Scotland's councils warned over scale of financial challenges
Councils must reform "at a pace and depth we've not yet seen" to avoid facing unsustainable losses, Scotland's public finance watchdog has warned.The Accounts Commission urged local authorities to be upfront about the "scale of financial challenge being faced". Its latest report, on the 2023-24 financial year, found councils had to plug a budget gap of £759m due to a real-terms decrease in revenue funding from the Scottish government.It said councils are increasingly reliant on cuts which becomes progressively more difficult year-on-year, and again had to use reserves to remain within their agreed budgets.
'Challenging future'
Jo Armstrong, who chairs the Accounts Commission, said: "Scotland's councils face a challenging future, with significant financial risks and uncertainties."This has been compounded by pressures outwith their control, including ever-increasing demand on services and inflation."An expected increase in funding for the year ahead doesn't cancel out the urgent need for transformation, at a pace and depth we've not yet seen."With services already being impacted, councils must be clear with communities the scale of financial challenge being faced. Working with communities to deliver differently is vital."
In its Local Government in Scotland Financial Bulletin for 2023-24, the Accounts Commission found there was a 3.3% reduction in councils' total revenue funding and income in 2023-24, compared with 2022-23.It also found that 12 out of 29 councils that provided data made unplanned use of their reserves in 2023-24 to manage budget pressures.The watchdog said councils needed to "intensify transformation activity, progressing at scale and pace to ensure their financial sustainability".It also said that how councils plan to use their reserves, make savings and transform their services needed to become more transparent.The need to consult local communities and clearly communicate the implications for local services of the budget decisions taken has "never been more important", according to the watchdog.
Council tax
Since 2007, council tax has generally either been frozen or increases have been capped by Holyrood.However, a current freeze on rates is due to end in April.The Scottish government says it is offering local authorities an extra £1bn in 2025-26 and hopes large council tax rises will not be needed.Individual authorities are expected to decide on any increases next month. Scottish Conservative finance spokesman Craig Hoy said: "The SNP has been starving councils of resources for years and Scots have seen public services crumble as a result."Scottish Labour local government spokesman Mark Griffin urged the government not to "bury its head in the sand about the timebomb in local government finances". He said: "Years of brutal budget cuts by the SNP and growing demands have left councils across Scotland at breaking point."A Scottish government spokesperson said the 2025-26 Budget would give councils a £1bn funding hike on the previous year.They added: "Alongside additional funding for local authorities to spend as they require for their communities, there is targeted investment in teacher numbers, additional support for learning and councils' work to tackle the climate emergency."Cosla has been asked for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
21 minutes ago
- The National
Starmer's approach to global trade is clearly not ‘pragmatic' at all
The UK Government estimates that annual economic output will be a stunning 0.1% higher by 2040 than it would have been without the India trade deal. In contrast, the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) noted in Spring 2023 that Brexit's impact in the long run reduces our overall output by around 4% compared with what we would have had we remained in the EU. The amount gained by the 'landmark' India deal is therefore one-fortieth of the amount lost due to Brexit. READ MORE: UK-India post-Brexit free trade deal agreed after years of negotiation Prime Minister Starmer has described the Indian trade deal as a 'pragmatic' approach to global trade. Such an approach would, however, involve the UK Government restoring frictionless trade with the UK's largest trading partner, the European Union. If the UK Government were looking to deliver a 'pragmatic' approach on the economic front, Sir Keir would be looking to get the UK back into the European single market as soon as possible. This would be far more productive than trying to deliver trade deals with far-off countries and deliver immensely higher economic benefits than the paltry 0.1% generated by the India trade deal. Alex Orr Edinburgh THE world must be having laugh at Starmer as they did with Boris Johnson. Starmer considered he had done well to claim first prize with his Trump deal, being the first in the world to do so. Then along came Joseph Stiglitz, an American Nobel-prize-winning economist, on Laura Kuenssberg's Sunday show stating that Trump's method for changing his business bargaining tariffs is to choose the weakest first, then move on to the other countries, which is indeed what he did with the UK. READ MORE: Scottish care sector chief compares Keir Starmer to Enoch Powell in damning comments Stiglitz was a breath of fresh air in his interview, even stating that Scotland did things differently to Westminster especially where student fees are concerned. Starmer behaved like a school boy bringing an apple for his teacher when he presented Trump with an invitation for tea with King Charles. 