Meta fends off authors' US copyright lawsuit over AI
June 25 (Reuters) - A federal judge in San Francisco ruled on Wednesday for Meta Platforms (META.O), opens new tab against a group of authors who had argued that its use of their books without permission to train its artificial intelligence system infringed their copyrights.
U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria said in his decision, opens new tab the authors had not presented enough evidence that Meta's AI would dilute the market for their work to show that the company's conduct was illegal under U.S. copyright law.
Chhabria also said, however, that using copyrighted work without permission to train AI would be unlawful in "many circumstances," splitting with another San Francisco judge who found on Monday in a separate lawsuit that Anthropic's AI training made "fair use" of copyrighted materials.
"This ruling does not stand for the proposition that Meta's use of copyrighted materials to train its language models is lawful," Chhabria said. "It stands only for the proposition that these plaintiffs made the wrong arguments and failed to develop a record in support of the right one."
Spokespeople for Meta and attorneys for the authors did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
The authors sued Meta in 2023, arguing the company misused pirated versions of their books to train its AI system Llama without permission or compensation.
The lawsuit is one of several copyright cases brought by writers, news outlets and other copyright owners against companies including OpenAI, Microsoft (MSFT.O), opens new tab and Anthropic over their AI training.
The legal doctrine of fair use allows the use of copyrighted works without the copyright owner's permission in some circumstances. It is a key defense for the tech companies.
Chhabria's decision is the second in the U.S. to address fair use in the context of generative AI, following U.S. District Judge William Alsup's ruling on the same issue in the Anthropic case.
AI companies argue their systems make fair use of copyrighted material by studying it to learn to create new, transformative content, and that being forced to pay copyright holders for their work could hamstring the burgeoning AI industry.
Copyright owners say AI companies unlawfully copy their work to generate competing content that threatens their livelihoods. Chhabria expressed sympathy for that argument during a hearing in May, which he reiterated on Wednesday.
The judge said generative AI had the potential to flood the market with endless images, songs, articles and books using a tiny fraction of the time and creativity that would otherwise be required to create them.
"So by training generative AI models with copyrighted works, companies are creating something that often will dramatically undermine the market for those works, and thus dramatically undermine the incentive for human beings to create things the old-fashioned way," Chhabria said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
17 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Famous American hotel chain fires hundreds of US staff and hands $400 a month jobs to El Salvador
Fewer American workers will be answering the phone at one of the US's largest hotel chains. Hyatt Hotels confirmed to that its cutting US staffers from its customer service department. The company is reportedly replacing the American workers with staff in El Salvador, who will allegedly receive $400 a month payments. Hyatt's reductions come as a raft of layoffs from some of the US's biggest firms, as companies look to cut costs and implement new AI technology. The hotel chain reduced staffing across guest services and support roles — who handled customer service requests including reservations, loyalty program support, and general guest assistance — by 30 percent in the US. Hyatt did not confirm how many workers were affected, but travel blog View From The Wing — run by travel expert Gary Leff — reported that roughly 300 US-based employees were let go. The blog also said operations were being shifted in part to El Salvador, where outsourced agents reportedly earn as little as $400 a month. While Hyatt declined to comment on those specifics, former employees shared layoff experiences on social media platforms including Reddit, TikTok, and Leff's blog. 'Today, Hyatt finished what they started six months ago and terminated the rest of their US call team,' a person, claiming to be a laid-off employee, said on Reddit. 'Enjoy the customer service y'all!' Another Redditor reported getting laid off in a Zoom call. A third said they recently attended a company-wide summit and received assurances about their job security. On TikTok, a former Hyatt employee posted a video of themselves getting laid off on June 18, including a recording of an alleged mass-layoff video chat. 'We have made the very difficult decision to reduce the number of guest services and support [staff],' a voice can be heard in the video. A commenter on View From The Wing, identifying as a former staffer, said they were given 60 days of paid leave following the layoffs. The company, which operates more than 1,300 hotels across 76 countries and ranks as the fifth-largest hotel chain in the US, said the changes reflect 'the evolving nature of guest inquiries and shifting business needs.' A spokesperson told that 'decisions and conversations with impacted colleagues were handled with utmost respect and care,' and emphasized that care centers continue to operate in Marion, Illinois and Omaha, Nebraska. The restructuring comes as Hyatt, like many major companies, turns toward automation, self-service tools, and offshore labor to cut costs. The hotel chain joined a growing list of companies cutting jobs and replacing humans with tech In May, MGM Resorts announced it was slimming its in-person concierge staff, cutting 34 employees. In April, Sonder, a short term rental management company that is now owned by Marriott, announced it was 'right-sizing' the organization. Outside of the leisure industry, technological advancements have made several positions redundant, especially for call teams. Last week, Lululemon announced that it was cutting 150 jobs from its support centres after making advancements with AI. In May, Walmart — America's largest private employer — announced it was cutting 1,500 jobs from its tech operations and e-commerce teams. As the hospitality and retail industries adapts to post-pandemic shopping habits, the shift toward leaner, more tech-driven operations could leave fewer roles for American workers. But this shift is different from past American mass job cuts.
