Taser cop Kristian White to learn fate after prosecutors' push for harsher sentence over Clare Nowland's manslaughter
Senior Constable Kristian White, now 35, was found guilty of manslaughter of 95-year-old Clare Nowland after he was called to Yallambee Lodge nursing home in Cooma in the state's south on May 17, 2023.
White was sentenced to a two-year community order and 425 hours of community service, but the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions is appealing the sentence.
The judgment will be given on July 30.
Mrs Nowland was described as being a 'very aggressive' resident who was holding two knives by a nurse, but was holding only one knife and a penlight when White found her sitting in an office after 5am.
He repeatedly told her to drop the blade during a confrontation that lasted less than three minutes.
When she failed to drop it, White said 'bugger it' before tasering her: Ms Nowland died in hospital days later.
White was found guilty of Mrs Nowland's manslaughter in November last year following a NSW Supreme Court trial.
White is expected to learn whether prosecutors were successful in their bid to impose a harsher sentence on him, with the matter listed for judgment in the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal (CCA).
Cop didn't give Ms Nowland 'any real chance'
The DPP's case hinges on four grounds of appeal, including the sentencing judge made several errors by assuming both parties agreed White honestly believed his conduct was necessary, in his assessment of objective seriousness, and in finding that general deterrence had 'little or no role' or only a 'minor' role to play in White's sentence.
The sentence is 'manifestly inadequate', the final ground claims.
Crown Prosecutor Sally Dowling SC last month argued White did not give Ms Nowland – clearly vulnerable and disoriented – any 'real chance to avoid being tasered'.
Footage of the fatal incident made it clear Ms Nowland didn't understand or hear White's instructions, Ms Dowling told a CCA hearing.
'The respondent did not give her any real chance to avoid being tasered,' Ms Dowling said.
'(There were) many alternate actions that he could have and should have taken.'
Ms Nowland didn't advance towards White at any point, and needed to hold onto her walker with both hands, Ms Dowling said, which all fell under the Crown's appeal of objective seriousness.
She told the court it took White less than three minutes after first seeing Mrs Nowland to deploy his taser, which caused her to immediately fall and hit her head.
'She never regained consciousness after that fall, and that injury caused her death seven days later,' Ms Dowling said.
White's lawyer, Troy Edwards SC, rejected the Crown's claims that Mrs Nowland posed no threat, arguing it was inconsistent with observations of the sentencing judge and witnesses.
He also urged the court not to place emphasis on footage from the incident, but to rely on the accounts of witnesses who he said felt frightened as the incident unfolded.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Heartbreaking truth about ‘depraved' image dividing ritzy Melbourne suburb
A woman stands in front of an abandoned shop on the busiest street in Melbourne for sex workers. She is photographed by locals who share her image on social media alongside a message written in chalk. 'I don't suck c*** for $50. Ask your mum,' the message reads. In a local Facebook group for residents of the glitzy Melbourne bayside suburb of St Kilda, the photographer shares a crude description of the scene. 'Protesting prossie depravity for our kids to enjoy.' The image sums up a huge divide in St Kilda among locals who either view it with sympathy and an attempt at understanding or who choose instead to gawk and judge. The picture is important, but it's what it doesn't show that matters more. Less than 30m from where that woman is standing, on quiet, residential Greeves Street, a crime that shocked Australia took place. At 2am on July 21, 2013, street-based sex worker Tracy Connelly was beaten to death inside her van after a night on Melbourne's red light mile. More than seven other St Kilda-based sex workers have lost their lives since. Ms Connelly's killer remains on the loose and her murder remains unsolved — a tragic and terrifying reminder of the dangers faced by those who work the streets, often because they have no other choice. Among them are the woman who was bullied into homelessness from her residential care home, the woman who witnessed a brutal murder and now lives in a world of scary hallucinations and the woman whose young life was spent in a war zone and who now heavily self-medicates to manage the trauma she witnessed. We know this because all of them visited St Kilda Gatehouse on the same street where Ms Connelly was murdered. They stopped in because it is one of the only places in Melbourne where they can get a coffee and a snack without judgment. CEO of the non-profit organisation Nickie Gyomber told that the image of the woman in front of the abandoned shop 'can suggest things that are untrue'. 'How likely is it that someone who is navigating homelessness — and this includes finding a toilet and a glass of water — is going to use valuable resources to write two-tone crafted messages on a street corner?' she said. She said it was 'disappointing and sad to see pictures and comments such as this posted to social media' because 'many of the women shown are having some of the most difficult days of their lives, exhausted from a cold night unable to properly sleep'. Street-based sex work in Victoria is legal. It was decriminalised in 2022. Prior to that, sex work was only legal if it took place under certain conditions set out in the Sex Work Act 1994. But even advocates admit it can be jarring, especially in areas frequented by children. The stigma around it has not gone away. 