'What a pushover', Trump must have thought, 'this guy is gonna be no trouble.' And so it was with Starmer claiming a success story with his 10% tariff in exchange for the 1.8% tariff on UK goods to America. Even more than before Brexit when we were part of the EU market. Alan Magnus-Bennett Fife STARMER'S Trump appeasement and grovelling is reaching the point where we're all reaching for the sick bag. Put aside the smarm-fest that was the 'royal' invitation. Put aside the bizarre trade deal, with oligarch-pal and yacht-botherer Peter Mandelson first lapping it up at Trump's left shoulder before looking like a puppet with cut strings when a real reporter (Scottish) pointed out it was all smoke and mirrors. Put aside all the UK's debasement. READ MORE: Police and fire brigade attend fire at Keir Starmer's house I ask again, when is enough going to be enough? Presidential adviser Stephen Miller, creep of creeps, has just announced a possible end to habeas corpus – the foundation stone of the most basic democracies. This follows the deportation of US citizens by ICE and Trump's befuddlement over whether or not he has to 'follow the constitution'. I just wait to see who Westminster will send along to represent Britain (England) at Trump's birthday military parade. Yes – the military parade for the draft dodger who has mocked veterans and banned transgender people from serving in the US military. Might I nominate Tony Blair as the perfect envoy to watch real heroes march by as slimeballs look down from a gold balcony? Amanda Baker Edinburgh I KNOW that modern journalists are generally illiterate about anything to do with religion these days but I would have thought that a journalist for The National would know a little more about the Scottish Catholic Church than shown in your article of May 9 on the election of Pope Leo XIV. The journalist quotes 'international development charity Cafod' about the Pope, obviously oblivious to the fact that this is the aid and development agency of the Catholic Church in England and Wales. Scotland's equivalent, Sciaf (Scottish Catholic International Aid Fund) is ignored, as is any source from the Scottish Catholic Church. READ MORE: Richard Murphy: Pope Leo can yield power stronger than political force The Vatican is the only state in the world which recognises Scotland as a separate entity from the rest of the UK. The then Pope Leo XXIII restored the Scottish hierarchy in 1878 and the current Scottish Bishops' Conference was born. The current pontiff has taken the name of Leo because he wants to acknowledge Leo XXIII's first modern Catholic Social Teaching encyclical, Reurum Novarum, which protected the rights of workers at the height of the industrial revolution – a sign that he will follow in the footsteps of Pope Francis. By the way, Sciaf, which transforms the lives of the poor, not making them comfortable in their poverty, is at the top of the recipients of funds for projects from the Scottish Government's overseas development fund (which would be much bigger had we been independent, of course). Please note for the future! Dr Duncan MacLaren KCSG Glasgow Former Director of SCIAF and former Secretary General of the Vatican-based Caritas Internationalis I HAD to laugh about the RBS bank notes article in last Monday's National. For the last two years, the ATM inside the Falkirk branch of the RBS only appears to dispense English bank notes (seven out of seven visits). All part of the anglicisation of Scotland, after the Tories changed the name of the parent company from RBS to the NatWest (National Westminster) Group in 2020? A Wilson Stirlingshire
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Plan to demolish pub to make way for student flats approved
Plans for new student flats at the site of the former Murrayfield Sports Bar in Gorgie were approved by a committee in Edinburgh. The proposals will create 80 units of student accommodation for the area which has nearby amenities for students and a direct public transport link to Edinburgh University's main campus. The developer said the proposals 'can also help shift students out of flatted accommodation to free up much needed housing during a 'housing emergency''. The site. (Image: Fletcher Joseph/Google) Maurice McCann, development manager on behalf of EH1 Students Gorgie, said: 'I'm absolutely delighted to get the backing of Edinburgh's planning committee for our first student housing proposal in the city. We're determined to make this a development of which Gorgie and the city can be proud and one that will provide an outstanding living experience for the students who choose to stay here.' Tony Banks, chief executive at EH1, said: 'It is good to see planning approved for this development. It will be a great addition to the city's accommodation for students and free up capacity in the stretched housing system in Edinburgh. We welcome this positive step and look forward to continuing to invest in the city as the project progresses.' Harrods-owned H Beauty officially launches Silverburn store H Beauty has opened its second Scottish store with the brand officially launching its Silverburn shop.
