Afghan man who worked as interpreter for US Army detained by ICE in San Diego
SAN DIEGO (FOX 5/KUSI) — An Afghan man who once helped the U.S. military abroad is being held in ICE detention after his arrest Thursday.
It's part of a recent wave of federal courthouse arrests in San Diego and across the country.
Cellphone video obtained by FOX 5/KUSI shows federal agents as they approached the asylum-seeker moments after his first hearing and repeatedly asked him for his name.
The man, who was accompanied by his attorney, refused to answer and agents proceeded to handcuff the man in the hallway of the federal courthouse in downtown San Diego before producing a warrant.
The man stated that he worked with the U.S. military in his home country and has documents to prove it.
His attorney, Brian McGoldrick, confirmed his client was an interpreter for the U.S. Army for three years before the 2021 Taliban takeover.
'He and his brothers had a logistics company in Afghanistan, and they provided a lot of material,' McGoldrick said.
Word of the arrest sent shockwaves through AfghanEvac, a local nonprofit organization dedicated to helping Afghan allies.
'Every message they're sending to Afghans is we don't want you here, get out, which is wild and especially considering how many Veterans care about this. Because if they get sent back, they're dead,' said Shawn VanDiver, President and Founder of AfghanEvac.
VanDiver said the man's wife was previously threatened by the Taliban at a wedding where one of his brother's was murdered.
'So, he fled to Iran. Got to Brazil on a humanitarian visa and walked here from Brazil,' VanDiver added.
'The whole world is watching what's happening with these folks. How is anybody going to stand by us again?' VanDiver said.
Meanwhile, McGoldrick is keeping his client's name confidential for safety reasons, but said he has a pending Special Immigrant visa, no criminal record and was legally paroled into the U.S.
'He finally got an appointment with CBP One and he presented himself at the San Ysidro Port of Entry, I think July 6 of 2024,' said Brian McGoldrick, immigration attorney for the Afghan asylum-seeker.
He said a judge denied the government's motion to dismiss the case.
'The government simply used a statue that allows them to say that his Notice to Appear was improvidently issued,' McGoldrick said.
'That means that the Notice to Appear would've been mistakenly issued,' explained immigration attorney Saman Nasseri.
He explained the approach is becoming more and more common in immigration court.
'The way that they've been justifying arresting people at these hearings is they're dismissing terminating the notices to appear, putting people in expedited removal proceedings,' Nasseri said.
However, McGoldrick said when he asked for more information regarding the Notice to Appear and reasoning behind the request for case dismissal, the government's attorney refused to elaborate.
McGoldrick said he hadn't been able to speak with his client while he's detained in Otay Mesa. He explained that he could remain in custody for months until his asylum hearing in September.
'It's really ICE's discretion to hold him or not,' he added. 'We don't have a relationship with Afghanistan that allows us to return immigrants. It's kind of scary to think that if he were put in expedited removal where would he go?'
FOX 5/KUSI reached out to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security for comment but have not heard back.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Stock market today: Dow, S&P 500, Nasdaq slide as Trump shakes hopes for an Israel-Iran truce
US stocks retreated on Tuesday amid dwindling hopes for a quick resolution to Israel-Iran hostilities, as President Trump played down the prospect of a truce and air strikes continued. The Dow Jones Industrial Average (^DJI) fell around 0.4%, while the benchmark S&P 500 (^GSPC) dipped roughly 0.3%. The tech-heavy Nasdaq Composite (^IXIC) also pulled back 0.3%. Overall, US stocks have so far proved resilient amid the conflict. The major gauges ended higher on Monday after a report that Iran is seeking a ceasefire and return to nuclear program negotiations. But Trump's overnight call for the evacuation of Iran's capital city amid a spike in Israel-Iran tensions has spooked markets worried about the risk of a descent into full-on regional war. The president's early exit from the G7 summit is also spurring fears of an escalation. Early on Tuesday, Trump rejected the idea he was working on a Middle East pause in hostilities, as suggested by France's President Macron. It "certainly has nothing to do with a Cease Fire. Much bigger than that,' he posted on social media. Pressed on what he was looking for, Trump said on Air Force One: "An end. A real end, not a ceasefire, an end." But the president did not provide more detail, including on next steps. Oil prices jumped nearly 2% as investors weighed the stream of remarks, with Brent futures (BZ=F) rising to almost $75 a barrel and West Texas Intermediate (CL=F) crude hovering around $73. At the same time, Wall Street