Truce proposal requiring Hamas to disarm not Egyptian, reflects Israel's 'military failure': SIS head
CAIRO – 17 April 2025: The head of the State Information Service (SIS) has clarified that a recent demand for Hamas to disarm as a condition for a ceasefire in Gaza is part of an Israeli proposal, not an Egyptian one.
In TV remarks on Wednesday, Diaa Rashwan refuted claims by Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz that Egypt was behind the proposal.
Katz claimed that Egypt had, for the first time, proposed the disarmament of Hamas and the demilitarization of Gaza as part of a ceasefire deal.
Rashwan said Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is imposing 'impossible' conditions for a ceasefire to avoid a permanent end to the war, which amounts to 'political suicide' for him.
He described this demand as an admission of Israel's complete 'military failure,' emphasizing that Israel has been unable to eliminate Hamas's weapons since the war began in October 2023.
'How can Israel now resort to a political condition at the negotiating table and seek to do what it has failed to do with an army backed by all types of American weapons? This is an admission of Israel's complete military failure,' Rashwan stated.
The Israeli proposal currently under consideration by Hamas suggests a 45-day ceasefire, during which the movement would release nine living Israeli captives and 16 deceased captives in exchange for hundreds of Palestinian prisoners, both living and deceased.
During this period, Hamas and Israel would negotiate a permanent end to the war and the disarmament of the Gaza Strip.
Hamas has consistently referred to its weapons as a 'red line,' firmly rejecting any demands to disarm, making acceptance of such an offer highly unlikely.
The Israeli proposal also includes the release of US-Israeli soldier Edan Alexander, supposedly the last living American captive held in Gaza, on the first day.
However, Hamas's military wing, the Al-Qassam Brigades, announced on Tuesday that they had lost contact with the captors of Edan Alexander following an Israeli airstrike on their location, leaving his fate uncertain.
In a video recorded by Hamas from captivity on Saturday, Alexander addressed former President Trump, blaming him for believing 'Netanyahu's lies,' and wondering why he is still held there.
Hamas continues to hold 59 captives, with at least 22 believed to be alive, and has expressed readiness to release all remaining captives in exchange for an end to the war and the withdrawal of Israeli troops under a permanent ceasefire agreement.
Meanwhile, Israel has only shown willingness to accept a temporary truce for the release of captives from Gaza, without any commitment to end the war.
Rashwan emphasized that Hamas will not abandon its demand for a permanent ceasefire in Gaza, insisting that the movement will not release all captives it holds unless an agreement is guaranteed by the US or has explicit Israeli approval signed as part of a permanent ceasefire.
On March 18, Israeli forces resumed the war in Gaza, shattering a ceasefire brokered by Egypt, Qatar and the US, and killing over 1,600 Palestinian, predominantly women and children, according to the Gaza health ministry.
The original multi-phase ceasefire agreement, which took effect in January, led to the release of 38 captives held by Hamas, 30 of them alive, in exchange for nearly 2,000 Palestinian prisoners, under the first phase.