'On the whole, the St Kilda community is very kind and understanding of the challenges for people living with the consequences of life trauma,' Ms Gyomber said. 'However, visible homelessness, sex work, and messages in public spaces can feel confronting — talking about these things with kids on the way to school can feel like a lot at 8:30am. 'But it is up to us — both as community and individuals — as to whether we use these sights to educate ourselves about causes of and responses to trauma. Alternatively, we can gawk and judge.' She says they put their lives at risk every single day using 'sex work to survive'. Many are addicted to street drugs that they used to self-medicate because of their past traumas. 'The risks faced by these women are enormous: sexual violence, mental health distress and crisis, everyday hunger, and poverty,' she said. She said the women who she sees are very aware of Ms Connelly's murder. 'Tracey Connelly's murder continues to grieve the women we support and we continue to hope for a time when there is accountability for her tragic loss. 'Safety is always an issue with a narrative that sex workers or people with life-controlling addiction or navigating homelessness are somehow 'less than'. It is a dehumanising narrative makes violence more likely.' A survey of sex workers conducted by St Kilda Gatehouse gathered first-hand accounts of what life on the street is like. 'In 2018, I started coming to drop in. I ended up there because someone had picked me up from Balaclava Station and dropped me off. I was unconscious on the platform. I can't really remember it. And I don't know who picked me up and dropped me at the drop in. But I am so lucky they did,' said one woman. 'It's really tough living on the street and not many people understand us,' another said. A third said simply: 'You see some pretty crazy stuff on the streets. People are bad.' previously spoke with sex worker Renee *, a friend of Ms Connelly who described her as 'a beautiful person'. 'I'm self sufficient, but I've been that way since I was 16,' she said. 'I respect the other girls, but most of them are heavy drug users. I don't take drugs ... I don't do this to pay for a drug habit.' She is an outlier but she is proof that stereotypes don't always fit. It's a truism that Ms Gyomber wishes St Kilda locals would learn to embrace. 'I wonder why this it's confronting (to see pictures of sex workers on the street),' she said. 'Why is it difficult to see someone in a difficult circumstance? What is it bringing up, emotionally, for us? 'I wonder whether these images stir an uncomfortable compassion, maybe something against the narrative that we all have equal choice in how we live. 'Trauma shapes these people's lives and all of the choices available to them — that is a hard truth to confront.'
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Surprising candidate in running for top police job
It's crunch time for the six candidates vying for a role many consider a 'poisoned chalice' – the NSW Police Commissioner. Interviews wrapped up this week and time will soon tell whether Premier Chris Minns has opted for a 'clean skin, dependable safe bet' to calm the storm after the force's turbulent recent history. In the running are hot favourite Mal Lanyon, as well as the current acting commissioner Peter Thurtell, Deputy Commissioner Paul Pisanos, former deputy Mick Willing and two assistant commissioners Peter Cotter and wildcard Rod Smith. The role has brought with it in recent years intense public scrutiny and relentless media attention, and the ever-present threat of misconduct scandals or mishandled critical incidents have created a perception that the job is exceptionally difficult and carries considerable reputational risk. Insiders have told the very dependable and well respected Mr Thurtell has excelled in the role since he took over from the state's first female Commissioner Karen Webb, and Mr Minns would be 'wise' to let him continue to 'steady the ship'. 'Thurtell has got a taste of the top job and knows he can do it,' one senior-placed NSW police officer said. 'Nothing negative has happened under his watch. Every major incident he has taken the lead, not waited or passed it on. 'If there is a critical incident the region commander has to take control but anything he should be in the public eye for, he has been and he's smashed it.' Mr Thurtell has appeared on television as part of a panel discussion on domestic violence and appeared in press conferences when issues arise. He's impressed the troops on the ground with his humble approach. 'He's been a region commander, he's got his battle scars, he has had everything thrown at him and he comes out with flying colours. You can't put him on the hop, if you try to trip him up you can't. 'And what's important is that those who know him absolutely trust him.' While Mr Thurtell might be popular among the troops, most believe Mr Lanyon is the Premier's favourite and a 'shoe in' for the job. 'He's been biding his time, networking with politicians and he's ready for his comeback,' one source said. Mr Lanyon has a long career in the police force, including heading the state crime command, and has been involved in disaster response and recovery, including leading flood recovery efforts in the Northern Rivers region in 2022. He missed out on the top job last time round – many say because of a night in February 2021 where he was found intoxicated, laying on the ground in Gouldburn by ambulance officers who later described him as argumentative and agitated. Mr Lanyon acknowledged his behaviour and sought to apologise personally. While he was publicly hauled over the coals for the incident he has since found new support in politicians and police alike, with many still saying 'he's the best one for the job'. 