is also grappling with concerns over Trump's trade policy and the direction of US interest rates. As the date for lifting the pause on Trump's sweeping tariffs approaches, US officials have used the G7 summit to pursue trade deals. The first completed deal emerged Monday, when Trump and British Prime Minister Keir Starmer signed off on the US-UK trade pact agreed in May. Read more: The latest on Trump's tariffs Meanwhile, in the week's key data release, US retail sales fell 0.9% in May, more than economists expected, as consumers pulled back from a pre-tariff splurge. Wall Street is looking to the Federal Reserve's two-day meeting that starts on Tuesday for clues to whether policymakers still want to cut interest rates twice in 2025, given recent signs of cooling inflation. The Fed is expected to hold rates steady in its decision on Wednesday. US stocks slid on Tuesday as President Trump played down the prospect of a truce between Israel and Iran and retail sales came in below expectations. The Dow Jones Industrial Average (^DJI) fell around 0.4%, while the benchmark S&P 500 (^GSPC) dipped roughly 0.3%. The tech-heavy Nasdaq Composite (^IXIC) also pulled back 0.3%. Kraft Heinz (KHC) stock edged higher after the maker of Kool-Aid and Jell-O said it's eliminating synthetic dyes across the remaining 10% of its US portfolio that contains them. Yahoo Finance's Brooke DiPalma reports that Kraft Heinz will replace artificial dyes with natural colors or reinvent items with new colors. The company will also refrain from launching new products that contain food additives. This announcement comes amid growing scrutiny of food additives. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has said he wants to remove artificial coloring from the food supply by the time he leaves office. Read more here. The US Department of Defense announced Monday that it awarded OpenAI ( a $200 million contract to "develop prototype frontier AI capabilities to address critical national security challenges in both warfighting and enterprise domains." "This contract is one of the largest Department of Defense contracts given to a software provider when measured by annual contract value," William Blair analyst Louie DiPalma wrote in a note to clients Monday. DiPalma said that the "contract announcement could signal increased competition from OpenAI going forward" for Palantir (PLTR) "if OpenAI moves into Palantir's ontology territory." Ontology refers to an operational layer in Palantir's platform. DiPalma noted that Palantir paved the way for OpenAI and others. "Palantir has pioneered software providers serving as prime contractors for Department of Defense programs," DiPalma wrote. "Traditionally, software providers served as subcontractors to systems integrators. Under the new administration, the Department of Defense is looking to contract directly with commercial software providers when possible." Palantir rose less than 1% on Tuesday. In December, Palantir shares dropped as much as 5% when defense tech firm Anduril ( announced a partnership with OpenAI to "develop and responsibly deploy advanced artificial intelligence (AI) solutions for national security missions." Retail sales fell in May, dragged down by declines in gas and auto purchases during the second month that a wide array of President Trump's tariffs were in effect. Headline retail sales declined 0.9% in May, surpassing economists' expectations for a 0.6% decline month on month. By comparison, sales decreased 0.1% in April, according to revised Census Bureau data. A 2% decline in gasoline sales, a 3.5% slide in auto purchases, and a 2.7% decline in building materials drove the May headline number lower. There was some positive news in the release: The control group in Thursday's release, which excludes several volatile categories and factors into the gross domestic product (GDP) reading for the quarter, rose 0.4%. That compares with a 0.1% decrease seen in April. Economists expected a 0.3% increase. May sales, excluding auto and gas, declined 0.1%. Economists had expected a 0.3% rise. In April, sales excluding auto and gas rose 0.1%. Reddit stock (RDDT) rose roughly 5% in premarket trading on Tuesday following the social media platform's release of new AI ad tools at the Cannes Lions festival for marketers on its platform. Meanwhile, broader S&P 500 futures (ES=F) fell by 0.3%. The gain follows Reddit's 6.8% jump Monday, after media reports spotlighted a recent analysis from data analytics firm Semrush, showing that Reddit is the second most cited website in Google AI overviews. 