to have moved while he was taking a practice swing for his second shot from the rough at the 12th hole.'
Three Key Rule Criteria
'The Rules require three things to be assessed in such situations:
1. Did the ball leave its original position and come to rest on another spot?
2. Was the ball's movement to another spot discernible to the naked eye?
And 3. If the ball did come to rest on another spot and the movement was discernible to the naked eye, is it known or virtually certain that the player's actions caused the ball to move?'
'Assessing whether the movement of the ball was visible to the naked eye in such a situation assumes the player being in a normal address position for the stroke,' the statement added.
'In Shane Lowry's situation, the movement of the ball to another spot, including the movement of the logo, was discernible to the naked eye. The naked eye test is satisfied whether or not the player was looking at the ball when it moved.
Assessing The Ball Movement
'It was clear that the ball moved immediately after the player's club touched foliage close to the ball during a practice swing and that the player's actions caused the ball to move.
'In these circumstances, there is a one-stroke penalty and the ball must be replaced. However, as the ball was played from the spot where it was moved to, the player played from the wrong place and incurred a total penalty of two strokes,' the statement concluded.
TV evidence and golf, over the years, has often created controversy when involved, and Rules have been adapted to ensure, wherever possible, disqualifications do not arise after scorecards are handed in. Every case needs to be looked at on its own merits.
The incident is unfortunate – especially as no one present in the group saw the ball move.
Why not make it a one-stroke penalty as the player was in no position to replace the ball – he had moved on?
Evaluating The Penalty Conditions
Commentator Paul McGinley argued it seemed unfair and the Rule should be looked at for revision – 'We should be looking at the spirit of the Rule.'
What else could Lowry have done?
Lowry was disappointed there were not more TV angles to prove the case – as it states – movement to the 'naked eye.' No naked eyes were watching – it was a TV camera.
A thought is - should the Rulings be restricted to the playing group and the walking Rules Official with that group, with all the information available at the time?
Where and when do we stop looking at all 156 players all over the golf course, for the first two rounds and 70, this week, for the last two rounds?
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Belgian GP: Lando Norris secures pole after Max Verstappen takes sprint-race honours
Belgian GP: Lando Norris secures pole after Max Verstappen takes sprint-race honours

The National

time3 minutes ago

  • The National

Belgian GP: Lando Norris secures pole after Max Verstappen takes sprint-race honours

It will be an all-McLaren front row in Sunday's Belgian Grand Prix after Lando Norris secured pole position ahead of teammate and championship leader Oscar Piastri. British driver Norris is looking for a hat-trick of wins – having been victorious in the previous two races at Silverstone, in front of his home fans, and Austria – and goes into Sunday's GP nine points behind Piastri in the drivers' standings. And Norris would pip Piastri by just 0.085 seconds at Spa-Francorchamps. Charles Leclerc's Ferrari is on the second row next to Max Verstappen's Red Bull after qualifying on Saturday, one position clear of Williams' Alex Albon, with George Russell sixth for Mercedes. Norris qualified six tenths behind Piastri in Friday's qualifying but insisted: 'I was confident after yesterday – 0.3 secs is just slipstream and not being first out of the pit lane. It was a decent lap, so I'm happy.' Rain is forecast for Sunday's 44-lap race, and Norris continued: 'I prefer it to stay dry. But I don't mind if it is wet, or dry, or somewhere in the middle. I just hope it is an exciting race.' Piastri admitted the day had been 'a bit disappointing' after the Australian had been bested by Norris again. 'The second lap was coming together really well but just made a little mistake into 14 and lost a lot of time,' he said. 'The car was really good but it's fine margins out there. 'We're a good teammate pairing, we learn a lot from each other. Felt like I did OK but didn't quite execute when it matters.' Lewis Hamilton's weekend took another nightmare twist after he qualified only 16th. The seven-time world champion, who started 18th and finished 15th in the sprint race, was eliminated in Q1 for Sunday's main event after his best lap was chalked off by the stewards. The Briton thought he had done enough to haul his Ferrari into the next phase of qualifying when he posted the seventh best time. But moments later, his lap was deleted after he was adjudged to have run all four wheels of his Ferrari off the circuit. That dropped him way down the order. Is everything OK?' Hamilton asked on the radio. 'Track limits,' replied Hamilton's race engineer, Ricardo Adami. 'Am I out?' Hamilton replied. 'Lap time is deleted, P16,' came the response. There was no response from the 40-year-old who is left to reflect on another sobering result of his difficult start to life at Ferrari, calling his own performance 'very poor'. Hamilton, who spun in qualifying for the sprint, enters Sunday's race without a podium for Ferrari – the deepest he has gone into a season in his career without a top-three finish. 'I was the same as I was for the rest of the weekend, we made some changes and the car didn't feel terrible,: said Hamilton. 'It was tough for us we had to even put our second set [of tyres] on just to get through Q1 so not great. 'From my side I made a mistake so I've got to look internal and I've got to apologise to my team because that is just unacceptable to be out in both Q1's. It's a very poor performance for myself.' Earlier, Verstappen had welcomed new Red Bull boss Laurent Mekies to the race team by winning the sprint race in style after starting from second on the grid. He held off the challenge of Piastri and Norris to earn Meckies an early success after replacing the sacked Christian Horner as team principal. 'Max was brilliant and all the guys did a great job,' said the former boss of Red Bull's 'B' team Racing Bulls. 'He was under massive pressure and he made almost no mistakes and the team extracted everything from the car and the tyres.'