Daily Mail
18 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Urgent rental warning as car giant exposed using James Bond tech to sting customer $440
Before returning his rented Volkswagen to Hertz, a driver steered his car through a high-tech scanner system. Arched LED lights and AI-enabled cameras scanned the vehicle's fenders and panels for scratches, wheels for scuffs, tires for tread wear, windows for cracks, and undercarriage for damage. According to Hertz, the system is designed to speed up inspections and reduce disputes. But minutes after pulling the VW through the automated scanner, the driver says he received a $440 bill — for a one-inch scrape on a wheel. The charge came after Hertz began rolling out the technology as part of its partnership with UVeye, an AI startup that builds automated vehicle inspection systems. The renter, identified only as Patrick, said the total included $250 for the repair, $125 for processing, and a $65 administrative fee, according to The Drive. He isn't alone. Another renter on Reddit claimed they were billed $195 for a minor 'ding' after returning a Toyota Corolla to a Hertz location equipped with the same AI system. In April, Hertz representatives told that the newly-implemented machines would not be used to bill customers for minor cosmetic issues. Instead, they said the system was intended to prioritize safety and maintenance — not penalties. A representative for Hertz verified Patrick's story and said the company's policy has not changed. They're standing by the $440 charge. Now, the company confirms it uses a 1-inch standard for dents — roughly the size of a golf ball — when determining whether to issue a damage charge. 'Over 97 percent of cars scanned with this technology have not detected any billable damage, proving a vast majority of rentals are incident-free,' a spokesperson for the company said. 'Vehicle damage has long been a common pain point across the car rental industry for customers and companies alike. 'At Hertz, we're using this technology to address this friction head-on and our goal is to always improve the customer experience while ensuring customers are not charged for damages they did not cause and by bringing greater transparency, precision, and speed to the process when they do.' Independent analysts told that Hertz's AI rollout reflects a growing tension between company's tech solutions and a customer's service expectations. 'A line is crossed when AI applications become overly aggressive and prioritize efficiency over customer fairness and satisfaction,' David Linthicum, an AI analyst, said. Independent analysts are concerned that the advancing use of AI could frustrate customers 'Customers value fairness and human interaction.' Still, Hertz believes the new systems will make damage fees more transparent. Traditionally, car rental companies relied on employees to inspect vehicles, a process that had its limitations — especially when it came to detecting undercarriage damage or worn tires. UVeye says its scanners apply a consistent, fleet-wide standard to inspections, improving accuracy and fairness. 'Hertz is setting a new standard for vehicle maintenance and fleet management in the rental industry,' Amir Hever, the CEO and Co-Founder of UVeye, said. 'Our AI-driven inspection systems complement manual checks with consistent, data-backed assessments completed in seconds.' But while the technology may be more consistent, some drivers who've been hit with fees say they're finished with Hertz altogether. 'I will no longer be using Hertz,' the Corolla renter said on Reddit. 'Reached out to customer service, and they said they stand by the AI.' Hertz is the second largest rental vehicle fleet in the US Its the latest major change from Hertz that has ruffled some customer feathers. In 2022, the rental company purchased thousands of Tesla and Polestar EVs as it attempted to entice trendy customers. But vacationers, who didn't want to navigate America's frustrating public charging infrastructure, infrequently rented the EVs. Hertz started selling the cars at a loss. In the positive direction, the company also started to gain a lot of attention on Wall Street after billionaire investor Bill Ackman said he started purchasing stock.
Daily Mail
18 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
JCPenney announces HUNDREDS of staffers will lose jobs in latest closing
Nearly 300 workers will be losing their jobs now that JCPenney is preparing to shutter Alliance Supply Chain facility in Texas. The struggling department chain will be closing the warehouse and begin its first round of layoffs on August 1, lasting until August 14. It will start the second round on November 1, which is scheduled to end on November 14. The warehouse will close for good in the same month. 'JCPenney is always seeking ways to adapt and enhance our operations with the goal of providing a better experience for our customers,' the company told 'After a thorough review of our organization, we've made the difficult decision to close our JCPenney Alliance Regional Logistics Center.' The chain has informed all affected employees of the decision and has offered them severance, benefits, and transition resources. The latest layoffs come a month after JCPenney shuttered seven stores in California, Colorado, Idaho, Kansas, New Hampshire. North Carolina, and West Virginia. Even though about 650 stores are still running, the brand has found it hard to bounce back from its 2020 bankruptcy filing. The chain's profit losses became noticeable in 2011, and worsened during the COVID-19 pandemic. JCPenney was forced to file for bankruptcy protection with $5 billion in debt and began closing 30 percent of its stores as part of a restructuring plan. Despite its bankruptcy exit in December 2020, the chain shuttered around 192 stores in 2021, and closed another 50 a year later. The previous closures, along with its upcoming warehouse shutdown, is meant to 'build a stronger, more competitive company,' according to JCPenney. Not including credit card sales, JCPenney finished 2024 with $6.3 billion in sales, an 8.6 percent decline compared to the year prior. It also suffered a $177 million loss in net sales, which came 'despite some reasonable cost control on general expenses.' JCPenney is fighting through its financial struggles, even launching exclusive lines created in collaboration with Ally Brooke, Dwayne Wade, and Gabrielle Union. While its collaborations may have helped with sales, the company's revenue fell over 9 percent to $2.09 billion during its fourth quarter, ultimately resulting in a $64 million net loss. JCPenney is one of many retailers that has left shoppers concerned over its future. Macy's is in the process of shuttering 66 locations this year after announcing its plan to close 150 stores by 2026. Once the planned closures are complete, the luxury retailer will only be operating 350 stores. Torrid, a once-popular mall staple, is set to close up to 180 stores following its sharp drop in sales. Other closures that left shoppers stunned include Saks' Union Square store and Neiman Marcus' downtown Dallas location. The struggles were too severe for chains such as Forever21 and Hudson's Bay to handle, resulting in total store closure.