'Reddit may also perform well because Google has a partnership with Reddit and uses Reddit data to train its systems,' Semrush analyst Rachel Handley wrote in the June 9 analysis. Google announced its $60 million deal with Reddit last February. Despite Reddit stock's climb this week, shares are far below their high of above $230 in February. The stock traded at around $131 before the market open Tuesday. Yahoo Finance's Hamza Shaban writes in today's Morning Brief newsletter: Read more here. A standout record-setting rally in gold (GC=F) is about to peter out, Citigroup strategists said as they forecast a slide back below $3,000 an ounce for the precious metal in coming quarters. Bloomberg reports: Read more here. Economic data: Retail sales (May); Industrial production (May); NAHB housing market index (June); Import price index (May) Earnings: La-Z-Boy Incorporated (LZB) Here are some of the biggest stories you may have missed overnight and early this morning: Investor optimism has squashed another downbeat catalyst Trump: EU not offering fair trade deal, Japan being 'tough' too Trump says he wants 'real end' to conflict, not just ceasefire Anne Wojcicki's 23andMe bid may not end DNA data lawsuit How a prolonged Israel-Iran conflict could speed up Fed rate cuts US solar stocks slammed after Senate changes to tax bill Trump says he will probably extend TikTok deadline again SoftBank sells T-Mobile stake for $4.8 billion to fund AI push Here are some top stocks trending on Yahoo Finance in premarket trading: T-Mobile US, Inc. (TMUS) stock fell 4% in premarket trading on Tuesday, after SoftBank Group Corp. (SFTBF, SFTBY) managed to raise $4.8B via the sale of T-Mobile US Inc. shares. The move is set to help fund Softbank's plans for artificial intelligence. Microsoft (MSFT) stock fell over 1% before the bell today following reports that the Big Tech's relationship with OpenAI has become "strained." Per The Wall Street Journal, OpenAI executives are weighing the option of whether to accuse Microsoft of anticompetitive behavior, according to people familiar with the matter. Solar stocks dropped in premarket trading Tuesday after Senate Republicans released a bill that would end tax credits for wind and solar earlier that other sources. The news caused SunRun Inc. (RUN) stock to drop by 28% and SolarEdge Technologies Inc. (SEDG) by 21%. US solar stocks have tumbled after a Senate panel released proposals for an early and full phase-out of solar and wind energy tax credits on Monday. The plan to remove credits by 2028 are among the several changes put forward by a Republican-controlled panel to President Trump's "big beautiful" tax and spending bill. Shares of Enphase Energy (ENPH), which makes solar inverters, dropped 17% before the bell. Meanwhile, solar panel seller Sunrun (RUN) tumbled 26%, while its peer SolarEdge Technologies (SEDG) sank more than 20%. First Solar (FSLR) pulled back 11%. Gold (GC=F) prices rose higher Monday night as the ongoing Israel-Iran conflict pushed risk-averse investors into safer positions, such as gold as a haven asset. Bloomberg reports: Read more here. US stocks slid on Tuesday as President Trump played down the prospect of a truce between Israel and Iran and retail sales came in below expectations. The Dow Jones Industrial Average (^DJI) fell around 0.4%, while the benchmark S&P 500 (^GSPC) dipped roughly 0.3%. The tech-heavy Nasdaq Composite (^IXIC) also pulled back 0.3%. Kraft Heinz (KHC) stock edged higher after the maker of Kool-Aid and Jell-O said it's eliminating synthetic dyes across the remaining 10% of its US portfolio that contains them. Yahoo Finance's Brooke DiPalma reports that Kraft Heinz will replace artificial dyes with natural colors or reinvent items with new colors. The company will also refrain from launching new products that contain food additives. This announcement comes amid growing scrutiny of food additives. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has said he wants to remove artificial coloring from the food supply by the time he leaves office. Read more here. The US Department of Defense announced Monday that it awarded OpenAI ( a $200 million contract to "develop prototype frontier AI capabilities to address critical national security challenges in both warfighting and enterprise domains." "This contract is one of the largest Department of Defense contracts given to a software provider when measured by annual contract value," William Blair analyst Louie DiPalma wrote in a note to clients Monday. DiPalma said that the "contract announcement could signal increased competition from OpenAI going forward" for Palantir (PLTR) "if OpenAI moves into Palantir's ontology territory." Ontology refers to an operational layer in Palantir's platform. DiPalma noted that Palantir paved the way for OpenAI and others. "Palantir has pioneered software providers serving as prime contractors for Department of Defense programs," DiPalma wrote. "Traditionally, software providers served as subcontractors to systems integrators. Under the new administration, the Department of Defense is looking to contract directly with commercial software providers when possible." Palantir rose less than 1% on Tuesday. In December, Palantir shares dropped as much as 5% when defense tech firm Anduril ( announced a partnership with OpenAI to "develop and responsibly deploy advanced artificial intelligence (AI) solutions for national security missions." Retail sales fell in May, dragged down by declines in gas and auto purchases during the second month that a wide array of President Trump's tariffs were in