Tadej Pogacar set to seal fourth Tour de France crown after coming through penultimate stage unscathed
Tadej Pogacar set to seal fourth Tour de France crown after coming through penultimate stage unscathed

The National

time33 minutes ago

  • The National

Tadej Pogacar set to seal fourth Tour de France crown after coming through penultimate stage unscathed

Slovenian superstar Tadej Pogacar has all but secured his fourth Tour de France crown after easing through Saturday's penultimate stage. The UAE Team Emirates-XRG rider and reigning champion maintained his advantage over Jonas Vingegaard of four minutes and twenty-four seconds going into Sunday's finish in Paris. However, the final stage is not a processional one, as is usually the case, and could potentially prove problematic towards the end with three consecutive climbs. But, barring any disaster in the French capital, Pogacar will be champion again. After winning the title in 2020, 2021 and 2024, the 26-year-old has dominated this year's race, winning four stages and having kept a grip on the yellow jersey since Stage 13 from which point his lead has never dropped below four minutes. Pogacar was given a pat on the back from Vingegaard as he crossed the line in Pontarlier with the rest of peloton, more than six minutes after stage winner Kaden Groves, with the Dane having been unable to drop his great rival despite numerous attempts in the final week. "It's starting to sink in," said Pogacar. "Tomorrow, all being well, I'll be celebrating with my team. "This has been another level of hard, all the way. I enjoyed it though and I'm really looking forward to the last day tomorrow." Alpecin-Deceuninck rider Groves took the honours claiming his first Tour victory after avoiding a crash on slippery roads before powering to a solo triumph on the 184.2km race from Nantua. Groves's bike-handling skills were on display when he managed to stay up as Spain's Ivan Romeo and France's Romain Gregoire skidded out of control in front of him on a wet descent 21 kilometres from the finish. The Alpecin-Deceuninck rider then attacked from a reduced breakaway bunch and never looked back in the remaining 17 kilometres, bursting into tears in a mix of disbelief and exhaustion after the line. The Australian finished 54 seconds ahead of Frank van den Broek (Picnic PostNL), who was in turn five seconds ahead of his countryman Pascal Eenkhoorn (Soudal Quick-Step). It meant Groves had completed the trilogy of winning a stage on each of the three Grand Tour races with victories in the Giro d'Italia and Vuelta a Espana already safely in the bag. Groves seized his opportunity as Alpecin's third man after teammates Jasper Philipsen (who won the opening stage) and Mathieu van der Poel (winner of Stage 2) dropped out of the race. 'There are so many emotions to win here, the team came here with so many different plans with Jasper and Mathieu, and in the end, I get my own opportunities,' said Groves. 'They haven't gone the right way, but today I had super legs and I just suffered to the line and it rewarded me with a Tour stage. 'The team gave me the free role in the last days, especially today we weren't sure whether to go for the stage or save for tomorrow. But when the rain starts to fall, I always have a super feeling normally in the cold weather, and it's like my first-ever time winning solo, and it's a Tour stage, so it's pretty incredible. 'It's not really a childhood dream because I only started cycling quite late, but there's so much pressure at the Tour, and having won at the Giro and the Vuelta, all I ever get asked is 'Am I good enough to win at the Tour?', and now I have shown them.' The final stage is a 132.3km ride from Mantes-la-Jolie to Paris, where the peloton will cycle up the famous Butte Montmartre three times before the final laps on the Champs-Elysees.

Remembering Jota: Liverpool players to wear 'Forever 20' patches in late teammate's memory
Remembering Jota: Liverpool players to wear 'Forever 20' patches in late teammate's memory

Khaleej Times

time7 hours ago

  • Khaleej Times

Remembering Jota: Liverpool players to wear 'Forever 20' patches in late teammate's memory

Liverpool players will wear a "Forever 20" emblem on their shirts and stadium jackets this Premier League season in memory of their former forward Diogo Jota who died in a car crash in Spain three weeks ago. The club also announced on Saturday a special commemoration including a fan mosaic and a minute's silence ahead of Liverpool's opening game of the season against Bournemouth on August 15. Thousands of flowers, scarves, banners and other tributes have been laid outside Anfield since Jota and his brother Andre Silva died. The club said they have been removed over the past week and stored, while the floral tributes will be composted and used in flower beds across club sites, including Anfield, the AXA Training Centre and AXA Melwood Training Centre. The remaining artefacts will be recycled and used to create a permanent memorial sculpture that will become a focal point of remembrance at Anfield. Liverpool had already announced after consultation with Jota's family that his number 20 shirt will be retired across all levels of the club, including the women's and academy teams. Supporters can have "Diogo J. 20" printed on shirts in club stores, with profits going to LFC Foundation, the club's official charity. The Foundation has committed to creating a grassroots football programme in Jota's name. A floral tribute will be also laid before kickoff at pre-season games in Hong Kong, Tokyo and at Anfield. x

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store