'You'd think the government might be worried though about the Merino incident coming up over and over again. The force has copped so much bad publicity, but a lot of cops think Mal knows what he's doing, is the most qualified, most media savvy and the best one for the job so I most think the Premier will back him and hope people have short memories.' Mr Lanyon will again go head to head with former sparring partner and fellow deputy Mr Willing. Both lost out to Ms Webb when Premier Dom Perrotet appointed her the state's first female commissioner. Mr Willing says he is an even better candidate today than he was three years ago, and believes he is the best fit to refocus the culture of the NSW Police Force. After being sacked by Ms Webb shortly after she took office, Mr Willing fought his own demons thanks to the sudden loss of identity but found a new purpose as head of Fortem Australia, a non-for-profit organisation devoted to helping first responders and their families. Police welfare is likely to be his key platform. Attracting fewer headlines than the other deputies is Mr Pisanos, best known for his work in regional youth crime. He's travelled the state building rapport with troops on the ground in remote country towns, community elders and kids themselves. He's passionate about steering them away from a life of crime and into the dozen of diversional programs, trying to give them hope of a better future – while talking tough and vowing to lock up the ones who won't cop the tip. 'Pisanos is a straight shooting kind of cop who shouldn't be underestimated,' one colleague said. 'He's a hard worker and commits to whatever he is tasked. 'History will show the favourites in the past haven't taken out the prize so he shouldn't be written-off. Webb certainly wasn't the favourite, nor was Fuller.' In the contest to become commissioner, history indicates that the frontrunner isn't always guaranteed success. Ken Moroney, Andrew Scipione, and Mick Fuller all ascended over more favoured deputy commissioners. Ms Webb was no exception. And lesser known assistant commissioners should not be written off. Mr Cotter, now head of Professional Standards, was left to face the media in 2023 after the tasering of 95-year-old grandmother Clare Nowland. Police were heavily criticised for not mentioning the 'taser' in initial media releases. Mr Cotter was the one to confirm to journalists that Ms Nowland had a serrated steak knife in a small treatment room when she moved slowly towards officers and was tasered. 'She had a walking frame but she had a knife,' he said. Mr Cotter also acted as in the position of Commissioner of the NSW Crime Commission in 2018 and was southern region commander as well as having worked in homicide investigations and is known for his work in victims' services. Mr Smith is the former principal of Goulburn Police Academy and heads the State Intelligence Command. His quest for the top job has surprised many. He joined the NSW Police Force in 1989, enjoying a successful and diverse career for over 30 years. 'We're a very professional organisation where we recognise professional qualifications, experience and knowledge,' Assistant Commissioner Smith told Police Insight in 2022. 'How you present yourself, your experience, and your qualifications goes a long way in being able to convey yourself and our organisation as a professional one.' Whoever takes the top job can expect to be thrust into the media spotlight instantaneously and how they convey themselves will be paramount to their success in one of the most challenging roles in the country. While Ms Webb's representatives claim her resignation was voluntary, numerous police sources suggest the government actively encouraged her departure due to leaks, persistent media criticism, and concerns about her public performance. Her supporters say she never stood a chance, with her detractors, including Mr Lanyon and Mr Willing working against her from day one. 'Whoever gets the job they can expect to be watched closely from day one and if they misstep it won't go unnoticed,' an officer said. What's not lost on the rank and file is the fact there is not a female candidate in sight. 'Wether Karen Webb copped it worse because she is a woman, I guess the record books will show, that's not for me to say, but you can be guaranteed of one thing, no woman will put their hand up any time soon nor will they be considered any time soon,' a senior female officer said. 'I would suggest the powers that be will pick someone who fits the profile of an old school blokey cop. Someone they feel oozes confidence and authority so the public and the media will be on board from day one. 'Whether that's a good thing or a bad thing, I guess time will tell. We will have to watch this space.'
Daily Telegraph
a day ago
- Daily Telegraph
Apology to Angus Bendall
Don't miss out on the headlines from NSW. Followed categories will be added to My News. On July 21, 2025 The Daily Telegraph published an article about Hugo Phipson who has been charged with wounding a person with intent to cause grievous bodily harm at a pool party in Mosman. A photo published with the article identified Angus Bendall (pictured) as the accused man. This was incorrect. Mr Bendall has no association whatsoever with the allegations described in the article and was not present at the party. We offer our sincere and unreserved apology to Mr Bendall for the distress and harm caused by this error.