effect. Headline retail sales declined 0.9% in May, surpassing economists' expectations for a 0.6% decline month on month. By comparison, sales decreased 0.1% in April, according to revised Census Bureau data. A 2% decline in gasoline sales, a 3.5% slide in auto purchases, and a 2.7% decline in building materials drove the May headline number lower. There was some positive news in the release: The control group in Thursday's release, which excludes several volatile categories and factors into the gross domestic product (GDP) reading for the quarter, rose 0.4%. That compares with a 0.1% decrease seen in April. Economists expected a 0.3% increase. May sales, excluding auto and gas, declined 0.1%. Economists had expected a 0.3% rise. In April, sales excluding auto and gas rose 0.1%. Reddit stock (RDDT) rose roughly 5% in premarket trading on Tuesday following the social media platform's release of new AI ad tools at the Cannes Lions festival for marketers on its platform. Meanwhile, broader S&P 500 futures (ES=F) fell by 0.3%. The gain follows Reddit's 6.8% jump Monday, after media reports spotlighted a recent analysis from data analytics firm Semrush, showing that Reddit is the second most cited website in Google AI overviews. 'Reddit may also perform well because Google has a partnership with Reddit and uses Reddit data to train its systems,' Semrush analyst Rachel Handley wrote in the June 9 analysis. Google announced its $60 million deal with Reddit last February. Despite Reddit stock's climb this week, shares are far below their high of above $230 in February. The stock traded at around $131 before the market open Tuesday. Yahoo Finance's Hamza Shaban writes in today's Morning Brief newsletter: Read more here. A standout record-setting rally in gold (GC=F) is about to peter out, Citigroup strategists said as they forecast a slide back below $3,000 an ounce for the precious metal in coming quarters. Bloomberg reports: Read more here. Economic data: Retail sales (May); Industrial production (May); NAHB housing market index (June); Import price index (May) Earnings: La-Z-Boy Incorporated (LZB) Here are some of the biggest stories you may have missed overnight and early this morning: Investor optimism has squashed another downbeat catalyst Trump: EU not offering fair trade deal, Japan being 'tough' too Trump says he wants 'real end' to conflict, not just ceasefire Anne Wojcicki's 23andMe bid may not end DNA data lawsuit How a prolonged Israel-Iran conflict could speed up Fed rate cuts US solar stocks slammed after Senate changes to tax bill Trump says he will probably extend TikTok deadline again SoftBank sells T-Mobile stake for $4.8 billion to fund AI push Here are some top stocks trending on Yahoo Finance in premarket trading: T-Mobile US, Inc. (TMUS) stock fell 4% in premarket trading on Tuesday, after SoftBank Group Corp. (SFTBF, SFTBY) managed to raise $4.8B via the sale of T-Mobile US Inc. shares. The move is set to help fund Softbank's plans for artificial intelligence. Microsoft (MSFT) stock fell over 1% before the bell today following reports that the Big Tech's relationship with OpenAI has become "strained." Per The Wall Street Journal, OpenAI executives are weighing the option of whether to accuse Microsoft of anticompetitive behavior, according to people familiar with the matter. Solar stocks dropped in premarket trading Tuesday after Senate Republicans released a bill that would end tax credits for wind and solar earlier that other sources. The news caused SunRun Inc. (RUN) stock to drop by 28% and SolarEdge Technologies Inc. (SEDG) by 21%. US solar stocks have tumbled after a Senate panel released proposals for an early and full phase-out of solar and wind energy tax credits on Monday. The plan to remove credits by 2028 are among the several changes put forward by a Republican-controlled panel to President Trump's "big beautiful" tax and spending bill. Shares of Enphase Energy (ENPH), which makes solar inverters, dropped 17% before the bell. Meanwhile, solar panel seller Sunrun (RUN) tumbled 26%, while its peer SolarEdge Technologies (SEDG) sank more than 20%. First Solar (FSLR) pulled back 11%. Gold (GC=F) prices rose higher Monday night as the ongoing Israel-Iran conflict pushed risk-averse investors into safer positions, such as gold as a haven asset. Bloomberg reports: Read more here.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Karen Read retrial: Jury ends first full day of deliberations with no verdict