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
SNP reject proposal for new tax on second homes in hotspots
The tax, known as the Additional Dwelling Supplement, is paid by the buyer in addition to the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax, the standard levy on home purchases. Currently it is 8% of the cost of the property but the Greens wanted it raised to 16% in areas where there is a housing shortage arguing that it made sense for the government to be able to change the tax in a targeted way in particular regions rather than having to make any change nationwide. Their demand was made more than a year after the Scottish Government declared a housing emergency. READ MORE: Analysis: Scottish Tories face 'existential crisis' as Reform support grows Badenoch, Findlay and For Women Scotland to speak at Scots Tory conference Councillors fined for safety failings after disabled swimmer almost drowned The Greens pointed to some communities such as Lochranza on Arran where more than a third of houses are holiday homes and that the situation pushes up housing costs and often forces young people to move out of their own communities in search of an affordable place to live. Ross Greer, the Scottish Greens' finance spokesman, who tabled the amendment to legislation going through Holyrood, told The Herald last month that a high number of holiday homes in some areas reduced housing supply for local people as he urged ministers and opposition parties to back his proposal when it was voted on at stage two of the parliamentary process. But the Scottish Government and the other parties rejected his calls. A spokesman for social justice secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville said decisions over the ADS levels were made at the Scottish Budget. 'A number of amendments to the Additional Dwelling Supplement (ADS) were put forward at Stage 2 of the Housing (Scotland) Bill. The amendments were not passed. Decisions on the rates and bands of Land and Buildings Transaction Tax, including the ADS, are taken centrally as part of the Scottish Budget process," he said. Mr Greer hit back accusing his political opponents of protecting the wealthy. 'Parliament voted to declare a housing emergency in Scotland last year, but now every other party has just voted against Scottish Green proposals to stop the richest people buying up homes they don't need in the communities with the worst housing shortages," he said. 'My proposals to increase the Additional Dwelling Supplement in rent control zones and National Parks would only have affected those wealthy enough to even consider buying a second or holiday home. The end result would have been to make it easier for first time buyers in particular to get a home in the community they've grown up in. 'It cannot be right that in a number of communities across Scotland up to half of the properties are either second homes or holiday lets, despite a housing crisis which has led to 10,000 children currently living in temporary accommodation. The wealthy have once again been protected at the expense of families desperately waiting for homes.' Since the 2021 election, the Scottish Government has doubled the Additional Dwelling Supplement from 4% to 8% and given councils the power to double council tax on holiday homes after coming under pressure from the Scottish Greens. The Greens say the reforms have reduced the sale of holiday home purchases, with 2455 fewer second homes bought last year than in 2023, the largest decrease in a decade. ADS will also raise more than a quarter of a billion pounds for public services in the current financial year, according to the party. Thirteen of Scotland's 32 councils have declared a housing emergency, beginning with Argyll and Bute Council in June 2023, with the most recent being East Lothian Council in November last year. A national housing emergency was announced by the Scottish Government for the whole country in May 2024. Experts believe the main driver of the emergency include pressures on homelessness services, high levels of people in temporary accommodation and a lack of affordable homes compared to high waiting lists. Mr Ross's proposals on ADS were among more than 400 amendments to the Housing Bill which were debated by MSPs on Holyrood's local government, housing and planning committee. The legislation will be voted on later at its final parliamentary stage - stage three - in the Holyrood chamber and if passed would allow councils to create rent control areas where rent is capped to certain levels. Ministers have tabled an amendment proposing that rent rises are capped to the rate of inflation plus 1% to a maximum of 6%. They have also set out exemptions to this rule. The Scottish Government has also set a target date for local authorities to make market assessments and recommendations on whether or not to introduce a rent control area. The new date is May 31 2027. Many in the property sector are opposed to rent controls arguing the root of the problem of high housing costs is an insufficient number of homes to buy or rent. They argue rent controls may make the problem worse by prompting landlords to sell up.