Israel, however, has refused to move to the second phase of the agreement, which included a permanent end to the war in exchange for the release of all captives, living and dead.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al-Ahram Weekly
2 minutes ago
- Al-Ahram Weekly
Countering Netanyahu's schemes - Egypt - Al-Ahram Weekly
Cairo is racing against time to halt Netanyahu's plans not just for Gaza, but for the entire surrounding of Israel. Cairo hosted a sequence of meetings with a Palestinian-Hamas delegation and a delegation from Israel on Tuesday and Wednesday, in what official sources qualified as a very last-ditch attempt to avert an upcoming Israeli military reoccupation of Gaza. The Cairo meetings come in the wake of consultations that have been unfolding during the past few weeks involving Cairo, Doha, Washington, and other players to find a possible exit from the ongoing impasse in the talks that aim to launch a ceasefire in Gaza. A source close to the Hamas delegation said that the talks were not coming with great expectations. Despite the pressure, the losses, and the 'awareness of the size of the disaster that has befallen the people of Gaza,' Hamas is clear about a set of red lines that 'it has no intention of crossing,' he said. 'It is very basic really — Hamas is determined not to hand over the remaining Israeli hostages unless there is a suspension of the Israeli strikes against Gaza, entry of adequate humanitarian aid, and a process of withdrawal,' the source said. According to sources informed on the positions of the Israeli government, this is not something that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will work with. What Netanyahu wants is to obtain the hostages and the bodies of the dead ones, force Hamas to hand over its arms to a third party, for Hamas leaders to leave Gaza, and to enforce a security scheme for Gaza that will ultimately be decided and monitored by Israel. According to an informed source, 'Netanyahu is negotiating to get a deal. He is going in circles, and his plans are elsewhere. He has a plan for Gaza, a plan for the West Bank, and a plan for the entire surrounding of Israel. This is what he is working on.' In the assessment of several sources, by 7 October 2025, on the second anniversary of Al-Aqsa Flood conducted by Hamas against targets in southern Israel, Netanyahu will want to declare his success in eradicating Hamas and expelling the Gazans out of the immediate surroundings of southern Israel. The sources say it would be unrealistic to think that Netanyahu will not move on with his plan to occupy Gaza as soon as the necessary military mobilisation and planning is secured. The same sources say that Israel is already sharing ideas about the day-after and not just for Gaza but also for the West Bank, Lebanon, and Syria. At the core of the many narratives that have been shared with Al-Ahram Weekly, Netanyahu is working to get the Middle East he has repeatedly said he wants to get. The elements of this Middle East are clear: no Palestinian state, full integration of Israel in the region, and an end of all scenarios for war. 'He has already gone very far in achieving his objectives,' said one Cairo-based European diplomat, who said that Netanyahu had already secured the near elimination of the regional hegemony of Iran, the significant weakness of Hizbullah, Hamas, and Islamic Jihad, and security and economic cooperation deals with many Arab countries. Today, the same source argued, Netanyahu is going to move ahead with more military aggression on Gaza to allow for a reshuffling of the reality on the ground around Israel. He said that as far as he knows from Israeli officials and diplomats, it is not just the Palestinians in Gaza who will be pushed into a limited strip of their land and be forced to live under miserable conditions or leave. Palestinians in the West Bank, too, he explained, are set to face more harassment in order to lump them into less than one third of the West Bank. 'Netanyahu wants Egypt and other Arab states to take responsibility for Gaza, or rather what he is not going to fully occupy in Gaza, which is essentially Rafah on the Palestinian side,' said a regional diplomatic source. He added that 'likewise' Netanyahu wants Jordan 'to take over the responsibility' of the segment of the West Bank where he wants the Palestinians to be located. After the 1948 War, Egypt and Jordan took administrative responsibility for both Gaza and the West Bank. This continued until the June 1967 War, when Israel completed its occupation of historic Palestine along with Sinai, parts of Jordan, Syria, and Lebanon. The entire process of Arab-Israeli peace was based on the return of Arab territories occupied in 1967 in return for the normalisation of relations with Israel. However, this concept of 'land-for-peace' has been sidelined by Israel, especially after the signing of the so-called Abraham Accords with some Arab states in the autumn of 2020. Commentators in the Israeli press claim that