Editor's note: This is a summary of jury deliberations in the Karen Read trial for Monday, June 16. For the latest on the deliberations, visit USA TODAY's story for Tuesday, June 17. Jurors in Karen Read's second murder trial ended their first full day of deliberations Monday without a verdict in the case over whether the Massachusetts woman killed her Boston police officer boyfriend. Judge Beverly Cannone sent jurors home for the evening, telling them to come back refreshed Tuesday at 9 a.m. The 12-person panel began discussing Read's fate Friday, June 13, for about two hours, after lawyers finished delivering closing arguments in the eight-week-long murder retrial. By 4:25 p.m. on Monday, after more than nine hours of deliberations, they still had not reached a decision. Read, 45, has pleaded not guilty on three charges, including second-degree murder, vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated and leaving the scene of a collision resulting in death. Discover WITNESS: Access our exclusive collection of true crime stories, podcasts, videos and more Prosecutors accuse Read of backing into John O'Keefe with her Lexus SUV after a night out drinking in January 2022. Her defense team has suggested she was framed for the crime by sloppy and biased investigators. 'Don't you have questions?' one of her lawyers, Alan Jackson, said, prodding jurors in his final message to them. He told them their confidence in the case against Read needed to be 'unshakeable' to convict her. Catch up with our coverage and analysis from the most pivotal moments of the retrial. Why Karen Read is a true-crime obsession Karen Read screams: Jennifer McCabe, prosecution's star witness, testifies Scratches, taillight shards, hair: Jurors get a look at Karen Read's SUV The dog did it? What to know about the German Shepherd tied to the Karen Read trial Karen Read claims police bungled the investigation. What did they supposedly do wrong? Was John O'Keefe struck by a baseball bat? Doctor testifies about cops injuries Karen Read Trial in hands of jury: Which evidence could tilt the case? What did lead investigator Michael Proctor say about the case over text? Lewd messages revealed The deliberations come nearly a year after the prosecution's first case against Read ended in a mistrial, when a jury could not come to a unanimous verdict on the charges against her. Crowds of people dressed head to toe in pink, Read's favorite color, milled outside the Dedham, Massachusetts courthouse Monday to cheer for Read as they waited for a verdict. The demonstrations have become a common site, as the years-long legal saga has garnered massive intrigue and captivated true-crime fans, This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: No verdict from Karen Read jury after first full day of deliberations
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
A broken taillight, a dead cop, a bombshell admission: Karen Read trial in hands of jury
Karen Read's voice boomed through the courtroom speakers. 'Could I have clipped him?' she asked. 'Could I have done something that knocked him out, and in his drunkenness, and in the cold, he didn't come to again?' It's a question the jury in Read's murder retrial is now considering as they decide whether she is responsible for the 2022 death of her police officer boyfriend, John O'Keefe. The 12-person panel began deliberating Friday, June 13 on the three charges against Read: second-degree murder, vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated, and leaving the scene of a collision resulting in death. Their verdict is expected to come nearly a year after Read's first trial ended, when, after five days of discussions, jurors were unable to come to a unanimous decision. This time around, Shira Diner, a professor at the Boston University School of Law, said it's impossible to gauge how long the jury could take. Through almost two months of testimony, prosecutors have painted a picture of a winter night in the suburbs of Boston gone horribly wrong. A relationship on the rocks. A historic snowstorm barreling down. Friends and coworkers drinking together at a local bar to start the weekend. An after-party at a cop's home. A body found under a pile of snow the next morning. Fueled by jealousy, anger and alcohol, prosecutors allege Read backed into O'Keefe with her Lexus SUV while dropping him off at the house party, then left him to die in the snow and cold. Her defense team maintains investigators were biased against Read and overlooked evidence pointing to another cause for O'Keefe's death: law enforcement officers inside the home at 34 Fairview Road may have beaten O'Keefe, let a violent dog attack him, and discarded his body, they suggested. The 45-year-old woman has never taken the stand. Yet, even more than in Read's first trial, the commonwealth's case against her hinges on what they describe as her own 'admissions.' Prosecutors peppered multiple clips from Read's media appearances throughout their case to reinforce witness testimony and crime scene evidence, adding a new twist to the years-long legal saga that has captivated true-crime fans, sparked conspiracy theories and splintered communities. The commonwealth is hoping the tactic will tip the trial in their favor. But legal experts say Read's fate more likely hangs on jurors' predispositions, the battle between expert witnesses and the definition of reasonable doubt. The prosecution and defense have largely followed the same blueprint for Read's second trial – with a few potentially critical changes. For one thing, they've each added more muscle to their bench; the commonwealth hired Hank Brennan, one of famed mobster James 'Whitey' Bulger's