many Arab countries are no longer committed to associate their current and future relations with Israel with the Palestinian cause. In the words of one recently published piece, Netanyahu is currently building 'his own kingdom'. Informed sources say that this means three things: no Palestinian state, now or in the future; the total elimination of the resistance movements and of the capacity of Iran to relaunch these movements anywhere in the region; and normalisation plans for both Syria and Lebanon. More than two regional diplomatic sources who make frequent visits to Israel have been saying for the past few weeks that Israel, through direct talks in the case of Syria and indirect talks in the case of Lebanon, has been examining the chances for normalisation schemes with both of its immediate neighbours. The same sources say that there is an appetite in Beirut and Damascus for this, though for different reasons. They said that while the temporary political regime in Damascus under Interim President Ahmed Al-Sharaa wants to gain international recognition through 'the gate of possible peace with Israel,' the Lebanese government wants to move forward 'beyond the Hizbullah moment,' work on a demarcation deal with Syria and a peace deal with Israel, and secure mega regional and international investments. With the elimination of the capacities of all resistance and radical movements in both countries being currently executed, several sources argue that the path towards Israeli normalisation with both Syria and Lebanon is being launched this year. There are different assessments about when these deals could be concluded. However, there is no disagreement that the process is already beginning, perhaps at greater speed on the Syrian front. Sources agree that it is hard to predict how things will unfold on the ground, however, given the anticipated carnage that will inevitably hit Gaza when Netanyahu orders Israel's further military aggression against the Strip and the anticipated 'failure and possibly fall' of the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank. Then, there is the question of the fate of the Netanyahu government itself, which seems to be at high risk of collapse if the Israeli prime minister fails to secure the cohesion of his radical coalition. Far-right ministers Bezalel Smotrich and Itamar Ben-Gvir have long warned that they will take the coalition down if Netanyahu succumbs to the growing international warnings not to go all the way to reoccupy Gaza. * A version of this article appears in print in the 14 August, 2025 edition of Al-Ahram Weekly Follow us on: Facebook Instagram Whatsapp Short link:
Al-Ahram Weekly
2 minutes ago
- Al-Ahram Weekly
Egypt FM pushes political track on Iran nuclear file in calls with Araghchi, Grossi - Foreign Affairs
Egyptian Foreign Minister Badr Abdelatty held separate phone calls on Tuesday with Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi and International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Director General Rafael Grossi to discuss reviving negotiations on Iran's nuclear program and reinforcing the political and diplomatic track. According to the Egyptian Foreign Ministry, Abdelatty told Araghchi that resuming cooperation with the IAEA was essential to building mutual trust and creating conditions for regional security and stability. He urged commitment to diplomatic channels to resolve outstanding issues. In his call with Grossi, Abdelatty reviewed the latest developments in the Iranian nuclear file, heard the agency chief's assessment of a recent visit to Tehran by the IAEA's deputy director general, and discussed ways to rebuild trust between Iran and the agency. The two also explored expanding cooperation in the peaceful uses of nuclear energy in a way that supports regional and international security. The calls came ahead of technical talks between Iran and the IAEA in Tehran on Monday — the agency's first visit since Iran suspended cooperation in July, following Israeli and US strikes on key nuclear facilities during the 12-day war in June. President Masoud Pezeshkian ordered the suspension on 2 July. In past negotiations with the West, Tehran has used limits on IAEA inspections as leverage. Earlier this month, Iran said it would hold the US accountable for any future attacks on its nuclear sites while ruling out direct talks with Washington. Similar calls between Abdelatty, Araghchi, and Grossi took place on 6 August, when the Egyptian minister voiced Cairo's support for resuming negotiations and advancing a peaceful political process. According to US intelligence agencies and the IAEA, Iran's last organized nuclear weapons program ended in 2003. However, it has since enriched uranium to 60 percent — a short technical step from the 90 percent level required for weapons-grade material. Follow us on: Facebook Instagram Whatsapp Short link:
Egypt Independent
2 minutes ago
- Egypt Independent
Armed group posing as aid workers targeted in Israeli strike, Israel says, as international calls mount for more Gaza aid