lawyers, and Read's defense brought on attorney Victoria George, an alternate juror from her first trial. Brennan focused more on analyzing evidence than on showing the chronology of events when questioning witnesses, as did the lead prosecutor in Read's first trial. He called only 38 people to the stand compared to the more than 60 prosecution witnesses who testified last time. Misty Marris, a New York-based legal expert who has been following the case, said Brennan's approach appeared aimed at putting 'pieces of the puzzle' together for jurors. He brought Jennifer McCabe, the sister-in-law of Brian Albert, whose home whose it was where O'Keefe was found, to the stand earlier in this trial to deliver bombshell testimony alleging Read said, 'I hit him, I hit him, I hit him,' when they discovered his unresponsive body in the snow around 6 a.m. Digital analysts spent hours presenting vehicle and phone data that mapped out Read and O'Keefe's actions in the hours before he died. Forensic scientists testified about small pieces of red plastic found near O'Keefe's body, the nature of his injuries and Read's fractured taillight. Notably missing: Michael Proctor, a former Massachusetts State Trooper and the lead investigator in O'Keefe's case. He testified for the prosecution in Read's first trial and was seen as a potential liability to their case, Marris said. Proctor sent crude text messages about Read during the investigation and was fired before the second trial began. The defense highlighted the texts as evidence that police were biased against Read from the beginning. Kensley Barrett, a Rhode Island defense attorney, said Brennan also presented several new pieces of evidence, including clips of interviews Read conducted and a crash reconstruction report showing Read's SUV moving 87 feet in reverse at about the time O'Keefe's car locked for the last time. The interview clips of Read appeared aimed at bolstering witness testimony about her intoxication and claims she 'hit him.' But Jeffrey Abramson, a former assistant district attorney in Massachusetts who has written daily about the trial in a Substack, told USA TODAY the video clips could play against the prosecution. 'It could humanize Karen Read in the eyes of the jury,' he suggested. 'She might come across as not a monster, and that could help (the defense).' Read's defense team slightly altered its strategy, too. In Read's first trial, her defense directly accused Albert, a police officer, and his friend Brian Higgins, of killing O'Keefe. This time, the defense does not have enough evidence for that approach, Judge Beverly Cannone ruled. Instead, they used a "Bowden defense," arguing that police failed to properly investigate Albert, Higgins and other potential suspects. 'While the judge's ruling sounded like a blow to the defense it isn't really,' Marris said, adding the defense can still raise reasonable doubt. Many of the most important elements from Read's first trial are still at play, however. To convict Read on charges of second-degree murder, vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated and leaving the scene of a collision resulting in death, the jury must find that prosecutors proved their case beyond a reasonable doubt. 'That's a really high standard,' said Diner, the Boston University School of Law professor who is also a defense attorney. Massachusetts' instructions on reasonable doubt tell jurors they need to be convinced to a 'moral certainty,' said Abramson, who also teaches at the University of Texas at Austin. The word 'reasonable,' he said, doesn't mean 'beyond all doubts, because everything human is subject to some doubt.' Read's lawyers have built their case by sowing doubt into the reliability of evidence and the trustworthiness of the prosecution's witnesses. The success of her team's central argument that investigators bungled O'Keefe's case may depend on whether 'jurors were predisposed before this trial began to trust law enforcement, and which jurors were predisposed to have some doubts about law enforcement,' Abramson said. But Christopher Dearborn, a law professor at Suffolk University in Boston, said the jury doesn't have to believe the defense's theory, or even a piece of it, to acquit Read. They merely have to think there's enough uncertainty in the facts prosecutors presented. Dearborn suggested one of the biggest challenges facing the jury could be deciding which experts to believe. The defense and prosecution have called witnesses who have presented competing testimony about what caused O'Keefe's injuries and Read's broken taillight and the reliability of evidence collected by police. 'A lot of this case is going to come down to which experts the jury found more credible,' Dearborn said. 'Was it a dog fight, or was it broken glass? Was the taillight completely broken before or not? Is there a possibility the officers messed with (Read's SUV) in the sally port?' The jury continues deliberating June 16. This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Karen Read trial in hands of jury: Which evidence could tilt decision?