The Israeli military says it struck an armed group posing as aid workers and using a vehicle marked with the logo of the World Central Kitchen (WCK), a US-based non-profit. The strike, which took place last week, killed 'five armed terrorists,' according to a Tuesday statement from the Israel Defense Forces (IDF). A video released by the IDF shows at least eight men wearing yellow vests and standing around a vehicle with a WCK logo on top. Several of the men in the video appear to be armed, 'cynically exploiting the status and trust afforded to aid organizations,' the IDF said. The video does not show the military striking the vehicle. Israel's Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories (COGAT) said it contacted WCK, which confirmed the vehicle had no connection to their operations. 'We strongly condemn anyone posing as World Central Kitchen or other humanitarians, as this endangers civilians and aid workers. The safety and security of our teams are our top priority,' WCK said in a statement to CNN. The vehicle was seen in the Deir al-Balah area in central Gaza, the IDF said, several hundred meters from an Israeli military position. In a briefing on Tuesday, the IDF said it's not clear to what group or organization the group belonged. The IDF also said it's unclear how many were killed in the strike. Growing calls for more aid Palestinians gather near Gaza's Zikim crossing, as flour and other essential supplies were distributed on Friday, August 8, 2025. Abaca Press/SIPAPRE/Sipa USA via AP The news comes as chaotic scenes continue to emerge from Gaza, with violence and starvation deepening amid Israel's tight control on aid to the territory. At least 227 people – including 103 children – have died from malnutrition since the beginning of the war, according to the Palestinian Ministry of Health. On Tuesday, foreign ministers from dozens of countries jointly called on Israel to allow more aid into Gaza and permit humanitarian organizations to operate there. 'Famine is unfolding before our eyes,' 24 foreign ministers said in the joint letter, demanding that Israel allow for 'all international NGO aid shipments' to enter Gaza and to authorize 'essential humanitarian actors' to operate on the ground. 'All crossings and routes must be used to allow a flood of aid into Gaza, including food, nutrition supplies, shelter, fuel, clean water, medicine and medical equipment,' the ministers said in the letter. The 24 countries and the European Union signed the letter, including Australia, Canada, Spain, and the United Kingdom, which have announced their intention to recognize a State of Palestine next month. CNN has reached out to Israel's Foreign Ministry for comment. Last week, the UN's World Food Programme (WFP) warned that acute malnutrition is spiking in Gaza, with more than 300,000 children at severe risk. Starvation and malnutrition in the besieged territory are at the 'highest levels ever' since the war began, WFP said, with half a million people 'on the brink of famine.' Israel has repeatedly claimed that starvation is not occurring in Gaza, saying on Tuesday that there are 'no signs of a 'widespread malnutrition phenomenon.' On Tuesday, five countries airdropped 97 aid packages into Gaza, according to COGAT. Israel and the US have continued to back the controversial Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) as the main means of distributing food, even as the UN says hundreds of Palestinians have been killed attempting to get food from the sites. On Tuesday, a small group of Israeli human rights activists in Tel Aviv protested against the controversial US and Israeli-backed aid initiative, in what appears to be the first such known demonstration against the group in Israel so far. 'Lethal force must not be used at distribution sites, and civilians, humanitarians and medical workers must be protected,' the foreign ministers wrote in their letter. Ceasefire talks continue Meanwhile Tuesday, a renewed push for a ceasefire in the 22-month war appears to be underway, as a Hamas delegation arrived in Cairo upon invitation from Egypt, to discuss the status of the negotiations, according to a Hamas statement. The delegation in Cairo comes after US envoy Steve Witkoff met with Qatari officials in Spain over the weekend to discuss the possibility of a comprehensive deal that would secure the release of the remaining 50 hostages, end the war and address the humanitarian situation in Gaza, according to two sources familiar with the matter. An Israeli source familiar with past rounds of talks declined to comment on the meeting. The last round of negotiations ended on July 24, when the US withdrew its negotiating team from Doha and accused Hamas of not 'acting in good faith,' Witkoff said at the time. The surprise withdrawal of the US, which was quickly followed by Israel, dashed hopes of an imminent ceasefire, even after the negotiating parties expressed considerable optimism around the talks.
